Equivalent Annual Worth

Spread a first cost over a machine's life, and it behaves like rent.

A contractor buys a $120,000 loader, runs it for 8 years, and sells it for $20,000. Money is worth 8% a year. What does the loader cost per year?

The quick answer: it lost $100,000 over 8 years, so $12,500 a year. Now picture a rental yard charging that. It gets its lost value back and nothing else, while $120,000 of its money sits in a machine instead of earning 8%. The rent that really covers the yard is about $19,000 a year, and two multiplications get you there.

The rent on a first cost

Be the rental yard. You hand over $120,000 today, and you want equal payments at the end of each of the next 8 years that return all of it, plus 8% on whatever hasn't come back yet. That's the job of A/P. The Handbook calls it the Capital Recovery factor, and its Interest Rate Tables give 0.1740 at 8% and n=8n = 8:

P (A/P, 8%, 8)=120,000(0.1740)=$20,880 a yearP\,(A/P,\ 8\%,\ 8) = 120{,}000(0.1740) = \$20{,}880 \text{ a year}

Now the salvage. The $20,000 comes back at year 8, on the last payment of the row. A lump at the back of a row is an FF, so it spreads with A/F, the Handbook's Uniform Series Sinking Fund factor:

S (A/F, 8%, 8)=20,000(0.0940)=$1,880 a yearS\,(A/F,\ 8\%,\ 8) = 20{,}000(0.0940) = \$1{,}880 \text{ a year}

Run it: deposit $1,880 a year at 8%, and the account holds about $20,000 at year 8. So the check at the end is worth $1,880 a year. It isn't worth $20,000 / 8 = $2,500, which ignores the wait, or the $3,480 that A/P gives, which pretends the check arrives on day one.

The first cost is a charge, and the salvage gives some of it back, so subtract. That's capital recovery with salvage:

A=P (A/P, i, n)−S (A/F, i, n)A = P\,(A/P,\ i,\ n) - S\,(A/F,\ i,\ n)

For the loader, that's 20,880−1,880=$19,00020{,}880 - 1{,}880 = \$19{,}000 a year, the rent from the top of this page. The Handbook prints the two factors, and writes salvage as SnS_n, but it doesn't print this relation. Nothing in it is new: each lump just takes the factor its position calls for.

What actually happens 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 End of year $120,000 first cost $20,000 salvage Each lump spread over the 8 years $20,000 (A/F, 8%, 8) = $1,880 a year 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 End of year $120,000 (A/P, 8%, 8) = $20,880 a year The rent 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 End of year $19,000 a year
The loader's two lumps, as one level rent

That level amount is the idea of annual worth: the uniform series, over years 1 through nn, that's equivalent to all of a project's cash flows. Any set of cash flows can get there the long way, by finding the net present worth and spreading it with A/P, so the two always share a sign.

Owning and operating

Machines also burn fuel and need repairs. Annual operating and maintenance cost (O&M) is already a row, so it takes no factor. Add it to the rent, and you have the equivalent uniform annual cost, or EUAC:

EUAC=P (A/P, i, n)+O&M−S (A/F, i, n)\text{EUAC} = P\,(A/P,\ i,\ n) + \text{O\&M} - S\,(A/F,\ i,\ n)

An annual cost is reported as a positive number. Costs count as plus, and salvage, which reduces the bill, counts as minus.

Worked Example A pump's yearly cost
1 of 2

A pump costs $60,000, takes $4,000 a year to run and maintain, and sells for $8,000 at the end of its 10-year life. At 10% per year, find its equivalent uniform annual cost.

Not everything gets sold at the end. A detour bridge goes up for a few years, and then someone has to pay a crew to take it out. That removal cost sits right where salvage would, at year nn, but its arrow points down. The position is the same, so the factor is the same. Only the sign changes, so the A/F term now adds to the annual cost instead of reducing it.

Salvage: a check at year n 0 1 2 … n End of year P O&M each year S EUAC = P(A/P, i, n) + O&M − S(A/F, i, n) Removal: a bill at year n 0 1 2 … n End of year P O&M each year R EUAC = P(A/P, i, n) + O&M + R(A/F, i, n)
Same tick, same factor, opposite arrow
Checkpoint

A temporary detour bridge costs $180,000 to build and $12,000 a year to inspect and maintain. At the end of its 5-year life, it costs $30,000 to remove. At 8% per year, what is its equivalent uniform annual cost?

dollars per year

Months instead of years

The factors count periods, and they have no idea how long a period is. So a monthly rate goes with a count of months, and the same relation returns a monthly rent. A purchase breaks even when its monthly benefit just covers that rent. At 1% per month, a 10-year life is i=1%i = 1\% and n=120n = 120.

