Slope Stability

A slope stands as long as the soil's strength outruns gravity's pull along the slip surface.

A hillside can stand for a century and then slide in one wet week. Nobody loaded it or dug at its toe, and it's no steeper than it ever was. What changed is the water: rain soaked in until the ground was saturated to the surface, and water began seeping down through it, parallel to the slope.

Picture that hillside as a clean sand at 25°, with a friction angle of 34°. Dry, it stands with room to spare. Soaked and seeping, the same sand at the same angle can't hold itself up. By the end of this Lesson you'll know why.

Strength against pull

Pick any surface through a slope that the soil above it could slip along. Gravity pulls that soil downhill, and the soil resists with shear along the surface. It's the block on the incline from Static Friction, with the soil above the surface as the block and the soil below it as the ramp.

Friction on the incline had a need and a ceiling. In a slope, the need is the mobilized shear, what the soil must carry along the surface to hold the soil above it in place. The ceiling is the soil's strength, τF=c+σNtan⁡ϕ\tau_F = c + \sigma_N\tan\phi from Shear Strength, added up over the surface. The factor of safety is their ratio:

FS=available shear strengthmobilized shearFS = \frac{\text{available shear strength}}{\text{mobilized shear}}

An FSFS of 1.5 says the soil could carry half again the shear gravity asks of it. At 1.0 the slope is on the verge. Below 1.0 the soil can't supply what equilibrium needs, so the slope can't stand as it is: the soil above slides until it reaches a shape it can hold. Permanent slopes are commonly designed for about 1.5.

A slope could slip on countless surfaces, and the weakest one governs. Software searches curved ones; two planes are simple enough to work by hand.

A wedge sliding on a plane

The simplest trial surface is a plane from the toe up to the ground behind the crest, with a wedge of soil above it. Work per foot or meter along the length of the slope, so every force is per unit width.

The Handbook's Slope Failure along Planar Surface diagram names the pieces: WMW_M is the wedge's weight, αS\alpha_S is the slip plane's angle from horizontal, and LSL_S is its length. Resolve the weight along and normal to the plane, as for any block on an incline:

αS β WM WM cos αS WM sin αS TFF Trial slip plane LS
A wedge above a trial slip plane through the toe

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Geotechnical section, Slope Failure along Planar Surface

  • Along the plane, WMsin⁡αSW_M\sin\alpha_S pulls the wedge downhill. That's the mobilized shear force, TMOBT_{MOB}.
  • Normal to it, WMcos⁡αSW_M\cos\alpha_S presses the wedge onto the plane.

The plane resists with its strength. Cohesion is a stress, so it acts on every foot of the plane, giving cLScL_S. Friction is the normal force times tan⁡ϕ\tan\phi. Together they're the available shearing resistance, TFFT_{FF}. The Handbook prints the two forces, and their ratio is

FS=TFFTMOB=cLS+WMcos⁡αStan⁡ϕWMsin⁡αSFS = \frac{T_{FF}}{T_{MOB}} = \frac{cL_S + W_M\cos\alpha_S\tan\phi}{W_M\sin\alpha_S}

The angle that goes in is the slip plane's αS\alpha_S, not the face's β\beta. The face is always steeper, since the plane has to come out behind the crest, and its angle is already built into WMW_M.

Worked Example A trial plane through the toe
1 of 3

A cut slope's face stands at 60°. A trial slip plane runs from its toe at 35° to the horizontal and is 52.3 ft long. The wedge above it weighs 46,000 lb per foot of slope, and the soil has c=300c = 300 psf and ϕ=25∘\phi = 25^\circ. Find the factor of safety against sliding on the plane.

A long, uniform slope

Now let the soil be a clean sand, with c=0c = 0. The cohesion term drops out, and what's left is

FS=WMcos⁡αStan⁡ϕWMsin⁡αS=tan⁡ϕtan⁡αSFS = \frac{W_M\cos\alpha_S\tan\phi}{W_M\sin\alpha_S} = \frac{\tan\phi}{\tan\alpha_S}

The weight cancels, and so does the length: it's the tilted board from Static Friction, which lets a block go at its friction angle whatever the block weighs.

