Reading Stress-Strain Curves

Stiff, strong, and tough are three different questions about the same curve.

Before this Lesson

A crane hook has four jobs. It mustn't stretch noticeably under its rated load, or bend for good. Overloaded, it should open up where everyone can see it, long before it lets go. And when a load drops onto it, it has to soak up the jolt without cracking. "Strong" answers only one of those. The stress-strain curve answers all four, each with a different feature.

Slope, height, width, and area

Ask one curve the hook's questions. How much does it stretch under a load? How much stress does it take before it gives? How far does it stretch before it breaks? How much energy does it take to break it? Each looks at a different feature, and a fifth question, how much energy it gives back, rides along with the fourth:

σy σu strength: height stiffness: slope E toughness: area under the whole curve resilience: area under the straight part ductility: width to fracture strain, ε stress, σ
One curve, read five ways
Not to scale. On a true scale, the straight part would nearly hug the stress axis, and the resilience triangle would be a sliver.

Stiff isn't strong

Slope and height are separate questions. The Handbook's Table 2 - Average Mechanical Properties of Typical Engineering Materials has a pair that shows it: the aluminum alloy 2014-T6 yields at 60 ksi and A36 steel at 36 ksi, so the aluminum is stronger. But its EE is 10,600 ksi against the steel's 29,000, so at the same stress it stretches almost three times as far.

Height has one catch. Some metals mark their yield with a sharp corner and a nearly flat stretch, as hot-rolled mild steel often does, and the yield strength is the height of the flat. Many others bend over so gradually that there's no corner to read. For those, the 0.2% offset from The Tension Test picks a point by agreement, and the Handbook's Materials Science chapter defines yield strength by that method.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
A B strain, ε stress, σ
Stress-strain curves of two metals

Which statement compares these two metals correctly?

A.
B is stiffer, and A is stronger.
B.
A is both stiffer and stronger.
C.
A is stiffer, and B is stronger.
D.
B is both stiffer and stronger.

Ductility: how far it stretches

Ductility is the curve's width, how much strain the metal takes before it breaks, and you measure it on the pieces. When the bar snaps, its elastic strain springs back, so fitting the halves together and measuring between the gauge marks gives the permanent stretch. The Handbook's Materials Science chapter defines ductility that way, under Properties of Materials: "Permanent engineering strain after failure," also called percent elongation. For a ductile metal, the springback is a sliver of the width. With LfL_f the distance between the gauge marks after fracture, and the change taken on the gauge length, not the whole specimen:

% EL=Lf−L0L0×100\%\,\text{EL} = \frac{L_f - L_0}{L_0} \times 100

The Handbook's Mechanics of Materials chapter prints it under Definitions as (ΔL/Lo)×100(\Delta L/L_o) \times 100.

The neck gives a second measure. Measure its smallest diameter and compare areas, for the percent reduction in area:

% RA=A0−AfA0×100=[1−(dfd0)2]×100\%\,\text{RA} = \frac{A_0 - A_f}{A_0} \times 100 = \left[1 - \left(\frac{d_f}{d_0}\right)^2\right] \times 100

The Handbook writes the areas as AiA_i and AfA_f. The π/4\pi/4 cancels, but the squares don't: it's a ratio of areas, so the diameters go in squared.

Worked Example Ductility from a broken specimen
1 of 3

A round steel specimen, 0.505 in. in diameter with a 2.00 in. gauge length, breaks with its neck down to a diameter of 0.32 in. Fitted back together, its gauge marks are 2.56 in. apart. Find its percent elongation and percent reduction in area.

Area is energy

Why should an area on this plot mean anything? Stress times strain is force over area times length over length:

lbin2⋅in.in.=in.-lbin3\frac{\text{lb}}{\text{in}^2} \cdot \frac{\text{in.}}{\text{in.}} = \frac{\text{in.-lb}}{\text{in}^3}

That's work per unit volume. The area under a load-elongation plot is the work done pulling the bar, and dividing the load by A0A_0 and the elongation by L0L_0 divides that work by the bar's volume. So an area under a stress-strain curve is energy per unit volume, in units of stress: a psi is an in.-lb per in³, and an MPa is a megajoule per m³.

