Concrete Modulus of Elasticity

Stronger, heavier concrete is stiffer, but only by a square root.

Two concretes go to the same lab. One is made with ordinary crushed stone and weighs 145 lb/ft³. The other uses a bubbly manufactured aggregate and weighs 110 lb/ft³. Their cylinders both break at 4,000 psi, so on the strength report they look identical.

Now stand two same-size columns of them under the same load and measure how much each one shortens. The lighter one gives about 50% more. The cylinder break never hinted at that, because it answers a different question. Strength says when concrete fails. This Lesson is about how much it gives before that, and how to get that number from the strength and the weight alone.

Why concrete has no one modulus

Steel makes this easy. The Handbook's Table 2 - Average Mechanical Properties of Typical Engineering Materials gives A36 structural steel a yield strength of 36 ksi and L2 tool steel a yield strength of 102 ksi, and it gives both the same modulus, 29,000 ksi. A steel's grade changes when its atoms start to slip, not how stiff the bonds between them are, so every structural grade shares one number.

Concrete doesn't. The same table lists 3,200 ksi for low-strength concrete and 4,200 ksi for high-strength. To see why, remember what concrete is: stiff rock held in softer paste. Load it, and the load runs through both, so how much the whole thing gives depends on how stiff each part is. That leaves two ways to change it:

  • Stronger paste. A pore is a hole where nothing pushes back. Lower W/CW/C and you get fewer of them, so the paste becomes stronger and stiffer at the same time. That's why strength and stiffness climb together in concrete, as they don't in steel.
  • Stiffer rock. Ordinary stone is a good deal stiffer than paste, and it fills most of the volume. Lightweight aggregate, such as expanded shale or clay, is rock puffed full of air bubbles. The bubbles make it light, and they make it soft.

Unit weight is how that second one shows from the outside: a heavier mix has more solid and less air in every cubic foot.

P P δ 1.5δ dense stone paste porous aggregate paste Normal-weight wc = 145 lb/ft3 Lightweight wc = 110 lb/ft3 Same size, same f'c = 4,000 psi, same load P
The same load on two concretes of the same strength
Schematic, with the shortening greatly exaggerated. The porous aggregate gives more than dense stone does, so the lightweight block shortens about 1.5 times as far.

One formula for both

The Handbook's Design of Reinforced Concrete Components section (ACI 318-14) puts strength and weight together in one line of its definitions:

Ec=33 wc1.5fc′E_c = 33\,w_c^{1.5}\sqrt{f'_c}

Here EcE_c is the modulus in psi, fc′f'_c is the compressive strength in psi, and wcw_c is what the Handbook calls the "weight of concrete," in lb/ft³. Everyone else calls it the unit weight. The power wc1.5w_c^{1.5} is just wcwcw_c\sqrt{w_c}, and your calculator's power key does it directly.

Now try the units. Lb/ft³ to the 1.5 power times the square root of psi doesn't come out to psi, or to anything else you'd recognize. That isn't a mistake. Nobody derived this equation from first principles. It's a curve fitted to a great many tests, and the 33 is the calibration that makes it land on the data, as long as you use the units it was fitted in. So the rule is firm: fc′f'_c in psi, not ksi, and wcw_c in lb/ft³. The answer comes out in psi, a number in the millions, and dividing by 1,000 gives ksi.

Worked Example The modulus of an ordinary mix
1 of 2

A concrete has a unit weight of 145 lb/ft³ and a 28-day compressive strength of 4,000 psi. Find its modulus of elasticity, in ksi.

Lightweight concrete, the soft case

Lightweight concrete gets no equation of its own. It goes through the same formula with a smaller wcw_c, and the 1.5 power does the rest. The Handbook prints no unit weight for lightweight concrete, so a question has to state it.

To compare two concretes of the same strength, you can skip most of the arithmetic. Write the formula for each and divide. The 33 and the fc′\sqrt{f'_c} cancel, so only the weights are left:

Ec1Ec2=(wc1wc2)1.5\frac{E_{c1}}{E_{c2}} = \left(\frac{w_{c1}}{w_{c2}}\right)^{1.5}

Since strength has cancelled, that ratio is the same at every strength. And under the same stress, strain is σ/E\sigma/E, so shortening goes as one over the modulus: half the modulus, twice the shortening.

Worked Example Back to the two columns
1 of 3

Both concretes from the opening have fc′=4,000 psif'_c = 4{,}000\ \text{psi}. The 145 lb/ft³ one has Ec=3,644 ksiE_c = 3{,}644\ \text{ksi}. Find the modulus of the 110 lb/ft³ one, and how much farther its column shortens under the same load.

Reading the exponents

The exponents say how hard each input pulls. Hold wcw_c fixed and double the strength, and EcE_c grows by 2=1.41\sqrt{2} = 1.41. Twice the strength buys only 41% more stiffness.

Why so little? The formula won't say, since it only records what the tests show. But the picture of rock in paste helps: a better paste does nothing to the rock, which was already supplying much of the stiffness, so improving the paste moves only part of the total.

Unit weight pulls harder. Raise wcw_c by 10%, and EcE_c rises 15%, because 1.101.5=1.151.10^{1.5} = 1.15. Raise fc′f'_c by 10%, and it rises only 5%.

