Traffic Loading and ESALs

One heavy truck axle can do the damage of thousands of cars.

Before this Lesson

A highway carries 20,000 cars and 1,000 loaded tractor-semitrailers a day. The cars outnumber the trucks twenty to one, so you might guess they do most of the wear. They don't come close. The 1,000 trucks do more than 300 times the damage of all 20,000 cars put together.

The reason is the weight on each axle, and how steeply damage climbs with it. Once you can measure that, you can turn a day of truck traffic into the 20-year total a pavement is designed to carry.

Pavements wear out one axle at a time

A pavement doesn't fail the way an overloaded beam does, under one load too big for it. Each axle that rolls over bends it a little, and it springs back. Bend a paperclip once and nothing happens; bend it a few dozen times and it snaps. A pavement works the same way, except the count runs into the millions. So what matters about traffic is how many axles cross the pavement and how heavy each one is.

That leaves a bookkeeping problem, because a 10-kip axle and a 30-kip axle aren't the same pass. The fix is one common currency, the 18-kip equivalent single axle load, or ESAL. One pass of a single axle carrying 18,000 lb is one ESAL. Any other axle converts through its load equivalency factor (LEF), the number of 18-kip passes that would do the same damage. An axle with an LEF of 0.5 does half the standard's damage, and one with an LEF of 3 does as much as three. A whole stream of axles then collapses to one number:

ESALs=∑ (number of axles)×LEF\text{ESALs} = \sum\,(\text{number of axles})\times\text{LEF}

The factors aren't derived from theory. They come from the AASHO Road Test, run in Illinois from 1958 to 1960, where test trucks with known axle loads drove laps of test pavement for two years while engineers tracked how fast each section wore out. The Handbook prints them in a table in its Highway Pavement Design section, from 1,000 lb to 50,000 lb for single axles and up to 80,000 lb for tandems, with each load in both lb and kN. The rows below are the part this Lesson uses.

Load equivalency factors, 10,000 to 40,000 lb
Gross axle load (lb)Single axlesTandem axles
10,0000.08770.00688
12,0000.1890.0144
14,0000.3600.0270
15,0000.4780.0360
16,0000.6230.0472
18,0001.0000.0773
20,0001.510.1206
22,0002.180.180
24,0003.030.260
25,0003.530.308
26,0004.090.364
28,0005.390.495
30,0006.970.658
32,0008.880.857
34,00011.181.095
35,00012.501.23
36,00013.931.38
38,00017.201.70
40,00021.082.08

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Highway Pavement Design

Damage climbs with the fourth power

Read down the table's single-axle column and the numbers take off. A 12-kip axle is worth 0.189 ESAL, 18 kips is 1 by definition, 24 kips is 3.03, and 36 kips is 13.93. Doubling the load from 18 to 36 kips multiplied the damage by nearly 14.

A rule of thumb captures the trend: damage grows roughly with the fourth power of the axle load PP.

LEF≈(P18 kips)4\text{LEF} \approx \left(\frac{P}{18\ \text{kips}}\right)^{4}

Double the load and the rule predicts 24=162^4 = 16, where the table says 13.93. That's close enough to reason with, but the Handbook doesn't print the rule, so when you need a number, use the table.

1 ESAL 0510152025303540 05101520 Gross axle load (kips) Load equivalency factor Single axle Tandem axle 18-kip single = 1 13.93 1.38
Load equivalency factors for single and tandem axles
Plotted from the Handbook's table. The single-axle curve hugs zero until about 15 kips, then sweeps upward.

Source: FE Reference Handbook, Highway Pavement Design

At the light end, a car barely registers. The table gives 0.00018 for a 2,000-lb single axle, so a 4,000-lb car on two of them is worth 0.00036 ESAL. It takes about 2,800 cars to do the damage of one 18-kip axle. The Hook's 20,000 cars add up to about 7 ESALs a day, and a loaded tractor-semitrailer comes to about 2.4 ESALs per pass, as you'll see below. All those cars together do the damage of three trucks. That's why pavement design counts trucks and lets the cars round to zero.

Two axles sharing a load

A heavy truck carries most of its weight on tandems, pairs of axles about 4 ft apart that work as a unit. The table gives tandems their own column, which you enter with the total load on the pair, not the load on each axle. In an axle count, a tandem counts once, as one unit. A 36-kip tandem, with 18 kips on each axle, is worth 1.38 ESALs. Put the same 36 kips on one single axle and it's worth 13.93, ten times as much.

The tandem puts the load on twice as many tires spread along a longer stretch of road, so the pavement bends into a broader, shallower bowl. Each axle carries half the load, and with damage climbing as the fourth power, half the load does far less than half the damage. The pair even does less than two separate 18-kip singles would, 1.38 against 2.0, because its axles sit so close that the pavement bends under them almost as one broad load.

Single axle LEF = 13.93 36 kips Tandem axle, 36 kips total LEF = 1.38 18 kips 18 kips about 4 ft Deflections exaggerated
The same 36 kips on one axle and on two

Turned around, a tandem has to carry about 33 kips, nearly twice the standard load, before it does the damage of one 18-kip single.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A single axle that should carry 20 kips is overloaded by 20%, to 24 kips. About how much more damage does each pass do?

