Construction Site Safety

Five feet of trench and six feet of height are where the rules start.

Stand in a trench as deep as you are tall, and the wall beside you is a slab of soil looming over your head, standing only because nothing has made it fall yet. At a typical 110 lb/ft³, each cubic yard of it weighs about 3,000 lb, as much as a small car, and a wall that lets go comes down faster than you can react.

Cave-ins and falls are construction's two classic killers, and OSHA's rules for both start at a handful of depths and heights. The Handbook prints none of them, so you carry them in yourself.

Who sets the rules

Workplace safety in the United States belongs to OSHA, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration. OSHA writes the safety standards employers must follow, including the personal protective equipment (PPE) workers need, and enforces them with inspections and fines. Exam questions set it beside agencies whose names or jobs sound close:

OSHA and the agencies it gets confused with
AgencyWhat it does
OSHASets and enforces workplace safety rules, PPE included
NIOSHResearches hazards and recommends limits
MSHASets and enforces safety rules for mines and quarries
EPAProtects air, water, and land from pollution
FHWAFunds highways and sets their design standards

The pair that trips people up is NIOSH and OSHA. NIOSH, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, studies what hurts workers and recommends limits; OSHA makes the rules and enforces them. NIOSH recommends, OSHA requires. The Handbook's agency table, under Definition of Safety, names these agencies (FHWA under USDOT) but not their jobs, and it labels NIOSH a regulatory agency too. Go by the table above.

Checkpoint

A contractor building a highway interchange wants the federal requirements for the hard hats, safety glasses, and hearing protection its crews must wear. Which agency sets them?

A.
FHWA
B.
NIOSH
C.
EPA
D.
OSHA

When a trench needs protection

A vertical cut stands only on the soil's own strength: the stickiness of clay, or, for a while, damp sand clinging together. Meanwhile the soil behind the wall pushes outward, and like water pressure, the push grows with depth. Cut deeper and more soil pushes, each foot harder than the one above, until the push wins, often without warning. So OSHA's excavation rules are written as depths:

  • 4 ft or deeper: a trench needs a means of egress, a ladder, stairway, or ramp, placed so that no worker has to travel more than 25 ft sideways to reach it.
  • 5 ft or deeper: workers need a protective system, unless the excavation is entirely in stable rock. Shallower, one is needed only if a competent person, someone trained to spot the hazards and authorized to fix them, sees signs of a possible cave-in.
  • Deeper than 20 ft: the protective system must be designed by a registered professional engineer.

A protective system is one of four things. Sloping lays the walls back to an angle the soil can hold, and benching cuts them into steps that do the same. Shoring braces the walls with struts and sheeting so they can't move. Shielding, usually a steel trench box, doesn't stop a wall from falling; it protects the workers inside when one does.

How far back a sloped wall must lean depends on the soil, and OSHA sorts soil into four classes for that decision. They aren't USCS or AASHTO groups: OSHA judges how well a cut face will stand, from the soil's strength and whether it's cracked, wet, or shaken by traffic, not from its grain size.

Maximum allowable slopes for excavations 20 ft deep or less
ClassTypical materialMax slope (H:V)
Stable rockSolid rockVertical (90°)
Type AStiff, uncracked clay¾ : 1 (53°)
Type BSofter clay, silt, previously dug soil1 : 1 (45°)
Type CSand, gravel, submerged or seeping soil1½ : 1 (34°)

Source: OSHA, 29 CFR 1926 Subpart P, Appendix B, Table B-1

Trench floor Stable rock: vertical Type A: ¾ : 1 Type B: 1 : 1 Type C: 1½ : 1 H 1.5H
The steepest wall each class of soil allows, drawn to the same depth
The weaker the soil, the farther the wall lays back. Type C lays back 1.5 ft for every foot of depth.

The Handbook doesn't print this table, and a question that needs a slope states it. What to carry is the order: the weaker the soil, the flatter the slope, and Type C is the flattest.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A trench for a water service line will be 4½ ft deep in Type B soil, and the competent person on site sees no sign of a possible cave-in. What does OSHA require?

A.
A protective system and a means of egress
B.
A protective system, but no means of egress
C.
Neither one until the trench reaches 5 ft
D.
A means of egress within 25 ft of travel, but no protective system

How wide a sloped trench gets

Excavation slopes are written horizontal to vertical, the reverse of a grade. A slope of 1½:1 means 1½ ft out for every 1 ft down. Call that horizontal number nn. Over a depth HH, a wall lays back a distance nHnH from the edge of the trench floor, and a trench has two walls doing it.

H b nH nH W 1 n
Cross-section of a trench with both walls sloped
Each wall lays back nHnH, so the top is wider than the bottom by twice that.
W=b+2nHW = b + 2nH

Here bb is the bottom width and WW the top width. A pit, sloped on all four sides, grows by 2nH2nH in each plan dimension, length and width alike.

Worked Example The top width of a trench in Type C soil
1 of 2

A sewer trench in Type C soil is 4 ft wide at the bottom and 8 ft deep, with both walls cut at the maximum allowable slope, 1½H:1V. How wide is it at the top?

Falls and ladders

The other killer runs the opposite way. Drop 6 ft and you hit at about 20 ft/s, roughly 13 mph, and that's where OSHA's construction standard draws the line. Anyone at an unprotected side or edge 6 ft or more above a lower level needs fall protection: a guardrail, a safety net, or a personal fall arrest system (a harness and lanyard tied to an anchor). General industry, such as factories and warehouses, uses 4 ft. A job site is construction, so the exam wants 6.

