Yellow, All-Red, and Pedestrian Intervals

The yellow gives a driver who can't stop comfortably the time to get through.

Before this Lesson

You're doing 45 mph toward a green light when it turns yellow. If the intersection is still a long way off, you brake. If you're nearly at the stop line, you keep going. Somewhere in between is a spot where you have to decide, and you get about a second to do it.

A well-timed yellow makes that spot harmless: wherever you are when it comes on, one of the two choices works. A badly timed one leaves a stretch of road where neither does. This Lesson times the yellow, the all-red after it, and the pedestrian signals that run alongside them.

The driver who could go either way

Freeze the approach at the instant the yellow comes on. A driver far back has room to react and then brake to a stop at a comfortable rate. A driver almost at the line doesn't, so the safe move is to keep going. Between them sits one driver exactly one comfortable stopping distance back:

xc=vt+v22ax_c = vt + \frac{v^2}{2a}

If this driver brakes, they stop right at the line. The yellow has to make the other choice work too: keeping speed vv, they must reach the stop line before the light turns red. Covering xcx_c at speed vv takes xc/vx_c/v, and that's the yellow change interval:

y=xcv=t+v2ay = \frac{x_c}{v} = t + \frac{v}{2a}
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 0 20 40 80 66 go stop equal areas reaches the stop line as red begins stops at the stop line yellow, y = 4.3 s 1.0 s 3.3 s 3.3 s time (s) speed, v (ft/s)
Stop or go at 66 ft/s, with a 1.0 s reaction and 10 ft/s² braking

That's our 45 mph driver, at 66 ft/s. Stopping takes 66 ft of reaction and 662/20=218 ft66^2/20 = 218\ \text{ft} of braking, 284 ft in all. Holding 66 ft/s over the same 284 ft takes 4.3 s, so that's the yellow. Braking itself takes v/a=6.6 sv/a = 6.6\ \text{s}, but the car averages only half its speed while it brakes, so at full speed it covers that ground in half the time, 3.3 s. In the figure, the go rectangle adds one shaded triangle and leaves out an equal one, so the two areas, and the two distances, match. The yellow is the reaction time plus half the braking time.

Notice the inputs. Signal timing commonly uses t=1.0 st = 1.0\ \text{s} and a=10 ft/s2a = 10\ \text{ft/s}^2, the Institute of Transportation Engineers' usual values, rather than stopping sight distance's 2.5 s and 11.2 ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2. A driver nearing a signal is watching for it to change; the sight-distance driver is being surprised. The Handbook prints neither pair, so use the values the question gives.

The Handbook's yellow, on a grade

A grade acts on this braking just as it did in stopping sight distance. Put a+gGa + gG in place of aa, with g=32.2 ft/s2g = 32.2\ \text{ft/s}^2, and 2a2a becomes 2a+64.4G2a + 64.4G. That's the yellow interval in the Handbook's Traffic Signal Timing section:

y=t+v2a±64.4Gy = t + \frac{v}{2a \pm 64.4G}

It defines tt as the driver reaction time in seconds, vv as the vehicle approach speed in ft/s, aa as the deceleration in ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2, and GG as the percent grade divided by 100, positive uphill, the same convention as stopping sight distance. It rounds yy to the nearest 0.1 s. As before, write 2a+64.4G2a + 64.4G and let GG carry its sign.

One difference from stopping sight distance matters more than any other: here vv is in ft/s. The SSD equation hides the mph conversion inside its 1.47 and 30. This one hides nothing, so multiply a speed in mph by 1.467 before it goes in.

Worked Example A yellow on a downhill approach
1 of 3

An approach with a 40 mph speed runs down a 4% grade to the stop line. Using t=1.0 st = 1.0\ \text{s} and a=10 ft/s2a = 10\ \text{ft/s}^2, find the yellow change interval.

