Bearing Capacity

A footing fails when it shoves a wedge of soil out from under itself.

Before this Lesson

In October 1913, a new grain elevator at Transcona, near Winnipeg, was being filled for the first time. As the bins neared full, the concrete bin house began to sink, and within about a day it had tipped over to nearly 27°. One side drove several meters down into the clay. Beside it, the ground heaved up.

The bin house barely cracked. It was later jacked back upright and set on piers carried down to rock. What gave way was the soil, and it gave way in a telling shape: down under the load, and up beside it. Bearing capacity measures how hard the soil resists moving that way.

Down under the load, up beside it

Picture a long concrete strip footing, BB wide, with its base at a depth DfD_f below the ground, and keep adding load. At first the soil under it just compresses a little. Push hard enough, though, and a wedge of soil directly under the footing locks onto the base and moves down with it as one block. The wedge can only go down by shoving the soil on either side out of its way, so that soil slides outward and upward along curved slip surfaces, and the ground beside the footing bulges up. That's a general shear failure, and three things resist it, numbered in the figure.

B Df γ′Df Load 1 2 3 1 Cohesion along the slip surfaces: cNc 2 Soil above the base level: γ′DfNq 3 Weight of soil in the failure zone: ½γ′BNγ
General shear failure under a strip footing
The wedge under the base moves down with the footing, and the soil beside it is pushed out and up along the slip surfaces. The numbers mark the three resistances.

Three resistances, three terms

The Handbook's Geotechnical section gives the strength of that mechanism for a strip footing, under Ultimate Bearing Capacity:

qULT=cNc+γ′DfNq+12γ′BNγq_{ULT} = cN_c + \gamma' D_f N_q + \tfrac{1}{2}\gamma' B N_\gamma

qULTq_{ULT} is the average pressure under the base at which the soil fails, BB is the footing's width, and DfD_f is the depth of its base. Each term is one of the three resistances, times a dimensionless bearing capacity factor that depends only on ϕ\phi:

  • cNccN_c, the cohesion term: cohesion along the slip surfaces. A wider footing has longer slip surfaces, but also more base for them to hold up, so per square foot of base, cohesion is worth cc times a fixed number.
  • γ′DfNq\gamma' D_f N_q, the overburden term: the soil beside the footing, above its base, which the heave has to lift. It presses on the base level with γ′Df\gamma' D_f, and that weight on the slip surfaces buys friction. The equation counts this soil's weight but not its strength, which is why the figure's slip surfaces stop at the base level. The Handbook calls NqN_q the factor for depth.
  • 12γ′BNγ\tfrac{1}{2}\gamma' B N_\gamma, the width term: the weight of the soil in the failure zone, which buys more friction. The zone's width and depth both grow in proportion to BB, so its weight grows with γB2\gamma B^2, and per foot of base, with γB\gamma B. The 12\tfrac{1}{2} is bookkeeping: values of NγN_\gamma are defined with it in place.

Only the width term grows with BB, and only the overburden term with DfD_f, so keep them straight.

One symbol needs care. In its phase relationships, the Handbook uses γ′\gamma' for the buoyant unit weight, γsat−γW\gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W. Here it means the effective unit weight: buoyant where the soil is below the water table, and the ordinary moist value where it's above. Every footing in this Lesson has the water table far below its failure zone, so γ′\gamma' is simply the moist γ\gamma. Footing Size and the Water Table brings the water table up.

The NN factors climb steeply with ϕ\phi. In one widely used set of values, NqN_q is about 18 at ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ and 64 at 40°. The Handbook prints no table of them, so exam questions give them to you.

Take away the friction

Now set the friction to zero, as it is for a saturated clay loaded faster than its water can drain. That's the undrained case from Shear Strength: ϕ=0\phi = 0, and the clay's strength is a fixed sus_u, which takes the place of cc.

A soil with strength but no friction is like a tub of stiff putty. To push a board down into it at some depth, you have to beat the pressure already there at that depth, plus the putty's strength. Beside a footing, that pressure is γDf\gamma D_f, and with no friction it buys nothing more, because pressing harder on a slip surface doesn't make it stronger. So Nq=1N_q = 1: the overburden counts once, at face value. For the same reason, the failure zone's own weight buys nothing, and Nγ=0N_\gamma = 0.