One hitch: the Handbook's Interest Rate Tables list every nn up to 25, then only 30, 40, 50, 60, and 100, so 120 isn't there. Go to the factor formulas printed at the top of the Handbook's Engineering Economics section:

(A/P, i%, n)=i(1+i)n(1+i)n−1(A/F, i%, n)=i(1+i)n−1\begin{aligned} (A/P,\ i\%,\ n) &= \frac{i(1 + i)^n}{(1 + i)^n - 1} \\[0.5em] (A/F,\ i\%,\ n) &= \frac{i}{(1 + i)^n - 1} \end{aligned}

Both use (1+i)n(1 + i)^n, so compute it once and store it. A nominal annual rate, such as 12% compounded monthly, gets divided by 12 first; for more, see Loans, Sinking Funds, and Compounding Periods.

Worked Example A monthly break-even
1 of 2

Equipment costs $50,000, lasts 10 years, and sells for $10,000 at the end. Money costs 1% per month. What uniform monthly benefit does the purchase need to break even?

Costs in the middle of the life

An overhaul in year 5 of a 10-year life sits at neither end of the row. A/P wants a lump at the front, and A/F wants a lump at the back. So put it where a factor can reach it: bring it back to time 0 with P/F, then spread it across the whole life with A/P.

First, back to time 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 End of year C (P/F, i, 5) P Then across the whole life 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 End of year P A each year: P (A/P, i, 10)
An overhaul, moved to the front and then spread

Carrying it forward to year nn with F/P and spreading it with A/F works just as well. Either way, there's a handy check. A/F alone would treat the cost as if it fell at the very end, and A/P alone as if it fell at the very start. The right answer has to land between those two.

A short irregular series takes the same route: each amount comes back with its own P/F, and the total spreads with A/P.

Worked Example An overhaul in year 5
1 of 3

A machine with a 12-year life needs a $15,000 overhaul at the end of year 5. At 8% per year, what is that overhaul's equivalent uniform annual cost over the machine's life?

What each cash flow does to the equivalent uniform annual cost
Cash flowWhere it sitsTerm in EUAC
First costFront+P (A/P, i, n)+P\,(A/P,\ i,\ n)
Annual O&MAlready a row+O&M+\text{O\&M}
SalvageBack, a receipt−S (A/F, i, n)-S\,(A/F,\ i,\ n)
Removal costBack, a bill+R (A/F, i, n)+R\,(A/F,\ i,\ n)
Cost C in year tMiddle+C (P/F, i, t)(A/P, i, n)+C\,(P/F,\ i,\ t)(A/P,\ i,\ n)

Annual worth at the MARR

So far it's all been cost. A project that earns money gets read the other way, with receipts as plus and costs as minus:

EAW=−P (A/P, i, n)+(revenue−annual costs)+S (A/F, i, n)\text{EAW} = -P\,(A/P,\ i,\ n) + (\text{revenue} - \text{annual costs}) + S\,(A/F,\ i,\ n)

Those are the same pieces with their signs turned over, so equivalent annual worth (EAW) is just revenue minus EUAC. The rate to use is the MARR, the minimum acceptable rate of return, which the Handbook's Rate-of-Return section describes as the rate one is willing to accept, or desires to earn, on investments.

Now the sign means something, because at the MARR the rent already includes the interest you demand. Say the loader, at an 8% MARR, nets $25,000 a year. Then EAW=25,000−19,000=+$6,000\text{EAW} = 25{,}000 - 19{,}000 = +\$6{,}000: it pays its rent with $6,000 a year left over, so it's acceptable. If it nets only $15,000 a year, EAW is −$4,000. It would still take in $140,000 on a $120,000 purchase, more dollars than went out, but it doesn't earn 8%, so it isn't acceptable. Right at zero, a project earns exactly the MARR.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A project costs $250,000, brings in $90,000 a year in revenue, costs $35,000 a year to run, and has a $40,000 salvage value after 10 years. At a 12% MARR, what is its equivalent annual worth, with its sign?

dollars per year

Running it backward

The exam doesn't always ask for the annual amount. "What's the most we can pay for a machine that saves $25,000 a year?" is the same relation run in reverse. A machine just breaks even when its yearly benefit exactly pays its rent, so set them equal and solve for whichever value is missing:

annual benefit=P (A/P, i, n)−S (A/F, i, n)\text{annual benefit} = P\,(A/P,\ i,\ n) - S\,(A/F,\ i,\ n)

Solve for PP, and you have the largest first cost the benefit can justify, since paying more turns annual worth negative. That PP is also the present worth of everything the machine brings in, which gives you a second route. Solve for SS, and you have the salvage a stated first cost needs.

Worked Example The most a machine can cost
1 of 2

A machine will save $25,000 a year for 10 years and sell for $30,000 at the end. At 10% per year, what is the largest first cost it can justify?

