Stopping Sight Distance

A driver travels a long way before even touching the brake.

Before this Lesson

At 60 mph, a car covers 88 ft every second. Highway design allows the driver 2.5 s to notice a stalled truck ahead, decide it matters, and get a foot onto the pedal. In that time the car goes 220 ft, most of a football field, at full speed with the brakes untouched. Only then does it start to slow down.

So a road has to let the driver see a good deal farther than the brakes alone would need. How much farther depends on the speed and the grade, and by the end of this Lesson you'll be able to compute it.

Stopping happens in two phases

Run the scene in your head. The truck comes into view, and for a while nothing happens to the car at all. The driver sees it, works out what it means, and moves a foot, and the whole time the car rolls on at full speed. That's the perception-reaction phase, and its distance is plain speed times time, vtvt.

Then the brakes go on, and the speed falls steadily to zero. That's the braking phase, and you've met its distance before: v2/2av^2/2a, with aa the size of the deceleration. Drawn as speed against time, the first phase is a rectangle and the second is a triangle, and the area under the line is the distance.

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 0 20 40 60 80 88 100 time, t (s) speed, v (ft/s) reaction distance 220 ft braking distance 346 ft sees the truck brakes on stopped 2.5 s 7.9 s
Stopping from 60 mph, drawn as speed against time

Add the two areas and you have the stopping sight distance, or SSD: how far ahead a driver has to be able to see an object to stop short of it. In geometric design, design speed is the governing input, and this is the first number it sets. Later Lessons on curves take it as the sight distance SS they have to provide.

SSD=vt+v22a\text{SSD} = vt + \frac{v^2}{2a}

Design work needs a number for the driver and a number for the brakes. AASHTO, whose guide sets U.S. highway design practice, uses a perception-reaction time of 2.5 s and a deceleration of 11.2 ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2. Both lean cautious. About nine drivers in ten react faster than 2.5 s, and about nine in ten can brake harder than 11.2 ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2 on a wet road and still keep the car in its lane. The Handbook prints neither number, so they're yours to carry, though most problems state them anyway.

Those are the values in the figure. At 88 ft/s, the car goes (88)(2.5)=220 ft(88)(2.5) = 220\ \text{ft} reacting and 882/[2(11.2)]=346 ft88^2/[2(11.2)] = 346\ \text{ft} braking, 566 ft in all. Nearly 40% of the distance is gone before the brakes do anything.

A hill works on the brakes, not on the driver

Stop on a hill and you can feel which way gravity is pulling. Going up, it helps the brakes. Going down, it fights them. Only the part of gravity along the road matters, and on the gentle slopes of real roads that part is simply the grade: on a 5% grade, about 5% of gg points along the road. So a grade GG, written as a decimal, is worth a deceleration of gGgG, added to the brakes' aa on the way up and taken off on the way down.

Upgrade: G positive direction of travel g a gG net slowing = a + gG Downgrade: G negative direction of travel g a g|G| net slowing = a − g|G|
Gravity's slice along the road, going up and going down
The slopes and arrow lengths are exaggerated so the directions show.

Put that total into the braking distance dd and pull out gg:

d=v22(a+gG)=v22g(ag+G)d = \frac{v^2}{2(a + gG)} = \frac{v^2}{2g\left(\dfrac{a}{g} + G\right)}

Now look at what sits in the parentheses. a/ga/g is the brakes' pull as a fraction of gravity. GG is the hill's pull as a fraction of gravity. They're the same kind of thing, so they add, and a hill acts exactly like a bit more or a bit less braking. The reaction distance has no slope in it at all, so the grade only ever touches this one term.

