Workability, Air Entrainment, and Admixtures

Make concrete flow without adding water, or pay for it in strength.

You're pouring a bridge deck in Minnesota. The pump crew wants a loose mix that flows. The deck has to survive decades of freezing, thawing, and road salt. And the spec says nobody adds water on site.

Water would buy the flow, at a price in strength, and it would make the frost problem worse. This Lesson is about the other ways to pay, and the tests at the truck that tell you whether you got what you paid for.

One number for how concrete flows

Workability is how easily fresh concrete can be moved, placed, and finished without separating into rock and soup. Ask two people whether a mix is workable and you'll get two opinions, so a job site needs a number. It comes from the slump test.

Stand a metal cone on a flat plate: 12 in. tall, 8 in. wide at the base, 4 in. wide at the top. Fill it in three layers, and rod each layer 25 times to settle it. Then lift the cone straight up. The concrete, suddenly unsupported, sags under its own weight. How far its top drops below the cone's original height is the slump, in inches.

Filled cone 12 in. 4 in. 8 in. Stiff mix slump = 1 in. Flowing mix slump = 7 in.
The slump test
The dashed outline shows where the concrete started. The slump is how far its top came down.

Before trusting the number, ask what you'd ask of any materials test: what does the test measure? Workability, in one narrow sense: the consistency of this batch, how stiff or fluid it is right now. A stiff mix might slump an inch or two, an ordinary one 3 or 4 in., and a flowing one 7 in. or more. Slump isn't strength. Water raises the slump and lowers the strength, while a superplasticizer, coming up next, raises the slump and leaves the strength alone. The cone reads the same either way.

Buying slump without water

The Handbook's Concrete section states the problem: "Water content affects workability. However, an increase in water without a corresponding increase in cement reduces the concrete strength." That leaves two ways out: free up water that's already in the mix, or add cement along with any new water.

Free the water that's already there

Cement grains don't stay separate in water. Their surfaces carry patches of opposite electric charge, so they stick together in clumps, and each clump traps water inside, where it lubricates nothing. A water reducer is a chemical whose molecules coat the grains and make them push each other apart. The clumps break up, and the trapped water goes to work.

No water reducer cement grain trapped water With water reducer admixture coating grains repel freed water Same cement, same water, same W/C
The same cement and water, with and without a water reducer
Schematic, not to scale.

A superplasticizer, also called a high-range water reducer, does the same job harder. The Handbook calls superplasticizers "the most typical way to increase workability" and doesn't say how they work.

The freed water can be spent two ways, and a question will say which:

  • Same water, more slump. W/C doesn't change, so the expected strength doesn't either.
  • Same slump, less water. W/C falls, so the strength rises.

Make more of the same paste

Paste is what lubricates the rock. It coats every stone and fills the gaps between them, and more of it gives the rock more room to slide. The paste stays just as good only if water and cement go up together at the same ratio, which is the Handbook's "corresponding increase in cement." At W/C = 0.50, each extra 10 lb of water brings 20 lb of cement. The price is more cement, the costliest of the main ingredients, along with the extra heat and shrinkage it brings.

Worked Example One stiff load, three fixes
1 of 4

A mix with no added air has 300 lb of water and 600 lb of cement per cubic yard, so W/C = 0.50 and the chart reads about 4,250 psi. It needs more slump. Find W/C and the expected 28-day strength for each fix:

  1. 30 lb more water
  2. 30 lb more water, plus enough cement to hold the ratio
  3. a superplasticizer, with water and cement unchanged
0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90 1.00 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 AVERAGE 28-DAY COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH, PSI W/C BY WEIGHT NO ADDED AIR RECOMMENDED PERCENT ENTRAINED AIR
Average 28-day compressive strength against W/C

Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Materials Science/Structure of Matter, Concrete

Bubbles on purpose

Flow was half the deck's problem. Frost is the other half. Hardened paste is full of tiny pores, and outdoors some of them hold water. Water expands about 9 percent as it freezes, so ice forming in a pore shoves the remaining water ahead of it. If that water has nowhere to go, the pressure cracks the paste. One freeze does little. Hundreds of them flake a deck apart.

Entrained air is the fix. An air-entraining admixture, essentially a soap, holds bubbles in the mix as it's stirred: microscopic, billions of them per cubic yard, typically adding up to about 4 to 7 percent of the volume. The bubbles are too big to soak up water the way fine pores do, so they stay mostly empty, and they sit so close together that freezing water never has far to travel to reach one. Each bubble is a relief chamber.

No entrained air ice water crack nowhere to go Entrained air ice water air bubble room to expand
A pore in hardened paste during a freeze
Schematic, not to scale.

The bubbles help the fresh mix too. They act like tiny ball bearings among the sand grains, so an air-entrained mix flows more easily with the same water.

The bill comes in strength. A bubble is a hole, and like a pore, it carries no load. That's the second line on the Handbook's chart, a price the Handbook accepts in one sentence: "Air entrainment is used to improve durability." At W/C = 0.50, the line with no added air reads about 4,250 psi and the line with entrained air reads about 3,600 psi.

0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90 1.00 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 AVERAGE 28-DAY COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH, PSI W/C BY WEIGHT NO ADDED AIR RECOMMENDED PERCENT ENTRAINED AIR about 4,250 psi about 3,600 psi
The same W/C on the two lines

Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Materials Science/Structure of Matter, Concrete, which credits the Concrete Manual, 8th ed., U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 1975. Gridlines and labels added.