Ladders get two rules. A ladder reaching an upper landing must have side rails extending at least 3 ft above the landing, so there's something to hold while stepping on and off. And it leans at 4 to 1: for every 4 ft of height to where the top rests, the foot sits 1 ft out from the wall. That's about 75°, steep enough that the foot won't skid out and not so steep that the ladder tips back. (OSHA words it as a quarter of the ladder's length from foot to top support, which comes out nearly the same.)

h 3 ft min. Upper landing h/4
A ladder set up to reach a roof
The rails run past the roof edge, and the foot sits 1 ft out for every 4 ft of height.

Put the trench and fall rules together, and every threshold you need is a depth below the ground or a height above it.

Ground 6 ft: fall protection 4 ft: egress within 25 ft 5 ft: protective system 20 ft: engineer-designed system beyond Height of an edge above the level below Trench depth
OSHA's construction thresholds, measured from the ground
Not to scale. The 4, 5, and 20 ft marks are trench depths; the 6 ft mark is the height of an edge above the level below.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A ladder gives access to a roof whose edge is 18 ft above the ground, with its rails resting against the roof edge. How far from the wall should its foot be set?

ft

Ranking the ways to control a hazard

The Handbook's Safety and Prevention section separates two words people often blur. A hazard is the capacity to cause harm, a property of the thing itself: a spinning saw blade, a trench wall in sand. Risk is the chance that someone actually gets hurt, and the Handbook writes it as

Risk=Hazard×Exposure\text{Risk} = \text{Hazard} \times \text{Exposure}

where exposure is how much contact people have with the hazard: how many, how close, how long. (It also writes probability in place of exposure.) A sand trench wall is just as hazardous with nobody in the trench, but then the risk is zero.

The ways to bring risk down are ranked in a fixed order, the hierarchy of controls, which the Handbook doesn't print.

Elimination Substitution Engineering controls Administrative controls PPE Most effective Least effective Works without anyone's cooperation Works only if each worker uses it, every time
The hierarchy of hazard controls
Elimination and substitution change the hazard, engineering controls change the workplace, and administrative controls and PPE change what people do.
  • Elimination removes the hazard. Cast an opening into a concrete wall instead of sawing it out later, and no one ever runs the saw.
  • Substitution swaps in something less hazardous, such as a water-based coating in place of a solvent-based one.
  • Engineering controls change the equipment or the workplace so the hazard can't reach people: a guardrail at an edge, a trench box, a water spray that keeps a saw's dust out of the air.
  • Administrative controls change how people work: training, procedures, warning signs, and schedules that limit who is near a hazard and for how long.
  • PPE goes on the worker: hard hats, safety glasses, earplugs, respirators, harnesses.

Read down the list and watch how much rests on people. A cast-in opening protects everyone without anyone remembering anything. A guardrail works as long as it's left up. Training works as long as people remember it, and a harness only if this worker clips it on this time. Some controls leave the hazard alone and cut the exposure instead: move the cutting station away from everyone else, and the saw is just as loud, but fewer people hear it.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

The roof trusses for a warehouse need permanent bracing. The crew can install it standing on top of the walls, 20 ft up, or the trusses and their bracing can be assembled on the ground and lifted into place as a unit. Which control for the fall hazard is most effective?

A.
Assembling trusses and bracing on the ground and lifting them as a unit
B.
Harnesses tied off to an anchor for everyone on the walls
C.
Fall-hazard training and a safety monitor watching the crew
D.
Guardrails along the tops of the walls

Keeping score with the incidence rate

One contractor had 6 recordable injuries last year and another had 3. Which is safer? You can't tell: the first might employ four times as many people. To compare fairly, divide by the hours worked. The Handbook's Safety chapter gives the formula under Incidence Variable Values:

IR=N×200,000T\text{IR} = \frac{N \times 200{,}000}{T}

NN is the number of injuries, illnesses, and fatalities needing more than first aid (the recordable cases), and TT is the total hours all employees worked in the period, usually built from crew size, hours per week, and weeks.

The 200,000 is 100 workers at 40 hours a week for 50 weeks, so the rate is cases per 100 full-time workers per year, whether the company has 20 people or 2,000.

Owners often prequalify contractors with a cap on the rate. Then the question runs backward: solve for NN, and since cases come whole, round down. Rounding up puts the rate over the cap.

Worked Example A contractor's incidence rate
1 of 3

A paving contractor's crew of 45 averaged 50 hours a week over a 48-week season and had 4 recordable cases. What was its incidence rate?

Recap

  • OSHA sets and enforces workplace safety rules, PPE included; NIOSH only researches and recommends.
  • A trench needs egress within 25 ft at 4 ft deep, a protective system at 5 ft unless in stable rock, and an engineer-designed system past 20 ft. Slopes are horizontal to vertical, Type C soil needs the flattest, and the top width is W=b+2nHW = b + 2nH.
  • Construction fall protection starts at 6 ft. Ladder rails extend 3 ft above the landing, and the foot sits 1 ft out for every 4 ft up.
  • Controls rank elimination, substitution, engineering, administrative, PPE, by how little depends on people. Less exposure means less risk, even with the hazard unchanged.
  • IR=N×200,000/T\text{IR} = N \times 200{,}000/T is cases per 100 full-time workers per year. Under a cap, solve for NN and round down.