Vertical Curve Length for Sight Distance

Over a crest, the hill itself is what blocks the driver's view.

A car sits stalled in your lane just past the top of a hill, and you're coming up the other side at 60 mph. From Stopping Sight Distance, you need about 570 ft to stop. Over a long, gentle crest, the car comes into view with room to spare. Over a short, sharp one, it pops up when you're already too close. Same grades, same car, same driver: the only difference is how long the designer made the curve.

By the end of this Lesson, you'll find the shortest curve that still works, over a crest and through a sag.

Your line of sight just grazes the hill

Stretch an imaginary string from your eyes to the top of the stalled car. While the hump of the road pokes up through the string, the car is hidden. Drive closer, and at some moment the string just touches the pavement at a single point. That's when the car comes into view, and the horizontal distance to it then is the sight distance SS.

The Handbook's table Vertical Curves: Sight Distance Related to Curve Length sets the heights: the driver's eye at h1=3.50 fth_1 = 3.50\ \text{ft} above the road, and the object at h2=2.0 fth_2 = 2.0\ \text{ft}, about the height of a car's taillights. A long, gentle curve has a flat hump, so the string can stretch a long way before it touches. A short, sharp one bulges up into it sooner.

d1 d2 S L Eye h1 = 3.5 ft Object h2 = 2.0 ft Line of sight PVC PVT
The line of sight touching the crest, with the eye and the object both on the curve
The heights are exaggerated far more than the grades, so they show.

Now the square law from Vertical Curve Geometry does the rest. It isn't special to the PVC. Draw the tangent at any point on a parabola, and the curve falls away below it by ∣a∣ d2|a|\,d^2, with dd the horizontal distance from that point and the same aa. The line of sight is the tangent at the touching point. The eye is d1d_1 back from it, where the road has fallen 3.5 ft below the line, and the object is d2d_2 ahead, where the road has fallen 2.0 ft:

∣a∣ d12=3.5∣a∣ d22=2.0with∣a∣=A200L|a|\,d_1^2 = 3.5 \qquad |a|\,d_2^2 = 2.0 \qquad\text{with}\quad |a| = \frac{A}{200L}

Solve each for its distance and add them: S=d1+d2=(3.5+2.0)200L/AS = d_1 + d_2 = (\sqrt{3.5} + \sqrt{2.0})\sqrt{200L/A}. Square that and solve for LL:

L=AS2200(3.5+2.0)2=AS22,158L = \frac{AS^2}{200\left(\sqrt{3.5} + \sqrt{2.0}\right)^2} = \frac{AS^2}{2{,}158}

So 2,158 is just the eye and object heights packed into one number. The Handbook's table prints this as its Standard Criteria row, under a general form in h1h_1 and h2h_2.

AA goes in as a positive percent. The hill in Vertical Curve Geometry went from +3% to −1%, so A=4A = 4, not 0.04 or −4. For 570 ft of sight, it needs L=4(570)2/2,158=602 ftL = 4(570)^2/2{,}158 = 602\ \text{ft}, and its 800 ft is plenty.

When the sight distance is longer than the curve

That picture put the eye and the object both on the curve, so it holds only when S≤LS \le L, as the Handbook labels the column. Shorten the curve enough, and the car comes into view while you're still on the straight back tangent and it's out on the forward tangent. Straight road doesn't fall away with the square, so the Handbook's S>LS > L column has a different equation:

L=2S−2,158A(S>L)L = 2S - \frac{2{,}158}{A} \qquad (S > L)
S L Eye h1 = 3.5 ft Object h2 = 2.0 ft Line of sight PVC PVT
A short crest, with the eye and the object out on the tangents

Which picture are you in? LL is the thing you're solving for, so assume, then check. The two equations give exactly the same length when L=SL = S, and they part ways from there.

  • Try the S≤LS \le L form first. If it gives a length at least as long as SS, the assumption holds, and that's the answer. Our hill passes: 602 ft is longer than 570 ft.
  • If it gives a length shorter than SS, it has described a curve that contradicts its own picture. Switch to the S>LS > L form. Its answer will come out shorter than SS, just as its picture requires.
Worked Example A crest with a small change in grade
1 of 3

A crest curve joins a +2.0% grade to a −0.5% grade. The design stopping sight distance is 570 ft. Find the minimum length of curve.

Through a sag, the headlights set the limit

Now turn the hill upside down. In daylight, a sag hides nothing: you're looking down into the dip and across it. At night, you see only what your headlights light, and the road ahead curves up into the beam. A sharp sag catches the beam close to the car, and a gentle one lets it reach farther. The beam has to light the road at least one stopping sight distance ahead.

AASHTO puts the headlight 2 ft above the road, with the top of the beam tilted 1° above the direction the car points. The Handbook prints neither number, only the constants they make, so here's where those come from. Put the car at the PVC, pointing along the back tangent. A distance SS ahead, the beam is 2+Stan⁡1∘2 + S\tan 1^\circ above that tangent, extended. The road has curved up above the same line by ∣a∣S2|a|S^2, the square law measured from the PVC. The beam lights the road where the two meet:

A200LS2=2+Stan⁡1∘⟹L=AS2400+3.5S\frac{A}{200L}S^2 = 2 + S\tan 1^\circ \quad\Longrightarrow\quad L = \frac{AS^2}{400 + 3.5S}
S L 2 ft 1° Headlight beam PVC PVT
At night, the road curves up into the headlight beam
The heights and the 1° tilt are exaggerated, so they show.