The cohesion factor for ϕ=0\phi = 0 comes from two classic solutions: 5.14, which is exactly 2+π2 + \pi, and Terzaghi's 5.7. A question gives you one of them, along with Nq=1N_q = 1 and Nγ=0N_\gamma = 0.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A strip footing rests on the ground surface, on a dry, clean sand. Which terms of the bearing capacity equation are left?

A.
All three terms
B.
The overburden and width terms
C.
Only the width term
D.
Only the overburden term

Working the equation

With the terms sorted out, a bearing capacity problem is substitution. Strike out the terms that vanish, then evaluate the rest one at a time, in consistent units.

Worked Example A footing 3 ft down in sand
1 of 2

A strip footing 4 ft wide has its base 3 ft below the ground, in a sand with γ=115\gamma = 115 lb/ft³, c=0c = 0, and ϕ=32∘\phi = 32^\circ. The water table is far below. For ϕ=32∘\phi = 32^\circ, take Nq=23.2N_q = 23.2 and Nγ=30.2N_\gamma = 30.2. Find qULTq_{ULT}.

Now a footing on clay.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A strip footing 1.2 m wide has its base 1.5 m deep in a saturated clay with su=60s_u = 60 kPa and γ=18.5\gamma = 18.5 kN/m³. The water table is far below, and the building goes up in a few months. Using Nc=5.14N_c = 5.14, Nq=1N_q = 1, and Nγ=0N_\gamma = 0, what is qULTq_{ULT}?

kPa

That's the contrast to carry away. On sand, a deeper or wider footing raises qULTq_{ULT} a lot, because every extra foot of DfD_f or BB is multiplied by a large NN factor. On a ϕ=0\phi = 0 clay, width does nothing for qULTq_{ULT}, and depth adds only γDf\gamma D_f. Transcona's clay was loaded in weeks, far faster than it could drain, and later analyses with its undrained strength predicted a failure pressure close to the one the full bins applied.

Ultimate is not allowable

qULTq_{ULT} is the pressure at which the soil fails, so no footing is designed for it: soil strengths are uncertain, and a footing that close to failure would settle far too much anyway. You divide by a factor of safety, often 3, which the question states. The Handbook stops at qULTq_{ULT}, so this step is yours:

qa=qULTFSq_a = \frac{q_{ULT}}{FS}

qaq_a is the allowable bearing pressure. A strip footing is long, so its load is given per unit length of wall, in kips per foot or kN per meter. Each foot of footing has BB square feet of base, so the allowable load per unit length is qaBq_a B.

To check an existing footing, run it backward: divide its load per unit length, PP, by BB for the pressure it applies, and compare that with the ultimate:

q=PBFS=qULTqq = \frac{P}{B} \qquad FS = \frac{q_{ULT}}{q}

The Handbook prints the same ratio for a retaining wall's base, as qULTq_{ULT} over the pressure at its toe.

Worked Example Allowable load on a wall footing
1 of 2

A wall footing 5 ft wide has its base 3 ft deep in a clayey sand with c=200c = 200 psf, ϕ=25∘\phi = 25^\circ, and γ=120\gamma = 120 lb/ft³. The water table is far below. For ϕ=25∘\phi = 25^\circ, Nc=20.7N_c = 20.7, Nq=10.7N_q = 10.7, and Nγ=10.9N_\gamma = 10.9. With FS=3FS = 3, find the allowable bearing pressure and the allowable load per foot of wall.

Checkpoint

A wall footing 3.5 ft wide carries 25.2 kips per foot of wall, its own weight included. The soil's ultimate bearing capacity is 21,000 psf. What is the factor of safety against bearing failure?

Spreading the load: footings and mats

Every foundation takes a load gathered into a column or a wall and hands it to the ground at a pressure the soil can carry without failing or settling too much. Shallow foundations do it near the surface, by spreading out. A spread footing is a pad, usually square, under a single column. A wall footing is a continuous strip under a bearing wall, the strip footing of the bearing capacity equation. A mat, or raft, is one thick slab under the whole building.