Costs that never end

A dam or a tunnel has no planned retirement. So how much would you set aside today to pay for its upkeep forever? An endless row of payments sounds like it ought to cost an endless amount. It doesn't, because dollars far in the future are worth almost nothing today. Watch P/A as nn grows:

0 20 40 60 80 100 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 Number of periods, n (P/A, 8%, n) 1/i = 12.5 6.71 10.67 12.23 12.49
P/A at 8% flattens against a ceiling

Going from 50 payments to 100 barely moves the factor. It's pressing against a ceiling, and the formula shows where. As nn grows, the (1+i)n(1 + i)^n terms swamp the −1 and cancel:

(P/A, i%, n)=(1+i)n−1i(1+i)n  ⟶  1i(P/A,\ i\%,\ n) = \frac{(1 + i)^n - 1}{i(1 + i)^n} \;\longrightarrow\; \frac{1}{i}

The Handbook prints the result under Capitalized Costs, as present worth over a perpetual period:

P=AiP = \frac{A}{i}

A bank account gives you the picture. Put $1,000,000 in at 5%, and every year it pays $50,000 in interest while the million sits there, ready to do it again. So $1,000,000 today and $50,000 a year forever are the same thing.

The capitalized cost of a facility is what it takes today to build it and fund it forever: the first cost, which is already at time 0, plus A/iA/i for the upkeep. With no facility in the picture, A/iA/i alone is the endowment that funds an expense forever.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A dam costs $4,000,000 to build and $120,000 a year to maintain, forever, starting a year from now. At 6% per year, what is its capitalized cost?

dollars

Bills that come every k years

Resurfacing a road every 10 years isn't a yearly cost, and A/iA/i needs a yearly one. So make one. Look at a single 10-year cycle. Its bill sits at the back, on the cycle's last year, which makes it an FF, and A/F over 10 years spreads it across that cycle. The next cycle is identical, and so is the one after that, so the bills turn into one level row that never ends. Then A/iA/i finishes the job:

P=C (A/F, i, k)iP = \frac{C\,(A/F,\ i,\ k)}{i}

Here kk is the length of the cycle, not the life of the road, which has no end anyway. A $500,000 resurfacing every 10 years, the first at year 10, comes at 6% to 500,000(0.0759)=$37,950500{,}000(0.0759) = \$37{,}950 a year, or 37,950/0.06=$632,50037{,}950 / 0.06 = \$632{,}500 today. Picture a fund that takes in $37,950 a year and hands over exactly $500,000 every tenth year. The Handbook stops at P=A/iP = A/i, so this step is yours to bring.

The real bills 0 10 20 30 forever End of year $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 The same bills as a level row 0 10 20 30 forever End of year one cycle: $500,000 (A/F, 6%, 10) = $37,950 a year
Bills every 10 years, as a level row that never ends
Checkpoint

A tunnel costs $8,000,000 to build and $100,000 a year to maintain, and it needs relining at $1,500,000 every 20 years, the first at year 20, all forever. At 6% per year, what is its capitalized cost?

A.
$11,846,667
B.
$10,134,367
C.
$34,666,667
D.
$10,346,667

Maintenance that starts late

A new canal might need nothing for its first 5 years, then AA a year forever, with the first payment at year 6. The Handbook doesn't say where A/iA/i lands, but it's just P/A with nn run out to forever, so it follows the same rule: one period before the first payment. That's year 5, not year 6, and from there it has 5 periods left to travel:

P=Ai (P/F, i, 5)P = \frac{A}{i}\,(P/F,\ i,\ 5)
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 forever End of year A A A A A A every year, forever (P/F, i, 5) P A/i lands at year 5
A perpetuity that starts late, in two moves
Checkpoint

An aqueduct costs $2,500,000 to build. It needs no maintenance for 10 years, then $60,000 a year forever, with the first payment at the end of year 11. At 8% per year, what is its capitalized cost?

A.
$3,250,000
B.
$2,821,675
C.
$2,847,400
D.
$347,400

Recap

  • Annual worth spreads every cash flow into one level yearly amount, so a first cost behaves like rent: A=P (A/P, i, n)−S (A/F, i, n)A = P\,(A/P,\ i,\ n) - S\,(A/F,\ i,\ n).
  • Position picks the factor: A/P for the front of the row, A/F for the back, and P/F then A/P over the whole life for anything in the middle.
  • EUAC reports costs as positive: O&M adds, salvage subtracts, and a removal cost adds. EAW at the MARR reads receipts as positive, and its sign says whether a project clears the MARR.
  • A monthly rate goes with a count of months, using the formulas when the tables skip that count. Run the relation backward for the largest first cost or the salvage needed.
  • A perpetuity is worth A/iA/i, one period before its first payment. Spread a bill every kk years with A/F over kk first, and move a late start back with P/F.