Pump Curves and Operating Points

A pump runs wherever its curve crosses the system's, so changing either one moves it.

Before this Lesson

A pump's nameplate might read 1,000 gpm at 125 ft. Bolt it to a short pipe that spills into a pond beside it, and it pours out far more than that. Bolt it to a long main climbing to a tank on a hill, and it manages a fraction of it. Nothing inside the pump changed. A pump doesn't have one flow; it has a curve of them, and the pipe it's connected to picks the spot. This Lesson finds that spot, and then moves it.

What a pump can do

A centrifugal pump's impeller is a spinning wheel of vanes that slings water outward, and the spin is what gives the water its head. With the discharge valve shut, the impeller just churns the trapped water: it delivers nothing, but it makes its greatest head, the shutoff head. Open the valve, and water rushing through carries off less spin per pound, so the more the pump delivers, the less head it makes. Plot head against flow, and you have the pump curve: highest at zero flow, falling as the flow rises. Manufacturers measure it on a test stand, and problems hand it to you.

The Handbook's Centrifugal Pump Characteristics section draws a generic pump curve at constant speed and impeller diameter, and a real manufacturer's chart with a separate curve for each of four impeller diameters. It writes the head HH, the same total dynamic head that Pump Head and Power called hph_p, and this Lesson does too.

What the pipeline needs

The pipeline has a curve of its own, and you've met it: the head needed to push a flow through is the static head, from water surface to water surface, plus losses that grow with roughly the square of the flow.

H=Hstatic+KQ2H = H_{\text{static}} + KQ^2

Here KK lumps the friction and fittings together, and one known point sets it. This is the system curve. It starts at the static head and bends upward, and it belongs to the pipes and the water levels, not to the pump.

Where the curves cross

Put both curves on one graph. The pump curve says what head the pump makes at each flow, and the system curve says what head the pipeline needs. Where they cross is the only flow that satisfies both, the operating point.

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 0 50 100 150 200 flow, Q (gpm) head, H (ft) pump curve system curve shutoff head 160 ft static head 100 ft operating point 1,000 gpm, 125 ft
The pump runs where its curve crosses the system curve
Pump curve H=160−35(Q/1,000)2H = 160 - 35(Q/1{,}000)^2; system curve H=100+25(Q/1,000)2H = 100 + 25(Q/1{,}000)^2, the pipeline from Pump Head and Power.

Why can't the pump run anywhere else? Suppose the water were moving at 1,400 gpm. The pump makes only 91 ft there, but the pipeline needs 149 ft, so the water slows. At 600 gpm, the pump makes 147 ft against a need of 109 ft, and the surplus speeds the water up. Either way, it settles at 1,000 gpm and 125 ft. When both curves come as equations, set them equal and solve for QQ. The Handbook prints pump curves but no system curve; you build that one yourself from the static head and one known point.

Changing the system

Because the operating point is a crossing, it moves whenever either curve does. The system curve can change in two ways, one for each of its terms.

Anything that adds loss at a given flow, such as a valve closed partway, raises the KQ2KQ^2 term: the curve starts at the same static head but climbs more steeply. The valve does nothing to the pump, so the pump curve stays put, and the crossing slides up and to the left along it. In the figure, throttling cuts the flow from 1,000 to about 800 gpm, while the head the pump makes rises from 125 to 138 ft.

A change in either water level changes the static head instead, which shifts the whole curve up or down. Raise the tank's water surface 30 ft, and the crossing again slides up the pump curve, to about 710 gpm at 142 ft.

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 0 50 100 150 200 flow, Q (gpm) head, H (ft) (a) valve throttled pump curve before throttled 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 0 50 100 150 200 flow, Q (gpm) head, H (ft) (b) static head raised pump curve before static head raised 130 ft
Two ways the system curve moves, and where the pump ends up
Throttled: H=100+60(Q/1,000)2H = 100 + 60(Q/1{,}000)^2, about 795 gpm at 138 ft. Static head raised: H=130+25(Q/1,000)2H = 130 + 25(Q/1{,}000)^2, about 707 gpm at 142.5 ft.

Either way, the pump can only move along its own curve, trading flow for head.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Over 25 years, the inside of a pumped water main roughens, and its Hazen-Williams C falls from 130 to 95. The pump and both water levels are unchanged. How does the operating point move?

A.
To more flow at a lower head
B.
To the same flow at a higher head, because the pump works harder
C.
To less flow at a higher head
D.
To less flow at a lower head, because the pump curve drops

Two pumps

Adding a second, identical pump changes the pump curve instead. In series, the water passes through one pump and then the other: both carry the same flow and their heads add, so the combined curve is twice as tall at every flow. In parallel, the pumps share the same suction and discharge pipes: both face the same head and their flows add, so the combined curve is twice as wide at every head. The Handbook doesn't cover pumps in series or parallel; the rules come straight from what the two words mean.

That doubles the curve, not the result, because the pump still has to run on the same system curve. In parallel, the doubled-flow point, 2,000 gpm at 125 ft, isn't on it: the pipeline needs 200 ft to carry 2,000 gpm. The crossing lands at about 1,330 gpm, a third more flow, not double. In series, the doubled-head point, 250 ft at 1,000 gpm, is far more head than the pipeline needs at that flow, so the water speeds up until the losses catch up, at about 158 ft. Either way, the operating point slides up the system curve, to more flow and more head. Parallel pumps never double the flow, and series pumps never double the head. Here series even ends up with more flow than parallel; which arrangement gains more depends on the shapes of both curves, and only the crossing can tell you.