One more step makes it ready for a speedometer. Write the speed as v=1.47Vv = 1.47V, with VV in mph and 1 mph = 1.467 ft/s rounded. With g=32.2 ft/s2g = 32.2\ \text{ft/s}^2, the leading constant is 1.472/[2(32.2)]=1/29.81.47^2/[2(32.2)] = 1/29.8, which rounds to 1/301/30. So the 30 isn't a fact about roads. It's gravity and a unit conversion packed into one number. That gives the equation printed in the Handbook's Stopping Sight Distance section:

SSD=1.47Vt+V230(a32.2±G)\text{SSD} = 1.47Vt + \frac{V^2}{30\left(\dfrac{a}{32.2} \pm G\right)}

The first term is the reaction distance and the second is the braking distance, names the Handbook leaves off. It defines VV as the design speed in mph, tt as the driver reaction time in seconds, aa as the deceleration in ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2, and GG as the percent grade divided by 100, with an uphill grade positive. Two habits keep this equation honest:

  • VV stays in mph. The 1.47 and the 30 already hold the conversion, so a speed in ft/s gets converted twice. It's the plain v2/2av^2/2a that wants ft/s.
  • GG is a signed decimal, set by the direction of travel. Read the ±\pm as one rule: write a/32.2+Ga/32.2 + G and let GG carry its sign, positive when this driver is climbing. A 3% downgrade is G=−0.03G = -0.03. A plan's grade in Stations and Grades is signed by the stationing instead, so traffic running against the stations flips it.

On level ground, our 60 mph car gets 220.5+345=565.5 ft220.5 + 345 = 565.5\ \text{ft}: the same 566 ft, so the rounded constants cost you nothing.

Worked Example Design stopping distance on a downgrade
1 of 3

A highway with a 60 mph design speed runs down a 3% grade. Using t=2.5 st = 2.5\ \text{s} and a=11.2 ft/s2a = 11.2\ \text{ft/s}^2, find the stopping sight distance.

Braking distance alone

Some questions stop at the second term: how far does the car travel once the brakes are on? Drop the 1.47Vt1.47Vt, and that's the answer.

They may also describe the brakes by a friction coefficient ff rather than a rate. Sliding tires push back on the car with a friction force of ff times its weight, which is F=μkNF = \mu_k N from the Handbook's Friction section in Dynamics. Divide that force by the car's mass, W/gW/g, and you get a=fga = fg, so a/g=fa/g = f. The same slot in the denominator takes either one:

d=V230(a32.2+G)ord=V230(f+G)d = \frac{V^2}{30\left(\dfrac{a}{32.2} + G\right)} \qquad\text{or}\qquad d = \frac{V^2}{30(f + G)}

The Handbook prints only the first form and gives no friction values for pavement, so the problem supplies ff. A friction coefficient goes in as it is. A rate in ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2 gets divided by 32.2 first.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A car doing 50 mph brakes on a 5% downgrade with a friction coefficient of 0.35. What is its braking distance?

ft

Reading speed from skid marks

Now run that term backward. An investigator measures a set of skid marks, tests the pavement's friction, and wants the speed. If the car skidded to a stop, solve the braking distance for VV:

V=30 d (f+G)V = \sqrt{30\,d\,(f + G)}

Often the car didn't stop. It hit something, and the crash gives an estimate of the impact speed VfV_f. Now the skid only carried the car from its starting speed V0V_0 down to VfV_f. Start from v2=v02+2a0(s−s0)v^2 = v_0^2 + 2a_0(s - s_0) in the Handbook's Constant Acceleration section, make the same moves as before, and you get:

V02=Vf2+30 d (f+G)V_0^2 = V_f^2 + 30\,d\,(f + G)

Notice what adds up here: squares, not speeds. A skid of a given length on a given road removes a fixed amount of V2V^2, whatever speed the car had, for the same reason friction over a fixed distance burns a fixed amount of energy. So you put back what the skid took, on top of what the car still had when it hit.

d friction f, grade G skid marks V0 braking begins Vf impact
What skid marks measure, and the two speeds at their ends

The marks begin where the wheels locked, so V0V_0 is the speed when braking began, not the speed at impact. The Handbook has no skid-mark equation. This is all the braking term, rearranged.

