Time Rate of Consolidation
Clay settles as fast as water can escape it, and halving the drainage path makes it four times faster.
Before this Lesson
The distribution center in Consolidation Settlement will settle 8.5 in under its 6 ft of fill. The owner's next question is one the settlement equation can't answer: when can the floor slab go down?
It depends on what lies under the clay. If the boring finds sand, 90 percent of the settlement is over in about 2.3 years. If it finds rock, the same clay under the same fill needs more than 9 years. Nothing about the clay changed, only how far its water has to travel.
The settlement waits for the water
Recall from Changing Effective Stress what happens the day a fill goes onto saturated clay. The water in the pores can't get out of the way, so it carries the whole new load as excess pore pressure, and hasn't changed yet. The clay compresses only as that water leaves, like Terzaghi's piston sinking only as fast as water leaks through its hole. So the rate of settlement is the rate at which water escapes.
The water escapes to the nearest boundary that drains: a layer of sand or gravel, or the ground surface. It can't flow into unfractured rock or a much tighter soil, so those boundaries count as impermeable. The drainage path is the longest distance any of the clay's water must travel to reach a draining boundary.
Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Different types of drainage with u₀ constant
With sand above and below, the clay drains both ways. Water in the upper half goes up, water in the lower half goes down, and the water with the farthest to go sits at mid-depth, so is half the layer. With rock below, every drop has to go up, and the water at the bottom has to cross the whole layer, so is the full thickness. The Handbook makes the same point in its sketches of the types of drainage, where a layer drained both ways is thick.
Twice the path, four times the wait
Doubling the drainage path doesn't double the time. It quadruples it, because two things work against you at once.
First, the excess pore pressure is the push that drives the water out. Over a path twice as long, that push is spread over twice the distance, so the hydraulic gradient is half as steep, and by Darcy's law the water flows half as fast. Second, twice the path means twice as much clay draining toward each boundary, so twice as much water has to leave. Half the speed and twice the water: four times the wait.
The Handbook packs this square law into one dimensionless number, the time factor, printed beneath its table of the degree of consolidation:
Here is the time since the load went on, and is the clay's coefficient of consolidation, which combines how easily water flows through it with how much it compresses. Its units are a length squared over a time, such as ft²/day, m²/yr, or cm²/s, and the Handbook leaves them to you: keep in the same time unit as , and in the same length unit.
Think of as a clock that runs in the clay's own units of time, . Every layer, thick or thin, reaches the same degree of consolidation at the same , so to find how long that takes, solve for :
Notice what isn't in it: the load. A heavier fill makes the clay settle more, but on the same schedule. The load sets how much, and the drainage path and set how fast.
Reading the time factor table
The time factor is the clock reading, and the Handbook's table turns it into progress. , the average degree of consolidation, is the fraction of its ultimate settlement the layer has reached, which is also the fraction of its excess pore pressure that has drained away, averaged over the layer. The table, Variation of time factor with degree of consolidation, lists for every whole percent of . Its values come from Terzaghi's theory for an excess pore pressure that starts out the same at every depth, as under a widespread fill. Here are a few of its rows:
| U (%) | U (%) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 0.00785 | 60 | 0.286 |
| 20 | 0.0314 | 70 | 0.403 |
| 30 | 0.0707 | 80 | 0.567 |
| 40 | 0.126 | 90 | 0.848 |
| 50 | 0.197 | 95 | 1.129 |
Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Variation of time factor with degree of consolidation
Plot the table and you can see how consolidation goes. It starts fast, because the water near the boundaries has only a short way to travel, and half the settlement is done by . Then it slows, because the water that's left is deep in the layer and the pressure pushing it out has faded. Reaching 90 percent takes until , more than four times as long, and 100 percent never quite arrives, which is why questions ask about 90 or 95 percent.
So is not proportional to time. Early on it's the square law again: going from 30 to 60 percent takes four times the time factor, 0.286 against 0.0707.
Now the Hook. The 20 ft clay has ft²/day. With sand below it as well as above, it drains both ways and ft, so 90 percent takes
With rock below, ft. The time factor for 90 percent is still 0.848, and the time is four times as long: 3,392 days, or 9.3 years.
How far along is it?
Most questions want a settlement, not a percent. The Handbook writes the settlement reached at a time as
where is the ultimate settlement, the you computed in Consolidation Settlement, and is the average degree of consolidation, the table's as a decimal. From an elapsed time, the chain runs . When falls between the rows above, interpolate; on the exam, the Handbook's full table lets you read to the nearest percent.
Some questions run the chain backward: when will the layer have settled a given amount? Divide the settlement by the ultimate to get , read from the table, and solve for . Don't scale the time in proportion to the settlement; the curve above shows why that fails.
Measuring the coefficient of consolidation
is measured in the same consolidation test that gives . A thin specimen, about an inch or 20 to 25 mm thick, sits between two porous stones, so it drains top and bottom, like the left panel of the drainage figure. Its is half its thickness. For a load increment, the lab records settlement against time and reads off the time to 50 or 90 percent consolidation, or . The Handbook doesn't describe the test, but its time factor equation, solved for , is all you need:
If you only need the field time for the same , you can skip . Same clay and same mean the same , so the time scales with the square of the drainage path:
Watch the units. Lab times come in minutes, with paths in inches or millimeters; field times come in years, with paths in feet or meters.
Shortening the path
A thick clay can take longer than any project can wait. A 40 ft layer of the Hook's clay, drained top and bottom, has ft and needs 9.3 years to reach 90 percent. The square law says where to attack: the path.
Wick drains, also called prefabricated vertical drains, are flat plastic cores wrapped in filter fabric, pushed down through the clay in a grid a few feet apart, with a sand blanket on top to carry the water away. The water no longer has to travel 20 ft up or down. It moves sideways a few feet to the nearest drain, then up the drain. Cut the path from 20 ft to a few feet, and because time goes with its square, years become months. (The exact analysis of flow toward a drain is beyond the FE exam; the shorter path is the idea.)
What the drains don't change is the ultimate settlement. That comes from , , , and the stresses, and a drain alters none of them. The clay settles just as much, only sooner. Drainage changes how fast a clay settles, never how much.
Preloading attacks the problem from the other side: it lets the settlement happen before there's anything to damage. A fill goes on the site before construction, often heavier than the future structure, which makes it a surcharge. It stays until the clay has settled as much as the structure would make it settle, and then it's removed and the structure is built. Drains and a preload often work together, the drains making the preload's wait months instead of years. The Handbook doesn't mention either one, so questions about them test the ideas rather than a formula.