High and Low Points on Vertical Curves

The high point is where the grade passes through zero.

Before this Lesson

Rain that lands on a sag curve runs along the gutter to one spot, and that's where the drainage inlet goes. Your eye goes straight to the PVI, the corner where the two grades meet, but on most sags the water collects somewhere else, often tens of feet away, so an inlet placed at the PVI sits uphill of a puddle in the travel lane. The right spot is the one place where the road is perfectly level.

The top is where the grade is zero

Walk over a crest and feel the slope under your feet. Before the top you're climbing, after it you're descending, and at the top itself, for one step, you're doing neither: the grade is zero. The bottom of a sag is the same moment in reverse. So finding the high point means finding where the grade passes through zero.

You already know how the grade behaves on the curve: it changes in a straight line, from g1g_1 at the PVC to g2g_2 at the PVT. Take the hill from Vertical Curve Geometry: +3% easing to −1% over an 800-ft curve, with the PVC at station 16+00, elevation 488.00 ft. The grade has 4 points to lose over 800 ft. To reach zero, it has to lose 3 of them, and that takes three quarters of the way, or 600 ft.

In general, the grade falls by g1g_1 to reach zero, out of a total change of g1−g2g_1 - g_2, so zero comes at the fraction g1/(g1−g2)g_1/(g_1 - g_2) of the way along:

xm=g1Lg1−g2x_m = \frac{g_1 L}{g_1 - g_2}

The Handbook's Vertical Curves section prints this as the horizontal distance to the minimum or maximum elevation on the curve, along with xm=−g1/2ax_m = -g_1/2a, the same result reached by setting the curve's slope, g1+2axg_1 + 2ax, to zero.

PVC PVI PVT −2 −1 0 +1 +2 +3 +4 484 488 492 496 500 504 0 200 400 600 800 x, distance from the PVC (ft) Grade (%) Elevation (ft) +3% −1% Grade = 0 High point, 497.00 xm = 600 ft
Where the grade line crosses zero, the curve tops out
Our hill, with its grade drawn above its elevation over the same distance.

Like every xx on the curve, xmx_m is measured from the PVC, so it isn't a station yet. Add the PVC's station: 16+00 plus 600 ft puts the top of our hill at station 22+00, a full 200 ft past the PVI at 20+00. For its elevation, put xmx_m into the curve equation, with a=−0.04/1,600=−0.000025a = -0.04/1{,}600 = -0.000025:

Y=488.00+(0.03)(600)+(−0.000025)(600)2=488.00+18.00−9.00=497.00 ftY = 488.00 + (0.03)(600) + (-0.000025)(600)^2 = 488.00 + 18.00 - 9.00 = 497.00\ \text{ft}
Worked Example A drainage inlet at a sag's low point
1 of 2

A sag curve 800 ft long joins a −2.4% grade to a +1.6% grade. Its PVI is at station 18+50, elevation 402.30 ft. Find the station and elevation of the low point, where the drainage inlet goes.

Inside the curve, and on which side

The fraction g1/(g1−g2)g_1/(g_1 - g_2) tells you more than where the turning point is. It tells you whether there is one.

A straight grade line can only cross zero if it starts on one side and ends on the other. So a high or low point lies within the curve only when g1g_1 and g2g_2 have opposite signs: up then down is a crest with a high point, and down then up is a sag with a low point. When the signs match, the fraction lands outside 0 to 1. Try +4% easing to +1%: xm=0.04L/0.03=1.33Lx_m = 0.04L/0.03 = 1.33L, past the PVT, on the parabola extended, which the road never follows. It's still a crest, since the grade falls, but the road climbs the whole way, so the highest point on the curve is its upper end, the PVT. The Handbook prints xmx_m with no warning about this, so the check is yours.

When there is a turning point, which side of the PVI is it on? Think of the grade draining away at a steady rate. On our hill, it spends 3 of its 4 points of change on the way down to zero and only 1 after, so three quarters of the curve comes before the top, which lands past the PVI. Whichever grade is larger in size claims the larger share of the curve, so the turning point lands on the side of the flatter grade, as the sag's low point did in the example, 80 ft past the PVI on the +1.6% side. Only when the grades are equal in size does it sit at the PVI.

PVC PVI PVT +1% −3% High point +1% to −3%: before the PVI PVC PVI PVT +2% −2% High point +2% to −2%: at the PVI PVC PVI PVT +4% +1% Highest point on the curve +4% to +1%: no top inside; highest at the PVT
Where a crest's highest point lands
Three 800-ft crest curves, each with its PVI at the middle.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A curve joins a −4.5% grade to a +1.5% grade. What turning point does it have, and where?

A.
A low point between the PVC and the PVI
B.
A high point between the PVI and the PVT
C.
A low point between the PVI and the PVT
D.
A low point at the PVI

Finding where the curve reaches an elevation

Sometimes the question runs the other way: you know an elevation, such as an existing cross street's, and need the station. Set the curve equation equal to that elevation YY and move everything to one side:

ax2+g1x+(YPVC−Y)=0ax^2 + g_1x + (Y_{\text{PVC}} - Y) = 0

That's a quadratic in xx. The Handbook's Quadratic Equation, in its Mathematics section, solves it, with its aa, bb, and cc standing for this curve's aa, g1g_1, and YPVC−YY_{\text{PVC}} - Y:

x=−g1±g12−4a (YPVC−Y)2ax = \frac{-g_1 \pm \sqrt{g_1^2 - 4a\,(Y_{\text{PVC}} - Y)}}{2a}

A calculator's polynomial solver works too. Either way you get two roots, because the equation describes the whole parabola, and a level line that cuts a parabola cuts it twice. The road is only the piece from x=0x = 0 to x=Lx = L, with straight tangents beyond. Keep the root on the curve, then add the PVC's station.