The all-red: clearing the far side

Follow the driver who went. They cross the stop line just as the yellow ends, which is legal in most states, but they're now in the intersection with cross traffic about to get its green. So the signal holds every approach on red for a moment: the all-red clearance interval, which the Handbook calls the red clearance interval. It has to last until this car's rear bumper is past the far side, so the car's front travels the intersection width plus the car's own length.

v stop line red begins all-red ends W l W + l
The car at the start and end of the all-red
r=W+lvr = \frac{W + l}{v}

The Handbook takes WW as the curb-to-curb width of the intersection and ll as the vehicle length, both in feet, with vv in ft/s again and rr to the nearest 0.1 s. For our 45 mph approach, a 20 ft car crossing a 60 ft intersection needs r=80/66=1.2 sr = 80/66 = 1.2\ \text{s}. The yellow and the all-red together make the total change interval, here 4.3+1.2=5.5 s4.3 + 1.2 = 5.5\ \text{s}.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A 35 mph approach enters an intersection 64 ft wide, curb to curb. For a 20 ft design vehicle, what all-red clearance interval does it need?

s

A yellow that's too short

Now shorten the yellow. Say our 45 mph approach gets only 3.0 s. A driver who keeps going now reaches the line before red only from within vy=66(3.0)=198 ftvy = 66(3.0) = 198\ \text{ft}. A driver who stops comfortably still needs 284 ft. From 198 to 284 ft back is a stretch of road where neither choice works, the dilemma zone. A driver caught in it can brake harder than comfortable and risk being rear-ended, or keep going and enter on red, into the path of cross traffic.

intersection can stop comfortably can reach the stop line before red xc = 284 ft Yellow 4.3 s can stop comfortably can reach the stop line before red dilemma zone xc = 284 ft vy = 198 ft 86 ft Yellow 3.0 s stop line traffic 0 100 200 300 400 500 distance from the stop line when the yellow begins (ft)
Who can stop and who can go, at 66 ft/s, for two yellows

With the yellow at t+v/2at + v/2a, the two stretches meet exactly at the driver who could go either way, and the dilemma zone shrinks to nothing. That's the whole reason for the formula.

Checkpoint

Which statements about change intervals are true?

A.
The all-red gives drivers far back extra time to brake before the stop line.
B.
The yellow must let a driver one comfortable stopping distance back reach the stop line at the approach speed.
C.
On our 66 ft/s approach, with a 3.5 s yellow, a driver 250 ft back when it comes on is in a dilemma zone.
D.
The all-red lets a driver who crossed the stop line as the yellow ended clear the intersection before cross traffic starts.
E.
A dilemma zone opens when the yellow is longer than t+v/2at + v/2a.

Checking an existing yellow

A signal already in service comes with its yellow, and the question becomes whether it's long enough. The equation is linear in vv, so solving for it takes one step:

v=(y−t)(2a+64.4G)v = (y - t)(2a + 64.4G)

That's the fastest approach the yellow accommodates. Any faster, and the driver who could go either way sits too far back to make the line. Divide by 1.467 to get back to mph. Or solve for aa, the deceleration the yellow quietly assumes:

a=12(vy−t−64.4G)a = \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{v}{y - t} - 64.4G\right)

If that comes out above a comfortable rate, the yellow is asking drivers to brake harder than they'd like, and the ones who won't are in a dilemma zone.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

An approach on a 2% downgrade has a 4.0 s yellow. Using t=1.0 st = 1.0\ \text{s} and a=10 ft/s2a = 10\ \text{ft/s}^2, what is the highest approach speed it accommodates?

mph

What moves the yellow

Some questions ask only which way the yellow moves. Each input sits in one place in y=t+v/(2a+64.4G)y = t + v/(2a + 64.4G), and where it sits tells you which way it pushes. The one that catches people is speed.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A city raises the speed on a level approach from 35 mph to 45 mph, about 29% faster. With t=1.0 st = 1.0\ \text{s} and a=10 ft/s2a = 10\ \text{ft/s}^2, how does the yellow change?

