Asphalt Concrete

Asphalt concrete is rock held together by just enough sticky binder, and the air left over matters most.

Before this Lesson

Look down at an old road on a hot afternoon. One stretch has two grooves pressed along the wheel paths, with a slick black sheen in them. Another stretch, paved the same year, is cracking and shedding loose stones. Both are made of the same two things: rock, and about 5% binder by weight.

A point or two of binder can be the difference between those two failures. So how does anyone know when a mix has enough? The check takes two specific gravities and one short formula, and you'll run it by the end of this Lesson.

Rock carries the load

In portland cement concrete, the paste hardens into a solid that carries load between the stones. Asphalt binder never does that. It's a thick, sticky petroleum product that stiffens as it cools and softens again on a hot day. If a truck's weight had to pass through it, every summer would squeeze the road flat.

So in asphalt concrete, the rock does the carrying. Stones press directly against stones, forming a skeleton, and the load travels down through those contacts. The binder has two jobs: glue the skeleton together, and seal it so air and water stay out. Rolling the hot mix packs it tight, but some air always stays trapped.

wheel load stone-on-stone contact carries the load binder coats and glues air void
Compacted asphalt concrete, magnified
Schematic, not to scale.

A finished mix has four jobs, each named for what it has to do:

  • Stability: hold its shape under wheels, with no ruts or shoving.
  • Durability: last through years of air and water, without the binder going brittle or the stones coming loose.
  • Flexibility: bend over a slowly settling base without cracking.
  • Skid resistance: give tires grip, especially in the rain.

The Handbook has no asphalt section at all, so everything in this Lesson is knowledge you bring into the exam yourself.

Building the skeleton

Pour marbles on a table and press down with your palm. They roll out from under your hand. Do the same with crushed rock, and the flat faces bear on each other, the corners catch, and the pile pushes back. That's particle shape in one experiment. Crushed, angular, rough-textured stone locks together and gives high stability. Smooth, rounded river gravel slides past itself and gives low stability, however good the binder is.

Crushed, angular, rough stones lock Smooth, rounded stones roll aside
The same load on two kinds of stone
Schematic, not to scale.

The other half of the skeleton is its gradation, the mix of stone sizes. Three patterns cover it.

Dense-graded every size, few small voids Open-graded mostly coarse, connected voids Gap-graded no middle sizes, big stones touch water mortar: sand, filler, binder
Three gradations in cross section
Schematic, not to scale.
  • Dense-graded has every size from coarse to fine, so smaller stones fill the gaps between bigger ones. Its few small voids don't connect. This is the usual road surface.
  • Open-graded is mostly coarse stone with few fines, so the gaps connect and water runs right through, draining rain away from the tires. With little to brace its stones and its binder exposed to air and water, it gives up stability and durability, though the looser skeleton has more give.
  • Gap-graded leaves out the middle sizes. The big stones touch rock-on-rock, and a rich mortar of sand, fine filler, and binder packs between them. Done well, as in stone matrix asphalt, it's stable, tight, and rough on top. Without enough mortar, it drains like an open-graded mix.
Checkpoint
1 of 3

To save money, a county proposes swapping its crushed limestone for smooth gravel from a nearby riverbed, keeping the same gradation and binder content. What should it expect?

A.
Higher stability, because rounded stones pack tighter
B.
No change, because gradation and binder set stability
C.
Lower stability, because rounded stones slide past each other
D.
Better skid resistance, because smooth stones shed water
How gradation moves the mix
GradationStabilityPermeabilitySkid resistance
DenseHighLowModerate
OpenLowerHighHigh, especially wet
GapHigh if stones touchLow if gaps are filledHigh

Just enough binder

Now a thought experiment. Take hot, clean stone and add binder a little at a time, compacting a sample at each step.

At first the binder is spread thin. Its films barely cover the stones, so they're poorly glued, and the voids between them stay large and connected. Air gets in and hardens the thin films until they're brittle, and water pries them off the stone.

