Back

Construction Engineering

  • Topic 14
  • 12 Lessons

Overview

Construction questions are bookkeeping, not physics. Almost every one hands you facts about a job and asks two things of you: lay the facts out where you can see them, as a network of activities, a cost or status table, or a chain of rates, and then compare what was planned with what actually happened. The arithmetic is easy. The skill is keeping the units straight, and for soil, the volume states.

Four ideas do most of the work:

  • Plan versus actual. Project control compares where the job should be by now with where it is, in time and in money.
  • The longest path sets the finish. A project takes as long as its longest chain of dependent work.
  • Cost follows production. A machine's output is its payload over its cycle time, adjusted for efficiency, and hours and dollars follow from that rate.
  • Soil changes volume. The same soil takes up a different volume in the ground, in a truck, and in a compacted fill.
Plan versus actual Longest path Production Volume states planned earned spent finish float payload cycle time yd³/hr $/yd³ dig compact bank 1.00 BCY loose 1.25 LCY compacted 0.80 CCY
The four ideas, one picture each
Earned value is set beside what was planned and what was spent. The longest path reaches the finish, and a shorter one has float. A work cycle sets an hourly rate, and the rate sets a cost per cubic yard. One bank cubic yard of soil becomes 1.25 loose and 0.80 compacted cubic yards.

Plan versus actual

For money, project control's tool is earned value. At a status date you know three dollar amounts: the value of the work the plan called for by now, the budgeted value of the work actually done, and what was actually spent. The middle one, the earned value, is the yardstick: compare it with the spending to judge cost, and with the plan to judge schedule. Comparing the spending with the plan, the obvious move, answers neither question. Earned Value and Earned Value Status and Forecasts build everything on those three amounts.

The longest path sets the finish

A schedule is a network: each activity waits on the ones before it, and several chains of work run side by side. Every chain has to be done before the project is, so the project takes as long as its longest path, and the activities on that path, the critical ones, set the finish date. A shorter path has room to slip, called float. So when plan versus actual flags an activity running late, the network tells you whether that matters: a delay that fits inside the float never reaches the finish. Activity Networks, The Forward Pass, and The Backward Pass and Float draw the network, date it, and measure the float.

Cost follows production

A machine's output is how much it carries per trip times how many trips it makes in the minutes it actually works. Once you have that rate, time and money follow by division: a quantity over the rate gives hours, and an hourly cost over the rate gives a cost per cubic yard. Machines that work together, like a loader feeding trucks, form a chain that moves only as fast as its slower link. Equipment Production and Fleet Balancing and Equipment Cost build that chain for machines, Crew Costs, Task Duration, and Markups runs the same divisions for crews, and Quantity Takeoff counts the cubic yards, square feet, and pounds the chain starts from.

Soil changes volume

Dig a cubic yard of soil out of the ground, shovel it back in loosely, and it won't fit in its own hole. Roll it hard in a fill, though, and it packs into less room than it had in the ground. No soil was added or lost; only the air between the grains changed. So a number of cubic yards means nothing until you know its state, and the habit that keeps you out of trouble is to label every volume with its state: bank, loose, or compacted. Earthwork Volume States and Hauling converts between them, and the labels follow the soil into Equipment Production and Quantity Takeoff.

Don't expect the Handbook to carry much of this. Its Construction section is short: the notation for schedule networks and the earned-value formulas. It gives no formulas for equipment production, crew costs, or swell, so those methods are yours to carry.

Two Lessons stand apart from the four ideas and are taught on their own: Project Delivery and Contract Administration, on who designs, builds, and pays, and Construction Site Safety, on OSHA's thresholds and the hierarchy of hazard controls.

Which idea?

Each situation below calls for one of the four ideas. Name it.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

On a highway cut, a loader fills a haul truck, then sits with its bucket on the ground until the next empty truck backs in. Which idea explains the idle loader?

A.
Plan versus actual
B.
The longest path sets the finish
C.
Cost follows production
D.
Soil changes volume