Footing Size and the Water Table

Wet soil carries less, so the footing has to grow to make up for it.

Before this Lesson

In Bearing Capacity, a strip footing 4 ft wide with its base 3 ft down in sand came out at qULT=15.0q_{ULT} = 15.0 ksf, with the water table far below. Keep the same sand, the same friction angle, the same footing, and let a wet spring bring the water table up to the ground surface. Now the soil fails at about 8.1 ksf. Nobody added a pound of load or weakened a single grain. The water came up, and the footing lost nearly half its capacity.

Water lifts the failure zone

Start with where each unit weight in the equation comes from:

qULT=cNc+γ′DfNq+12γ′BNγq_{ULT} = cN_c + \gamma' D_f N_q + \tfrac{1}{2}\gamma' B N_\gamma

The γ′\gamma' in the overburden term belongs to the soil beside the footing, above its base: γ′Df\gamma' D_f is the pressure that soil puts on the base level. The γ′\gamma' in the width term belongs to the soil in the failure zone, below the base, which reaches down about one footing width. Both weights do the same job. They press the grains on the slip surfaces together, and pressed grains resist sliding by friction.

Below the water table, every grain sits in a tank. As in Unit Weights of Soil, the water pushes up on each grain with the weight of the water it displaces, so the grains press on each other with only the effective (submerged) unit weight, which the Handbook prints under Phase Relationships:

γ′=γsat−γW\gamma' = \gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W

That's roughly half the moist unit weight. Friction doesn't care how heavy the soil is. It cares how hard the grains press together. So each term takes the unit weight of its own soil: the moist γ\gamma where that soil is above the water table, and γ′\gamma' where it's below. The Handbook prints the equation with γ′\gamma' in both terms and says nothing about the water table, so the sorting is yours:

  • Water table far below. A water table deeper than about BB below the base touches neither body of soil, so both terms use the moist γ\gamma. That was every footing in Bearing Capacity.
  • Water table at the base. The failure zone is under water, so the width term uses γ′\gamma'. The soil above the base is still above the water, so the overburden term keeps the moist γ\gamma.
  • Water table at the ground surface. Both bodies of soil are under water, so both terms use γ′\gamma'.
B Df soil abovethe base failurezone Water table far below Overburden term: moist γ Width term: moist γ Water table at the base Overburden term: moist γ Width term: γ′ Water table at the surface Overburden term: γ′ Width term: γ′
The same footing with the water table far below, at its base, and at the surface
Tinted soil is below the water table. Each term takes the unit weight of its own soil: the overburden term from the soil above the base, the width term from the failure zone.

The water doesn't change the sand's friction angle, so the NN factors stay put, and so does cc. And it's γ′\gamma', not γsat\gamma_{sat}: the saturated unit weight includes the water, and the pore pressure carries that share, not the grain contacts.

If this sounds like Effective Stress, it is. The overburden term's γ′Df\gamma' D_f is the vertical effective stress at the base level: γDf\gamma D_f with the water table at the base, γ′Df\gamma' D_f with it at the surface. Find σ′\sigma' first, and the overburden term follows.

Run the Hook's footing through all three cases. Its sand weighs γ=115\gamma = 115 lb/ft³ moist and γsat=125\gamma_{sat} = 125 lb/ft³ saturated, so γ′=125−62.4=62.6\gamma' = 125 - 62.4 = 62.6 lb/ft³. Under water, the width term becomes 12(62.6)(4)(30.2)=3,781\tfrac{1}{2}(62.6)(4)(30.2) = 3{,}781 psf, and the overburden term 62.6(3)(23.2)=4,35762.6(3)(23.2) = 4{,}357 psf.

