Soil as Three Phases

Draw the box of solids, water, and air, and every soil property is a ratio of its parts.

A can of soil from a boring holds 0.10 ft³. The soil weighs 11.6 lb going into the oven and 10.0 lb coming out the next morning. Nobody has seen a single pore in it. Yet those three numbers, plus one fact about the grains, say exactly how much of that can is air.

Sort the soil into a box

Soil is a heap of grains with gaps between them, and the gaps hold water, air, or some of each. In the ground all three are tangled together, which is hard to think about. So sort them in your head. Slide every grain to the bottom until no gap is left between them, let the water settle on top, and leave the air above that. Nothing has been added or removed. What you've drawn is the Handbook's phase diagram: weights down one side, volumes down the other.

Water Grain Air In the ground Sort Air Water Solids 0 Ww Ws W Va Vw Vs Vv V WEIGHTS VOLUMES Sorted
One sample, as it sits in the ground and sorted into its three phases

Box adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Phase Relationships

The air and water together make up the voids, so Vv=Va+VwV_v = V_a + V_w, and the whole sample is V=Vs+VvV = V_s + V_v. Air takes up room but weighs next to nothing, which is why the Handbook writes 0 on the weight side and W=Ws+WwW = W_s + W_w. The Handbook's equations capitalize these subscripts, as in WSW_S and VVV_V, and they mean the same thing.

Here's the idea that runs through this whole Lesson: every phase term is a ratio of two parts of that box.

The phase terms, each a ratio of two parts of the box
TermRatioReads as
Water content, ω\omegaWw/WsW_w / W_sWater per dry grains, by weight
Void ratio, eeVv/VsV_v / V_sVoids per solids, by volume
Porosity, nnVv/VV_v / VVoids as a share of the sample
Degree of saturation, SSVw/VvV_w / V_vShare of the voids holding water
Specific gravity of solids, GsG_s(Ws/Vs)/γW(W_s / V_s) / \gamma_WGrains against water
Total (moist) unit weight, γ\gammaW/VW / VWhole sample per volume
Dry unit weight, γD\gamma_DWs/VW_s / VGrains alone per sample volume

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Phase Relationships

Look at what sits underneath in ω\omega and ee: the solids. That's deliberate. The grains are the one thing in the box that stays put. Dry the soil and the water leaves. Squeeze it and the voids shrink, which, as Compressibility and Preconsolidation will show, is all settlement is. Through all of it the grains stay, so they make a yardstick that doesn't move. That's why water content is figured on dry weight, even though total weight is the number that feels natural.

GsG_s describes the grains alone, not the soil as a whole: how many times heavier a chunk of solid grain is than the same volume of water. For most soils it's close to 2.7. The Handbook prints no typical value, and exam questions give you the number. The reference it compares against is γW\gamma_W, which the Handbook's Phase Relationships section gives as 62.4 lb/ft³ or 9.81 kN/m³. It's the same specific weight of water that Fluid Properties writes as γw\gamma_w.

Fill in the box from lab weights

A lab gives you weights, because weights are what a scale measures. The oven-dry weight is WsW_s, and whatever the oven drove off is WwW_w. Each weight converts to a volume:

Vw=WwγWVs=WsGsγWV_w = \frac{W_w}{\gamma_W} \qquad V_s = \frac{W_s}{G_s \gamma_W}

The second is the Handbook's definition of GsG_s solved for VsV_s. Air has no weight to convert, so it comes last, as whatever room is left. Once the box is full, every ratio reads straight off it. Try it on the can from the start of the Lesson.

Worked Example The can of soil
1 of 3

A sample has a total volume of 0.10 ft³, a moist weight of 11.6 lb, an oven-dry weight of 10.0 lb, and Gs=2.70G_s = 2.70. Find its water content, void ratio, porosity, and degree of saturation.