Add more. The films thicken, the stones stick better, and the binder lubricates them during rolling so they pack tighter. Stability climbs. Then the binder runs out of room. The voids are nearly full, so the next bit can only go between the stones, prying them apart. Rock-on-rock contact fades, and the load starts passing through the binder, which is what it can't take on a hot day. The extra binder also squeezes up to the surface and coats the stones in a slick film, which is called bleeding.

Too little binder air voids well above 4% permeable, ages fast stones come loose Near optimum air voids near 4% stones still touch sealed and stable Too much binder air voids well below 4% stones pushed apart ruts and bleeds bleeding
The same stone at three binder contents
Schematic, not to scale.

So stability rises to a peak and falls again, and the top of that hump is near the optimum binder content. Air voids behave more simply. They fall the whole way, since every added pound of binder takes room from the air, and that makes air a handy gauge: a mix near its optimum compacts to about 4% air.

stability 0 2 4 6 8 air voids (%) 4 5 6 7 binder content (% of mix weight) 4% too little binder too much binder optimum
Stability and air voids as binder content rises
Schematic of the usual trend. The peak falls near the 4% point, though not always exactly on it.

Zero air isn't the goal, because a hot day expands the binder and traffic packs the mix a little tighter, and both need somewhere to go. Lab procedures such as Marshall and Superpave gyratory compaction choose the binder content by compacting trial specimens across a range of binder contents. You won't need their steps.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

Back to the road at the top of the Lesson. Cores from the grooved, shiny stretch show 1.5% air voids. Where was its binder content most likely?

A.
Below optimum, because thin films let stones slide
B.
Above optimum, because binder pushed the stones apart
C.
At optimum, because low air voids mean a well-sealed mix

Matching the job to the mix

You now have enough to work out each job's recipe. A failed road tells you which job went undone, so start there, then ask what that job needs from the stone and the binder.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

A truck climbing lane ruts every few summers, though its surface hasn't cracked or aged badly. What should the repaving mix add?

A.
Binder above optimum, to hold the stones tighter
B.
Crushed, angular, rough-textured aggregate
C.
Open-graded aggregate with ample binder
D.
Smooth, rounded aggregate that packs tightly
What each job asks for
PropertyPreventsFeature that maximizes it
StabilityRuts, shovingCrushed, angular, rough stone
DurabilityAging, loose stonesFully coated stone, filled voids
FlexibilityCrackingOpen-graded mix, ample binder
Skid resistanceSlidingRough, hard stone, no excess binder

These pull against each other. Flexibility wants the open skeleton that stability and durability don't, so no mix maxes out all four. A designer leans toward whatever would end this road first, and a question usually names the property it wants.

The air left over

Now the numbers. Three specific gravities do the bookkeeping.

The three specific gravities of an asphalt mix
SymbolNameWhat it describes
GmbG_{mb}Bulk SG of compacted mixThe specimen, air included
GmmG_{mm}Maximum SG of the mixThe same mix with no air
GsbG_{sb}Bulk SG of the aggregateDry stone, pores in its outline

GmbG_{mb} comes from weighing a compacted specimen and finding its volume. GmmG_{mm} comes from breaking up a loose sample and pulling the air out under vacuum. The same mix with no air is packed tighter, so GmmG_{mm} always exceeds GmbG_{mb}.

That gap is the air, and the weight-to-volume bookkeeping shows why. Take exactly 1 ft³ of compacted mix with Gmb=2.40G_{mb} = 2.40. It weighs (Gmbγw)(1 ft3)(G_{mb}\gamma_w)(1\ \text{ft}^3). Now squeeze out every bubble without losing a crumb. The weight hasn't changed, but the mix now has Gmm=2.50G_{mm} = 2.50, so it fills only

V=(Gmbγw)(1 ft3)Gmmγw=GmbGmm (1 ft3)=2.402.50 (1 ft3)=0.96 ft3V = \frac{(G_{mb}\gamma_w)(1\ \text{ft}^3)}{G_{mm}\gamma_w} = \frac{G_{mb}}{G_{mm}}\,(1\ \text{ft}^3) = \frac{2.40}{2.50}\,(1\ \text{ft}^3) = 0.96\ \text{ft}^3

The missing 0.04 ft³ was the air: 4%.