The Hook's footing: B=4B = 4 ft, Df=3D_f = 3 ft, Nq=23.2N_q = 23.2, Nγ=30.2N_\gamma = 30.2
Water tableOverburden term (psf)Width term (psf)qULTq_{ULT} (ksf)
Far below8,0046,94615.0
At the base8,0043,78111.8
At the surface4,3573,7818.1

Questions often say which terms take γ′\gamma'. When one doesn't, sort them by where the water table is.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A strip footing 1.8 m wide has its base 1.2 m deep in a sand that weighs 17.8 kN/m³ moist and 19.8 kN/m³ saturated. The water table is at the ground surface. For the sand's friction angle, Nq=23.2N_q = 23.2 and Nγ=30.2N_\gamma = 30.2. What is qULTq_{ULT}?

kPa

Deeper, wider, wetter

Read the table down its rows. When the water table rose to the base, only the width term changed, and it shrank in the same ratio as the unit weight, 62.6/11562.6/115, to a little over half. When the water rose on to the surface, the overburden term followed. That's the whole pattern: each term moves on its own, and how far qULTq_{ULT} moves depends on how much of it that term was carrying.

The footing's size works the same way. On sand, DfD_f appears only in the overburden term and BB only in the width term, each to the first power. Bury the footing deeper and the overburden term grows in proportion; widen it and the width term does. Water doesn't stop either from helping, but each extra foot of depth or width is worth only about half as much when the soil involved is under water.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A strip footing rests on the ground surface, on sand, with the water table far below. A wet season brings the water table up to the footing's base. About what does its qULTq_{ULT} become?

A.
The same, because the soil above the base is unaffected
B.
About 80 percent of what it was, like the Hook's footing
C.
About half of what it was
D.
About a quarter of what it was

Sizing a footing

Here's where a wet site costs you. The allowable bearing pressure, qaq_a, is qULTq_{ULT} divided by a factor of safety, often 3, so it falls with qULTq_{ULT}. When the water reaches the surface, the Hook's footing drops from about 5.0 ksf to about 2.7 ksf, and each square foot of it may carry little more than half what it could. A footing's job is to spread a column's load over enough ground that the pressure stays within qaq_a, so sizing is a division:

A=PqaA = \frac{P}{q_a}

A column carrying a dead load of 120 kips and a live load of 80 kips puts 200 kips on its footing. On soil with qa=4q_a = 4 ksf, it needs 50 ft², a square spread footing 50=7.07\sqrt{50} = 7.07 ft on a side. A wall footing works per foot of wall: each foot of footing has BB square feet of base, so its width is the wall load per unit length over qaq_a, with no square root. The Handbook prints none of this; it stops at qULTq_{ULT}.

The 200 kips is the service load: the dead and live loads the column really carries, unfactored. The Handbook's Loads (ASCE 7-16) prints it as the simplest allowable stress design combination, D+LD + L. The soil's margin is already in qaq_a, through its factor of safety. The strength design combinations on the same page, such as 1.2D+1.6L1.2D + 1.6L, are for a different job: designing the footing's concrete, its thickness and reinforcement, the way every concrete member is designed.

Checkpoint

For the same column (dead load 120 kips, live load 80 kips) on soil with qa=4q_a = 4 ksf, a designer sizes the footing's plan area with 1.2D+1.6L=2721.2D + 1.6L = 272 kips. What's the result?

A.
The footing is too small, so the soil is loaded past its allowable pressure.
B.
The footing is the right size, since designs always use factored loads.
C.
The footing is the right size, as long as its concrete is also designed for 272 kips.
D.
The footing is bigger than it needs to be: 68 ft² where 50 ft² would do.

Some questions add one more load: the footing itself and the soil backfilled over it. The ground feels them as surely as it feels the column. Picture what stands on each square foot of base: concrete as thick as the footing, then soil up to the ground. That much of qaq_a is spent before the column gets any.

γc t γs(Df − t) per unit area of base P = D + L qa B t Df
What stands on each unit area of a footing's base
γc\gamma_c is the unit weight of the concrete, γs\gamma_s that of the backfill, and tt the footing's thickness.

Whatever's left is what the column can have:

A=Pqa−γct−γs(Df−t)A = \frac{P}{q_a - \gamma_c t - \gamma_s(D_f - t)}
Worked Example The same column, with the footing's weight
1 of 3

The column from before (dead load 120 kips, live load 80 kips) stands on a square footing 2 ft thick, with its base 4 ft below the ground. Concrete weighs 150 lb/ft³ and the backfill 120 lb/ft³, and qa=4,000q_a = 4{,}000 psf. Including the weight of the footing and the soil above it, find the footing's side length.

