Beams with One Redundant

Remove the extra support, then push the beam back to where that support held it.

A steel beam cantilevers 20 ft from a wall under 2 kips per foot, and its tip sags 1.2 in. Jack the tip back to level and slide a post under it. How hard does the post push? With four reactions and three equations, statics can't say. But you know how far the post holds the tip up, 1.2 in., and a push at the bare tip lifts it 0.08 in. per kip. So the post pushes 1.2/0.08=151.2/0.08 = 15 kips.

Take the support away, then push back

From Determinacy and Stability, a beam fixed at one end and propped at the other, a propped cantilever, is indeterminate to degree 1, so one reaction is a redundant: the beam would stand without it. The force method takes the redundant away, leaving a released structure (or primary structure) that statics can handle. It finds how far that beam moves where the support was, then makes the redundant push it back, just as the bar between two walls in Thermal Strain and Indeterminate Bars grew freely and was pushed back until it fit. The Handbook's Elementary Statically Indeterminate Structures by Force Method of Analysis says it in one line: the deflection from removing the support is equal and opposite to the deflection the redundant causes. Its sketch is the hook's beam.

= + w A B L w ΔBB A B δBB By A B
The propped cantilever as a released cantilever under the load, plus the same cantilever under the redundant

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Elementary Statically Indeterminate Structures by Force Method of Analysis

With the post's force ByB_y positive upward, as in the Handbook, the load's deflection at BB on the released beam is ΔBB\Delta_{BB}, and the redundant's is δBB\delta_{BB}:

ΔBB=−wL48EIδBB=ByL33EI\Delta_{BB} = -\frac{wL^4}{8EI} \qquad \delta_{BB} = \frac{B_yL^3}{3EI}
0=ΔBB+δBB⟹By=3wL80 = \Delta_{BB} + \delta_{BB} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad B_y = \frac{3wL}{8}

That's 15 kips for the hook's beam. And EIEI cancelled: a stiffer beam sags less, but it's harder to push back up by the same factor. With supports that stay put, the reactions depend only on the loads and the lengths. Once ByB_y is known, statics gives the rest, including the moment at the wall.

Worked Example A propped cantilever with a midspan load
1 of 3

A beam is fixed at A and propped by a roller at B, 24 ft away. A 20-kip load acts at midspan. Find the prop reaction and the moment at the fixed end.

Two spans: the released beam is twice as long

A beam continuous over two equal spans LL, on a pin and two rollers, has one redundant too. Remove the middle support, BB, and the released structure is one simple beam 2L2L long. That's the length that goes into the table:

= + w A B C L L w ΔBB A B C 2L δBB By A B C 2L
The two-span beam as a simple beam 2L long, under the load and under the redundant

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Elementary Statically Indeterminate Structures by Force Method of Analysis

ΔBB=−5w(2L)4384EIδBB=By(2L)348EI⟹By=5wL4\Delta_{BB} = -\frac{5w(2L)^4}{384EI} \qquad \delta_{BB} = \frac{B_y(2L)^3}{48EI} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad B_y = \frac{5wL}{4}

The Handbook's force-method page sketches this beam but calls the whole length LL, so solving its equations gives 5wL/85wL/8. Either way, the middle support takes 5/8 of the total load. Each end gets the rest, (2wL−5wL/4)/2=3wL/8(2wL - 5wL/4)/2 = 3wL/8, which is the propped cantilever's prop reaction. That's no coincidence. By symmetry, the beam is level over BB, as if clamped there, so each span is a propped cantilever with its wall at BB.

w slope = 0 A B C L L w w A C B 3wL/8 3wL/8 5wL/8 5wL/8
A symmetric two-span beam is level over its middle support, like two propped cantilevers back to back

So the moment over BB is the propped cantilever's wall moment: MB=(3wL/8)L−wL2/2=−wL2/8M_B = (3wL/8)L - wL^2/2 = -wL^2/8, with tension on top.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A 60-ft beam rests on three supports, one at each end and one at the middle, and carries 2 kip/ft. What reaction does the middle support provide?

kips

Choosing what to release

Any one restraint can be the redundant, as long as the released structure is stable and determinate. A propped cantilever can keep its roller and release the wall's grip on rotation instead, leaving a simple beam. The redundant is then the wall's moment MAM_A, and compatibility is a slope: the load tilts the end by wL3/(24EI)wL^3/(24EI), and the table's end-couple row says MAM_A tilts it back by MAL/(3EI)M_AL/(3EI), so MA=wL2/8M_A = wL^2/8. On a continuous beam, the same move puts a hinge over an interior support.

