Tanks, Siphons, and Weirs

Water leaving a tank moves as fast as if it had fallen from the surface.

Drill a small hole in a rain barrel, 1 ft below the water surface, and the water squirts out at 8 ft/s. Drill one 1 ft below the surface of the reservoir behind a dam: 8 ft/s. Fill the barrel with oil: still 8 ft/s. That's exactly how fast a dropped stone is moving after a 1 ft fall. Only the height matters, and nozzles, siphons, and weirs all run on that one fact.

Height turns into speed

Pick two points: point 1 on the free surface, and point 2 in the jet just outside the opening, whether that's a hole in the wall or the end of a pipe.

h P1 = 0, v1 ≈ 0 P2 = 0
A reservoir draining through a pipe and nozzle

Both points are open to the air, so both gauge pressures are zero. A jet in open air has no walls to hold any other pressure. The surface sinks so slowly that its velocity head is negligible: by continuity, a tank with 100 times the hole's area sinks at a hundredth of the jet's speed, with a velocity head 10,000 times smaller. Only height and speed are left:

z1=v222g+z2⇒v2=2ghz_1 = \frac{v_2^2}{2g} + z_2 \quad\Rightarrow\quad v_2 = \sqrt{2gh}

That's the falling stone's speed. The liquid doesn't matter, because γ\gamma enters only through the pressure heads, and both are zero. The result is Torricelli's theorem, and the Handbook prints it, unnamed, under Jet Propulsion.

A pipe changes nothing. Without friction, its length and route drop out, and hh is the outlet's depth below the surface. The flow is Q=A2v2Q = A_2v_2 through the exit, a nozzle's if there is one, and the velocity in the pipe follows by continuity. The Energy Equation adds the friction real pipes have.

Worked Example A reservoir drain with a nozzle
1 of 2

A reservoir's surface is at elevation 320 ft. A 6 in. pipe leaves its base, runs downhill, and ends in a nozzle with a 2 in. exit at elevation 284 ft, discharging into the air. Ignoring losses, find the flow rate and the velocity in the pipe.

A siphon climbs before it falls

A siphon is a drain that climbs first: a tube from a reservoir up over its bank and down to an outlet below the water surface. Fill it with water, and it keeps flowing on its own. The Handbook has no siphon section, and needs none. It's Bernoulli between the right points.

datum z1 zC z2 flow 1 C 2
A siphon over a bank

The flow comes from the surface and the outlet, both at atmospheric pressure: v=2g(z1−z2)v = \sqrt{2g(z_1 - z_2)}. The crest isn't in it, since the water gets back every foot it climbs on the way down.

The crest sets the pressure instead. From the surface to the crest:

z1=PCγ+v22g+zC⇒PCγ=−(zC−z1)−v22gz_1 = \frac{P_C}{\gamma} + \frac{v^2}{2g} + z_C \quad\Rightarrow\quad \frac{P_C}{\gamma} = -(z_C - z_1) - \frac{v^2}{2g}

Both terms are negative, so the crest is under suction. In a tube of one diameter, v2/2g=z1−z2v^2/2g = z_1 - z_2 all along it, and the crest's pressure head works out to −(zC−z2)-(z_C - z_2), minus its height above the outlet.

Nothing pulls the water up there; water isn't a rope. The atmosphere pushes on the reservoir's surface, and the water rises toward the lower pressure at the crest, like a barometer's column. That push has a limit. When the crest's absolute pressure falls to the water's vapor pressure, PvP_v, the water boils, cold as it is. Vapor fills the crest, and the siphon stops.

The Handbook's Properties of Water tables, read as in Fluid Properties, give PvP_v as an absolute pressure: their 212°F row reads 14.70 psi, a full atmosphere. So compare absolute with absolute, Patm+PC≥PvP_{\text{atm}} + P_C \ge P_v. For 60°F water, the most suction the crest can take is (14.7−0.26)(144)/62.37=33.3(14.7 - 0.26)(144)/62.37 = 33.3 ft of water, and that has to cover both the crest's height above the surface and the velocity head.

Specific weight and vapor pressure of water
Temperatureγ\gammaPvP_v
40°F62.43 lbf/ft³0.12 psi
60°F62.37 lbf/ft³0.26 psi
80°F62.22 lbf/ft³0.51 psi
10°C9.804 kN/m³1.23 kPa
20°C9.789 kN/m³2.34 kPa
30°C9.764 kN/m³4.24 kPa

Source: FE Reference Handbook, Properties of Water (English Units) and (SI Metric Units), selected rows

Worked Example A siphon's flow, crest pressure, and highest crest
1 of 3

A siphon of uniform 4 in. diameter draws 60°F water from a reservoir whose surface is at elevation 100 ft, carries it over a crest at elevation 112 ft, and discharges it to the air at elevation 90 ft. Ignoring losses, find the flow, the pressure at the crest, and the highest crest elevation at which the siphon would still run.

