Contracts and Professional Liability
A contract decides who pays when costs run over, and negligence decides who pays when something fails.
Before this Lesson
A contractor starts a sewer job for a city, expecting it to cost $1,000,000 to build, and hits rock nobody knew was there. Nobody was careless. The job will now cost $1,300,000, because that's what the ground costs. So who finds the extra $300,000?
You can't work that out from the rock. It was settled months ago, when someone chose a type of contract. Under one type, the contractor earns more because of the rock.
The exam asks about contracts and liability, but the Handbook's Ethics and Professional Practice section is all licensure and conduct. It prints nothing on contract types, contract law, or civil liability, so everything here is yours to carry in.
Who pays when it runs over
Two parties to start. The owner wants something built and pays for it, here the city. The contractor builds it. Before the first shovel, neither knows what the job will really cost, so the contract has to settle one question in advance: who pays if it costs more than expected?
Every contract type answers it the same way. Look at what the contract fixes. What's fixed, the contractor has to live with. What's left open, the owner pays for.
Take the two extremes on the sewer job. Say the contractor expects to spend $1,000,000 and wants $100,000 of profit.
A lump sum contract, also called single fixed price, fixes the total. The contractor says $1,100,000, and the city pays $1,100,000 however the digging goes. With the rock, the contractor spends $1,300,000 and loses $200,000. Had the digging gone easily, the contractor would have kept the savings. Either way, the city's bill doesn't move. Real contracts often add a clause that hands surprise ground back to the owner, but left alone, a lump sum leaves it with the contractor.
Cost plus a fee fixes almost nothing. The city pays the actual cost plus a fee, say a fixed fee of $100,000. With the rock, the city pays $1,400,000, and the contractor still makes its $100,000.
At the estimate, the two deals cost the city the same. They part ways only when reality does.
Fixing the rate, not the total
Some work sits in between. You know exactly what a cubic yard of excavation is. You just don't know how many you'll move until you're in the ground. A unit price contract fixes the rate per unit, and the owner pays that rate on whatever quantity is actually measured. So the risk splits in two: the quantity is the owner's, and what each unit costs to produce is the contractor's.
When nobody can describe the job
Lump sum and unit price have something in common: the contractor has to price something up front, a total or a rate. But nobody can price what nobody can describe. Ask for a lump sum on work that can't yet be defined, and you get a padded number, then a fight over every change.
A fast-tracked project runs into the same wall. To save calendar time, construction starts before the design is finished.
The deal that pays for spending
Now the deal from the Hook. Under cost plus a percentage of cost, the fee is a share of whatever gets spent, say 10%. At the estimate, that's $1,000,000 plus $100,000, the same as before. With the rock, it's $1,300,000 plus $130,000. The job went worse, and the contractor made $30,000 more.
You don't need a crooked contractor for this to matter. Picture the ordinary daily choices: the pricier pump or the cheaper one, one more crew on overtime or not. Under this deal, every dollar spent comes back as a dollar and ten cents, and every dollar saved costs the contractor a dime.
Two alternatives take that reward away. A fixed fee flattens the line: extra spending earns nothing, though the owner still pays the overrun. A guaranteed maximum price (GMP) goes further. It's cost plus a fee with a ceiling. The owner pays the actual cost and the fee up to an agreed maximum, and above that, the contractor pays. Set the ceiling at $1,200,000, and with the rock, the city's bill stops there. Next to the fixed-fee deal, that moves $200,000 onto the contractor: the last $100,000 of cost, and its $100,000 fee.
Lining them up
That's five deals and one rule: what's fixed, the contractor lives with, and what's left open, the owner pays for. Try it on both ends.
Here's the whole range. The ends follow straight from that rule, and they're what the exam asks about. The two bracketed deals split the risk differently, a GMP at its ceiling and unit price between rate and quantity, so don't read much into their order.
What makes it a contract
Step back from the money. What makes an agreement a contract at all? A contract is a promise a court will enforce, and before it enforces anything, a court wants to see five things:
- Offer: one party proposes definite terms.
- Acceptance: the other party agrees to those terms.
- Consideration: each side gives something of value. That's what separates a deal from a favor. This isn't rule C.2's "valuable consideration," which means a gift or commission to win work.
- Competent parties: each side is legally able to agree, which generally rules out a minor or someone a court has found incapacitated. This has nothing to do with engineering competence.
- Lawful purpose: no court will enforce a deal to do something illegal.
That's the whole list. Anything else, however official it looks, is something people add around a contract, not part of what makes one.
When the promise breaks
A breach is a failure to do what the contract promised. Courts usually answer with money, and one breach shows the two main kinds. A contractor walks off a half-built store, and the owner has to pay a replacement $60,000 more than the original price. That's the direct loss of the bargain, and money to cover it is compensatory damages, enough to put the owner where the contract would have. The store then opens four months late and loses $90,000 in sales. That's a knock-on loss, coming from what the owner meant to do with the building rather than from the work itself, and money for it is consequential damages.
Sometimes money won't do. If a seller backs out of selling the one parcel a pump station has to sit on, no damages can buy another. So a court can order specific performance: do what you promised. Courts keep that for one-of-a-kind things like land, and rarely use it to make anyone finish building.
Who decides all this? There are three routes.
| Method | Who decides | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Mediation | The parties, with a mediator's help | Nonbinding |
| Arbitration | A private arbitrator | Binding |
| Litigation | A judge or jury, in court | Binding, subject to appeal |
A mediator helps you decide. An arbitrator decides for you. Litigation is the lawsuit, public and usually the slowest and costliest of the three.
Negligence: paying without a contract
Everything so far has been between people who signed something. The family on a collapsing balcony signed nothing with the engineer, and they can still make the engineer pay. That's negligence: a civil claim that you harmed someone by failing to use the care you owed them.
The Handbook uses the word only in the Model Law's grounds for disciplinary action, and never defines it. That's the board acting on your license. A negligence claim is about who pays, and one error can lead to both.
A claim has to prove four things, and they work like a chain.
Duty is usually the easy link: you owe care to your client and to anyone your work could foreseeably hurt. Breach is where the standard of care goes to work, and here it means falling short of that care, not breaking a contract's promise.
The care a reasonably competent engineer would exercise in similar circumstances, not perfection or a guarantee of results. A failure alone doesn't show you fell short. For more, see Licensure, Seals, and Responsible Charge.
The last two are the ones people forget. Your error has to be what caused the harm, and there has to be harm.
How far it reaches you
One more question. A beam fails, and people die. A claim will name the firm, and it may well reach individuals too. How far?
You know part of the answer already. The Handbook's definition of responsible charge ends with "Accept full responsibility for the work," and that's as far as it goes on the subject. For the rest, compare three engineers, each at a different firm where this has happened.
- The salaried engineer who sealed the beam. She works for a corporation and owns none of it, so the firm's debts aren't hers. But the beam is her own work, and she can be held liable for it personally. The corporate name doesn't stand between her and her own negligence.
- The general partner who never saw the beam. Another partner handled that job. But a partnership has no wall between the business and its owners, so the firm's debt is his debt too.
- The shareholder who never saw the beam. She also owns part of her firm and also never touched the job, but her firm is a corporation. That wall keeps the firm's debts from reaching her.