The two lines stay about 15 percent apart all the way along. A lower ratio wins that back: to reach 4,250 psi with entrained air, the lower line says W/C of about 0.43, not 0.50. Still, at a given ratio, air makes concrete weaker and makes it last.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A mix with no added air has W/C = 0.60, which the chart reads as about 3,350 psi. The designer adds the recommended entrained air and leaves W/C alone. What is the expected 28-day strength?

0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90 1.00 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 AVERAGE 28-DAY COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH, PSI W/C BY WEIGHT NO ADDED AIR RECOMMENDED PERCENT ENTRAINED AIR
Average 28-day compressive strength against W/C

Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Materials Science/Structure of Matter, Concrete

A.
About 3,950 psi
B.
About 3,350 psi
C.
About 2,850 psi
D.
About 2,250 psi

Three checks before it hardens

A cylinder gives its verdict at 28 days, long after the concrete is in the deck. So fresh concrete also gets checked at the truck, by the slump test and two others. Ask each one the same question: what does the test measure?

The pressure meter finds the air content, and it relies on one fact: air is the only ingredient that compresses. Seal a sample of fresh concrete in a bowl and apply a known air pressure. The water, cement, and rock barely give while the bubbles shrink, so the more the sample gives, the more air it holds. The gauge reads directly in percent of volume, counting all the air, including larger voids trapped by accident. Too little means too little frost protection. Too much means strength lost for nothing.

The unit weight test is the simplest: fill a container of known volume, rod it, strike it flush, and weigh it. Net weight over volume is the unit weight, and ordinary concrete runs about 145 to 150 lb/ft³. Bubbles weigh nothing, and water weighs less than the rock it displaces, so a reading below the design value points to extra air or extra water. Each extra percentage point of air takes about 1 percent off. The result alone doesn't say which it is, and the pressure meter settles it.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

A crew says a load is too stiff to place. Which test puts a number on its workability?

A.
Pressure meter
B.
Slump test
C.
Unit weight test
D.
Compression test on a cylinder at 28 days
Three tests of fresh concrete
TestReportsWhat the result says
Slump testDrop of the cone, in.Workability, not strength
Pressure meterAir, % of volumeLow: frost risk. High: weaker
Unit weight testWeight / volume, lb/ft³Low: extra air or water

The Handbook describes none of the three, so this table is yours to remember.

Replacing part of the cement

Fly ash is the fine powder caught from the exhaust of coal-burning power plants. Slag is a by-product of ironmaking, ground to a powder. Neither is filler. In the paste, each reacts and makes the same kind of binder that cement makes, only more slowly. So they're called supplementary cementitious materials, and a mix uses them to replace part of its cement. The Handbook's Concrete section mentions neither, so this section is yours to remember. They solve two problems that cement causes.

The first is heat. Hydration gives off heat. A sidewalk loses it as fast as it's made, but in mass concrete, such as a dam or a thick footing, the concrete is its own insulation. The center runs far hotter than the surface. The surface cools and tries to shrink while the hot core doesn't, so the surface goes into tension and cracks. Fly ash and slag give off less heat, and more slowly, so replacing part of the cement lowers the peak.

Temperature Time after placing surface, near air temperature center, all cement larger gap center, part fly ash or slag smaller gap
Temperature in a thick pour
Schematic, with no numbers. The wider the gap between center and surface, the greater the risk of cracking.

The second is sulfates. Some soils and groundwater carry dissolved sulfates, which soak into concrete and react with compounds in the hardened cement. The products take up more room than what they replaced, so the paste cracks from within. Less cement means less of those compounds, and the slower reactions of fly ash and slag fill in the pores and let less sulfate in.

The same slowness has a price: early strength comes later, so forms may have to stay on longer.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A test block for a 10 ft thick mat foundation runs hot at its center, and the engineer worries about the surface cracking as it cools. Which change to the mix addresses that?

A.
Raise the cement content so it gains strength faster
B.
Replace part of the cement with fly ash or slag
C.
Entrain air so the bubbles relieve the pressure
D.
Add a superplasticizer, with water and cement unchanged

Counting fly ash and slag in the ratio

Fly ash and slag act as binder, so they belong in the ratio's denominator. The water-cementitious materials ratio is:

W/CM=weight of waterweight of cement+fly ash+slagW/CM = \frac{\text{weight of water}}{\text{weight of cement} + \text{fly ash} + \text{slag}}

It's by weight, as W/C is, and with no fly ash or slag it is simply W/C. The Handbook prints only W/C, so this one is yours to remember too.

Worked Example Fly ash in place of cement
1 of 3

A mix has 270 lb of water and 600 lb of cement per cubic yard. The designer replaces 25 percent of the cement with fly ash, by weight, and leaves the water alone. Find the cement and fly ash weights, and W/CM.

Absolute Volume Mix Design carries these into a real batch: entrained air, fly ash and slag, W/CM, and unit weight.

Recap

  • Slump measures workability, not strength. The pressure meter reads air content in percent of volume. A low unit weight points to extra air or water.
  • To raise slump without losing strength, use a water reducer or superplasticizer, or more paste at the same W/C. The admixture frees trapped water: more slump at the same water, or less water at the same slump, which raises strength.
  • Entrained air gives freezing water room to expand and helps the mix flow, but at the same W/C it costs about 15 percent of the strength: the chart's lower line.
  • Fly ash or slag replacing part of the cement lowers the heat of hydration in mass concrete and improves sulfate resistance. Count it in the ratio: W/CM=water/(cement+fly ash+slag)W/CM = \text{water}/(\text{cement} + \text{fly ash} + \text{slag}).