Flexible Pavement Structural Number

Each layer spreads the wheel load a little wider, and the structural number adds up their contributions.

Before this Lesson

Walk across deep snow in boots and you sink to your knees. Strap on snowshoes and you stay near the top. You weigh the same either way; the snowshoes just hand your weight to the snow over a bigger area, so each square inch of snow carries less.

A loaded truck tire presses on the road at about its inflation pressure, roughly 100 psi, through a patch not much bigger than your hand. The soil under the road would soon rut under that, pass after pass. A flexible pavement is a stack of snowshoes between the two, and the structural number is how you add up what the stack can do.

Each layer spreads the load wider

A typical flexible pavement puts three layers on top of the natural soil, which is called the subgrade:

  • an asphalt concrete surface, the rock skeleton glued and sealed by binder from Asphalt Concrete;
  • a base of compacted crushed stone, with no binder;
  • a subbase of cheaper gravel or sand.

Each layer receives the load on a small area at its top and hands it down over a larger area at its bottom. By the time the load reaches the subgrade, it covers many times the area of the tire's patch, and the pressure is a small fraction of 100 psi.

How far a layer spreads the load depends on how stiff it is. Press a coin into a foam pad and only the foam right under the coin squashes. Lay a stiff board on the pad and press the same coin on the board, and the whole pad under the board shares the load. A stiff layer is the board. An inch of asphalt concrete spreads the load farther than an inch of crushed stone, which spreads it farther than an inch of gravel or sand.

wheel load about 100 psi on a small patch wide area, low pressure Asphalt concrete surface Base (crushed stone) Subbase (gravel or sand) Subgrade (natural soil) D1 D2 D3
A wheel load spreading through the layers
Not to scale. The load spreads fastest in the stiff asphalt layer.

That's why the layers come in this order. The pressure is highest right under the tire, so the stiffest and most expensive material goes on top, where it does the most good, and cheaper material goes lower, where the load has already spread out. The stack is called flexible because it bends a little under every wheel and springs back, instead of bridging the load the way a stiff concrete slab does.

The structural number adds up the stack

AASHTO's method boils the whole stack down to one number, the structural number SNSN, an index of the pavement's total load-spreading capacity. It isn't a thickness, and you can't measure it with a ruler. It's each layer's thickness, weighted by how good that material is at spreading load, all added up.

The weight is the layer coefficient aa, the structural number that one inch of a material adds. The classic values come from the same AASHO Road Test as the load equivalency factors in Traffic Loading and ESALs: about 0.44 for asphalt concrete, 0.14 for a crushed-stone base, and 0.11 for a sandy gravel subbase. Asphalt concrete's is the highest, and an inch of it is worth about three inches of base. The Handbook prints no layer coefficients, so a question gives them.

Leaving drainage aside for the moment, each layer contributes its coefficient times its thickness in inches. For 4 in of asphalt concrete over 10 in of base and 12 in of subbase:

SN=0.44(4)+0.14(10)+0.11(12)=1.76+1.40+1.32=4.48SN = 0.44(4) + 0.14(10) + 0.11(12) = 1.76 + 1.40 + 1.32 = 4.48
× 0.44 × 0.14 × 0.11 4 in 10 in 12 in 1.76 1.40 1.32 Thickness Structural number SN = 4.48 Asphalt concrete Base Subbase
The same pavement measured two ways
The asphalt is less than a sixth of the depth but supplies almost two-fifths of the structural number.

A design starts from the structural number the pavement needs. AASHTO's design equation takes the design ESALs, the subgrade's stiffness, and how reliable the agency wants the pavement to be, and returns the required SN. More trucks or a weaker subgrade call for a larger one. The Handbook doesn't print that equation, so on the exam the required SN is given, and your job is the stack.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Which statements about the structural number and layer coefficients are true?

A.
A layer coefficient is the structural number one inch of that layer adds
B.
Two pavements with the same structural number have the same total thickness
C.
A 2-in asphalt concrete layer contributes less than a 6-in base
D.
Replacing 3 in of base with 1 in of asphalt concrete leaves the structural number about the same

Water weakens the base

The asphalt surface is held together by its binder. The base and subbase are unbound: nothing glues them, and they hold their shape only because their stones press and grind against each other. Water undermines that. When the voids fill with water, each passing wheel squeezes the layer faster than the water can get out, so for that instant the water carries part of the load and the stones press together less. Fines mix with the water into a slurry that lubricates the contacts. A wet base is a softer base.

So AASHTO discounts the two unbound layers with a drainage coefficient mm, which multiplies each one's contribution. Two things set it: how quickly water drains out of the layer, and how much of the year the layer spends near saturation. AASHTO's design guide tabulates it, and the Handbook doesn't, so here is a reduced version.

Drainage coefficient m, by drainage quality and the share of the year the layer is near saturation
DrainageWater drains inUnder 1%Over 25%
Excellent2 hours1.35–1.401.20
Good1 day1.25–1.351.00
Fair1 week1.15–1.250.80
Poor1 month1.05–1.150.60
Very poorDoesn't drain0.95–1.050.40

Adapted from the AASHTO Guide for Design of Pavement Structures, 1993

Read across a row and the coefficient falls as the layer spends more of the year wet. Read down a column and it falls as drainage gets worse. Notice that 1.0 is middling, not perfect, and it's the Handbook's default: assume m=1.0m = 1.0 unless a question gives you something else.

