Fleet Balancing and Equipment Cost

A fleet moves only as fast as its slowest link.

Before this Lesson

A loader on a highway cut fills a haul truck in 3 minutes. Each truck then spends 9 minutes hauling, dumping, and driving back, so it's ready for another load every 12 minutes. The contractor has three trucks. Watch the loader for a while, and you'll see it fill all three, then sit with its bucket on the ground for 3 minutes until the first one is back. Hire a fourth truck, and the job moves a third more dirt every hour. Hire a fifth, and it moves exactly as much as it did with four, while the fifth driver spends the day in line.

Two machines, one chain

A loader and its trucks form a chain. The loader can't load soil faster than trucks arrive to take it, and the trucks can't haul more than the loader puts in them. To see how the two fit together, you need one time from each machine.

The first is the loading time, LL: how long the loader takes to fill one truck. It fills the truck a bucket at a time, so LL is the number of bucket passes times the loader's cycle time, and the passes are the truck's capacity over the bucket's payload. A 15 LCY truck under a 3 LCY bucket takes 5 passes, and at 36 seconds a pass, L=5(0.6)=3.0L = 5(0.6) = 3.0 minutes.

The second is the truck's cycle time, TT, built from its five parts, and the minutes under the loader are one of them. A question often gives the other four and leaves LL for you to work out and add. Here is the Hook's loader over two truck cycles:

3 trucks 4 trucks 1 2 3 idle 1 2 3 idle load load load load load load 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 load load load load load load load load haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot haul, dump, return, spot loader truck 1 truck 2 truck 3 loader truck 1 truck 2 truck 3 truck 4 L = 3 min T = 12 min 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24 minutes
The Hook's loader with three trucks and with four
Each truck spends 3 minutes under the loader and 9 away, so its cycle is 12 minutes. With three trucks, the loader fills all of them with 3 minutes to spare before the first one returns.

While one truck goes through its 12-minute cycle, the loader has time to fill 12/3=412/3 = 4 trucks. So the number of trucks that keeps a loader busy is the number of loading times that fit into one truck cycle:

N=TLN = \frac{T}{L}

On a real job, T/LT/L is rarely a whole number. Say it comes out 5.6. With five trucks, the loader waits for part of every cycle. With six, it never waits, and each truck waits a little in turn instead. Keeping the loader busy takes six, so the count rounds up.

The slower link sets the pace

Each link in the chain has a production of its own. If a truck is always waiting, the loader puts one truckload qq into a truck every LL minutes. Each truck delivers its qq once every TT minutes, and NN trucks deliver NN times as much. What the loader loads, the trucks carry, so the fleet moves whichever is smaller:

Ploader=qnLPtrucks=N(qnT)Pfleet=min⁡(Ploader, Ptrucks)P_{\text{loader}} = \frac{qn}{L} \qquad P_{\text{trucks}} = N\left(\frac{qn}{T}\right) \qquad P_{\text{fleet}} = \min\left(P_{\text{loader}},\ P_{\text{trucks}}\right)

Divide the trucks' production by the loader's, and almost everything cancels, leaving NL/TNL/T. The trucks are the slower link when NN is less than T/LT/L, and the loader is when it's more: the truck count from the last section, seen from the other side.

Give the Hook's trucks a 15 LCY payload and the job a 50-minute hour. Each truck hauls 15(50)/12=62.515(50)/12 = 62.5 LCY/hr, and the loader can load 15(50)/3=25015(50)/3 = 250 LCY/hr, the same as its 3 LCY bucket on a 36-second cycle, 3(50)/0.63(50)/0.6. Add trucks one at a time and watch the fleet:

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 0 100 200 300 400 number of trucks production (LCY/hr) trucks can haul: 62.5 per truck loader can load: 250 fleet 187.5 balanced: T/L = 4 undertrucked:trucks limit overtrucked:loader limits
Fleet production as trucks join the Hook's loader
Up to four trucks, each one adds 62.5 LCY/hr. At four, the trucks can haul everything the loader can load, and a fifth truck adds nothing.

A fleet with too few trucks is undertrucked: the trucks limit production, and the loader waits. A fleet with too many is overtrucked: the loader limits, and trucks wait in line to be loaded. Either way, the waiting machine is still being paid for by the hour.

Two pieces of bookkeeping keep the comparison honest. Both rates must be in the same volume state: a bucket and a truck bed both carry loose soil, so take the smaller rate in LCY and convert it to bank yards once, if the question asks. And the job efficiency scales both rates alike, so it can never change which one is smaller, and it goes in once. The Handbook prints none of this Lesson's relations, so a question gives every payload, cycle, and rate you need.

Worked Example A loader one truck short
1 of 3

A loader with a 5 LCY bucket and a 36-second cycle loads 20 LCY haul trucks. Each truck spots in 0.6 min, hauls for 5.8 min, dumps in 1.2 min, and returns in 4.0 min. The job runs a 50-minute hour, and the soil swells 25%. How many trucks keep the loader busy? The contractor has only five. What does the fleet produce, in BCY/hr?