Picture a hillside that runs on at the same angle β\beta, in the same soil, far beyond any slip you'd look at: an infinite slope. It tends to fail as a sheet of soil sliding on a plane parallel to the surface, so αS=β\alpha_S = \beta. On a slice of that sheet, the soil uphill and downhill pushes equally and oppositely, because the slope is the same everywhere, so only the weight and the plane matter. For a dry, cohesionless soil,

FS=tan⁡ϕtan⁡βFS = \frac{\tan\phi}{\tan\beta}
β z Ground surface Slip plane, parallel to the surface WM E E
A slice of an infinite slope
EE is the push of the neighboring soil on each side, and zz is the depth of the slip plane.

The depth dropped out too: a sheet 2 ft thick and one 20 ft thick are equally safe. At FS=1FS = 1, β=ϕ\beta = \phi, so a dry sand can stand at any angle up to its friction angle, and no steeper.

That holds only for c=0c = 0. Cohesion supplies a fixed cc on each square foot of plane, while the weight above it grows with depth, so with cohesion the deep slips are the critical ones. The Handbook prints no infinite-slope expression; this one is its planar equation with c=0c = 0 and αS=β\alpha_S = \beta.

For the steepest slope that gives a required factor of safety, turn it around. The factor of safety divides the tangent, not the angle:

tan⁡β=tan⁡ϕFS\tan\beta = \frac{\tan\phi}{FS}
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A long natural slope of dry, clean sand stands at 27°, and the sand has ϕ=35∘\phi = 35^\circ. What is its factor of safety against a slide parallel to the surface?

The equations also say which way the factor of safety moves when a slope changes.

Checkpoint

Which statements about a slope's factor of safety are true?

A.
A factor of safety of 0.9 means the slope is stable but is using 90 percent of its strength.
B.
Flattening a dry sand slope from 30° to 25° raises its factor of safety.
C.
On an infinite slope of dry, clean sand, a deep slip plane has a lower factor of safety than a shallow one.
D.
A factor of safety of 0.9 means gravity needs more shear along that surface than the soil can supply, so the slope can't stand as it is.
E.
More cohesion along a planar slip surface raises its factor of safety.

Water flowing down the slope

Back to the hillside. Rain has brought the water table up to the ground surface, and water seeps downhill through the soil, parallel to the slope. Two things happen on the slip plane.

The grip weakens. The pore water pushes the grains apart, and only the effective normal stress buys friction. With the water flowing parallel to the slope, what's left of it comes from the soil's submerged weight, γ′\gamma'.

The pull doesn't ease. Buoyancy takes part of the grains' downhill pull away, but the flowing water drags them downhill by exactly as much, so the shear still comes from the full saturated weight.

β z Ground surface Slip plane, parallel to the surface γsat Seepage parallel to the slope Water table at the surface
The same slope, saturated, with water seeping down it

Friction runs on γ′\gamma' and the pull on γsat\gamma_{sat}, so

FS=γ′γsat tan⁡ϕtan⁡βFS = \frac{\gamma'}{\gamma_{sat}}\,\frac{\tan\phi}{\tan\beta}

where γ′=γsat−γW\gamma' = \gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W is the buoyant unit weight from Unit Weights of Soil, the Handbook's effective (submerged) unit weight. The Handbook doesn't print this expression, so a question gives it. Since γ′\gamma' is about half of γsat\gamma_{sat}, seepage roughly halves the factor of safety. That's no trim: a slope that stood dry at a comfortable 1.3 drops to about 0.65 and slides.

Still water is another matter. Sink the slope in a lake, with no flow, and buoyancy cuts the grip and the pull by the same fraction, so γ′\gamma' cancels and FS=tan⁡ϕ/tan⁡βFS = \tan\phi/\tan\beta, as if dry. The harm comes from water flowing out through a slope, not from water around it, and that matters for the earth dam below.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

The hillside from the start is a clean sand at 25°, with ϕ=34∘\phi = 34^\circ and γsat=125\gamma_{sat} = 125 lb/ft³. With the water table at the surface and seepage parallel to the slope, FS=(γ′/γsat)(tan⁡ϕ/tan⁡β)FS = (\gamma'/\gamma_{sat})(\tan\phi/\tan\beta). What is its factor of safety?

