Beam Deflection by Superposition

The deflections from separate loads simply add.

Before this Lesson

A steel floor beam spans 24 ft. It carries its slab as a uniform load, and a 12-kip air handler sits on it 8 ft from one support. How far does the beam sag under the unit? Look through the Handbook's beam tables and you won't find this beam. Every row holds exactly one load, and no table could print a row for every mix of loads a real beam carries. Two of those one-load rows, read at the right point, are all you need.

Why separate loads add

Put both loads on the beam and cut it anywhere. The moment at the cut is the uniform load's moment plus the point load's, because statics just adds forces. From Beam Deflection, each piece of a beam bends with curvature M/EIM/EI, so the curvature is a sum too. Integrate a sum and you get a sum: the slopes add, and so do the deflections. Each load's curve is zero at both supports, so their sum is too. The curve under both loads is the two one-load curves, added point by point.

The Handbook calls this the Principle of Superposition and asks two things: each effect is linear in its load, and the deformations are too small to change how the other loads act. A steel beam in service stays elastic and sags a fraction of an inch over many feet, so it qualifies. Beams with One Redundant uses the same idea on a beam with one support too many.

C w alone w v1 P alone P v2 w and P w P v1 + v2 lowest point of each curve
Each load's curve, and their sum, read at the same point

That's the one rule that matters: add at the same point. Each curve is lowest somewhere else, and adding the lowest values gives a deflection the beam has nowhere. The question asks about the point under the load, CC, so read every curve there. The tables measure vv upward, so a sag prints with a minus sign. Every load in this Lesson pushes the same way, so drop the signs and add sizes.

Reading a curve at the point you need

A row's vmaxv_{\text{max}} is the deflection at one point. For a full-span uniform load, 5wL4/(384EI)5wL^4/(384EI) is the sag at midspan and nowhere else. For any other point, the row's Elastic Curve column gives the whole curve, with xx measured from the left support:

v=−wx24EI(x3−2Lx2+L3)v = -\frac{wx}{24EI}\left(x^3 - 2Lx^2 + L^3\right)

Put in x=L/2x = L/2 and you get the 5/3845/384 back. Put in x=L/3x = L/3, and the sag is 11wL4/(972EI)11wL^4/(972EI), about 13% less.

The point load has its own row, the off-center point load, with PP a distance aa from the left support and bb from the right. Its Deflection column gives the sag under the load itself:

v∣x=a=−Pba6EIL(L2−b2−a2)v\big|_{x=a} = -\frac{Pba}{6EIL}\left(L^2 - b^2 - a^2\right)

Since a+b=La + b = L, the bracket is 2ab2ab, so this is Pa2b2/(3EIL)Pa^2b^2/(3EIL), the same from either end. The row's elastic curve is fussier: it holds only for 0≤x≤a0 \le x \le a. For a point past the load, measure xx from the right support and swap aa and bb.

Worked Example The sag under the air handler
1 of 2

A W18X50 spans 24 ft, simply supported, under a uniform load of 1.5 kip/ft, including its own weight. A 12-kip air handler sits on it 8 ft from the left support. Find the deflection under the air handler.

The same point, not the lowest point

Now load only half a beam. The Handbook has a row for that too, a uniform load over the left half, and it prints two deflections. One is vmax=−0.006563wL4/EIv_{\text{max}} = -0.006563wL^4/EI, at x=0.4598Lx = 0.4598L: the lopsided load pulls the lowest point a little toward the loaded side. The other is the deflection at midspan:

v∣x=L/2=−5wL4768EIv\big|_{x=L/2} = -\frac{5wL^4}{768EI}

Pair this load with a point load at midspan, and the point load's sag is a midspan sag, so the half-span load's has to be too. Take the second number.

That 5/7685/768 is exactly half of the full span's 5/3845/384, and superposition says why. Load the right half instead, and you get the mirror image of the curve, with the same sag at midspan. Now load both halves. That's the whole span, so the two midspan sags add to 5wL4/(384EI)5wL^4/(384EI). Two equal shares of it are 5wL4/(768EI)5wL^4/(768EI) each.

left half w 5wL4/(768EI) right half w 5wL4/(768EI) whole span w 5wL4/(384EI) + =
A load on each half adds up to a load on the whole span
Checkpoint

A steel beam spans 6 m, simply supported, with I=40×106 mm4I = 40 \times 10^6\ \text{mm}^4. A uniform load of 10 kN/m covers the right half of the span, and a 20 kN point load acts at midspan. What is the midspan deflection?

mm

Past the last load, a cantilever is straight

Put a point load PP on a cantilever a distance aa from the wall, short of the free end. Between the wall and the load, the beam carries moment and bends. Past the load, nothing acts on it, the moment is zero, and that stretch doesn't bend at all. The tail just goes along for the ride: it leaves the load at whatever tilt the beam has there and runs straight to the tip.

P a L − a θa va vtip θa(L − a) bends (M ≠ 0) straight (M = 0)
A cantilever with its load short of the free end

So the tip deflection comes in two pieces. Up to the load, the beam is a cantilever of length aa loaded at its end, so the Handbook's point-load row with the load at the end gives:

va=Pa33EIθa=Pa22EIv_a = \frac{Pa^3}{3EI} \qquad \theta_a = \frac{Pa^2}{2EI}

The straight tail, L−aL - a long and tilted at θa\theta_a radians, drops another θa(L−a)\theta_a(L - a):

vtip=va+θa(L−a)v_{\text{tip}} = v_a + \theta_a(L - a)

Multiplied out, that's the row's own vmax=−Pa2(3L−a)/(6EI)v_{\text{max}} = -Pa^2(3L - a)/(6EI), so either works. A uniform load with a point load at the free end needs no such move: both deflections are at the tip, so add wL4/(8EI)wL^4/(8EI) and PL3/(3EI)PL^3/(3EI).