Worked Example Skid marks ending at a parked van
1 of 3

A car leaves 120 ft of skid marks on a 3% upgrade before hitting a parked van at an estimated 20 mph. The friction coefficient is 0.60. Find the car's speed when braking began.

The fastest safe speed for the road you can see

Now let the road set the limit. A crest or a parked truck means the driver can see only so far. How fast can they go and still stop in that distance? Set SSD equal to the distance available and solve for VV.

VV appears twice, to the first power in the reaction term and squared in the braking term, so simple algebra won't pull it out. Move everything to one side and you have a quadratic:

V230(a32.2+G)+1.47tV−SSD=0\frac{V^2}{30\left(\dfrac{a}{32.2} + G\right)} + 1.47tV - \text{SSD} = 0

Use your calculator's polynomial solver or the quadratic formula. One root is positive, and that's the speed. The other is negative and belongs to no car. Any rounding goes down, because a higher speed needs more road than the driver can see.

Worked Example The view over a crest
1 of 2

A driver climbing a 2% grade can see only 400 ft ahead before a crest cuts off the view. Using t=2.5 st = 2.5\ \text{s} and a=11.2 ft/s2a = 11.2\ \text{ft/s}^2, find the maximum safe speed.

What each change does to the distance

Many questions skip the arithmetic and ask what a change does. For those, keep the two terms apart, because they care about different things.

  • The reaction distance, 1.47Vt1.47Vt, is proportional to VV and to tt. Grade and deceleration aren't in it.
  • The braking distance is proportional to V2V^2. Grade and deceleration act on it through the denominator, and tt isn't in it.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 design speed, V (mph) distance (ft) reaction distance braking distance SSD about 38 mph
The two terms against speed, on level ground with AASHTO's values

The straight line and the parabola trade places at about 38 mph. Below that, the driver's reaction uses up more road than the brakes do. Above it, braking takes over, and its lead keeps growing.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

Which statements about stopping sight distance are true?

A.
AASHTO's design deceleration rate is 32.2 ft/s².
B.
It's the distance covered during perception and reaction plus the braking distance.
C.
AASHTO's design perception-reaction time is 2.5 s.
D.
During perception and reaction, the car is already slowing at the design rate.
E.
AASHTO's design deceleration rate is 11.2 ft/s².

One road, two directions

On a two-way road, one steady slope is a climb for one direction and a descent for the other. Both directions have the same design speed and the same driver, so the reaction distances match and cancel.

Downgrade traffic (G = −0.05) Upgrade traffic (G = +0.05) reaction 220.5 ft braking 403 ft reaction 220.5 ft braking 302 ft 101 ft longer
Both directions of a 60 mph road on a 5% grade, with AASHTO's values

So "how much longer for downgrade traffic?" needs just two braking distances and a subtraction. Here it's 403−302=101 ft403 - 302 = 101\ \text{ft}, and the reaction time never enters.

Checkpoint

A two-way road with a 55 mph design speed runs on a steady 4% grade. Using t=2.5 st = 2.5\ \text{s} and a=11.2 ft/s2a = 11.2\ \text{ft/s}^2, how much longer is the stopping sight distance for downgrade traffic than for upgrade traffic?

ft

Recap

  • Stopping sight distance is the reaction distance, covered at full speed, plus the braking distance. AASHTO's design values, not printed in the Handbook, are 2.5 s and 11.2 ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2.
  • SSD=1.47Vt+V2/[30(a/32.2±G)]\text{SSD} = 1.47Vt + V^2/[30(a/32.2 \pm G)], with VV in mph and GG a decimal, positive uphill in the direction of travel. A grade is a slice of gravity, so it sits beside a/32.2a/32.2 or ff and changes only the braking term.
  • Skid marks give the speed when braking began: V02=Vf2+30d(f+G)V_0^2 = V_f^2 + 30d(f + G). Squares add, not speeds.
  • The maximum safe speed is the positive root of the equation as a quadratic in V.
  • Doubling the speed doubles the reaction distance and quadruples the braking distance. A longer reaction time changes only the first term, and a two-way road's directions differ only in the second.