Uniform Series and Equivalence

A row of equal payments collapses to a single number at one point in time.

A dealer will sell a county a road grader for $210,000 cash, or for $45,000 a year for 6 years, with the first payment a year from now. County money is worth 8% a year. Which is cheaper?

Six payments come to $270,000, so cash looks $60,000 cheaper. But that total adds dollars at six different times, which you know better than to do. You could move each payment back to time 0 with its own P/F. Because they're all the same size, though, there's a shortcut: one multiplication handles all six.

A row of single payments

A uniform series is a row of equal amounts, one at the end of every period from 1 through nn. The Handbook's symbol for each amount is AA. A row of four $1,000 payments is just four single amounts, so you already know what it's worth today: move each one to time 0 and add. At 8%, their P/F factors for 1, 2, 3, and 4 periods give:

P=1,000(0.9259+0.8573+0.7938+0.7350)=$3,312P = 1{,}000(0.9259 + 0.8573 + 0.7938 + 0.7350) = \$3{,}312

Each term is the one before it divided by 1.08, and a sum with that pattern has a closed form. The Handbook's Engineering Economics section prints it as the Uniform Series Present Worth factor:

(P/A, i%, n)=(1+i)n−1i(1+i)n(P/A,\ i\%,\ n) = \frac{(1 + i)^n - 1}{i(1 + i)^n}

The fraction comes from a neat trick: multiply the row by 1+i1 + i, and every term slides one slot over. Subtract the original row, and everything cancels except the two ends.

At 8% and n=4n = 4, the factor is 3.3121, which is the four P/F factors added up, give or take rounding. Then P=A (P/A, i, n)P = A\,(P/A,\ i,\ n), so 1,000(3.3121)=$3,3121{,}000(3.3121) = \$3{,}312, in one multiplication instead of four.

Now the road grader. Its six payments collapse in one step:

P=45,000 (P/A, 8%, 6)=45,000(4.6229)≈$208,000P = 45{,}000\,(P/A,\ 8\%,\ 6) = 45{,}000(4.6229) \approx \$208{,}000

The installments are worth about $2,000 less than the cash price, even with $60,000 more dollars in them. If that feels like a trick, run it: put the $210,000 in a bank at 8% and pay each installment out of the account. After the sixth payment, about $3,100 is still sitting there.

Checkpoint

A transit agency can buy a bus for $300,000 cash, or pay $60,000 down today plus $55,000 a year for 5 years, with the first annual payment a year from now. Money is worth 6% per year. Which is cheaper?

A.
Cash: the plan is worth $330,452 today
B.
Installments: the plan is worth $231,682 today
C.
Installments: the plan is worth $291,682 today
D.
Cash: the plan totals $335,000

The same row, moved forward

Move the row to the other end instead, to the moment of the last payment, and each amount grows. The first has 3 periods to grow, the next 2, the next 1, and the last lands on the spot and earns nothing:

F=1,000(1.2597+1.1664+1.0800+1)=$4,506F = 1{,}000(1.2597 + 1.1664 + 1.0800 + 1) = \$4{,}506

The Handbook's Uniform Series Compound Amount factor is that sum in closed form:

(F/A, i%, n)=(1+i)n−1i=1+(1+i)+(1+i)2+⋯+(1+i)n−1(F/A,\ i\%,\ n) = \frac{(1 + i)^n - 1}{i} = 1 + (1 + i) + (1 + i)^2 + \cdots + (1 + i)^{n-1}

Look at that sum and notice that nothing in it knows about money. It adds up anything that starts at 1 and grows by a fixed rate each period. Truck traffic growing 3% a year for 20 years totals (1.0320−1)/0.03=26.9(1.03^{20} - 1)/0.03 = 26.9 times the first year's count, which is how pavement design adds up traffic in Traffic Loading and ESALs.

Where the lump lands

Each factor swaps a row for one lump, and that lump sits at a definite tick. The two sums show which. In the P/A sum, the first payment moved back one period, so the lump lands one period before the first payment. In the F/A sum, the last payment didn't move at all, so the lump lands on the last payment.