0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 f'c (psi) Ec (ksi) wc = 145 lb/ft3 wc = 110 lb/ft3 f'c doubles Ec × 1.41 × 0.66 3,644 ksi 5,154 ksi 2,408 ksi
Modulus against strength at two unit weights
Each curve flattens as strength climbs: doubling the strength multiplies the modulus by only 1.41. The lower curve stays at 0.66 of the upper one at every strength.

The 57,000 shortcut

Most concrete is made with ordinary stone and weighs close to 145 lb/ft³. Put that weight in, and 33(145)1.5=57,60033(145)^{1.5} = 57{,}600. Design codes round that off and give it as a shortcut for normal-weight concrete:

Ec=57,000fc′E_c = 57{,}000\sqrt{f'_c}

It's the same formula with the weight already built in, still with fc′f'_c in psi and EcE_c in psi. The Handbook prints only the general formula, so the shortcut is yours to recognize. And it's only as good as that built-in weight. For the 110 lb/ft³ concrete, it gives 3,605 ksi where the formula gives 2,408 ksi: about 50% too stiff.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

A mix's fc′f'_c rises from 4,000 to 5,000 psi, and its unit weight doesn't change. About how much does EcE_c rise?

A.
About 25%
B.
About 56%
C.
About 12%
D.
About 40%

Working backward from a required stiffness

Sometimes stiffness is the requirement. A floor that mustn't bounce or a beam with a deflection limit can call for a minimum EcE_c, and the question becomes what strength or weight gets you there. Undo the formula one power at a time, with EcE_c in psi:

fc′=(Ec33 wc1.5)2wc=(Ec33fc′)2/3\begin{aligned} f'_c &= \left(\frac{E_c}{33\,w_c^{1.5}}\right)^{2} \\[6pt] w_c &= \left(\frac{E_c}{33\sqrt{f'_c}}\right)^{2/3} \end{aligned}

That square is why stiffness is expensive to buy with strength alone: 20% more stiffness takes 1.22=1.441.2^2 = 1.44, or 44% more strength. The 2/3 power undoes the 1.5, and your calculator's power key handles it.

Worked Example The strength for a required modulus
1 of 3

A concrete weighing 145 lb/ft³ needs a modulus of at least 3,600 ksi. Find the minimum fc′f'_c.

Steel against concrete: the modular ratio

Reinforcing bars are bonded to the concrete around them, so the two strain together. Give them the same strain, and σ=Eε\sigma = E\varepsilon says the stiffer material carries proportionally more stress. That proportion is the modular ratio:

n=EsEcn = \frac{E_s}{E_c}

The Handbook defines it under Composite Sections, in its Mechanics of Materials chapter, as "modular ratio = E1/E2E_1/E_2," where Material 1 is the stiffer one, so steel goes on top. For EsE_s, use 29,000 ksi, the value in the heading of the Handbook's Design of Steel Components section. The reinforced concrete section prints no steel modulus, but bars are steel like any other. Put EcE_c in ksi to match.

For the 3,644 ksi concrete from earlier, n=29,000/3,644=7.96n = 29{,}000/3{,}644 = 7.96. So next to that concrete, the steel carries about 8 times the stress. About 8 is the right size for ordinary concrete, and an answer like 0.13 means the ratio is upside down.

0 0.0002 0.0004 0.0006 0 4 8 12 16 strain, ε stress, σ (ksi) Steel, slope Es = 29,000 ksi Concrete, slope Ec = 3,644 ksi same strain, 0.0005 14.5 ksi 1.82 ksi
Steel and concrete at the same strain
Each line's slope is that material's modulus. At a strain of 0.0005, the steel carries 14.5 ksi and the concrete 1.82 ksi, a ratio of about 8, which is the ratio of the slopes.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A concrete weighs 145 lb/ft³ and has fc′=5,000 psif'_c = 5{,}000\ \text{psi}. What is the modular ratio of steel to this concrete?

Recap

  • Concrete is stiff rock held in softer paste, so it gets stiffer as the paste gets stronger and as the mix gets denser. Lightweight concrete's porous aggregate is the soft case. Steel, by contrast, has one modulus for every structural grade: 29,000 ksi.
  • Ec=33wc1.5fc′E_c = 33 w_c^{1.5}\sqrt{f'_c} is a fit to test data, so it works only with fc′f'_c in psi and wcw_c in lb/ft³. The answer is in psi, so divide by 1,000 for ksi. To work backward, start from psi and undo the powers: square to get fc′f'_c, or raise to the 2/3 power to get wcw_c.
  • Doubling fc′f'_c raises EcE_c by only about 41%. Unit weight pulls harder, to the 1.5 power, so at the same strength Ec1/Ec2=(wc1/wc2)1.5E_{c1}/E_{c2} = (w_{c1}/w_{c2})^{1.5}.
  • 57,000fc′57{,}000\sqrt{f'_c} is the normal-weight shortcut, with about 145 lb/ft³ built in. It overstates lightweight concrete.
  • The modular ratio is steel over concrete, n=Es/Ecn = E_s/E_c, about 8 for ordinary concrete. A softer concrete has a larger nn.