Off-center loads

So far the load has come down the middle, and the soil has pushed back evenly with P/AP/A. Now give the column a moment as well, from wind on the building, say. Look at the footing's base as a cross-section, the way you looked at a short post in Combined Stresses. It carries an axial load and a moment, so the contact pressure is P/A±M/SP/A \pm M/S, where S=I/cS = I/c is the base's section modulus.

Call BB the side along which the load shifts and LL the other side. Combined Stresses called that side bb, but footings use BB. The Handbook's area table gives a rectangle's I=LB3/12I = LB^3/12, and with c=B/2c = B/2, S=LB2/6S = LB^2/6. Write the moment as the load times its eccentricity, M=PeM = Pe, and the bending part becomes a fixed multiple of the even part:

q=PA±PeLB2/6=PA(1±6eB)e=MPq = \frac{P}{A} \pm \frac{Pe}{LB^2/6} = \frac{P}{A}\left(1 \pm \frac{6e}{B}\right) \qquad e = \frac{M}{P}

PP is the total vertical load on the base. For a wall footing, work per unit length: AA is BB times 1, and PP is the load per unit length. The Handbook prints the plus half for a retaining wall's base, under Retaining Walls, as qtoe=(ΣV/B)(1+6e/B)q_{toe} = (\Sigma V/B)(1 + 6e/B).

P/A qmin qmax middle third P e B
Contact pressure under a footing with an off-center load
The pressure is largest under the side the load is on and averages P/AP/A. With the load inside the middle third, it stays positive across the whole base.

Soil can push, but it can't pull. The minus sign gives the pressure at the far edge, qmin=(P/A)(1−6e/B)q_{min} = (P/A)(1 - 6e/B), and it stays at or above zero only while

e≤B6e \le \frac{B}{6}

That's the middle third again: keep the load within it, and the whole base presses on the soil. Past B/6B/6, the formula asks the soil for tension at the far edge. Real soil can't supply it, so that edge lifts and the rest of the base takes more pressure than the formula says. A negative qminq_{min} is a warning, not an answer.

Worked Example Pressures under a square footing with a moment
1 of 3

A footing 8 ft square carries a vertical load of 160 kips, its own weight included, and a moment of 120 kip·ft. Find the maximum and minimum contact pressures.

How far off center

Turn the question around: how large a moment can a footing take? Two limits apply, and whichever comes first governs.

  • The maximum pressure reaches qaq_a. Set (P/A)(1+6e/B)=qa(P/A)(1 + 6e/B) = q_a and solve for ee.
  • The minimum pressure reaches zero, at e=B/6e = B/6.

Take the smaller ee, then M=PeM = Pe. Which limit comes first depends on how hard the footing is already working. At e=B/6e = B/6, the maximum pressure is exactly 2P/A2P/A, so a footing whose average pressure is more than half of qaq_a reaches qaq_a first, and a lightly loaded one reaches zero first.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A footing 2.5 m square carries a vertical load of 1,000 kN, and the allowable bearing pressure is 250 kPa. What is the largest moment it can carry?

kN·m

Recap

  • Each unit weight in qULTq_{ULT} belongs to its own soil: the overburden term to the soil above the base, the width term to the failure zone below it. Above the water table, use the moist γ\gamma; below it, γ′=γsat−γW\gamma' = \gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W, never γsat\gamma_{sat}. With the water table at the base, only the width term takes γ′\gamma'; at the surface, both do.
  • γ′\gamma' is about half of γ\gamma, so a term that goes under water shrinks to about half, and qULTq_{ULT} loses about half of that term's share. On sand, a deeper footing raises the overburden term and a wider one the width term.
  • Size with service loads, D+LD + L: A=P/qaA = P/q_a, a square side of A\sqrt{A}, or a wall footing width of load per unit length over qaq_a. To include the footing and backfill, subtract γct+γs(Df−t)\gamma_c t + \gamma_s(D_f - t) from qaq_a first. Factored loads are for the footing's concrete.
  • An off-center load gives q=(P/A)(1±6e/B)q = (P/A)(1 \pm 6e/B), with e=M/Pe = M/P and BB the side along the shift. Keep e≤B/6e \le B/6, so the soil is never asked to pull.
  • The largest eccentricity is the smaller of the one that brings qmaxq_{max} to qaq_a and B/6B/6. Then M=PeM = Pe.