Back to time 0, with P/F 0 1 2 3 4 $926 $857 $794 $735 P = $3,312 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 1 period 2 periods 3 periods 4 periods one period before the first payment End of year Forward to year 4, with F/P 0 1 2 3 4 $1,000 $1,080 $1,166 $1,260 F = $4,506 $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 1 period 2 periods 3 periods didn't move on the last payment End of year
One row, collapsed to each end
$1,000 a year for 4 years at 8%.

Carry that rule with you, because the Handbook prints the factors without saying where their results land. Every late or early series below comes down to tracking that lump.

Four factors, two pairs

F/P and P/F were a reciprocal pair, and these come in pairs too. Flip P/A and you get A/P, which spreads a lump back out into a row. Flip F/A and you get A/F.

The uniform-series factors
SymbolFactor nameFormula
(P/A, i%, n)(P/A,\ i\%,\ n)Uniform Series Present Worth(1+i)n−1i(1+i)n\frac{(1 + i)^n - 1}{i(1 + i)^n}
(A/P, i%, n)(A/P,\ i\%,\ n)Capital Recoveryi(1+i)n(1+i)n−1\frac{i(1 + i)^n}{(1 + i)^n - 1}
(F/A, i%, n)(F/A,\ i\%,\ n)Uniform Series Compound Amount(1+i)n−1i\frac{(1 + i)^n - 1}{i}
(A/F, i%, n)(A/F,\ i\%,\ n)Uniform Series Sinking Fundi(1+i)n−1\frac{i}{(1 + i)^n - 1}

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Engineering Economics

To keep A/P and A/F apart, ask where the lump sits. A lump at the front of the row, one period before the first payment, is a PP, so it spreads with A/P. A lump at the back, on the last payment, is an FF, so it spreads with A/F. Loans, Sinking Funds, and Compounding Periods puts both to work.

The Handbook's Interest Rate Tables list all four beside P/F and F/P, and each pair multiplies to 1: at 8% and n=4n = 4, (P/A)(A/P)=(3.3121)(0.3019)=1.000(P/A)(A/P) = (3.3121)(0.3019) = 1.000. For rates the tables skip, such as 5% or 7%, use the formulas.

Net present worth

A real investment is more than a row. A machine costs money up front, saves money every year, and can be sold at the end of its life. Its net present worth (NPW) is the total of every cash flow's present worth, with receipts counted as plus and costs as minus. Positive means that, at the stated rate, what comes in is worth more than what goes out. The Handbook prints no NPW formula, and it doesn't need one: draw the diagram, then move everything to one point in time.

Each piece takes the move its position calls for:

  • First cost is already at time 0, so it takes no factor at all.
  • Uniform annual savings start at year 1, so P/A lands them right on time 0.
  • Salvage, what you can sell the machine for at the end, is a receipt at year nn: an up arrow with its own P/F.
Worked Example A machine with savings and salvage
1 of 3

A machine costs $80,000, saves $18,000 at the end of each year for 8 years, and sells for $12,000 at the end of year 8. At 10% per year, find its net present worth.

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 $80,000 first cost $12,000 salvage $18,000 savings each year End of year
The machine's cash flows

Series that start late or early

A series doesn't have to begin at year 1. Take payments in years 4 through 10. There are 7 of them, so n=7n = 7, not 10. P/A knows nothing about the calendar: it counts 7 payments and drops the lump one period before the first, at year 3. That isn't time 0, so the lump needs one more move, 3 periods back:

P=A (P/A, i, 7) (P/F, i, 3)P = A\,(P/A,\ i,\ 7)\,(P/F,\ i,\ 3)
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 A A A A A A A 7 payments, so n = 7 End of year (P/A, i, 7) lands at year 3 (F/A, i, 7) lands at year 10 (P/F, i, 3) P
Payments in years 4 through 10, in two moves

A series can also start early. Rent is usually paid in advance, so the first yearly payment falls at the start of year 1, which is time 0, and 5 payments fall at ticks 0 through 4. Apply (P/A, i, 5)(P/A,\ i,\ 5) and the rule still holds: the lump lands one period before the first payment, at tick −1, a year before now. So shift it forward one period. Or set aside the first payment, which is already at time 0, and treat the other 4 as an ordinary series:

P=A (P/A, i, 5) (F/P, i, 1)=A+A (P/A, i, 4)P = A\,(P/A,\ i,\ 5)\,(F/P,\ i,\ 1) = A + A\,(P/A,\ i,\ 4)

Either way, the result is 1+i1 + i times the end-of-period answer, since every payment comes one period sooner.

