Comparing Alternatives

Compare options on the same footing, and ignore money that's already gone.

Before this Lesson

A water district is choosing a pump, and the spreadsheet is already done. At 10%, the present worth of Pump A's costs is $63,874. Pump B comes to $80,491. So A is about $16,600 cheaper, and everyone can go home.

Except that Pump A lasts 6 years and Pump B lasts 9. The spreadsheet just compared six years of pumping with nine. Put them on equal terms, and the cheaper pump is B.

The same footing

A choice like this is between mutually exclusive alternatives: pick one, and the others are off the table. Their numbers can be compared only if they measure the same thing, and that takes three matches:

  • The same rate. That's the MARR, your minimum acceptable rate of return, and every comparison uses it.
  • The same point in time. Everything at time 0, or everything as a yearly amount, but not one of each.
  • The same span of service. Six years of pumping isn't nine.

The Handbook prints the factors and the MARR, but no procedure for comparing alternatives, so this part is yours to bring.

When the lives match, the span takes care of itself, and the simplest method works: find the present worth of each option's costs. Count costs as plus and salvage as minus, as with annual cost, and take the lowest. A lease fits right in. It's just another row of costs, set against buying's first cost, upkeep, and resale.

Worked Example Two compressors with the same life
1 of 2

Two compressors each last 8 years. X costs $30,000, takes $5,000 a year to run, and sells for $3,000 at the end. Y costs $42,000, takes $3,000 a year to run, and sells for $5,000. The MARR is 12%. Which is more economical, and by how much?

When the lives don't match

Back to the pumps. To give them the same span, let each one repeat until they finish together. The least common multiple of 6 and 9 is 18 years: three Pump A's in a row, or two Pump B's. Now they're doing the same job, and their present worths can be compared: about $120,300 for A and $114,600 for B. B wins.

Those repeated cycles also hand you a shortcut. Every A cycle is identical, so spreading one cycle into a yearly amount gives the same row as spreading any other. Lay those rows end to end, and you have one level row across all 18 years, at the annual cost of a single cycle.

Pump A: 3 cycles of 6 years Actual cash flows Cycle 1 Cycle 2 Cycle 3 0 6 12 18 First cost $40,000 · O&M $6,000 a year · Salvage $4,000 As one level row EUAC = $14,666 every year 0 6 12 18 Pump B: 2 cycles of 9 years Actual cash flows Cycle 1 Cycle 2 0 9 18 First cost $60,000 · O&M $4,000 a year · Salvage $6,000 As one level row EUAC = $13,974 every year 0 9 18
Three A's or two B's, and one level row for each

So one life's annual cost stands for every repeated cycle, and you never need to find the 18. EUAC is already a cost per year of service, and a year of pumping is a year of pumping. That's why annual worth handles unequal lives and present worth over different lives doesn't.

The shortcut rests on an assumption, which the exam takes for granted unless it says otherwise: each replacement costs the same as the original. If a question states a study period instead, present worth works again: cut both options off at that year, and count what each is worth then as its salvage.

Worked Example The pumps, a year at a time
1 of 2

At 10% per year, find each pump's equivalent uniform annual cost, then the cheaper pump and its annual advantage.

The two pumps
PumpFirst costAnnual O&MSalvageLife
A$40,000$6,000$4,0006 years
B$60,000$4,000$6,0009 years
Checkpoint
1 of 2

Two machines last 4 and 6 years. Which of these are valid ways to compare them at the MARR?

A.
Present worth of each over its own life
B.
Annual cost of each over its own life
C.
Present worth over 12 years, with the 4-year machine bought 3 times and the 6-year machine bought twice
D.
Total cost of each, divided by its life
E.
Present worth over a stated 3-year study period, with a value for each machine at year 3

Where net present worth hits zero

So far, someone has handed you the rate. Now turn the question around: what rate does an investment actually earn? Take a $60,000 machine that returns $12,000 a year for 8 years, and find its NPW at several rates. At 0%, it's just raw dollars: +$36,000. At 8%, it's +$8,959. At 10%, +$4,019. At 12%, −$389.

The first cost sits at time 0 and never changes, while the returns shrink as the rate climbs, so NPW keeps falling. Somewhere it crosses zero.

