Break-Even and Payback
Break-even is where two cost lines cross.
Before this Lesson
A contractor needs an excavator. A rental yard charges $90 an hour. Owning one costs $36,000 a year, whether it digs or sits in the yard, plus $30 an hour to run. Which is cheaper?
It can't be answered yet, and that's the useful part. At 50 hours a year, owning is absurd. At 2,000 hours, renting is. Somewhere in between the two cost exactly the same, and that one number of hours is all the contractor needs to know.
Costs that stay and costs that move
Here's a test for any cost: if the machine sits idle all year, does the bill still come? The $36,000 a year of owning the excavator comes either way, so it's a fixed cost. Fuel and wear come only when it digs, so they're a variable cost, and they grow with every hour.
The Handbook's Breakeven Analysis entry is a few sentences of words, with no formula or symbols, and it never defines these costs. So this Lesson uses plain symbols of its own: for the fixed cost ( already means future worth), for the variable cost per hour or unit, and for the quantity, in hours or units per year. Total cost is then:
For owning the excavator, that's : a straight line that starts at $36,000 at zero hours and climbs $30 for every hour.
Average cost is total cost shared over all the hours or units:
At 200 hours, the excavator has cost $42,000, or $210 an hour. At 1,200 hours, it has cost $72,000, or $60 an hour. The $36,000 hasn't changed. It's just shared among more hours. So the average keeps falling as volume rises, but it never gets below , because every hour still burns its own $30.
Marginal cost, also called incremental cost, asks something different: what does one more hour cost? Just : $30, at 200 hours or at 1,200. That's the slope of the total-cost line, so you can find it from two totals without knowing or :
Average is what each hour has cost so far. Marginal is what the next hour will cost.
Two cost lines
Now bring in the rental yard, and leave interest out for the moment. Renting has no fixed cost here, so its line starts at zero and climbs steeply: . Owning starts high and climbs gently: . The steep line has to catch the gentle one.
The crossing is the break-even point. The Handbook's Breakeven Analysis entry puts it in words: the value of a variable that makes two alternatives equally economical. So set the two costs equal and solve:
Look at the shape of that answer. Owning means taking on $36,000 a year to save $60 every hour you dig. How many $60 savings does it take to pay off $36,000? That's 600. In general, it's the extra fixed cost over the variable cost saved, where alternative 2 is the one with the higher fixed cost:
Below 600 hours, renting is cheaper. Above 600, owning is. The alternative with the lower variable cost wins above the crossing, every time. And notice that 600 hours is exactly where owning's average cost falls to the $90 rental rate. Both values must be per the same thing, hours or units, and comes out in that same thing.
When the other line is revenue
The same picture works when you're selling something, with revenue as the second line. A precast shop makes parking curbs. Rent and equipment cost $60,000 a year, and each curb takes $20 of materials and labor and sells for $50. With price , revenue is , a line from the origin.
Think about what one curb does. It brings in $50, and $20 of that pays for making it. The other $30 goes toward the $60,000. That leftover, , is each unit's contribution, and break-even is how many contributions it takes to cover the fixed cost:
That's the same answer you get from setting . Below 2,000 curbs, the shop loses money. Past 2,000, the whole $30 from each curb is profit. A profit target is just one more thing to cover, so it joins the fixed cost on top. For $30,000 of profit:
Reading the chart
Two questions come up with any break-even chart. The first is which side you're on. Find the crossing, then see which line is lower at your volume. The line that starts low looks cheap, and it is, but only until the crossing.
The second is what moves the crossing. Look at . More fixed cost means more to pay off, so break-even moves right. A bigger contribution pays it off faster, so break-even moves left. Raise the curb price to $60, and break-even drops from 2,000 to 1,500 curbs. Raise the fixed cost to $90,000, or the variable cost to $30, and it climbs to 3,000.
Two alternatives behave the same way, since their crossing is the extra fixed cost over the variable cost saved. If the rental yard raises its rate to $120, owning saves $90 an hour, and the crossing drops from 600 hours to 400.
How fast the money comes back
Break-even asks how much use an investment needs. Payback asks how long it takes. The Handbook gives it one sentence, under Breakeven Analysis: the payback period is "the period of time required for the profit or other benefits of an investment to equal the cost of the investment." Counting those benefits at face value, with no interest, is simple payback. With level savings, it's a division: a $60,000 upgrade that saves $15,000 a year pays back in 4 years.
Often the investment that matters is only the extra cost of the better option. Say hand tools cost $4,000 and make a part for $9, while an automated system costs $34,000 and makes it for $5, at 5,000 parts a year. You'd spend the $4,000 either way, so what automation puts at stake is the $30,000 difference. It saves a year, so the extra investment pays back in 1.5 years.
When savings aren't level, a single division can't see when the money arrives, so keep a running total. Start in the hole by the first cost, and add each year's savings until you reach zero. Take a $50,000 upgrade that saves $12,000, $15,000, $18,000, $20,000, and $10,000 over 5 years.
After 3 years, $45,000 has come back, so it's $5,000 short. Year 4 brings $20,000, and if that arrives evenly through the year, the last $5,000 takes of a year. Payback is 3.25 years. A question that asks for whole years wants 4, the first year-end with the cost fully recovered.
What payback can't see
Payback is a stopwatch, not a scorecard. It says how fast the money comes back, not whether the investment is worth making, and it has two blind spots.
It ignores everything after payback. Take two $30,000 projects. One returns $15,000 a year for 2 years, then nothing. The other returns $10,000 a year for 10 years. The first pays back sooner, 2 years against 3, and leaves you with only your money back. The second ends up $70,000 ahead.
It also ignores the time value of money, since a dollar in year 3 counts the same as a dollar today. Discounted payback fixes that one by running each year's savings through P/F before adding them. At 10%, the second project's payback stretches from 3 years to about 3.75. The Handbook's sentence doesn't distinguish the two.
That's two kinds of reading: a chart, and what a payback number does and doesn't tell you. Try both.
Putting interest back
All of those break-evens ignored interest. So where did the excavator's $36,000 come from? It costs $200,000 and sells for $20,000 after 5 years, so it loses $180,000 over 5 years, or $36,000 a year. That pays back the lost value and nothing else, while $200,000 of your money sits in a machine instead of earning interest.
A first cost with a salvage value spreads into a level yearly charge, the "rent" on the machine. A/P spreads the lump at the front of the row, and A/F spreads the salvage at the back, which reduces the charge. For more, see Equivalent Annual Worth.
With money worth 10%, the Handbook's Interest Rate Tables give 0.2638 for A/P and 0.1638 for A/F at :
Nothing else changes. That yearly charge comes due whether the excavator digs or not, so it's a fixed cost. Annualize first, then break even the same way, with $60 saved each hour:
So interest moved the crossing from 600 hours to about 825. A contractor digging 700 hours a year looks like a buyer without interest and a renter with it.