Freeway Level of Service

Level of service grades how crowded a lane feels, and density is the measure.

Drive the same freeway twice, with the cruise control set at 65 mph both times. At 6 a.m., the car ahead of you in your lane is a fifth of a mile up the road, and you can change lanes whenever you like. At 4 p.m., you're still doing 65, but now there's a car every 250 feet in every lane, and changing lanes takes some planning. Your speedometer can't tell the two trips apart. You can, instantly, and the grade a freeway gets is built to tell them apart the same way you do: by how close the cars around you are.

Density is what you feel

Level of service, or LOS, is a letter grade from A to F for how well a road works from the driver's seat. On a basic freeway segment, a stretch of freeway away from the merging and weaving near ramps, it grades exactly one quantity, and it's worth seeing why it isn't either of the other two.

Speed can't be the grade. Freeway drivers hold their speed across a wide range of traffic, which is why the speedometer read 65 on both trips. Flow can't be the grade either. As Traffic Flow Fundamentals showed, every flow below the maximum happens at two densities, so 1,500 cars an hour in a lane could be a fast, open road or a slow, packed one. Density works. It's how close the cars are, since the spacing in a lane is 5,280/D5{,}280/D feet, and it only rises as cars are added, from an empty road all the way to a jam.

The Handbook's Basic Freeway Segment Highway Capacity section computes it from the demand flow rate:

D=vpSD = \frac{v_p}{S}

Here DD is the density in passenger cars per mile per lane (pc/mi/ln), vpv_p is the demand flow rate in pc/h/ln from Peak Hour Factor and Demand Flow Rate, and SS is the mean speed of the traffic stream in mph, the average passenger-car speed. It's V=DSV = DS rearranged, with vpv_p in place of the hourly volume VV, because the grade is for one lane, in passenger cars, in the busiest 15 minutes. The same section grades the result:

Level of service for basic freeway segments
Level of serviceDensity (pc/mi/ln)
A≤ 11
B> 11–18
C> 18–26
D> 26–35
E> 35–45
F> 45, or demand exceeds capacity

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Basic Freeway Segment Highway Capacity

One letter does double duty here: DD is a density, and LOS D is a grade. Each step down the table packs the lane tighter. At the top of LOS A, the car ahead in your lane is 480 ft away. At the top of E, it's 117 ft.

traffic LOS A 11 pc/mi/ln,480 ft apart LOS B 18 pc/mi/ln,293 ft apart LOS C 26 pc/mi/ln,203 ft apart LOS D 35 pc/mi/ln,151 ft apart LOS E 45 pc/mi/ln,117 ft apart 1,320 ft = 0.25 mi
A quarter mile of one lane at the top of each grade
Cars are 5,280/D feet apart, at the highest density each grade allows. Distances along the lane are to scale; car and lane widths aren't.

The Handbook attaches no words to the letters, but two of them carry a meaning you need. E's ceiling of 45 pc/mi/ln is the number the same section's Parameters for Speed-Flow Curves table lists as the density at capacity, DcD_c. So LOS E is operation at capacity: the lane is carrying close to the most it ever will, with no slack, and one driver tapping the brakes sends a ripple back through everyone behind. LOS F is breakdown. Demand exceeds capacity, more cars arrive than the lane can pass, and a queue forms. Inside the queue the density climbs past 45 while the flow that gets through falls, which is the congested branch of the flow-density curve.

Back to the two trips. A car every fifth of a mile is 5 pc/mi/ln, LOS A. A car every 250 ft is 21 pc/mi/ln, LOS C. Same speed, two grades apart.

Checkpoint

Which of these statements about basic freeway level of service are true?

A.
It's graded by density, in pc/mi/ln.
B.
Two segments, both moving at 65 mph, carry 1,000 and 1,350 pc/h/ln. They have the same level of service.
C.
A density of 38 pc/mi/ln is LOS E.
D.
LOS F is a density just under 45 pc/mi/ln, where the lane carries the most traffic.
E.
Of two segments, the one carrying more pc/h/ln always has the worse level of service.

Speed holds until the breakpoint

To use D=vp/SD = v_p/S, you need SS. Start with an empty freeway. The speed drivers choose when the segment is lightly used is its free-flow speed, FFS, the freeway's version of the Greenshields SfS_f. The road sets it: wide lanes, clear room to the right of the lane, and few ramps let drivers go faster, and the Handbook predicts the FFS from those three things. That calculation is outside this Lesson, so here the FFS is given. It isn't the posted speed limit. A limit is a number on a sign, and the FFS is what drivers actually do when nobody is in their way. The two can differ in either direction.

Now add traffic. At first nobody slows down: the cars are closer, but there's still room to hold your speed and change lanes. That's different from the Greenshields straight line, where speed falls from the first car on. The Handbook's freeway model, in its Parameters for Speed-Flow Curves table, keeps the speed at exactly the FFS up to a demand flow called the breakpoint, BP. With the table's speed and capacity adjustment factors at 1.00, their value for base conditions, that's

S=FFS  for vp≤BP,BP=1,000+40(75−FFS)S = \text{FFS} \ \text{ for } v_p \le \text{BP}, \qquad \text{BP} = 1{,}000 + 40(75 - \text{FFS})

with vpv_p and BP in pc/h/ln. A 65 mph freeway holds its speed up to 1,400 pc/h/ln. A faster one breaks sooner: at 75 mph, the breakpoint is 1,000. Past the breakpoint, each new car makes drivers ease off a little more, and the speed falls along a curve until the lane reaches capacity, at a density of 45.