Say a sag curve 800 ft long joins a −3% grade to a +1% grade, with its PVC at station 10+00, elevation 250.00 ft, so a=0.04/1,600=0.000025a = 0.04/1{,}600 = 0.000025. A cross street it must meet is at elevation 245.00 ft:

0.000025x2−0.03x+5.00=0⇒x=200 ft  or  1,000 ft0.000025x^2 - 0.03x + 5.00 = 0 \quad\Rightarrow\quad x = 200\ \text{ft} \ \text{ or } \ 1{,}000\ \text{ft}

The curve ends at x=800 ftx = 800\ \text{ft}, so the 1,000-ft root is on the parabola extended past the PVT, where the road isn't. Keep 200 ft, and the curve meets the street at station 12+00.

240 242 244 246 248 250 252 254 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 x, distance from the PVC (ft) Elevation (ft) Elev.245.00 PVC PVT x = 200 ft x = 1,000 ft off the curve Curve Parabola extended
The parabola crosses the street's elevation twice, and the road once

Both roots can land on the curve. On a crest, a level higher than both ends but below the top is reached twice, once going up and once coming down, and the question has to say which it wants.

Checkpoint

A crest curve 600 ft long joins a +4% grade to a −2% grade. Its PVC is at station 8+00, elevation 312.00 ft. At what station does the curve reach elevation 317.12 ft, to meet an existing cross street?

A.
Station 12+60
B.
Station 9+60
C.
Station 14+40
D.
Both 9+60 and 14+40

Choosing the length to hit a target

The last kind of problem fixes a point and asks for the length that fits it, with the grades and the PVI fixed by the tangents. The catch is that changing LL moves the point everything is measured from. Lengthen the curve and the PVC slides back, so every station's xx grows while aa shrinks. The Handbook has no formula for this. It's the curve equation, with LL as the unknown.

Placing a low point is the gentler case. The low point sits at the fraction g1/(g1−g2)g_1/(g_1 - g_2) of the way along, and the PVI sits at one half, so:

Low point station=PVI station+L(g1g1−g2−12)\text{Low point station} = \text{PVI station} + L\left(\frac{g_1}{g_1 - g_2} - \frac{1}{2}\right)

For a −3% to +1% sag, the fraction is 3/4, so the low point is always L/4L/4 past the PVI. To put it 150 ft past, use L=600 ftL = 600\ \text{ft}. One unknown, and it's linear.

Carrying the curve through a fixed elevation takes one more idea. The tangents don't move when LL changes. So at a given station, a distance dd past the PVI (negative if it's before), the back tangent, extended past the PVI if need be, is at YPVI+g1dY_{\text{PVI}} + g_1d no matter what, and the offset the curve needs from it is fixed too. That station sits at x=L/2+dx = L/2 + d from the PVC, so:

Offset needed=ax2=g2−g12L(L2+d)2\text{Offset needed} = ax^2 = \frac{g_2 - g_1}{2L}\left(\frac{L}{2} + d\right)^2

LL is in both aa and xx, and multiplying out gives a quadratic in LL. Keep the root that puts the station on the curve, which needs L/2L/2 to be at least ∣d∣|d|. At the PVI's own station, d=0d = 0 and the equation collapses to the middle offset, AL/800AL/800, which is linear.

26+00 28+00 30+00 32+00 34+00 31+00 Bridge −4% +2% PVI 350.00 PVC PVC L = 800 ft L = 400 ft 355.38 Road must be at 354.00 352.75
A longer sag sits higher at the bridge
Two sag curves through the same PVI, with the elevation the road must reach under a bridge at station 31+00.

Under the bridge, the 400-ft sag passes at 352.75 ft and the 800-ft sag at 355.38 ft, on either side of the 354.00 ft the road needs, so some length between them threads the point. A longer curve swings wider of the corner at every station, so under a bridge that length is the longest sag that keeps the clearance. On a crest, it's the shortest.

Worked Example Fitting a sag under a bridge
1 of 3

A sag curve joins a −4% grade to a +2% grade at a PVI at station 30+00, elevation 350.00 ft. A bridge crosses over the road at station 31+00, and to leave the required clearance, the road there must be at elevation 354.00 ft. What curve length does that?

Recap

  • A high or low point is where the grade passes through zero, at xm=g1L/(g1−g2)x_m = g_1L/(g_1 - g_2) from the PVC. Add the PVC's station, and take the elevation from the curve equation.
  • It lies within the curve only when g1g_1 and g2g_2 differ in sign, and then on the flatter grade's side of the PVI. Otherwise, the highest or lowest point is an end.
  • For the station at an elevation, solve the curve equation as a quadratic in xx and keep the root between 0 and LL.
  • To fit a curve to a point, solve for LL, remembering that the PVC moves with it: linear for a low point at a station, quadratic for an elevation at a station.