Interest and Single Payments

Compounding is interest earning interest, and one factor moves a sum through time.

Before this Lesson

A supplier will sell you a pump for $50,000 today, or for $60,000 if you pay three years from now. Your bank pays 6% a year. Which price is lower?

Subtracting won't tell you. Paying later costs $10,000 more, but it also leaves your $50,000 in the bank, earning money. The two prices sit at different times, and money at different times is like feet and meters: the numbers mean nothing side by side until you convert one into the other. That conversion takes one multiplication.

Interest is the price of having money now

Money in hand can earn interest. Put $1,000 in an account paying 6% a year, and next year it's $1,060. So if someone offers you $1,000 today or $1,060 a year from now, you have no reason to prefer either: take the $1,000, bank it, and you end up in the same place. At 6%, the two sums are equivalent: one grows into the other at the stated rate.

The rate did all the work. If your money earned only 2%, the $1,060 next year would be the better deal, and at 10%, the $1,000 today would. That's why every economics question states an interest rate: it's the price of having money now instead of later, and it sets the exchange rate between dollars at different times.

Interest on interest

Follow $1,000 at 10% a year. The first year earns $100. Simple interest pays 10% on the original $1,000 every year, so the balance climbs by the same $100 forever. Compound interest pays 10% on whatever's in the account, so the second year earns $110: $100 on the original, and $10 on last year's interest.

$1,000 at 10% per year
End of yearSimpleCompound
1$1,100$1,100
2$1,200$1,210
3$1,300$1,331

Each compounding year multiplies the balance by the same 1.10, so after nn years you've multiplied by 1+i1 + i a total of nn times:

F=P(1+i)nF = P(1 + i)^n

Here PP is the present amount, FF the future amount, ii the interest rate per period, and nn the number of periods, the symbols the Handbook's Engineering Economics section uses. In the formula, ii is a decimal, so 6% goes in as 0.06. Every period in this Lesson is a year.

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 Balance ($) End of year Interest on interest Interest on the original Original $1,000 $6,727 simple interest stops here: $3,000
What $1,000 at 10% per year is made of
Interest on interest starts as a sliver. By year 20 it's $3,727, the largest slice of the $6,727 balance.

The Handbook's factors are all compound and it prints no formula for simple interest, so treat every rate as compound unless a question says otherwise.

The cash flow diagram

A problem with several sums at several times gets hard to hold in your head, so you draw it. A cash flow diagram is a time line with arrows on it. The Handbook doesn't print one, so these are simply the standard conventions:

  • The axis counts periods, and time 0 is now.
  • Amounts sit at the end of a period. Tick 3 is the end of year 3, the same moment as the start of year 4.
  • Receipts go up and costs go down.
  • It shows one party's point of view. Every payment is someone else's receipt, so the other party's diagram is the same picture flipped over.
Your view (borrower) 0 1 2 3 End of year $10,000 received $13,310 paid time 0 = now end of year 3 year 1 The bank's view (lender) 0 1 2 3 End of year $10,000 paid $13,310 received
One loan, two points of view
You borrow $10,000 today and repay $13,310 at the end of year 3.

Almost every economics question comes down to one habit: draw the diagram, then move everything to one point in time. Sums at different times can't be added or compared until they're at the same time.

One factor forward, its reciprocal back

F=P(1+i)nF = P(1 + i)^n moves a sum forward in time. To move one backward, divide the same multiplier back out, which is called discounting:

P=F(1+i)−nP = F(1 + i)^{-n}

The Handbook names both multipliers in the factor table that opens its Engineering Economics section:

The two single-payment factors
Factor nameConvertsSymbolFormula
Single Payment Compound Amountto F given P(F/P, i%, n)(F/P,\ i\%,\ n)(1+i)n(1 + i)^n
Single Payment Present Worthto P given F(P/F, i%, n)(P/F,\ i\%,\ n)(1+i)−n(1 + i)^{-n}

Source: FE Reference Handbook, Engineering Economics

Read (F/P, 6%, 5)(F/P,\ 6\%,\ 5) as "find FF given PP, at 6%, over 5 periods." The general form is also written (F/P, i, n)(F/P,\ i,\ n). It works like a unit conversion: in F=P(F/P, i, n)F = P(F/P,\ i,\ n), the PPs cancel and leave FF.