Worked Example A load short of the tip
1 of 3

A W12X40 cantilevers 9 ft from a column, with an 8-kip load hung 6 ft from the column. Find the deflection at its free end.

Stand the cantilever on end

Fence posts and the stems of retaining walls are cantilevers too: fixed at the bottom, free at the top, and pushed from the side. Soil and water push harder the deeper you go, so the load on a wall stem grows from zero at the top to a peak at the base. Turn the page sideways, and that's the Handbook's cantilever row for a triangular load, which peaks at the wall at w0w_0 and falls to zero at the free end. The tables don't care which way the beam points.

post w0 P vtop L turn 90° Handbook cantilever w0 P L
A post pushed from the side is a cantilever turned on end

Right panel adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Cantilevered Beam Slopes and Deflections

Add a point load at the top, from a rail bolted to the wall, and superposition finishes the job:

vtop=w0L430EI+PL33EIv_{\text{top}} = \frac{w_0L^4}{30EI} + \frac{PL^3}{3EI}

That 1/301/30 is well under the uniform load's 1/81/8. The triangle carries half the total of a uniform w0w_0, and most of that presses low on the post, on short lever arms, so it makes less moment everywhere. Check which end has the peak: the row puts it at the fixed end, which is where soil puts it.

Checkpoint

A W10X39 post, with I=209 in4I = 209\ \text{in}^4 about the axis it bends on, stands 10 ft above its fixed base and holds back soil. The soil pushes on it with a load that grows from zero at the top to 1.2 kip/ft at the base, and a barrier rail at the top pushes 2 kips the same way. What is the sideways deflection at the top?

in

Slopes add too

Slope is the first integral of the curvature, so slopes add just as deflections do, at the same point. The exam asks for the ones the tables print: at a simple beam's supports and a cantilever's free end. Three things to watch:

  • θ\theta is in radians. A slope of 0.005 rad is about 0.29°. Multiply by 180/π180/\pi for degrees.
  • A centered load or a full-span uniform load tilts both ends of a simple beam equally, by PL2/(16EI)PL^2/(16EI) or wL3/(24EI)wL^3/(24EI). An off-center load doesn't. The Handbook gives θ1=Pab(L+b)/(6EIL)\theta_1 = Pab(L + b)/(6EIL) at the left end and θ2=Pab(L+a)/(6EIL)\theta_2 = Pab(L + a)/(6EIL) at the right, so the end nearer the load tilts more.
  • On a cantilever, the straight tail has the slope at the load, so a load short of the free end tilts the tip by Pa2/(2EI)Pa^2/(2EI), the row's θmax\theta_{\text{max}}.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A W16X36, with I=448 in4I = 448\ \text{in}^4, spans 20 ft, simply supported, under a uniform load of 0.8 kip/ft. A 12-kip point load acts 5 ft from the left support. What is the slope at the left support, in radians?

rad

Spread out or piled up

Gather a simple beam's uniform load into one point load of the same total at midspan. What happens to its sag? Write the total as W=wLW = wL, and compare:

5wL4384EI=5WL3384EIWL348EI=8WL3384EI\frac{5wL^4}{384EI} = \frac{5WL^3}{384EI} \qquad \frac{WL^3}{48EI} = \frac{8WL^3}{384EI}

The ratio is 8/58/5: piled at midspan, the load sags the beam 1.6 times as far. The pile sits as far from both supports as a load can get, so it makes more moment everywhere, and more moment means more curvature. Its peak moment is twice the uniform load's, but its sag isn't, because near the supports the two diagrams nearly agree.

w = W/L W spread out W W at midspan x M 0 L/2 L WL/8 WL/4
The same total load, spread out and piled up

Keep the totals equal: the point load that matches ww is P=wLP = wL, not P=wP = w. With the total fixed, the sag goes as WL3/(EI)WL^3/(EI) either way, so, as in Beam Deflection, it grows 8 times when the span doubles and halves when II doubles.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A simply supported beam carries one point load at midspan. The same total load is spread evenly over the whole span instead. What happens to the maximum deflection?

A.
It grows to 1.6 times its value.
B.
It halves.
C.
It stays the same.
D.
It drops to 0.625 times its value.

Recap

  • Deflections and slopes from separate loads add, in radians for slopes, but only at the same point.
  • 5wL4/(384EI)5wL^4/(384EI) is a midspan value. Elsewhere, use the elastic curve. A load on half the span sags 5wL4/(768EI)5wL^4/(768EI) at midspan.
  • Past a cantilever's last load, the tail is straight: vtip=va+θa(L−a)v_{\text{tip}} = v_a + \theta_a(L - a).
  • A post with a load peaking at its base is the triangular cantilever on end: w0L4/(30EI)w_0L^4/(30EI), plus PL3/(3EI)PL^3/(3EI) for a load at the top.
  • Piled at midspan, the same total load W=wLW = wL sags a simple beam 1.6 times as far as spread out. Either way the sag goes as WL3/(EI)WL^3/(EI), so span dominates.