Real openings: the jet shrinks and slows

A real opening falls short of 2gh\sqrt{2gh} in two ways.

The jet shrinks. Water heading for a sharp-edged hole arrives from every direction, some of it sliding along the wall straight at the edge. It can't turn that corner at once, so the jet keeps narrowing for about half a diameter outside the hole. Its narrowest section is the vena contracta, where the streamlines run parallel and the pressure is atmospheric, so that's where point 2 really belongs. The Handbook writes its area as A2=CcA0A_2 = C_cA_0, with A0A_0 the opening's area and CcC_c the coefficient of contraction.

h A0 A2 vena contracta 1 2
A jet leaving a sharp-edged orifice

The jet slows. Friction at the edge costs it a little energy: v2=Cv2ghv_2 = C_v\sqrt{2gh}, with CvC_v the coefficient of velocity. Real area times real speed is the real flow:

Q=A2v2=CcCvA02gh=CA02ghQ = A_2v_2 = C_cC_vA_0\sqrt{2gh} = CA_0\sqrt{2gh}

The product C=CcCvC = C_cC_v is the coefficient of discharge. This is the Handbook's Orifice Discharging Freely into Atmosphere, with hh from the liquid surface to the centroid of the opening. Its table of Orifices and Their Nominal Coefficients, printed with the flow meters, gives typical values:

Nominal coefficients of two openings
OpeningCcC_cCvC_vCC
Sharp-edged0.620.980.61
Rounded1.000.980.98

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Fluid Flow Measurement, Orifices and Their Nominal Coefficients

A rounded entrance guides the water through the turn, so the jet fills it and C=CvC = C_v. Keep each coefficient on its own quantity: the velocity takes CvC_v alone, while the flow takes CC. Both grow with the square root of the head.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A tank drains through a 2 in. sharp-edged orifice whose centroid is 9.0 ft below the water surface. Its coefficients are Cc=0.62C_c = 0.62 and Cv=0.98C_v = 0.98. What is the jet's velocity at the vena contracta?

ft/s
Checkpoint

A sharp-edged orifice discharges from the side of an open tank. Which statements are true?

A.
CvC_v accounts for the jet's narrowing, and CcC_c for the speed it loses to friction.
B.
The jet is narrowest a short distance outside the opening, at the vena contracta.
C.
Quadrupling the head doubles the discharge.
D.
Quadrupling the head doubles the jet velocity but quadruples the discharge.
E.
Its discharge coefficient is the product of its coefficients of contraction and velocity.

Below the water, or under pressure

Two variations change only the head that drives the jet.

Q h1 h2 h1 − h2 1 2 (a) submerged orifice air at gauge pressure P h 1 2 (b) pressurized tank
A submerged orifice and a pressurized tank

A submerged orifice sits in a wall between two tanks, below both surfaces. Its jet is surrounded by still water, so at the vena contracta its pressure head is h2h_2, its depth below the second tank's surface. From the first tank's surface, with the datum at the orifice:

h1=h2+v222g⇒v2=2g(h1−h2)h_1 = h_2 + \frac{v_2^2}{2g} \quad\Rightarrow\quad v_2 = \sqrt{2g(h_1 - h_2)}

That's the Handbook's Submerged Orifice Operating under Steady-Flow Conditions, Q=CA2g(h1−h2)Q = CA\sqrt{2g(h_1 - h_2)}, with AA the opening's area. Raise or lower the orifice, and both depths change together: only the difference in water levels drives the flow.

A pressurized tank has air at a gauge pressure PP above the water, which adds a pressure head at point 1:

Q=CA02g(h+Pγ)Q = CA_0\sqrt{2g\left(h + \frac{P}{\gamma}\right)}

The γ\gamma is the water's, because a head is a height of the liquid that flows. So 10 psi of air adds 10(144)/62.4=23.110(144)/62.4 = 23.1 ft. For a target flow, run it backward: the driving head is (Q/CA0)2/2g(Q/CA_0)^2/2g, and the problem tells you how much of it is depth and how much is air.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Two tanks share a wall with a 3 in. orifice, C=0.60C = 0.60. The orifice's centerline is 14 ft below the water surface on one side and 5 ft below it on the other. What is the discharge?

cfs

Weirs: an orifice with no top

A sharp-crested weir is a wall across a channel, topped with a sharp-edged plate, the crest, that the water spills over. The water backs up until it stands just high enough above the crest to pass the flow, so that height, the head HH, measures the flow. Read it upstream, before the surface dips toward the crest, and from the crest, not the floor. The water below crest level isn't going anywhere.