The Handbook's Interest Rate Tables print these factors at 0.5%, 1%, 1.5%, 2%, 4%, 6%, 8%, 10%, 12%, and 18%, for nn from 1 to 25 and a few larger values. Here are a few rows of the 6% table. Along any row, the two factors multiply to 1, because one undoes the other.

A few rows of the Handbook's 6% table
nP/FF/P
10.94341.0600
30.83961.1910
50.74731.3382
80.62741.5938
100.55841.7908

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Interest Rate Tables, Factor Table - i = 6.00%

One check catches most factor mix-ups: before you compute, ask whether the answer should be bigger or smaller than the number you were given. Money moved forward grows, and money moved back shrinks.

Worked Example A deposit for a future replacement
1 of 3

A water district will need $250,000 to replace a filter system 8 years from now. An account pays 6% per year. How much must the district deposit today?

Pay now or pay later

That's everything the pump needs. Draw both offers from the buyer's side: one arrow down at time 0, and one down at year 3. Now move them to one point in time. Time 0 is handy, since the $50,000 is already there, which leaves the $60,000:

P=60,000 (P/F, 6%, 3)=60,000(0.8396)=$50,376P = 60{,}000\,(P/F,\ 6\%,\ 3) = 60{,}000(0.8396) = \$50{,}376

At 6%, paying $60,000 later is the same as paying $50,376 today, so paying $50,000 now is cheaper, by $376. Moving forward gives the same verdict: $50,000 grows to 50,000(1.1910)=$59,55050{,}000(1.1910) = \$59{,}550 by year 3, under $60,000. Any point works, as long as both offers get there.

Now raise the rate to 7%. The later payment becomes 60,000(1.07)−3=$48,97860{,}000(1.07)^{-3} = \$48{,}978, and paying later wins. Nothing about the offers changed. Your money just earns more while you wait, so future dollars are worth less today.

40,000 45,000 50,000 55,000 60,000 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% Worth today ($) Interest rate, i $50,000 paid now $60,000 paid in year 3 about 6.3% pay now is cheaper pay later is cheaper
The verdict flips with the rate
The later payment's worth today falls as the rate rises, and it crosses $50,000 a little above 6%.
Checkpoint

A county can pay a paving contractor $85,000 today or $120,000 five years from now. Money is worth 8% per year. Which is cheaper?

A.
Pay now: the later payment is worth $85,714 today
B.
Pay later: it's worth $79,090 today
C.
Pay now: the later payment is worth $176,316 today
D.
Pay later: it's worth $81,672 today

Escalating a cost, and rates the tables skip

A cost that rises by a stated percentage each year behaves exactly like money at compound interest, because each year's rise applies to last year's higher price. So you escalate today's cost with F/P, using the escalation rate as ii. The Handbook's Engineering Economics section never mentions escalation, but it's the same (1+i)n(1 + i)^n.

There's a catch: escalation rates are often 5% or 7%, and the tables skip both. Use the formula. Don't interpolate, because F/P is a curve that bends upward, and a straight line between two points on it runs above it. For a $4,000,000 job escalating at 5% for 20 years:

(F/P, 5%, 20)=(1.05)20=2.6533(F/P,\ 5\%,\ 20) = (1.05)^{20} = 2.6533

Averaging the table values for 4% and 6% gives (2.1911+3.2071)/2=2.6991(2.1911 + 3.2071)/2 = 2.6991. That looks close, but on $4,000,000 it's a $183,000 mistake.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A culvert replacement costs $1,200,000 at today's prices, and construction costs are rising 5% per year. What will it cost 12 years from now?