NPW ($) 0 4 8 12 16 20 −20,000 −10,000 0 +10,000 +20,000 +30,000 +40,000 Interest rate, i (%) MARR here: accept MARR here: reject +$36,000 MARR 10%: NPW = +$4,019 MARR 15%: NPW = −$6,152 Rate of return, 11.8%
A $60,000 machine's net present worth, rate by rate

That crossing is the rate of return. The Handbook's Rate-of-Return section calls it the interest rate that makes the benefits and costs equal, which is the same as NPW = 0. Here it's about 11.8%: at that rate, the returns pay back the $60,000 plus interest, with nothing left over.

A project is acceptable when its rate of return is at least the MARR. The Handbook doesn't print that rule, and the curve lets you test it without ever finding the crossing. For an ordinary investment, money out first and back later, just compute NPW at the MARR. Positive means you're left of the crossing, so the rate of return is above the MARR. Negative means you're right of it, so it's below. Zero means it earns exactly the MARR.

One thing a rate of return can't do is pick the winner among mutually exclusive options. Would you rather earn 50% on $10 or 20% on $10,000? The rate says whether an option clears the bar. Among those that do, the higher worth at the MARR decides.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

An investment's NPW is +$8,000 at 8% and −$3,000 at 12%. Which of these are true?

A.
Its rate of return is between 8% and 12%
B.
It's acceptable at a MARR of 12%
C.
It's acceptable at a MARR of 8%
D.
It takes in fewer total dollars than it spends
E.
Its NPW is zero at its rate of return

Finding the rate from a factor

To find the crossing, set NPW to zero. With a first cost and a level row, and no salvage, only one factor is left:

0=−P+A (P/A, i, n)⇒(P/A, i, n)=PA0 = -P + A\,(P/A,\ i,\ n) \quad\Rightarrow\quad (P/A,\ i,\ n) = \frac{P}{A}

So the first cost divided by the annual return is the P/A factor. Flip it, and you have A/P. Go to the row for nn in the Handbook's Interest Rate Tables, find the two rates whose factors straddle your number, and interpolate. Or enter the NPW equation in your calculator's solver, using the factor's formula, and let it hunt for the rate.

Worked Example A rate of return with no salvage
1 of 2

A $60,000 machine returns $12,000 at the end of each year for 8 years. Find its rate of return.

Finding the rate from two trials

Add a salvage value and there are two factors, so no single lookup will do. Go back to NPW itself and try a rate. If NPW comes out positive, the crossing is to the right, so try higher. If it's negative, try lower. Once you have one of each, draw a straight line between them and see where it hits zero:

i≈i1+(i2−i1) NPW1NPW1−NPW2i \approx i_1 + (i_2 - i_1)\,\frac{\text{NPW}_1}{\text{NPW}_1 - \text{NPW}_2}

Since NPW2\text{NPW}_2 is negative, the bottom is the two sizes added together. That line is standing in for a curve, so the two rates need to be close. Take a $100,000 machine that returns $15,000 a year for 10 years and sells for $30,000. Its true rate is 10.8%. Interpolating from 10% and 12% lands right on it, while interpolating from 8% and 18% gives 11.5%.

NPW ($) 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 −30,000 −20,000 −10,000 0 +10,000 +20,000 +30,000 Interest rate, i (%) NPW 10% and 12%: 10.8% 8% and 18%: 11.5%
One curve, interpolated two ways

Watch for this in the Handbook's tables, which jump from 12% straight to 18%. For a rate in that gap, use a solver, or the factor formulas at a rate in between.

Worked Example A rate of return with salvage
1 of 3

Take that same machine: $100,000 up front, $15,000 a year for 10 years, and $30,000 at the end. Estimate its rate of return by interpolating.

Only what differs, from here on

So far, every number has been a future cash flow that differs between options. Those are the only numbers a decision can change, so everything else drops out. The Handbook doesn't define the terms below, but the exam uses them.

A town is choosing between a box culvert and a pipe. It has already spent $60,000 on plans for the box and $25,000 on plans for the pipe. Those are sunk costs: gone, whichever way the town goes. Either option needs the same $30,000 of traffic control. That's a common cost: it's in both, so it cancels. What's left is $110,000 to build the box and $90,000 to build the pipe. The incremental cost of the box is the difference, $20,000.