Shift the lump forward one period −1 0 1 2 3 4 now End of year A A A A A (P/A, i, 5) lands here (F/P, i, 1) 5 payments Or set the first payment aside 0 1 2 3 4 now End of year A A A A A, already at time 0 (P/A, i, 4) lands here 4 payments
Five payments starting now, handled two ways
Worked Example Payments that start in year 4
1 of 3

A utility will receive $25,000 at the end of each of years 4 through 10. At 10% per year, what is that series worth today?

Making two series equal

Two series are equivalent at a given rate when they're worth the same at any one point in time. So a question like "what deposit funds these withdrawals?" has one recipe: pick a point, move both series there, set them equal, and solve for the unknown.

The location rule usually picks the point for you. Picture deposits of AA at the ends of years 1 through 10, paying for withdrawals in years 11 through 14. F/A puts the deposits' lump on the last deposit, at year 10. P/A puts the withdrawals' lump one period before the first withdrawal, also at year 10. That's no coincidence: year 10 is the moment the fund holds everything the deposits built and still owes everything the withdrawals will take.

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 4 withdrawals of $20,000 10 deposits of A End of year (P/A, i, 4) lands at year 10 (F/A, i, 10) lands at year 10
Two lumps, one tick
Worked Example Deposits that fund withdrawals
1 of 3

A city makes equal deposits at the ends of years 1 through 10 in an account paying 8% per year. It then withdraws $20,000 at the ends of years 11 through 14, which empties the account. Find the deposit.

Reading a diagram as an expression

Some questions skip the arithmetic. They show a diagram and ask which expression gives its present worth. Take payments of AA in years 3 through 8 and an amount FF at year 8:

P=A (P/A, i, 6) (P/F, i, 2)+F (P/F, i, 8)P = A\,(P/A,\ i,\ 6)\,(P/F,\ i,\ 2) + F\,(P/F,\ i,\ 8)
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 A A A A A A F 6 payments, so n = 6 End of year (P/A, i, 6) lands at year 2 (P/F, i, 2) (P/F, i, 8) P
Each factor is a move on the diagram

Read it as a story. Six payments collapse to a lump at year 2, and the lump moves back 2 periods. FF sits alone at year 8 and moves back 8. To test an expression, ask three questions of each series: how many payments, where does the lump land, and how far is that from where it needs to be?

Checkpoint
1 of 3

Equal payments fall at the ends of years 5 through 12. Which statements are true?

A.
(P/A, i, 8)(P/A,\ i,\ 8) puts its result at year 5
B.
(P/A, i, 8)(P/A,\ i,\ 8) puts its result at year 4
C.
(F/A, i, 8)(F/A,\ i,\ 8) puts its result at year 12
D.
(F/A, i, 8)(F/A,\ i,\ 8) puts its result at year 13

Recap

  • A uniform series is a row of single payments. P/A and F/A are its P/F and F/P terms added up in closed form, and A/P and A/F are their reciprocals.
  • P/A lands one period before the first payment, and F/A lands on the last payment. nn counts payments, so years 4 through 10 is n=7n = 7, with the P/A lump at year 3.
  • Net present worth adds every cash flow's present worth with its sign. A first cost takes no factor, and salvage is an end-of-life receipt.
  • A series that starts late takes (P/A)(P/F)(P/A)(P/F). One that starts at time 0 lands a period early, so shift it forward with (F/P, i, 1)(F/P,\ i,\ 1).
  • For installment plans and series that must match, draw the diagram, then move everything to one point in time.