Release the roller w By A B Compatibility: deflection at B = 0 Release the wall's rotation w θA MA A B Compatibility: slope at A = 0
Two released structures for the same propped cantilever, each with its compatibility condition

Watch three things.

  • Stability. Release a propped cantilever's horizontal restraint at the wall, and nothing resists a sideways push. As in Determinacy and Stability, the released structure must pass the count and the look.
  • Direction. The redundant pushes the beam back, so δBB\delta_{BB} and ΔBB\Delta_{BB} have opposite signs.
  • Settlement. If the support sinks, the beam has to meet it where it now sits, not at zero.

With a settlement Δ\Delta, EIEI no longer cancels:

By=3wL8−3EI ΔL3B_y = \frac{3wL}{8} - \frac{3EI\,\Delta}{L^3}

The settlement takes load off the support, and more of it the stiffer the beam.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A propped cantilever, fixed at A with a roller at B, carries a uniform load. The roller's footing settles 0.25 in. You take the roller's upward reaction ByB_y as the redundant and measure deflections up as positive. Which compatibility equation is right?

A.
−wL48EI+ByL33EI=0-\dfrac{wL^4}{8EI} + \dfrac{B_yL^3}{3EI} = 0
B.
−wL48EI−ByL33EI=−0.25 in.-\dfrac{wL^4}{8EI} - \dfrac{B_yL^3}{3EI} = -0.25\ \text{in.}
C.
−wL48EI+ByL33EI=−0.25 in.-\dfrac{wL^4}{8EI} + \dfrac{B_yL^3}{3EI} = -0.25\ \text{in.}
D.
−wL48EI+ByL33EI=+0.25 in.-\dfrac{wL^4}{8EI} + \dfrac{B_yL^3}{3EI} = +0.25\ \text{in.}

Fixed at both ends

Clamp both ends, and the count says three redundants, but under vertical loads the horizontal reactions are zero, which leaves two: the wall moments. That's past the one-redundant method, but the Handbook's Fixed End Moments table has done the work. A fixed-end moment, FEM, is the twist a wall needs to hold its end level while the load tries to tilt it. Under gravity loads, both are negative, with tension on top.

Fixed-end moments, with the load P a distance a from end A and b from end B
LoadFixed–fixed, FEMAB\text{FEM}_{AB}Fixed–fixed, FEMBA\text{FEM}_{BA}Fixed–roller, FEMAB\text{FEM}_{AB}
Uniform wwwL2/12wL^2/12wL2/12wL^2/12wL2/8wL^2/8
PP at midspanPL/8PL/8PL/8PL/83PL/163PL/16
PP at aaPab2/L2Pab^2/L^2Pa2b/L2Pa^2b/L^2(P/L2)(ab2+a2b/2)(P/L^2)(ab^2 + a^2b/2)

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Fixed End Moments

The table gives sizes, and its last column is the propped cantilever from earlier. For the moment anywhere else, superpose once more. A fixed-fixed beam is a simple beam under the load plus a moment at each end, and end moments make a straight-line diagram. So hang the simple beam's diagram from a line joining the end moments. At midspan:

Mmid=Msimple−FEMAB+FEMBA2M_{\text{mid}} = M_{\text{simple}} - \frac{\text{FEM}_{AB} + \text{FEM}_{BA}}{2}

For a uniform load, that's wL2/8−wL2/12=wL2/24wL^2/8 - wL^2/12 = wL^2/24. The walls lower the parabola's baseline by two-thirds of its height.

w A B L wL2/8 +wL2/24 closing line −wL2/12 −wL2/12 + − − 0.211L IP IP
A fixed-fixed beam's moment diagram is the simple beam's parabola, hung from a line at the end moments
Worked Example A fixed-fixed beam with a midspan load
1 of 3

A beam fixed at both ends spans 20 ft and carries a 36-kip load at midspan. Find the end moments and the moment at midspan.