Water is the usual trigger

That hillside is the story behind many landslides, and Shear Strength gave its core: at constant total stress, a rise Δu\Delta u in pore pressure costs Δutan⁡ϕ′\Delta u\tan\phi' of strength, while the shear the slope must carry stays put. Rain, snowmelt, or a leaking water main raises uu on a potential slip surface, and the factor of safety falls with no load added. That's why landslides cluster in wet seasons. Groundwater does the same kind of damage elsewhere:

  • Embankments. Pore pressure on a slip surface cuts the strength, and water seeping through adds its drag.
  • Retaining walls. Water trapped behind a wall pushes on it at full hydrostatic pressure, on top of the soil's push, as Earth Pressure with Water and Surcharge shows.
  • Pavement subgrades. A saturated subgrade loses strength and stiffness, and the pavement above it breaks up under traffic.

So the first fix for all of them is the same: drainage, from drains in slopes to weep holes in walls to drainable layers under pavements.

Checkpoint

After an unusually wet spring on one stretch of highway, a cut slope slumps onto the shoulder, a retaining wall tilts outward, and the pavement on a nearby embankment cracks and breaks up. What single cause best explains all three?

A.
The weight of the rainwater that soaked into the soil
B.
Water lowering the soils' friction angles
C.
Rising groundwater and the pore pressure it brought
D.
Traffic loads heavier than the design assumed

The riskiest moment

A slope's factor of safety moves as its pore pressures move, and in clay they move slowly, for months or years after construction. So ask when the factor of safety is lowest. The Handbook is silent here, but three cases cover it.

An embankment on soft clay is most at risk at the end of construction. As Changing Effective Stress showed, a fill placed quickly on saturated clay is carried at first by excess pore pressure, so σ′\sigma' hasn't grown. The clay still has only its undrained sus_u, with ϕ=0\phi = 0, while the full weight already pulls. As the excess drains, σ′\sigma' rises and the clay grows stronger under the same load.

A cut in clay runs the story backward. Digging removes weight, and water can't flow into the clay fast enough to keep up, so its pore pressure drops below the steady groundwater value, holding σ′\sigma' up at first. Over months or years, water seeps in, the pore pressure climbs back, and σ′\sigma' and the strength fall. So a cut in clay is most at risk in the long term, analyzed as drained, with c′c', ϕ′\phi', and the steady groundwater pressure.

Embankment on soft clay Construction FS Time Cut in clay Construction FS Time Lowest: end of construction Lowest: long term
How the factor of safety changes with time
Loading a clay leaves it weakest at first; unloading one leaves it weakest last.

The upstream face of an earth dam is most at risk just after a rapid drawdown. With the reservoir full, the water against the face holds it in, and like the slope in the lake it's about as safe as if it were dry. Lower the reservoir in days rather than months, and that water is gone, but the dam's fine-grained soil can't drain so fast. Its pores stay full, and their water seeps out through the face toward the lowered reservoir: a heavy, saturated face seeping outward, with nothing holding it in. Lowered slowly, the water inside has time to follow.

Reservoir full Reservoir Upstream face Phreatic surface Just after rapid drawdown Former level Lowered reservoir Seepage out of the face Soil still saturated
An earth dam before and just after a rapid drawdown
Checkpoint
1 of 3

A highway embankment is built in six weeks over a deep deposit of soft, saturated clay. When is a slope failure through the clay most likely?

A.
Years later, once the clay has finished consolidating
B.
At the end of construction
C.
Partway through consolidation, while the clay is still settling

Recap

  • FSFS is available shear strength over mobilized shear. Below 1.0 the slope can't stand; flattening it or adding cohesion raises FSFS.
  • Planar slip through the toe: FS=(cLS+WMcos⁡αStan⁡ϕ)/(WMsin⁡αS)FS = (cL_S + W_M\cos\alpha_S\tan\phi)/(W_M\sin\alpha_S), with the plane's angle, not the face's.
  • Dry, cohesionless infinite slope: FS=tan⁡ϕ/tan⁡βFS = \tan\phi/\tan\beta, at any depth. The steepest slope for a required FSFS has tan⁡β=tan⁡ϕ/FS\tan\beta = \tan\phi/FS.
  • Seepage parallel to the slope: FS=(γ′/γsat)(tan⁡ϕ/tan⁡β)FS = (\gamma'/\gamma_{sat})(\tan\phi/\tan\beta), about half the dry value.
  • Rising pore pressure is the usual cause of failures in slopes, embankments, walls, and subgrades. The riskiest moments: an embankment on soft clay at the end of construction, a cut in clay in the long term, a dam's upstream face just after a rapid drawdown.