Spread footings 15% of area Bigger footings 60% of area Mat Whole area
Spread footings, and when they give way to a mat
The same column layout in plan, three ways. On weaker soil, each footing needs more area to keep its pressure under qaq_a.

Each footing's area is its column load over qaq_a, so heavy loads on weak soil make the footings grow until they nearly touch. Once they'd cover more than about half the building's area, one slab is simpler and cheaper. A mat is also stiff, so it bridges over soft pockets and the building settles more evenly, which makes it the choice when differential settlement must be kept small. It still has a bearing capacity, though: Transcona sat on a mat.

A compensated mat goes a step further. Dig a basement deep enough that the soil removed weighs about as much as the building, and the stress under the mat ends up about where it started. It's a ship's trick: a ship floats by displacing its own weight of water. The soil carries about what it always did, so it barely settles, even when it's soft clay.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Which of these point to a mat rather than spread footings?

A.
Spread footings sized for the allowable pressure would cover about two-thirds of the building's area.
B.
Light column loads on a dense sand.
C.
Heavy column loads on a weak clay.
D.
Equipment inside that can tolerate very little differential settlement.
E.
Sound rock 3 ft below the ground surface.

Going down to firm ground

Sometimes the soil near the surface is so soft or loose that a footing would fail, or settle too much, at any practical size. Then the load goes down through the weak soil on deep foundations, piles and drilled shafts. When rock or another firm layer lies within reach, they carry the load down to it, and the soft soil above barely feels it.

An end-bearing pile stands on a firm layer like a column on a footing: its tip pushes on the rock or dense soil. Where no firm layer is within reach, a friction pile carries its load along its sides instead, by skin friction with the soil, the way a nail holds in wood. Most piles do some of both, and the name says which does most of the work.

End-bearing piles Load Soft clay End bearing Rock Friction piles Load Soft clay Skin friction
End-bearing and friction piles
End-bearing piles carry the load through soft soil to rock. Friction piles, with no firm layer in reach, shed it into the soil along their length.

They also go in two ways. A driven pile of steel, precast concrete, or timber is made first, then hammered or vibrated into the ground. Driving densifies a loose sand around it, and the blows it takes give a field check on its capacity, but the hammering shakes the ground and can damage older buildings nearby. A drilled shaft is a drilled hole, often several feet across, filled with reinforced concrete. Drilling is nearly vibration free, one large shaft can carry a heavy column by itself, and its bottom can be drilled into rock as a rock socket.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

A boring log for a heavy building shows 20 ft of very soft clay, then 8 ft of loose silty sand, then limestone. Which foundation will settle least?

A.
Spread footings sized for the clay's allowable pressure
B.
A mat on the soft clay
C.
Friction piles ending in the soft clay
D.
End-bearing piles or drilled shafts carried to the limestone

Recap

  • A footing fails by driving a wedge down and shoving the soil beside it out and up. Cohesion, the soil above the base, and the weight of the failure zone resist: qULT=cNc+γ′DfNq+12γ′BNγq_{ULT} = cN_c + \gamma' D_f N_q + \tfrac{1}{2}\gamma' B N_\gamma, with γ′\gamma' the moist unit weight when the water table is far below.
  • A surface footing on clean sand keeps only the width term. A ϕ=0\phi = 0 clay keeps Ncsu+γDfN_c s_u + \gamma D_f (Nc=5.14N_c = 5.14 or 5.7, Nq=1N_q = 1), so width doesn't raise its qULTq_{ULT}.
  • qa=qULT/FSq_a = q_{ULT}/FS, the allowable load per unit length is qaBq_a B, and FS=qULT/(P/B)FS = q_{ULT}/(P/B).
  • Spread footings go under columns and wall footings under walls. A mat suits heavy loads on weak soil, footings covering over half the area, or tight limits on differential settlement; a compensated mat removes about the building's weight in soil.
  • Over soft soil, carry the load to a firm layer with end-bearing piles or drilled shafts, which avoid driving vibration. With no firm layer in reach, use friction piles.