A.
About 20% more
B.
About 44% more
C.
About twice as much
D.
About four times as much

Counting a day of axles

Two habits keep the lookups in the table straight:

  • Choose the column by axle type. A tandem goes in the tandem column at the pair's total load. Reading a 34-kip tandem in the single column gives 11.18 instead of 1.095.
  • Interpolate between rows. A 27-kip single axle sits halfway between 26,000 lb (4.09) and 28,000 lb (5.39), so its factor sits halfway too, at 4.74.

With each factor in hand, multiply by its count and add. Axle counts usually come per day, so that sum is daily ESALs. Multiply by 365 for a year's worth, the same daily-to-annual step as in Crash Rates and Countermeasures.

Worked Example Daily and annual ESALs from an axle count
1 of 2

A weigh-in-motion station records, per day, 800 single axles at 12 kips, 150 single axles at 23 kips, and 500 tandem axles at 34 kips. Find the daily and annual ESALs.

Truck factors

Traffic counts usually arrive as trucks, not axles. A truck factor is the ESALs one pass of a truck does: the sum of the factors of all its axles, including the light steering axle up front. Each axle group is read in its own column, a single in the single column and a tandem in the tandem column at its total load.

80 kips total Steering axle single, 12 kips Drive tandem 34 kips Trailer tandem 34 kips
A five-axle tractor-semitrailer at 80 kips

A tractor-semitrailer loaded to the 80,000-lb federal limit typically carries about 12 kips on its steering axle and 34 kips on each tandem, the federal limit for a tandem. Its truck factor is:

TF=0.189+1.095+1.095=2.38 ESALs per truck\text{TF} = 0.189 + 1.095 + 1.095 = 2.38\ \text{ESALs per truck}

The steering axle is only 8% of that total, which is why it's easy to forget, and why forgetting it gives a wrong answer that looks right. With the truck factor known, the daily ESALs are just the trucks per day times the truck factor.

Checkpoint

A tractor-semitrailer has a 10-kip steering axle, a drive tandem with 16 kips on each axle, and a trailer tandem with 15 kips on each axle. What is its truck factor?

A.
1.52
B.
2.29
C.
1.60
D.
0.17

From one year to the design period

A pavement is designed for its whole design period, often 20 years, and truck traffic grows. If the first year brings W1W_1 ESALs and traffic grows at a rate gg a year, the second year brings W1(1+g)W_1(1 + g), the third W1(1+g)2W_1(1 + g)^2, and so on. Adding up all nn years:

W1[1+(1+g)+(1+g)2+⋯+(1+g)n−1]=W1 (1+g)n−1gW_1\left[1 + (1+g) + (1+g)^2 + \cdots + (1+g)^{n-1}\right] = W_1\,\frac{(1+g)^n - 1}{g}

That bracket is the Uniform Series Compound Amount factor, (F/A, i%, n)(F/A,\ i\%,\ n), from the Handbook's Engineering Economics section, with gg in place of ii, just as in Uniform Series and Equivalence. As with interest, gg goes in as a decimal, so 4% is 0.04.

That total counts both directions and every lane, but the pavement is designed for its most heavily loaded lane. Two factors narrow it down:

  • The directional distribution factor DDD_D is the share of the two-way ESALs traveling in the heavier direction, usually 0.5.
  • The lane distribution factor DLD_L is the share of that direction's ESALs in the design lane, the outer lane where trucks stay. It's 1.0 with one lane each way and less with more lanes.
Design-lane ESALs=W1 (1+g)n−1g DD DL\text{Design-lane ESALs} = W_1\,\frac{(1+g)^n - 1}{g}\,D_D\,D_L

The Handbook prints none of this: no ESAL equation, no traffic growth factor, and no distribution factors. A question gives DDD_D and DLD_L, and the growth factor is the F/A formula. Apply DDD_D only to two-way traffic. A count taken in the design direction alone has already been split, so it takes DLD_L and nothing more.

Worked Example Design-lane ESALs over 20 years
1 of 3

A highway with two lanes each way carries 1,500 tractor-semitrailers a day in both directions, each with the truck factor of 2.38 found above. Truck traffic grows 4% a year, DD=0.5D_D = 0.5, and DL=0.9D_L = 0.9. Find the design-lane ESALs for a 20-year design period.

That design-lane total is the traffic a pavement's layers are sized to carry in Flexible Pavement Structural Number.

Recap

  • Pavements wear out under repeated axle passes, so traffic is counted in 18-kip ESALs. An axle's load equivalency factor is the number of 18-kip single-axle passes that do its damage.
  • Damage climbs roughly with the fourth power of axle load, so heavy trucks govern and cars round to zero.
  • A tandem does far less damage than a single axle carrying the same total. Read it in the tandem column at the pair's total load.
  • Daily ESALs sum each count times its factor, interpolating between rows, and annual ESALs are 365 times that. A truck factor sums every axle, steering axle included.
  • Design-lane ESALs are W1 [(1+g)n−1]/g×DD×DLW_1\,[(1+g)^n - 1]/g \times D_D \times D_L, with gg as a decimal and DDD_D applied only to two-way traffic.