$60,000 $25,000 Sunk: already spent $30,000 $30,000 Common: in both $110,000 $90,000 Box culvert Pipe Today $20,000 incremental cost
Only the top of each stack is still a decision

Total each column and you'd say the box costs $55,000 more. But $35,000 of that gap is past spending, and nothing the town decides today can change it.

Checkpoint

A plant has a worn conveyor. Last year it spent $9,000 on a repair study, and it has paid a $14,000 nonrefundable deposit toward a new conveyor. Repairing now costs $32,000. Buying new costs another $58,000. Either way, $6,000 of floor work is needed. What is the incremental cost of buying new rather than repairing?

dollars

The cost with no invoice

A firm owns a lot it bought years ago for $100,000. The estimate for a new warehouse lists the land at $0, since the firm already owns it. But the lot would sell for $400,000 today, and building on it gives that up. That's an opportunity cost: the value of the best alternative you turn down. The land costs this project $400,000, not $0, and not the $100,000 from years ago.

Cash has one too. Pull $50,000 out of an account paying 4%, and you give up $2,000 a year in interest.

Checkpoint

A contractor owns a yard it bought for $200,000 years ago, and it could rent the yard out for $40,000 a year. Instead, it plans to use the yard for its own precast plant. What is the opportunity cost of that choice?

A.
Nothing, since the yard is already paid for
B.
The $200,000 it paid for the yard
C.
The cost of building the precast plant
D.
The $40,000 a year in rent it gives up

Book value is a ledger entry

Accountants spread a first cost over the years of use. Straight-line depreciation takes the same amount each year, from the first cost CC down to the expected salvage SnS_n over nn years. The Handbook's Depreciation and Book Value entries give:

Dj=C−SnnBV=initial cost−∑DjD_j = \frac{C - S_n}{n} \qquad\quad BV = \text{initial cost} - \sum D_j

A truck that costs $90,000, with a $10,000 salvage and an 8-year life, depreciates by $10,000 a year, so its book value after 3 years is $60,000. But that's a bookkeeping line, and nobody has offered that price. A buyer might pay $48,000. And no check goes out for depreciation, so before taxes it has no place in a comparison of cash flows.

Value ($) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 0 20,000 40,000 60,000 80,000 100,000 Year Book value Market value $60,000 $48,000
Book value follows a rule, and market value follows buyers
The market curve is illustrative.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

An excavator costs $150,000 and has a $30,000 salvage value at the end of its 10-year life. What is its straight-line book value after 4 years?

dollars

Keep it or replace it

Now put it together. That truck cost $90,000 three years ago, its book value is $60,000, and a dealer offers $48,000 today. Should you replace it? The $90,000 is sunk, and the $60,000 is a ledger line. The only real money in that story is the $48,000, because keeping the truck means turning down that check. So in the comparison, keeping it starts with a $48,000 cost at time 0. And the $12,000 between book and market isn't a loss that selling would cause. That value is already gone, whether or not the ledger has noticed.

A half-built project works the same way. Say a garage has $3 million in it, needs $2 million more, and will be worth $2.5 million when done. As it stands, the site would sell for $0.2 million. Finishing nets $0.5 million, and selling nets $0.2 million, so finish. The $3 million appears nowhere. If finishing took $2.4 million, it would net only $0.1 million, and you should walk away, however much it hurts.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A crane bought 5 years ago for $300,000 has a book value of $120,000. A dealer will pay $80,000 for it today. In comparing keeping it with replacing it, what amount stands for the old crane at time 0?

A.
$120,000, its book value
B.
$40,000, the loss from selling below book value
C.
$300,000, its original price
D.
$80,000, its market value

Recap

  • Options compare fairly only with the same rate (the MARR), the same point in time, and the same span of service. Use present worth of costs for equal lives, and EUAC, or present worth over a common multiple or study period, for unequal lives.
  • NPW falls as the rate rises and crosses zero at the rate of return, so its sign at the MARR tells you which side the rate of return is on. Among acceptable options, the higher worth at the MARR decides.
  • Find a rate of return from a P/A or A/P factor, from two close rates with NPWs of opposite sign, or with a solver.
  • Only future cash flows that differ matter. Sunk and common costs drop out, opportunity costs count, and market value counts where the original price and book value don't.
  • Straight-line depreciation is (C−Sn)/n(C - S_n)/n a year. Book value is an accounting figure, not a cash flow.