Compacted mix Same mix, no air air aggregate + binder aggregate + binder 1 ft3 0.04 ft3 = 4% air 0.96 ft3 squeeze out the air same weight Gmb = 2.40 Gmm = 2.50
Squeezing the air out of 1 ft³ of compacted mix
The air is drawn thicker than 4% so you can see it.

The same steps with any two values give the percent air voids:

Va=100 Gmm−GmbGmmV_a = 100\,\frac{G_{mm} - G_{mb}}{G_{mm}}

This is the one formula here worth memorizing. The bottom of the fraction is GmmG_{mm}, not GmbG_{mb}, and a negative result means the two got swapped. Compare the answer with the target, usually about 4%. Well above it points to too little binder or too little compaction, and a porous mix. Well below it points to too much binder, and a mix that ruts and bleeds.

Two more measures look at the room between the stones. Voids in mineral aggregate (VMA) is all the space in the compacted mix that isn't stone: the air, plus the binder coating the stones. Binder that soaks into a stone's pores doesn't count, because GsbG_{sb} already puts the pores inside the stone's outline. Voids filled with asphalt (VFA) is the percent of the VMA that binder fills.

air (Va) binder coating the stones aggregate (pores inside its outline) VFA = binder's share of VMA VMA binder soaked into the pores counts here
Where the volume goes in compacted mix
Proportions typical of a mix near 4% air.

Expect a question on these to give you the formulas, along with GsbG_{sb} and the binder content:

VMA=100−GmbPsGsbVFA=100 VMA−VaVMA\begin{aligned} \text{VMA} &= 100 - \frac{G_{mb}P_s}{G_{sb}} \\[6pt] \text{VFA} &= 100\,\frac{\text{VMA} - V_a}{\text{VMA}} \end{aligned}

Here Ps=100−PbP_s = 100 - P_b is the aggregate and PbP_b is the binder, each as a percent of the total mix weight. The VMA formula is the same squeeze: 1 ft³ of mix holds Ps/100P_s/100 of GmbγwG_{mb}\gamma_w as aggregate, dividing by GsbγwG_{sb}\gamma_w gives that aggregate's volume, and the rest is VMA.

Worked Example Checking a lab specimen
1 of 4

A compacted specimen has Gmb=2.376G_{mb} = 2.376, and the same mix has Gmm=2.475G_{mm} = 2.475. The aggregate has Gsb=2.665G_{sb} = 2.665, and the binder is 5.2% of the total mix weight. Find the air voids and compare them with a 4% target, then find VMA and VFA.

VMA=100−GmbPsGsbVFA=100 VMA−VaVMA\text{VMA} = 100 - \frac{G_{mb}P_s}{G_{sb}} \qquad \text{VFA} = 100\,\frac{\text{VMA} - V_a}{\text{VMA}}

Recap

  • Asphalt concrete carries load through rock-on-rock contact. The binder glues and seals that skeleton.
  • Angular, rough stone locks together, and smooth, rounded stone doesn't. Dense-graded mixes are stable and tight, open-graded mixes drain and flex, and gap-graded mixes skip the middle sizes and fill the gaps with mortar.
  • Too little binder leaves a mix porous and quick to age. Too much pushes the stones apart, so it ruts, bleeds, and loses skid resistance.
  • Stability wants crushed, angular stone, durability wants full coating and filled voids, flexibility wants an open-graded mix with ample binder, and skid resistance wants rough, hard stone.
  • Air voids are 100(Gmm−Gmb)/Gmm100(G_{mm} - G_{mb})/G_{mm}, with a target near 4%. VMA is the air plus the binder between the stones, and VFA is the share of the VMA that binder fills.