The water, counted twice

Often a question hands you ratios and no sample at all. Ratios don't care how big the sample is, so you're free to pick its size, and the friendliest size sets the solids to 1. With Vs=1V_s = 1, the definitions fill in the box on their own:

  • e=Vv/Vse = V_v / V_s, so Vv=eV_v = e.
  • S=Vw/VvS = V_w / V_v, so Vw=SeV_w = Se.
  • Gs=(Ws/Vs)/γWG_s = (W_s / V_s) / \gamma_W, so Ws=GsγWW_s = G_s \gamma_W.
  • ω=Ww/Ws\omega = W_w / W_s, so Ww=ωGsγWW_w = \omega G_s \gamma_W.
Air Water Solids 0 Ww = ωGsγW Ws = GsγW Vw = Se Vs = 1 Vv = e V = 1 + e WEIGHTS VOLUMES
The box with one unit of solids

Now look at the water layer. The volume side calls it SeSe. The weight side calls it ωGsγW\omega G_s \gamma_W, and dividing a weight by γW\gamma_W turns it into a volume, so the water's volume is also ωGs\omega G_s. One layer, two names:

Se=ωGsSe = \omega G_s

This isn't a new law. It's bookkeeping: both sides are the volume of water per volume of solids. The Handbook prints it rearranged, as S=ωGS/eS = \omega G_S / e. Its one demand is that SS and ω\omega match. Use both as decimals or both as percents, because mixing them throws the answer off by a factor of 100. A saturated soil simply has S=1S = 1, or 100%.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A saturated clay has a void ratio of 1.20 and Gs=2.72G_s = 2.72. What is its water content?

%

Start from a unit weight

A unit weight is another ratio with no sample attached, but this one is per total volume, so the friendly size is V=1V = 1. Set V=1 ft3V = 1\ \text{ft}^3 and the moist unit weight γ=W/V\gamma = W / V is simply the weight in the box. Water content then splits that weight, because W=Ws+ωWsW = W_s + \omega W_s:

Ws=W1+ωW_s = \frac{W}{1 + \omega}

The weight of solids in that 1 ft³ box is also the dry unit weight, γD=Ws/V\gamma_D = W_s / V. From there it goes just like the can of soil.

The method, whatever the question
  1. Draw the box.
  2. If no sample size is given, pick one: Vs=1V_s = 1 when the question leans on ee or ω\omega and GsG_s, and V=1V = 1 when it leans on a unit weight or nn.
  3. Fill in the rest from the definitions.
  4. Read off the ratio asked for.
Worked Example From a unit weight to a void ratio
1 of 2

A soil has a moist unit weight of 120 lb/ft³, a water content of 15%, and Gs=2.70G_s = 2.70. Find its void ratio and degree of saturation.

One set of voids, two yardsticks

Porosity and void ratio measure the same voids. The only difference is what they measure against: ee compares the voids with the solids, and nn compares them with the whole sample. That makes them easy to swap by accident, and also easy to convert, because each conversion is a box you already know how to draw.

Voids Solids e 1 1 + e Vs = 1 n = e/(1 + e) Voids Solids n 1 − n 1 V = 1 e = n/(1 − n)
One soil, labeled for each choice of size

With Vs=1V_s = 1, the voids are ee and the whole box is 1+e1 + e, so n=e/(1+e)n = e / (1 + e). A void ratio of 0.60 is a porosity of 0.375. With V=1V = 1, the voids are nn and the solids are 1−n1 - n, so e=n/(1−n)e = n / (1 - n). The Handbook prints only the first of these, and the second is the same equation rearranged.

The V=1V = 1 box also gets you porosity from the dry unit weight. The solids in the box weigh γD\gamma_D, so they fill Vs=γD/(GsγW)V_s = \gamma_D / (G_s \gamma_W), and everything else is voids:

n=1−γDGsγWn = 1 - \frac{\gamma_D}{G_s \gamma_W}
Checkpoint
1 of 2

A sand has a porosity of 0.40. What is its void ratio?