Time is quantity over production

Once you know what a fleet produces, the schedule follows from one division:

time=quantityproduction\text{time} = \frac{\text{quantity}}{\text{production}}

Yards divided by yards per hour leaves hours, and the working hours in a day turn hours into days. The quantity and the production have to be in the same state, and they often aren't, because a cut is measured in the ground and a fleet's production in its trucks.

Put the Hook's four-truck fleet, 250 LCY/hr, on a cut of 30,000 BCY that swells 25%. In loose yards the cut is 30,000(1.25)=37,50030{,}000(1.25) = 37{,}500 LCY, and 37,500/250=15037{,}500/250 = 150 hours is 15 ten-hour days.

A deadline runs the same division the other way. The quantity over the hours available is the production the job needs, and that over what one machine or fleet produces is how many it takes. To finish the cut in 10 days, the job needs 37,500/(10×10)=37537{,}500/(10 \times 10) = 375 LCY/hr, or 375/250=1.5375/250 = 1.5 fleets. Half a loader doesn't exist, and one fleet would finish late, so the job needs 2 fleets, each a loader with its four trucks. A count of working days rounds up too, since the fleet is on site for the last partial day. Crews are counted the same way: 12,000 ft² of forms set in 5 days takes 2,400 ft² a day, and at 1,500 ft² per crew a day, that's 1.6 crews, so 2. Crew Costs, Task Duration, and Markups carries the same division into crew costs.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A highway cut holds 168,000 BCY and must be moved in 35 working days of 10 hours. Each scraper produces 250 LCY/hr, and the soil swells 25%. How many scrapers does the job need?

scrapers

Cost per cubic yard

Equipment is rented by the hour, but earthwork is paid for by the yard. To compare machines on the yard's terms, divide what each costs in an hour by what it moves in that hour:

unit cost=hourly costhourly production\text{unit cost} = \frac{\text{hourly cost}}{\text{hourly production}}

An $80/hr loader that moves 160 LCY/hr costs $0.50 a yard. A $120/hr loader that moves 300 LCY/hr costs $0.40, less per yard though it costs half again as much to rent. A bigger machine rents for more and moves more, and only the ratio says which grows faster. Some questions ask for the highest production per dollar instead, hourly production over hourly cost. That's the same ratio upside down, so the same machine wins. A machine's rental rate or its production alone is half the ratio, and can point to the wrong machine.

Worked Example Choosing an excavator
1 of 2

Three excavators can be rented for a job that runs a 50-minute hour. Which one moves dirt at the lowest cost per cubic yard?

Three excavators for rent
ExcavatorBucket (LCY)Cycle (s)Rate ($/hr)
Small2.02596
Medium3.025126
Large4.530198

When the fleet changes

For a whole fleet, the hourly cost is everything on the clock, the loader plus every truck, and the production is the fleet's. Price the Hook's fleet with the loader at $150/hr and each truck at $90/hr:

The Hook's fleet with three, four, and five trucks
TrucksCost ($/hr)Production (LCY/hr)Unit cost ($/LCY)
3420187.52.24
45102502.04
56002502.40

While the fleet is undertrucked, an added truck brings its full 62.5 LCY/hr along with its $90, and the loader's $150 is spread over more yards, so the unit cost falls. Once the fleet is overtrucked, an added truck brings $90 and no yards, so the unit cost only rises. The cheapest yard comes from a balanced fleet. When T/LT/L isn't a whole number, the best fleet is one of the two truck counts on either side of it, so price both.

A longer haul upsets the balance from the trucks' side. It stretches TT and leaves LL alone, since the loader fills a truck just as fast as before, so T/LT/L grows and a balanced fleet becomes undertrucked. The loader starts waiting, production falls to what the trucks can haul, and the unit cost climbs, because every machine is still on the clock. More trucks, as many as the new T/LT/L calls for, bring the loader back to full work. An overtrucked fleet has trucks to spare, so it can take a little more haul before the trucks become the slower link.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

In this soil, a loader can load 300 BCY/hr. Its trucks can together haul 330 LCY/hr, and the soil swells 20%. Which limits the fleet, the loader or the trucks, and what does the fleet produce?

A.
The loader limits, at 300 BCY/hr.
B.
The trucks limit, at 264 BCY/hr.
C.
The trucks limit, at 275 BCY/hr.

Recap

  • Loading time is bucket passes times the loader's cycle, and it's part of the truck's cycle. A busy loader takes N=T/LN = T/L trucks, rounded up.
  • A fleet produces at the slower link's rate, the smaller of the loader's and the trucks' production, compared in one volume state.
  • Time = quantity / production. Machines or crews for a deadline, and whole working days, round up.
  • Unit cost = hourly cost / hourly production. Production per dollar is its reciprocal, and neither the lowest rate nor the highest production decides it.
  • An extra truck in an undertrucked fleet raises production and lowers the cost per yard; past balance, it only adds cost. A longer haul stretches only the truck cycle, so a balanced fleet goes undertrucked.