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Demand flow rate, vp (pc/h/ln) Mean speed, S (mph) 11 18 26 35 45 dashed lines: density, pc/mi/ln A B C D E F breakpoint, 1,400 pc/h/ln FFS = 65 mph capacity
Speed against demand flow on a 65 mph freeway
Each dashed line from the origin holds one density, S = v_p/D, and the letters mark the grade between the lines.

Source: plotted from the speed-flow equations in the FE Reference Handbook, Basic Freeway Segment Highway Capacity

Below the breakpoint, SS is just the FFS, so

D=vpFFSD = \frac{v_p}{\text{FFS}}

and density climbs in step with flow while the speedometer sits still: double vpv_p and you double DD. On this 65 mph freeway, that stretch carries the segment through A and B and into C before anyone slows down, and both of the Hook's trips sit on it. Past the breakpoint, speed falls as flow rises, so density climbs by a larger percentage than flow, and the segment slides through the rest of C, then D and E, to capacity. The Handbook gives an equation for that falling part too. This Lesson leaves it aside, so when vpv_p is past the breakpoint, use the speed the question gives.

Checkpoint

A basic freeway segment has a free-flow speed of 60 mph. Which of these statements are true?

A.
The speed stays at 60 mph until vpv_p passes 1,600 pc/h/ln.
B.
The free-flow speed is, by definition, the segment's posted speed limit.
C.
At a demand flow rate of 900 pc/h/ln, the density is 15 pc/mi/ln.
D.
Each added vehicle lowers the speed a little, starting from an empty road.
E.
At a demand flow rate of 1,800 pc/h/ln, the density is 30 pc/mi/ln.

From demand flow to a letter grade

Put the pieces together, and grading a segment takes four moves:

  1. Find the demand flow rate, vp=V/(PHF×N×fHV)v_p = V/(\text{PHF} \times N \times f_{HV}), if the question gives the hourly volume.
  2. Choose the speed: the FFS if vpv_p is at or below the breakpoint, or the mean speed the question gives.
  3. Divide: D=vp/SD = v_p/S.
  4. Read the letter from the table.

Step 3 divides vpv_p, never the hourly volume, which counts a whole direction's vehicles across a whole hour.

Worked Example Grading a segment from its hourly volume
1 of 3

A three-lane freeway direction with a free-flow speed of 65 mph carries 2,700 veh/h in its peak hour, with a PHF of 0.90 and 15% trucks on rolling terrain. Find the density and the level of service.

Working back from a target grade

Now turn the question around. A design calls for LOS C or better: how much traffic can the freeway carry and still get it? Run the chain backward. The top of the grade's range is the most density it allows, 26 pc/mi/ln for C. Multiply by the speed to get the most demand flow, vp=DSv_p = DS. Then undo the demand flow rate. Every factor that divided on the way in multiplies on the way out:

V=vp×PHF×N×fHVV = v_p \times \text{PHF} \times N \times f_{HV}

Using S=FFSS = \text{FFS} assumes that vpv_p sits at or below the breakpoint, so check it. If it lands past the breakpoint, traffic at that density moves slower than the FFS, and you'd use the speed the question gives for it.

Worked Example The most traffic at LOS C
1 of 2

A two-lane freeway direction has a free-flow speed of 60 mph, a PHF of 0.85, and 10% trucks on rolling terrain. What is the largest hourly volume it can carry at LOS C?

What moves the grade

Hold the hourly volume fixed, and anything that raises vpv_p raises the density and pushes the grade toward F. Below the breakpoint it does so in exact proportion, since D=vp/FFSD = v_p/\text{FFS}: a vpv_p 20% higher is a density 20% higher. Past the breakpoint the effect is stronger, because the speed falls too. So to judge a change, trace it through vpv_p as in Peak Hour Factor and Demand Flow Rate, then through the table.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A two-lane freeway direction with a free-flow speed of 55 mph runs at a density of 30 pc/mi/ln, LOS D. A third lane is added, and the hourly volume, PHF, and truck share don't change. What is the new level of service?

A.
LOS B
B.
LOS D
C.
LOS C
D.
LOS A

Recap

  • Basic freeway LOS grades density, D=vp/SD = v_p/S in pc/mi/ln, because density is how close the cars are. Speed holds steady over a wide range of flow, and one flow can be fast or jammed.
  • A is up to 11 pc/mi/ln, B up to 18, C up to 26, D up to 35, and E up to 45. E is operation at capacity, and F is breakdown, with demand above capacity.
  • Speed stays at the free-flow speed until vpv_p passes the breakpoint, BP=1,000+40(75−FFS)\text{BP} = 1{,}000 + 40(75 - \text{FFS}), so below it D=vp/FFSD = v_p/\text{FFS}. The FFS is what drivers choose on a lightly used segment, not the posted limit.
  • To grade a segment, find vpv_p, choose the speed, divide, and read the table, always dividing vpv_p and never the hourly volume. To work back, multiply the grade's top density by the speed, then multiply through the PHF, NN, and fHVf_{HV}.
  • More trucks, rolling terrain, or a lower PHF raise the density and can worsen the grade, and an added lane lowers it.