Energy you get back: resilience

Load a bar on its straight part and let go, and it gives back all the work, like a spring. That energy is the triangle under the straight part, 12σ(σ/E)\tfrac{1}{2}\sigma(\sigma/E). The Handbook prints it under Elastic Strain Energy, in its Mechanics of Materials chapter, as the strain energy per unit volume:

u=σ22Eu = \frac{\sigma^2}{2E}

The most a metal can store and give back is the triangle up to yield. Past yield, the work goes into permanent slip, and you don't get it back. That triangle is the modulus of resilience, a name the Handbook doesn't use:

ur=σy22Eu_r = \frac{\sigma_y^2}{2E}

It takes the yield strength, not the ultimate. For A36 steel, Table 2 gives σy=36 ksi\sigma_y = 36\ \text{ksi} and E=29,000 ksiE = 29{,}000\ \text{ksi}:

ur=(36)22(29,000)=0.0223 ksi=22.3 psi=22.3 in.-lb/in3u_r = \frac{(36)^2}{2(29{,}000)} = 0.0223\ \text{ksi} = 22.3\ \text{psi} = 22.3\ \text{in.-lb/in}^3

Tool steel L2 has the same EE and yields at 102 ksi. Squared, that's eight times the resilience, which is why springs are made of high-strength steel.

Checkpoint

A steel has a yield strength of 350 MPa, an ultimate strength of 480 MPa, and E=200 GPaE = 200\ \text{GPa}. What is its modulus of resilience?

A.
0.576 MPa
B.
0.306 MPa
C.
0.613 MPa
D.
0.000875 MPa

Energy to break it: toughness

Toughness is the area under the whole curve: the energy per unit volume a material absorbs before it breaks. It takes height and width together, so a strong brittle material can be less tough than a weaker ductile one. The Handbook doesn't define it. Its "fracture toughness," KICK_{IC}, is a different quantity, about cracks.

A question gives an idealized curve made of straight lines, so the area splits into triangles, rectangles, and trapezoids. The most common is elastic-perfectly plastic: straight up to σy\sigma_y, then flat until it breaks at a strain of εf\varepsilon_f.

εy εf σy σy(εf − εy) slope E ½σyεy strain, ε stress, σ
Toughness of an elastic-perfectly plastic curve
Not to scale. The elastic triangle is drawn far wider than it really is.
ut=12σyεy+σy(εf−εy)εy=σyEu_t = \tfrac{1}{2}\sigma_y\varepsilon_y + \sigma_y(\varepsilon_f - \varepsilon_y) \qquad \varepsilon_y = \frac{\sigma_y}{E}

The triangle is the modulus of resilience. This shape comes back in Steel Beam Flexural Strength, behind the plastic moment.

Worked Example Toughness of an idealized steel
1 of 3

Idealize A36 steel as elastic-perfectly plastic, with Table 2's σy=36 ksi\sigma_y = 36\ \text{ksi} and E=29,000 ksiE = 29{,}000\ \text{ksi}, and fracture at a strain of 0.30. Find its toughness.

Several curves at once

On a plot of several materials, each question still looks at its own feature. Toughness trips people, because it needs height and width at once. And the most brittle is the one with the least strain past its straight part.

Checkpoint
1 of 3
A B C strain, ε stress, σ
Stress-strain curves of three materials

Which material is the toughest?

A.
Material A
B.
Material B
C.
Material C

A sudden blow at a notch

A tension test is gentle: a smooth bar, pulled slowly. Real fractures tend to start at a notch, such as a weld toe or a crack, often under a sudden load, and both push a metal toward brittle behavior. The Charpy test combines them. A small bar with a V-notch lies across two supports, and a heavy pendulum swings down, strikes the face opposite the notch, and breaks it. The pendulum swings on up the other side, but not as high as it started:

release weight W rise notched specimen h1 h2 specimen, seen from above hammerstrikes here V-notch
A Charpy impact test
energy absorbed=W(h1−h2)\text{energy absorbed} = W(h_1 - h_2)

WW is the pendulum's weight, and h1h_1 and h2h_2 are its release and rise heights, both from the bottom of its swing. It's potential energy, as in Work and Energy, with friction ignored. Wh1Wh_1 alone is everything the pendulum had, not what the bar took. In SI, a pendulum given by its mass needs W=mgW = mg, for an answer in joules.

