Overview
Ethics questions on the FE aren't testing whether you're a good person. They test one fixed priority order, so the answer key never changes: protect the public first, then choose the option that's most open about the problem.
That order comes from the NCEES Model Rules, whose Rules of Professional Conduct the Handbook reprints. Four ideas run through this topic, and most of its ethics questions come down to spotting which one is in play.
A license exists to protect the public. You drive across a bridge without checking the calculations, because you couldn't check them if you tried. So the state checks the person instead. Its licensing board decides who may practice and disciplines violations, and the Handbook's Model Law excerpt lets it fine anyone practicing without a license, however good their work happens to be.
Duties form a ladder. The public is on the top rung, employer and clients are in the middle, and other licensees are at the bottom. When two duties collide, the higher rung wins.
Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Rules of Professional Conduct
The Handbook groups its rules by the same three audiences, so the ladder doubles as a way to find a rule: ask who it protects. The Handbook doesn't rank the groups outright, and only calls the public's safety your "first and foremost responsibility," but the exam's answers follow this order.
A seal means personal responsibility for work you controlled. Your seal on a drawing says, "I did this or directed it as it was done, and I answer for it." The Handbook's rules bar sealing anything else, so a careful look at someone's finished work doesn't qualify, and your employer can't take the promise over for you.
When duties conflict, disclose through proper channels. A problem in the open can be dealt with, and a hidden one can't. So a hazard, a design error, or a conflict of interest gets told to someone who can act on it, beginning with your employer or client. Silence fails, and so does a call to a reporter. The ladder tells you whose interest wins, and disclosure is how you act on it.
The elimination habit
Those ideas, plus the rule that you practice only in fields you're qualified in, boil down to a routine for any ethics question, which this topic calls the elimination habit:
- Eliminate any answer that puts profit, convenience, or loyalty ahead of public safety.
- Eliminate any answer that has the engineer practicing outside their competence or sealing work they didn't control.
- Among what remains, pick the most transparent option that uses proper channels.
Here it is on a typical question. Your client, short on budget, tells you to thin a parking deck's slab below what your calculations require, and you believe that endangers the people who'll use the deck. What do you do?
- A. Thin the slab, since the client is paying for it.
- B. Seal an alternate slab design drawn by the contractor's designer, after checking it carefully.
- C. Leave the full slab on the drawings, and tell no one.
- D. Warn the client in writing of the possible consequences, and notify the building official if the danger isn't corrected.
A puts the client's money first, and B seals work you didn't control. C keeps the slab safe for now, but nobody knows there's a dispute, so the next revision can undo it. D is what's left, and it puts the risk in front of people who can act.
Which idea is it?
Each of these situations calls for one of the four ideas. Name the one that decides it.
During a confidential inspection, you find a hazard in an occupied building, and your client asks you to keep it quiet. Which idea settles whether you can do as your client asks?
A developer offers you a fee to seal a finished set of drawings you had no part in preparing. Which idea does this call for?
You're evaluating bids for a client, and your brother owns one of the bidding contractors. You're sure you can score every bid fairly. Which idea does this call for?
A state board fines someone who's been selling engineering designs without a license. None of the designs has failed. Which idea explains why the board acts anyway?
The Lessons below fill in the rules behind each idea. Contracts and Professional Liability is the exception: its questions ask who pays when costs run over or something fails, so the ladder and the habit step aside there.
Lessons
- 1Obligations to the PublicWhen safety and loyalty collide, safety wins, and the engineer says so in writing.
- 2Professional CompetenceA license in civil engineering doesn't make you an electrical engineer.
- 3Conflicts of InterestThe appearance of a conflict counts, so disclose it before anyone else finds it.
- 4Licensure, Seals, and Responsible ChargeA seal is a signature on your own work, never a rubber stamp on someone else's.
- 5Contracts and Professional LiabilityA contract decides who pays when costs run over, and negligence decides who pays when something fails.