The 400 is 200 times the 2-ft headlight height, and 3.5 is 200tan⁡1∘=3.49200\tan 1^\circ = 3.49, rounded. It's the same parabola and the same square law as on the crest. Only the sight line changed: a string over a hump there, a beam into a bowl here. The Handbook lists it as the Sag Vertical Curve (based on standard headlight criteria), with an S>LS > L form beside it and the same check:

L=AS2400+3.5S(S≤L)L=2S−400+3.5SA(S>L)L = \frac{AS^2}{400 + 3.5S}\quad (S \le L) \qquad\qquad L = 2S - \frac{400 + 3.5S}{A}\quad (S > L)

Keep the two families apart: 2,158 is eyes over a crest, and 400+3.5S400 + 3.5S is headlights into a sag.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A sag curve joins a −3.5% grade to a +1.5% grade. The design stopping sight distance is 450 ft. What minimum length does the headlight criterion require?

ft

Through a sag, comfort sets a second limit

A sag gets one more check. Through the bottom, the car's path bends upward, so the seat has to push you up harder than gravity alone would. You feel heavier for a moment, the way you do at the bottom of a swing. AASHTO keeps that extra push to about 1 ft/s2\text{ft/s}^2, a few percent of gg. The Handbook's row for the Sag Vertical Curve (based on riding comfort) is that limit, with the mph conversion folded into the 46.5:

L=AV246.5L = \frac{AV^2}{46.5}

This one takes the design speed VV in mph, not a sight distance. It usually asks for a much shorter curve than the headlights do, so on an unlit highway, the headlights govern. Comfort controls where street lighting does the headlights' job. Here are all three criteria together:

Minimum vertical curve lengths
Curve and criterionS≤LS \le LS>LS > L
Crest, line of sightAS2/2,158AS^2/2{,}1582S−2,158/A2S - 2{,}158/A
Sag, headlightsAS2/(400+3.5S)AS^2/(400 + 3.5S)2S−(400+3.5S)/A2S - (400 + 3.5S)/A
Sag, comfortAV2/46.5AV^2/46.5AV2/46.5AV^2/46.5

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Vertical Curves: Sight Distance Related to Curve Length

K, the length per percent of grade

Run down the S≤LS \le L column. Every entry is AA times something, and AA is the only place the grades appear. That something has a name. The Handbook defines the rate of vertical curvature as

K=LAK = \frac{L}{A}

the horizontal distance, in feet, that the curve takes to change the grade by 1%. Our hill turned 4% of grade in 800 ft, so K=200K = 200 ft per percent. A bigger KK is a gentler curve.

Look at what's left once AA comes out: S2/2,158S^2/2{,}158 on a crest, S2/(400+3.5S)S^2/(400 + 3.5S) for headlights, and V2/46.5V^2/46.5 for comfort. Only the speed is in there, directly or through the sight distance it sets, which is why a design KK goes with a design speed. Problems use it two ways:

  • Given a design KK, the minimum length is L=KAL = KA.
  • Given an existing curve, find its K=L/AK = L/A and compare. At least the design value means the curve is long enough. Less means it's too sharp.
Checkpoint
1 of 3

A sag curve joins a −2.0% grade to a +3.5% grade, and the design KK for the road's speed is 96. What is the minimum length of curve?

ft

Speed is what makes curves long

Divide the crest's S≤LS \le L form by AA, and K=S2/2,158K = S^2/2{,}158 tells the whole story of how the required length moves.

  • The grade difference scales the length and leaves KK alone. L=KAL = KA, so twice the change in grade needs twice the curve.
  • The design speed works through S2S^2, and SS itself grows faster than the speed, because its braking term goes with V2V^2. On level ground with AASHTO's values, going from 30 mph to 60 mph takes SS from 197 ft to 566 ft, nearly three times. Square that, and KK goes from 18 to 148, about eight times.

Double the design speed, and a crest with the same grades needs about eight times the curve. That's why fast highways roll over long, lazy crests.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Which statements about minimum vertical curve lengths are true?

A.
A crest's minimum length is set by the driver's line of sight over the hill to an object on the road
B.
A larger K means a sharper curve
C.
On an unlit highway, a sag's minimum length is usually set by how far the headlights reach
D.
If the S ≤ L form gives a length shorter than S, that length is the minimum
E.
Two crests share a design speed, with S ≤ L. One turns 6% of grade and the other 3%, so the first needs twice the length and twice the K

Recap

  • Over a crest, the line of sight from a 3.5-ft eye to a 2.0-ft object grazes the road, and those heights make the 2,158. Through a sag at night, the headlight beam meets the rising road, and its height and tilt make the 400 + 3.5S.
  • Try the S≤LS \le L form first, and switch to the S>LS > L form if it gives a length shorter than SS. AA goes in as a positive percent.
  • Rider comfort through a sag needs L=AV2/46.5L = AV^2/46.5, with VV in mph, usually less than the headlights need.
  • K=L/AK = L/A is the length per percent of grade change, so L=KAL = KA, and a curve with KK below the design value is too sharp.
  • A crest's K grows with the square of the sight distance, which itself grows faster than speed, so fast roads need much longer curves.