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 flow, Q (gpm) head, H (ft) (a) two pumps in parallel 2 × flow two in parallel 2 pumps one pump system curve 1 pump 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 flow, Q (gpm) head, H (ft) (b) two pumps in series 2 × head two in series 2 pumps one pump system curve 1 pump
Two pumps double the curve, but not the flow or the head
Parallel: H=160−35(Q/2,000)2H = 160 - 35(Q/2{,}000)^2, which meets the system curve at about 1,333 gpm and 144 ft. Series: H=2[160−35(Q/1,000)2]H = 2[160 - 35(Q/1{,}000)^2], which meets it at about 158 ft.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

Running alone, a pump delivers 900 gpm at 110 ft. A second, identical pump is connected in parallel with it. Which of these could be the new operating point?

A.
1,800 gpm at 110 ft
B.
1,250 gpm at 128 ft
C.
900 gpm at 220 ft
D.
1,250 gpm at 96 ft

Changing the speed or the impeller

The other way to move a pump curve is to change the pump: spin it faster or slower, as a variable-speed drive does, or fit a different impeller. Every velocity inside a pump scales with the impeller's rim speed, which goes as NDND, the rotational speed times the diameter. The rest follows:

  • Flow is velocity times area, and the passages' area goes as D2D^2, so QQ goes as ND3ND^3.
  • Head is a velocity head, v2/2gv^2/2g, so HH goes as N2D2N^2D^2.
  • Power is QγHQ\gamma H, so its exponents add: W˙\dot W goes as N3D5N^3D^5.

The Handbook prints these as its Scaling Laws; Affinity Laws, under Fans, Pumps, and Compressors, for one pump at two conditions or two similar pumps:

(QND3)2=(QND3)1(HN2D2)2=(HN2D2)1(W˙ρN3D5)2=(W˙ρN3D5)1\begin{gathered} \left(\frac{Q}{ND^3}\right)_2 = \left(\frac{Q}{ND^3}\right)_1 \qquad \left(\frac{H}{N^2D^2}\right)_2 = \left(\frac{H}{N^2D^2}\right)_1 \\[6pt] \left(\frac{\dot W}{\rho N^3D^5}\right)_2 = \left(\frac{\dot W}{\rho N^3D^5}\right)_1 \end{gathered}

For a speed change on the same pump, DD cancels:

Q2Q1=N2N1H2H1=(N2N1)2W˙2W˙1=(N2N1)3\frac{Q_2}{Q_1} = \frac{N_2}{N_1} \qquad \frac{H_2}{H_1} = \left(\frac{N_2}{N_1}\right)^2 \qquad \frac{\dot W_2}{\dot W_1} = \left(\frac{N_2}{N_1}\right)^3

For a diameter change at the same speed, NN cancels, and the exponents are 3, 2, and 5. These diameter laws compare similar pumps, scaled in every dimension. Pump makers estimate an impeller trimmed inside its own casing with exponents 1, 2, and 3 instead, a rule the Handbook doesn't print, so use it only when a problem gives it.

Say this Lesson's pump turns at 1,750 rpm. Slow it to 1,400 rpm, a ratio of 0.8, and its point at 1,000 gpm and 125 ft moves to 800 gpm and 0.82(125)=80 ft0.8^2(125) = 80\ \text{ft}. Every point moves the same way, along a parabola through the origin, because HH goes as N2N^2 while QQ goes as NN.

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 0 50 100 150 200 flow, Q (gpm) head, H (ft) 1,750 rpm 1,400 rpm H ∝ Q2 1,000 gpm, 125 ft 800 gpm,80 ft
Slowing the pump shrinks its whole curve toward the origin

Those two points correspond, but where the slowed pump actually runs is still its crossing with the system curve. With static head, the flow falls by more than the speed ratio; in this Lesson's pipeline, it drops to about 200 gpm, because the slowed pump's shutoff head, 0.64(160)=102 ft0.64(160) = 102\ \text{ft}, barely beats the 100 ft static head. A problem that asks for a pump's flow or head at a new speed means the corresponding point, straight from the laws.

Worked Example Slowing a pump
1 of 3

A pump turning at 1,750 rpm delivers 1,200 gpm against 140 ft and takes 50 hp at its shaft. A variable-speed drive slows it to 1,450 rpm. Find the flow, head, and brake power at the corresponding point.

Recap

  • The pump curve falls from the shutoff head as flow rises; the system curve, H=Hstatic+KQ2H = H_{\text{static}} + KQ^2, rises from the static head. The pump runs where they cross.
  • A throttled valve or an aging pipe steepens the system curve, and a water-level change shifts it. The pump curve stays put, so the operating point trades flow for head along it.
  • Identical pumps in series add heads at each flow; in parallel, they add flows at each head. On the unchanged system curve, flow and head both rise, but parallel pumps never double the flow, and series pumps never double the head.
  • Affinity laws: Q∝ND3Q \propto ND^3, H∝N2D2H \propto N^2D^2, W˙∝N3D5\dot W \propto N^3D^5. Speed alone: exponents 1, 2, 3. Diameter alone: 3, 2, 5.