Moisture Corrections to Batch Weights

Wet sand brings its own water to the mix, so the batch water has to go down.

A scale can't tell sand from water. The ticket calls for 1,300 lb of sand and 290 lb of water per cubic yard, and the sand pile sat through a night of rain. The operator weighs out exactly 1,300 lb from the pile and exactly 290 lb from the tank. About 61 lb of that "sand" is water riding on the grains.

So the mix comes up 61 lb short on sand and 61 lb over on water, about the same dose as 7 gallons from a driver's hose, except that nobody saw it happen. This Lesson shows how to rewrite the ticket so the mix comes out as designed, whatever state the stockpiles are in.

What the mix actually needs

Strip a mix ticket down and it makes two promises: a fixed weight of aggregate solids, and a fixed weight of free water in the paste. Those are what the concrete cares about. The solids fill the volume, and the paste water, over the cement, sets W/C. The ticket states them for one condition of the rock, usually saturated surface-dry (SSD). At SSD the rock neither gives water nor takes it, so the water on the ticket is the water the paste gets. Call that the design water.

A real pile is less polite. Take the wet one from the top of the page. The film on the grains washes off in the mixer and joins the paste, where it counts the same as water from the tank. So two lines on the ticket have to move, each to keep a promise:

  • Less batch water from the tank. The film is already part of the paste's water, so hold back exactly that weight.
  • More weight on the scale. Part of what the scale reads is now film, so it takes a higher reading to get the same solids.

The two changes are the same size. Weight that used to come from the tank now rides in on the rock, so the total weight of the batch doesn't change.

Stockpile at SSD on the scale dry solids pore water from the tank design water Stockpile wetter than SSD on the scale dry solids pore water free water scale readsmore from the tank water to add held back tank gives less same weight
The same mix on two tickets
Not to scale. The free water riding on the rock comes off the tank's line and goes on the aggregate's line.

The same two promises tell you what a dry stockpile does to the ticket.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

After a dry week, the sand and gravel both test below their absorptions. Compared with an SSD ticket, how should the batch change?

A.
Aggregate weights up, batch water down
B.
Aggregate weights up, batch water up, since the rock is short of water
C.
Aggregate weights down, batch water up
D.
Aggregate weights unchanged, batch water up

Every weight goes through the oven-dry weight

Now for the sizes of those changes. Absorption and moisture content are both percentages of the dry solids, so the oven-dry weight is the hub that connects every other weight. Write aa for the absorption and ω\omega for the stockpile's moisture content, both as decimals, so 6.0% goes in as 0.060. These three lines are just those definitions rearranged:

WSSD=WOD(1+a)Wstock=WOD(1+ω)F=WOD(ω−a)\begin{aligned} W_{\text{SSD}} &= W_{\text{OD}}(1 + a) \\ W_{\text{stock}} &= W_{\text{OD}}(1 + \omega) \\ F &= W_{\text{OD}}(\omega - a) \end{aligned}

FF is the free water in pounds: the moisture above absorption. It's positive when a pile gives water and negative when a pile takes it. The symbol ω\omega comes from the Handbook's Phase Relationships section, where it means water content on the weight of solids. The Handbook has nothing on aggregate moisture, so the rest of this bookkeeping is yours to carry.

WSSD pores full WOD dry solids Wstock stockpile ÷ (1 + a) × (1 + a) × (1 + ω) ÷ (1 + ω) × (ω − a) F free water
One aggregate's weights, connected through the oven-dry weight

The tank then supplies whatever the design water still needs after the piles have had their say. That's the mixing water to add:

water to add=design water−∑F\text{water to add} = \text{design water} - \sum F

Keep the signs, and drier piles take care of themselves, since subtracting a negative raises the water.

The tempting move is to jump straight across the hub and multiply the SSD weight by (1+ω)(1 + \omega). That counts the pore water twice: the SSD weight already holds it, and ω\omega includes it again. For the 1,300 lb of sand at the top of the page, with a=1.0%a = 1.0\% and ω=6.0%\omega = 6.0\%, that gives 1,378 lb when the right answer is 1,364 lb. A gentler shortcut, WSSD(1+ω−a)W_{\text{SSD}}(1 + \omega - a), treats the SSD and oven-dry weights as equal and gets 1,365 lb. That's close enough to pick the same answer on an exam, but the hub is exact, and it works in every direction.

Worked Example Rewriting the rainy-morning ticket
1 of 4

An SSD ticket lists, per cubic yard, 600 lb of cement, 290 lb of water, and the aggregates below. Find the weights of wet gravel and wet sand to batch, and the water to add.

Aggregates on the ticket
AggregateSSD weight (lb)AbsorptionMoisture content
Gravel1,8000.6%0.2%
Sand1,3001.0%6.0%

Tickets written on oven-dry weights

Some mixes list their aggregates at oven-dry weight. There's no new method, because the ticket hands you the hub and you skip the first step. But one thing catches people: the weight to batch now gets the full moisture content, not just the part above absorption.