The Handbook's Materials Science chapter names the test under Impact Test, as "used to find energy required to fracture and to identify ductile to brittle transition," but prints no formula.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A Charpy pendulum weighs 50 lb. Released from a height of 4.5 ft, it breaks the specimen and rises to 3.8 ft. How much energy did the specimen absorb?

ft-lb

Cold steel turns brittle

Repeat the test over a range of temperatures, as the Handbook's Impact Test entry describes, and many steels show a cliff. Warm, the bar bends and tears, leaving a dull, fibrous face, and absorbs a lot of energy: the upper shelf. Cold, it snaps, leaving a flat, shiny face, and absorbs little: the lower shelf. The ductile-to-brittle transition temperature sits in the steep middle.

transition temperature upper shelf: ductile, tears lower shelf: brittle, snaps temperature Charpy energy absorbed
Charpy energy against temperature for a steel

Source: Adapted from FE Reference Handbook, Impact Test

Why? To tear, layers of atoms have to slip, and in steel, cold makes slipping harder, while splitting the crystal along its planes hardly changes. Below the transition, splitting wins, and a crack runs through without the metal yielding ahead of it. Aluminum and the common stainless steels, such as 304, have no such transition.

Many welded cargo ships of World War II cracked in cold seas, and a few broke in two. The investigations blamed hull steel below its transition temperature, with sharp hatch corners acting as notches. So steel for cold-weather service needs a transition temperature below its lowest service temperature, to stay on its upper shelf on the coldest day.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
−120 −80 −40 0 40 80 120 0 20 40 60 80 100 steel 1 steel 2 temperature (°F) Charpy energy (ft-lb)
Charpy energy against temperature for two steels

About what is steel 1's ductile-to-brittle transition temperature?

A.
−40°F
B.
0°F
C.
40°F
D.
100°F

How hard it is to dent

The Handbook defines hardness under Hardenability, in its Materials Science chapter, as "resistance to penetration," measured by denting the material and measuring the dent. The Brinell test presses a hard ball in and measures the dent's diameter: the smaller the dent, the higher the Brinell hardness number, BHN. The Rockwell test reads how deep a diamond cone or a small ball sinks. The Handbook prints neither procedure.

A dent is permanent, so the metal under it has yielded, and a metal that resists flowing there resists it in a tension test too. For plain carbon steels, the Handbook's Relationship Between Hardness and Tensile Strength gives:

TS (psi)≃500 BHNTS (MPa)≃3.5 BHN\text{TS (psi)} \simeq 500\ \text{BHN} \qquad \text{TS (MPa)} \simeq 3.5\ \text{BHN}

That's one rule in two unit systems, since 3.5 MPa is about 508 psi, so match the constant to the units you want. A BHN of 200 means about 100,000 psi, or 700 MPa.

Checkpoint

A plain carbon steel has a Brinell hardness number of 180. About what is its tensile strength?

A.
90,000 MPa
B.
630 MPa
C.
51 MPa
D.
90 MPa

What does the test measure?

Every property here comes from a test. One more is worth naming: an endurance, or fatigue, test cycles the stress up and down many times, and the Handbook's Properties of Materials defines the endurance limit as "the stress below which fatigue failure is unlikely." When a question names a test, ask what the test measures.

Checkpoint

Which pairings of a test with what it measures are correct?

A.
Brinell: resistance to indentation, from the size of a dent
B.
Charpy: a steel's tensile strength, from a notched bar
C.
Rockwell: resistance to indentation, from the depth of a dent
D.
Charpy: the energy to fracture a notched bar at a set temperature
E.
Endurance: the energy a bar absorbs under one sudden blow

Recap

  • Stiffness, strength, ductility, and toughness are a curve's slope, height, width, and area: four separate questions. With no sharp yield corner, the yield strength comes from the 0.2% offset.
  • Percent elongation is (Lf−L0)/L0×100(L_f - L_0)/L_0 \times 100 on the gauge length, and percent reduction in area is [1−(df/d0)2]×100[1 - (d_f/d_0)^2] \times 100.
  • Areas are energy per unit volume. Resilience is the elastic triangle, ur=σy2/2Eu_r = \sigma_y^2/2E, and toughness is the whole area.
  • Charpy measures the energy a notched bar absorbs under a sudden blow, W(h1−h2)W(h_1 - h_2). Cold-weather steel needs a transition temperature below its lowest service temperature.
  • Hardness is resistance to indentation. For plain carbon steels, TS≃500 BHN\text{TS} \simeq 500\ \text{BHN} in psi, or 3.5 BHN3.5\ \text{BHN} in MPa.