A.
It stays the same, because the intersection didn't change
B.
It grows, but by less than 29%
C.
It grows by 29%, in proportion to the speed
D.
It grows by about 65%, with the square of the speed

Pedestrians get three signals

A pedestrian signal runs alongside the green for the street the pedestrian walks beside, and it shows three things:

  • WALK (a walking person): start crossing.
  • Flashing DON'T WALK (a flashing hand): don't start, but if you're already in the crosswalk, keep going. This is the pedestrian clearance interval, the pedestrian's version of the yellow.
  • Steady DON'T WALK (a steady hand): nobody should be in the crosswalk.

The hard case is the person who steps off the curb at the last instant of WALK. Walking at SpS_p, they need L/SpL/S_p seconds to cross a crosswalk of length LL, so the flashing DON'T WALK must last at least that long. When it has to end by the end of the green, the green must hold both intervals:

minimum green=WALK+LSp\text{minimum green} = \text{WALK} + \frac{L}{S_p}
green yellow red all-red vehicle signal WALK flashing DON'T WALK steady DON'T WALK pedestrian signal minimum green = WALK + L/Sp = 19 s 7 s L/Sp = 12 s pedestrian clearance
A 7 s WALK and a 42 ft crossing at 3.5 ft/s

The Handbook doesn't print this one, but it comes straight from the picture. Some questions let the flashing DON'T WALK run on through the yellow and all-red instead, and then those seconds come off the green. The question says which.

Checkpoint

A crosswalk is 63 ft long. The WALK lasts 5 s, the design walking speed is 3.5 ft/s, and the flashing DON'T WALK must end when the green does. What is the minimum green?

s

The Handbook's pedestrian minimum green

The Handbook's Traffic Signal Timing section gives a second minimum green, built for a crowd:

Gp=3.2+LSp+0.27NpedG_p = 3.2 + \frac{L}{S_p} + 0.27N_{ped}

It defines GpG_p as the minimum green time for pedestrians in seconds, LL as the crosswalk length in feet, SpS_p as the pedestrian speed in ft/s, with a default of 3.5 ft/s, and NpedN_{ped} as the number of pedestrians crossing in an interval. Read it as the same picture, with the WALK replaced by an estimate of how long the crowd takes to get going. The Handbook leaves the 3.2 s unexplained. The Highway Capacity Manual, where the equation comes from, calls it the pedestrian start-up time. Then each person waiting at the curb adds about a quarter of a second before the last one is on the way. For the 42 ft crossing in the figure, with 10 pedestrians, Gp=3.2+12+2.7=17.9 sG_p = 3.2 + 12 + 2.7 = 17.9\ \text{s}.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A crosswalk is 56 ft long, and 20 pedestrians cross in a typical interval. Using the Handbook's default walking speed, what is the pedestrian minimum green?

s

Recap

  • The yellow lets the driver one comfortable stopping distance back either stop at the line or reach it before red: the reaction time plus half the braking time, t+v/2at + v/2a. Anything shorter opens a dilemma zone, where neither choice works.
  • The Handbook's y=t+v/(2a±64.4G)y = t + v/(2a \pm 64.4G) takes vv in ft/s and GG as a decimal, positive uphill. Signal timing commonly uses 1.0 s and 10 ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2, not stopping sight distance's values.
  • The all-red, r=(W+l)/vr = (W + l)/v, lets that driver's rear bumper clear the far side. Yellow plus all-red is the total change interval.
  • Solve for vv or aa to check an existing yellow. The yellow grows with the reaction time, with speed (but not its square), and on a downgrade, and shrinks with harder assumed braking.
  • The flashing DON'T WALK is the pedestrian clearance interval, L/SpL/S_p long. Ending with the green, the minimum green is WALK + L/SpL/S_p. The Handbook's Gp=3.2+L/Sp+0.27NpedG_p = 3.2 + L/S_p + 0.27N_{ped} uses a default SpS_p of 3.5 ft/s.