Restraint pulls moment toward the supports

In the Handbook's sign convention, a positive moment bends a beam concave upward. So a moment diagram is a map of curvature: where MM is positive, the beam smiles, and where it's negative, it frowns. Where MM crosses zero, the curvature flips at an inflection point. The supports supply the rest of the shape:

  • Every support holds the beam at zero deflection.
  • A fixed end also holds it level.
  • The beam passes over an interior support without a kink. Only a hinge makes one.
  • On a line of symmetry, the slope is zero.

Now restrain one uniformly loaded span three ways.

Simply supported w Propped w L/4 Fixed at both ends w 0.211L +wL2/8 + +9wL2/128 + − −wL2/8 +wL2/24 + − − −wL2/12 −wL2/12
One span under the same uniform load, simply supported, propped, and fixed at both ends
Moments share one scale, and the deflected shapes share another, exaggerated. Open circles mark the inflection points.

Restraint pulls moment toward the supports. The simple beam carries wL2/8wL^2/8 at midspan. A wall at one end takes wL2/8wL^2/8 itself, leaving 9wL2/1289wL^2/128 in the span, and walls at both ends take wL2/12wL^2/12 each, leaving wL2/24wL^2/24. The sag shrinks with the midspan moment. Each sign change in MM is one inflection point: two in a span that's negative at both ends and positive between, one in a span that runs from negative to positive and ends at a simple support, and none where MM keeps its sign.

Checkpoint

A beam runs continuously over four simple supports, making three equal spans, with a uniform load on all three. Which of these are true?

A.
The moment is negative over both interior supports.
B.
The slope is zero over each interior support.
C.
Each end span has one inflection point, and the center span has two.
D.
The moment at each end support is negative, as at a fixed end.
E.
The slope is zero at the middle of the center span.

Load one span, and the next one lifts

Load just one span, and its neighbor moves the other way. On two spans with a load in ABAB only, ABAB sags and tips the beam over BB like a seesaw. The beam can't kink at BB, so the unloaded span BCBC bows up, enough that the roller at CC has to hold it down. Its moment runs straight from the negative MBM_B back to zero at CC, a frown the whole way with no inflection point. Influence Lines uses this pattern to choose which spans to load.

P A B C L L RC IP + −
A two-span beam with only one span loaded: its deflected shape and moment diagram
Checkpoint
1 of 2
P A B C L L
A beam fixed at A, on rollers at B and C, with a point load at the middle of span BC

Which moment diagram belongs to this beam?

A.
+ − A B C
B.
+ − + A B C
C.
+ − A B C

Portal frames pushed sideways

A portal frame's corners are rigid, and a rigid joint keeps its angle: if a column top turns, the girder end turns with it. The Handbook says nothing about the shapes of frames, so this is reasoning you bring.

Push the top sideways with a force HH. Both column tops sway together, and the girder resists turning, so they turn only a little. A fixed base holds its column vertical, so the column starts and ends nearly vertical, but offset. That takes an S, with an inflection point near mid-height: exactly there if the girder were rigid, and a bit higher for a real one. Both girder ends turn the same way, so the girder is an S too, with its inflection point at midspan.

A frame has no top or bottom, so these diagrams plot each member's moment on its compression side, the concave side. For a beam, that puts positive moment above the axis, as usual. The moment changes sides at every inflection point.

IP IP IP H h H
A fixed-base portal frame pushed sideways: its deflected shape and moment diagram
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A portal frame with pinned bases and rigid corners is pushed to the right at its top. Which deflected shape is right?

A.
H
B.
H
C.
H

Recap

  • Remove the redundant, leaving a stable released structure, then push it back: 0=ΔBB+δBB0 = \Delta_{BB} + \delta_{BB}, or −Δ-\Delta for a settlement.
  • Propped cantilever: 3wL/83wL/8 or 5P/165P/16 at the prop, then wL2/8wL^2/8 or 3PL/163PL/16 at the wall. Two equal spans: 5wL/45wL/4 on the middle support, with 2L2L in the table, and wL2/8wL^2/8 over it.
  • Fixed-fixed: end moments from the Fixed End Moments table, then the simple beam's diagram hung from the line joining them.
  • Restraint pulls moment toward the supports, a fixed end holds the beam level, and every sign change in the moment is an inflection point.
  • A loaded span bows its neighbor up. A fixed-base portal pushed sideways bends its columns into an S; a pinned-base one bends them one way, from zero moment at the base.