H crest height flow air
The head on a sharp-crested weir

Why should the flow follow HH? Slice the overflow into thin horizontal strips, an orifice with no top. Each strip discharges under its own head, at about 2gy\sqrt{2gy} for a strip a depth yy below the surface. So the average speed grows as H\sqrt{H}, while the area, LHLH for a crest of length LL, grows as HH. Area times speed gives Q∝LH3/2Q \propto LH^{3/2}. The Handbook's Weir Formulas, under Hydrology/Water Resources, fold the constants and a contraction like an orifice's into one coefficient:

suppressed: Q=CLH3/2contracted: Q=C(L−0.2H)H3/2\text{suppressed: } Q = CLH^{3/2} \qquad \text{contracted: } Q = C(L - 0.2H)H^{3/2}

Here C=3.33C = 3.33 for feet and cfs, and 1.841.84 for meters and m³/s. It carries g\sqrt{g} inside it, which is why it changes with the units: 3.33/1.84≈32.2/9.813.33/1.84 \approx \sqrt{32.2/9.81}.

A suppressed weir spans the channel wall to wall, so its ends don't contract. A contracted weir's crest is shorter than the channel is wide, and the water turning in around each end pulls the sheet narrower, as at a sharp-edged orifice. The Handbook charges 0.2H0.2H of crest length for the two ends. The usual convention is 0.1H0.1H per end, so a weir with one end against a channel wall gives up 0.1H0.1H.

L H suppressed L H end contractions contracted 90° H 2H 90° V-notch
Three sharp-crested weirs at the same head, seen from downstream

Working backward is direct for a suppressed weir's head, H=(QCL)2/3H = \left(\frac{Q}{CL}\right)^{2/3}, and for a contracted weir's crest length, L=QCH3/2+0.2HL = \frac{Q}{CH^{3/2}} + 0.2H. A contracted weir's head appears twice in its equation, so solve for it with your calculator's equation solver.

Worked Example A contracted rectangular weir
1 of 4

A rectangular weir with a 4.0 ft crest sits in a wider channel, so both of its ends are contracted. Its crest is 2.5 ft above the channel floor, and upstream the water is 3.3 ft deep. Find the discharge.

The V-notch, for small flows

Cut the crest into a 90° V, and the opening widens as it fills. At a head HH, it's 2H2H wide at the surface, a triangle of area H2H^2, as the right panel of the weir figure above shows. Times the same H\sqrt{H} speed, that gives Q∝H5/2Q \propto H^{5/2}. The Handbook's V-Notch formula, Q=CH5/2Q = CH^{5/2}, takes C=2.54C = 2.54 in USCS units and 1.40 in SI, for a 90° notch only.

That narrow bottom suits small flows. At 0.10 cfs, a 2 ft rectangular crest runs at a head of just 0.73 in., hard to read precisely, in a sheet thin enough to cling to the plate instead of springing clear as the coefficient assumes. A 90° notch stacks the same flow 3.3 in. deep.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A 90° V-notch weir runs at a head of 0.75 ft. What is the discharge?

cfs
Checkpoint

Which statements about sharp-crested weirs are true?

A.
Doubling the head over a 90° V-notch multiplies its discharge by about 4.
B.
Doubling the head over a rectangular weir multiplies its discharge by about 2.8.
C.
A V-notch suits small flows because its smaller coefficient, 2.54 against 3.33, makes it more precise.
D.
A V-notch suits small flows because even a small flow stands at a readable head in the narrow notch.
E.
A V-notch's discharge grows faster with the head than a rectangular weir's because its opening widens as it fills.

Recap

  • From a still surface to a free jet, both at atmospheric pressure, Bernoulli leaves v=2ghv = \sqrt{2gh}. A frictionless drain pipe's route doesn't matter; Q=A2v2Q = A_2v_2 at the exit.
  • A siphon's flow is set by the outlet's drop, not the crest. The crest is under suction, PC/γ=−(zC−z1)−v2/2gP_C/\gamma = -(z_C - z_1) - v^2/2g, and its absolute pressure can't fall below PvP_v.
  • A real jet shrinks to the vena contracta and slows slightly: v2=Cv2ghv_2 = C_v\sqrt{2gh}, Q=CA02ghQ = CA_0\sqrt{2gh}, and C=CcCvC = C_cC_v.
  • A submerged orifice runs on h1−h2h_1 - h_2; air in a closed tank adds P/γP/\gamma of water.
  • Weir heads are measured above the crest. Rectangular: Q=CLH3/2Q = CLH^{3/2}, with L−0.2HL - 0.2H for two end contractions. 90° V-notch: Q=CH5/2Q = CH^{5/2}, the choice for small flows.