Wstock=WOD(1+ω)W_{\text{stock}} = W_{\text{OD}}(1 + \omega)

Why the full amount? An SSD weight already holds the pore water, so reaching the stockpile weight adds only the moisture above absorption. An oven-dry weight holds no water at all. The rock on the belt has pore water and surface water, the scale reads both, and both have to be added. Add only the part above absorption, and the scale stops early, with too little solid rock in the hopper.

oven-dry ticket weight dry solids SSD ticket weight dry solids pore water on the scale, from the pile dry solids free water SSD ticket adds ω − a oven-dry ticket adds ω
What each ticket weight already holds
Not to scale. Each ticket has to climb from its own bar to the same reading on the scale.

The water line doesn't change. The listed water is still the water the paste should get, unless a question says otherwise, and pore water still stays in the rock, so the free water is still WOD(ω−a)W_{\text{OD}}(\omega - a). Take 1,800 lb of oven-dry gravel with a=1.0%a = 1.0\% and ω=2.5%\omega = 2.5\%. You batch 1,845 lb, and the free water is 27 lb. The aggregate goes up by 45 lb while the water comes down by only 27 lb. The other 18 lb is pore water, which an oven-dry ticket never listed.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A mix lists 1,240 lb of fine aggregate on the oven-dry basis. Its absorption is 1.5% and the stockpile's moisture content is 5.0%. What weight of wet fine aggregate should be batched?

A.
1,178 lb
B.
1,259 lb
C.
1,283 lb
D.
1,302 lb

When nobody corrects the ticket

Now the rainy-morning operator, who batched the ticket as written. What mix did that make? The weights on the scale are stockpile weights, so enter the hub from that side, and find each pile's free water the usual way:

WOD=Wstock1+ωW_{\text{OD}} = \frac{W_{\text{stock}}}{1 + \omega}

The paste gets everything from the tank plus all the free water, so the ratio the concrete actually has, the effective W/C, is:

(WC)eff=batch water+∑Fcement\left(\frac{W}{C}\right)_{\text{eff}} = \frac{\text{batch water} + \sum F}{\text{cement}}

The batch water is whatever came out of the tank. Use it alone, and you get the ratio the ticket hoped for, not the one in the concrete. To see what the effective W/C costs in strength, take it to the chart in the Handbook's Concrete section, as in Concrete Strength and the Water-Cement Ratio.

Worked Example The ratio nobody ordered
1 of 3

The ticket goes in as written: 600 lb of cement and 290 lb of water from the tank, for an intended W/C of 0.48. The scale weighs out 1,800 lb from the gravel pile (absorption 0.6%, moisture content 0.2%) and 1,300 lb from the sand pile (absorption 1.0%, moisture content 6.0%). Find the net free water they bring and the effective W/C.

Running the ledger backward

So far the stockpile's moisture has been given, and the water has been the answer. Flip it around. The plant's records show how much water went in, the mix came out as designed, and the question is how wet the sand must have been. It's the same ledger: the design water came from somewhere, and there are only three places.

design water=water added+Fcoarse+Ffine\text{design water} = \text{water added} + F_{\text{coarse}} + F_{\text{fine}}
design water water added coarsefree water ? known known fine free water
The design water and where it came from

Everything except FfineF_{\text{fine}} is known or computable, and a pile drier than SSD just enters with a negative FF. Once you have that weight of water, turn it back into a percentage on the oven-dry weight. That gives only the moisture above absorption, so add the absorption back:

ωfine=afine+FfineWOD, fine\omega_{\text{fine}} = a_{\text{fine}} + \frac{F_{\text{fine}}}{W_{\text{OD, fine}}}
Worked Example How wet was the sand?
1 of 2

A mix has 300 lb of design water, 1,800 lb of SSD gravel (absorption 0.8%, moisture content 1.5%), and 1,250 lb of SSD sand (absorption 1.4%). The operator added 235 lb of water per cubic yard to get the design water into the paste. Find the sand's moisture content.

Recap

  • A mix needs a fixed weight of aggregate solids and a fixed weight of free water in the paste. The corrections keep both fixed when the stockpile isn't saturated surface-dry.
  • Wetter than SSD means less batch water and more aggregate weight. Drier means the reverse. On an SSD ticket the two changes are equal, so the batch's total weight stays the same.
  • Go through the oven-dry weight: WSSD=WOD(1+a)W_{\text{SSD}} = W_{\text{OD}}(1 + a), Wstock=WOD(1+ω)W_{\text{stock}} = W_{\text{OD}}(1 + \omega), and F=WOD(ω−a)F = W_{\text{OD}}(\omega - a). Multiplying an SSD weight by (1+ω)(1 + \omega) counts the pore water twice.
  • An oven-dry ticket adds the full moisture content to the aggregate weight, but the batch water still comes down only by the free water.
  • The water to add is the design water minus ∑F\sum F. Effective W/C is the batch water plus ∑F\sum F, over the cement. Run the same ledger backward to find a stockpile's moisture, then add the absorption back.