A.
$1,920,000
B.
$2,155,000
C.
$2,168,000
D.
$668,000

Several amounts, one point in time

A settlement pays $20,000 at the end of year 2, $30,000 at the end of year 5, and $50,000 at the end of year 8. What is it worth? Saying $100,000 is adding feet to meters. Draw it, move each arrow to one point in time, and then add. At 8%, moving to time 0 gives each arrow its own P/F:

P=20,000 (P/F, 8%, 2)+30,000 (P/F, 8%, 5)+50,000 (P/F, 8%, 8)P = 20{,}000\,(P/F,\ 8\%,\ 2) + 30{,}000\,(P/F,\ 8\%,\ 5) + 50{,}000\,(P/F,\ 8\%,\ 8)

A question may instead ask for the single equivalent amount at a stated year, such as year 5. It's the same move with a different destination: arrows before year 5 move forward with F/P, arrows after it move back with P/F, and the one at year 5 stays put. The nn in a factor counts the periods an amount moves, not the year on its label, so year 2 to year 5 is 3 periods.

To time 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 End of year $20,000 $30,000 $50,000 (P/F, 8%, 2) (P/F, 8%, 5) (P/F, 8%, 8) To year 5 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 End of year $20,000 $30,000 stays put $50,000 (F/P, 8%, 3) (P/F, 8%, 3)
Three amounts, two destinations
Worked Example What the settlement is worth
1 of 3

At 8% per year, find the settlement's present worth and its single equivalent amount at year 5.

Running the factor backward

Sometimes a question hands you PP and FF and asks for the time or the rate. Divide first, and only the ratio is left:

(1+i)n=FP(1 + i)^n = \frac{F}{P}

The dollars vanished. Doubling means F/P=2F/P = 2, whether you start with $10 or $10 million.

Solving for the time

When nn is the unknown, it's stuck in an exponent, and logs get it down. The Handbook doesn't print this formula or the next one, since each is a line of algebra from its (1+i)n(1 + i)^n.

n=ln⁡(F/P)ln⁡(1+i)n = \frac{\ln(F/P)}{\ln(1 + i)}

At 8%, money doubles in ln⁡2/ln⁡1.08=9.01\ln 2 / \ln 1.08 = 9.01 years. The tables get you there too: walk down the F/P column of the 8% table until you reach 2, through 1.8509 at n=8n = 8, 1.9990 at n=9n = 9, and 2.1589 at n=10n = 10.

1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 F/P Years, n 6% 8% 12% F/P = 2 6.1 years 9.0 years 11.9 years
Time to double is where each curve crosses F/P = 2

Solving for the rate

When ii is the unknown, take the nnth root of both sides:

i=(FP)1/n−1i = \left(\frac{F}{P}\right)^{1/n} - 1

That finds the pump's flip point. $50,000 grows into $60,000 in 3 years at i=(1.2)1/3−1=0.0627i = (1.2)^{1/3} - 1 = 0.0627, or 6.27%, where the curve crossed the $50,000 line in the pump's graph. If your money can earn more than that, wait. The tables can bracket it: at n=3n = 3, F/P is 1.1910 at 6% and 1.2597 at 8%, so 1.2 sits just above 6%.

It's also the annual rate of return. The Handbook's Rate-of-Return section calls that the interest rate that makes the benefits and costs equal, and with one sum in and one sum out, that's the rate that grows PP into FF. Don't divide the growth by the years: 20% over 3 years isn't 6.67% a year. That's simple interest again, and compounding gets there on less.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

A fund holds $30,000 and earns 6% per year. To the nearest 0.1 year, how long until it reaches $75,000?

years

Recap

  • Interest is the price of having money now instead of later. Two sums at different times are equivalent when one grows into the other at the stated rate.
  • Compounding multiplies by 1+i1 + i every period, so F=P(1+i)nF = P(1 + i)^n, and discounting divides it back out. (F/P, i, n)(F/P,\ i,\ n) reads "find FF given PP."
  • On a cash flow diagram, time 0 is now, amounts sit at period ends, receipts go up, and costs go down, from one party's view. Draw the diagram, then move everything to one point in time.
  • The nn in a factor counts the periods an amount moves, so year 2 to year 7 is 5 periods. For a rate the tables skip, such as 5% or 7%, use the formula instead of interpolating.
  • Run it backward with n=ln⁡(F/P)/ln⁡(1+i)n = \ln(F/P) / \ln(1 + i) and i=(F/P)1/n−1i = (F/P)^{1/n} - 1.