A.
0.67
B.
0.29
C.
0.40
D.
0.60

Which ratios can top 1?

A part over its own whole can never exceed 1. The voids can't be bigger than the sample they sit in, so porosity stops short of 1. A part over a different part has no such ceiling. If the grains of a soft clay sit far apart, with the voids taking up more room than the grains do, then ee passes 1 while nn stays below it.

Voids Solids Sand e = 0.60 n = 0.375 Voids Solids Soft clay e = 1.50 n = 0.60
A sand and a soft clay in same-sized boxes

So for any ratio, ask whether its bottom is the whole that contains its top. Two more ratios are on the way in Grain Size and Plasticity, printed in the Handbook's Phase Relationships section: the coefficient of uniformity CU=D60/D10C_U = D_{60} / D_{10} and the coefficient of curvature CC=(D30)2/(D10D60)C_C = (D_{30})^2 / (D_{10} D_{60}), where D60D_{60} is the grain diameter that 60% of the soil by weight is finer than. They aren't phase terms, but exam questions list them alongside.

Checkpoint

Which of these can exceed 1.0? Take nn and SS as decimals.

A.
Porosity, nn
B.
Void ratio, ee
C.
Specific gravity of solids, GsG_s
D.
Degree of saturation, SS
E.
Coefficient of uniformity, CUC_U
F.
Coefficient of curvature, CCC_C

A sample with a real size

Give the box a real size and the ratios turn into real amounts. If you know VV and ee, the solids and voids split the volume in the ratio 1 to ee, so Vs=V/(1+e)V_s = V / (1 + e). The rest of the box follows from the definitions, the same as before.

The usual follow-up: how much water brings the sample to full saturation at constant void ratio? Constant void ratio means the grains don't move, so the voids stay exactly as they are. The only room left for water is the room the air is using. So the volume of water to add is exactly VaV_a, and it weighs VaγWV_a \gamma_W.

Air Water Solids Va Vw Vs Vv Water Solids Added water = Va Vs Vv Partly saturated Saturated Add water
Filling the air space at constant void ratio
Worked Example Every phase in a 2 m³ sample
1 of 3

A 2.0 m³ sample has e=0.60e = 0.60, ω=12%\omega = 12\%, and Gs=2.70G_s = 2.70. Find the weight and volume of its solids and water and the volume of its air. How much water brings it to full saturation at constant void ratio?

What moves when water goes in

That same before-and-after picture settles another exam favorite: how the terms change when water is added and the soil's total volume stays fixed. There's no need to memorize the answer. Ask which parts of the box moved, then check whether each part appears in the ratio. Definition questions come down to the box too: a wrong answer usually swaps one part of a ratio for another.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Water is added to a partly saturated soil, and its total volume stays the same. What happens to its water content, degree of saturation, and void ratio?

A.
ω\omega rises, SS stays the same, ee stays the same
B.
ω\omega stays the same, SS rises, ee falls
C.
ω\omega rises, SS rises, ee rises
D.
ω\omega rises, SS rises, ee stays the same

Recap

  • Every phase term is a ratio of two parts of the box of solids, water, and air. Water content is on dry weight, ω=Ww/Ws\omega = W_w / W_s, because the grains are the yardstick that doesn't move.
  • Any problem yields to the same moves: pick Vs=1V_s = 1 or V=1V = 1 if no size is given, fill in the box from the definitions, and read off the ratio.
  • Se=ωGsSe = \omega G_s is the water's volume per volume of solids, written two ways. Keep SS and ω\omega both decimal or both percent.
  • ee compares voids with solids and nn with the whole: n=e/(1+e)n = e / (1 + e). Porosity and saturation stop at 1, while ee, GsG_s, CUC_U, and CCC_C can pass it.
  • Water added at constant volume fills the air space: the water to saturate is VaV_a, ω\omega and SS rise, and ee holds still.