The asphalt surface takes no drainage coefficient. Its binder glues the stones, and a dense-graded mix's small voids don't connect, so water runs off the top instead of soaking through. Water still weakens the pavement, but it does it in the layers below, and that's where mm goes. With drainage in, this is the Handbook's AASHTO Structural Number Equation:

SN=a1D1+a2D2m2+a3D3m3SN = a_1D_1 + a_2D_2m_2 + a_3D_3m_3

Layer 1 is the surface, 2 the base, and 3 the subbase, and the Handbook's version runs on the same way for more layers. Each DD is a thickness in inches, so a 1-ft layer goes in as 12. That makes three meanings of DD in this topic, after the degree of curve and traffic density. The Handbook uses the same letter for all three, and the equation around it tells you which one you have.

Worked Example The structural number on a wet site
1 of 2

The pavement above, 4 in of asphalt concrete over 10 in of base and 12 in of subbase, is built on a site where the base has m2=0.9m_2 = 0.9 and the subbase has m3=0.8m_3 = 0.8. The layer coefficients are 0.44, 0.14, and 0.11. Find its structural number.

Sizing one layer

A design question runs the equation backward. It gives the required SN and every layer but one, and asks how thick that one must be. Subtract what the known layers supply, then divide what's left by what one inch of the missing layer buys: aa for the surface, amam for the base or subbase. For the base, that reads:

D2=SN−a1D1−a3D3m3a2m2D_2 = \frac{SN - a_1D_1 - a_3D_3m_3}{a_2m_2}

Then round up to the next half inch. Thicknesses are specified in half-inch steps, and a layer rounded down, even by a tenth of an inch, leaves the pavement short of the SN its traffic needs. So 13.1 in becomes 13.5, 13.6 becomes 14.0, and only an exact 13.5 stays put.

Worked Example The minimum base thickness
1 of 3

A pavement needs SN=4.5SN = 4.5. It will have 4 in of asphalt concrete (a1=0.44a_1 = 0.44) and 8 in of subbase (a3=0.11a_3 = 0.11) on a base with a2=0.14a_2 = 0.14, and both drainage coefficients are 1.0. Find the minimum base thickness.

Drainage changes these answers too. Before the next two questions, find where m2m_2 and m3m_3 sit in the base equation above.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

At a new site, water takes about a week to drain out of the base and subbase, and they sit near saturation more than a quarter of the year. Which statements are true?

A.
The base and subbase drainage coefficients are about 0.80
B.
The surface term, a₁D₁, should also be multiplied by about 0.80
C.
Compared with m = 1.0, the whole structural number falls by 20%
D.
If the layers were near saturation less than 1% of the year instead, m would be above 1.0
E.
To reach the same required SN, the base must be thicker

That's the base equation at work. m2m_2 sits in its denominator, so a wetter base buys less per inch and needs more inches, and m3m_3 shrinks the subbase's term on top, leaving the base even more to make up. Good drainage is structural capacity you don't have to pave.

An overlay makes up the difference

Pavements wear out. After years of trucks, the asphalt cracks and the base picks up fines and water, so the same layers no longer spread the load as well as they did when new. What they still supply is their effective structural number SNeffSN_{eff}: the same equation, with each layer coefficient marked down to match the layer's condition. It comes from a condition survey or deflection testing, and a question gives it.

When the traffic forecast for the years ahead calls for a future structural number SNfSN_f, a new asphalt overlay on top supplies the shortfall, and only the shortfall:

SNol=SNf−SNeffDol=SNolaolSN_{ol} = SN_f - SN_{eff} \qquad D_{ol} = \frac{SN_{ol}}{a_{ol}}
Asphalt overlay (new) Existing surface (cracked) Existing base Existing subbase Subgrade Dol SNol = aolDol SNeff SNf
An overlay on a worn pavement
Not to scale. The old layers still count, at their marked-down value.

The overlay is new asphalt concrete, so it takes no drainage coefficient. Round up to the next half inch, as for any layer. The Handbook says nothing about overlays, so expect the question to tell you that the overlay's SN is the difference.

Checkpoint

A worn pavement was built with SN=4.4SN = 4.4. A condition survey puts its effective structural number at 3.1, with its cracked asphalt surface now rated at a=0.25a = 0.25. Traffic over the next 15 years calls for SNf=4.9SN_f = 4.9, and new asphalt concrete has a=0.44a = 0.44. What is the minimum overlay thickness, rounded up to the next half inch?

A.
1.5 in
B.
4.0 in
C.
11.5 in
D.
4.5 in
E.
7.5 in

Recap

  • A flexible pavement spreads a wheel load wider at each layer, and stiffer material spreads it more per inch, so the best material goes on top.
  • The structural number is an index of the stack's load-spreading capacity, not a thickness. A layer coefficient is the SN one inch of a material adds, and asphalt concrete's, about 0.44, is the highest.
  • SN=a1D1+a2D2m2+a3D3m3SN = a_1D_1 + a_2D_2m_2 + a_3D_3m_3, with each DD in inches. Only the unbound base and subbase take a drainage coefficient: 1.0 unless given, and lower for slower drainage or more time near saturation.
  • To size one layer, subtract what the other layers supply from the required SN, divide by aa for the surface or amam for the base or subbase, and round up to the next half inch. Poorer drainage means a thicker base.
  • An overlay supplies SNf−SNeffSN_f - SN_{eff}, divided by the new asphalt's own layer coefficient.