Unit Weights of Soil

The same soil weighs more or less depending on how much water fills its voids.

Before this Lesson

How much does a cubic foot of soil weigh? For one particular sand, the honest answer is "when?" Bone dry, it weighs about 99 lb. Soaked, about 125 lb. Sunk below the water table, its grains press on each other with only about 62 lb. The grains never changed. All of those numbers come out of one box, one short expression, and one subtraction.

Dry means the grains alone

From Soil as Three Phases you already have two unit weights. The moist unit weight, which the Handbook's Phase Relationships section calls the total unit weight, counts everything: γ=W/V\gamma = W / V. The dry unit weight counts only the grains: γD=Ws/V\gamma_D = W_s / V. Both divide by the sample's whole volume. So "dry" doesn't mean anyone dried the soil. A soggy sample has a dry unit weight too. It just means you're leaving the water out of the count.

Water content connects the two. The water weighs ω\omega times what the grains weigh, so W=Ws(1+ω)W = W_s(1 + \omega). Divide both sides by VV and you have a conversion the Handbook leaves you to work out:

γD=γ1+ω\gamma_D = \frac{\gamma}{1 + \omega}

Here ω\omega goes in as a decimal, so 15% is 0.15.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A soil has a moist unit weight of 118 lb/ft³ and a water content of 12%. What is its dry unit weight?

A.
103.8 lb/ft³
B.
132.2 lb/ft³
C.
105.4 lb/ft³
D.
9.1 lb/ft³

One expression for any amount of water

Often a question gives you no measured unit weight, only GsG_s, ee, and how full the voids are. Those are ratios with no sample attached, so set Vs=1V_s = 1 and fill in the box, as you did in the last Lesson.

Air Water Solids WEIGHTS 0 Ww = SeγW Ws = GsγW W = (Gs + Se)γW VOLUMES Vw = Se Vs = 1 Vv = e V = 1 + e
The box with one unit of solids

Box adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Phase Relationships

The voids are ee, and water fills the fraction SS of them, so its volume is SeSe and its weight is SeγWSe\gamma_W. One unit of solid grain weighs GsG_s times as much as the same volume of water, so the solids weigh GsγWG_s\gamma_W. A unit weight is weight over volume, so read it off the box:

γ=(Gs+Se)γW1+e\gamma = \frac{(G_s + Se)\gamma_W}{1 + e}

Grains plus water on top, total volume underneath. The Handbook doesn't print this general form, only the saturated case below, so the box is how you get it on exam day. When a question gives ω\omega instead of SS, the Se=ωGsSe = \omega G_s from the last Lesson swaps one for the other.

Now treat SS as a dial, with GsG_s and ee holding still. Turn it down to 0 and the water term vanishes. Turn it up to 1 and the voids are full:

γD=GsγW1+eγsat=(Gs+e)γW1+e\gamma_D = \frac{G_s\gamma_W}{1 + e} \qquad \gamma_{sat} = \frac{(G_s + e)\gamma_W}{1 + e}

The second is the form the Handbook prints, under Saturated unit weight. The first deserves a second look. There's no SS in it, because the dry unit weight never counted the water. Two samples of a soil at the same void ratio share one γD\gamma_D, however wet they are.

Take a sand with Gs=2.70G_s = 2.70 and e=0.70e = 0.70, and the dial gives the Hook's numbers, plus one in between: 99 lb/ft³ dry, 112 half full, and 125 saturated. With γW=9.81 kN/m3\gamma_W = 9.81\ \text{kN/m}^3, the same sand reads 15.6, 17.6, and 19.6 kN/m³.

Air Solids S = 0 Ws = 168.5 lb V = 1.70 ft3 W = 168.5 lb γD = 99.1 lb/ft3 Air Water Solids S = 50% Ws = 168.5 lb Ww = 21.8 lb V = 1.70 ft3 W = 190.3 lb γ = 112.0 lb/ft3 Water Solids S = 100% Ws = 168.5 lb Ww = 43.7 lb V = 1.70 ft3 W = 212.2 lb γsat = 124.8 lb/ft3
One sand with 1 ft³ of solids, as water fills its voids
Worked Example From a water content to two unit weights
1 of 3

A soil has Gs=2.65G_s = 2.65, e=0.60e = 0.60, and ω=15%\omega = 15\%. Find its moist and dry unit weights.

Below the water table

The saturated unit weight is the full weight of a cubic foot of soaked soil, water included. Below the water table there's a second question: how hard do the grains press on each other? The box can't answer that alone, because the water is doing something a weight label doesn't show.

Hang one cubic foot of solid grain from a spring scale. With Gs=2.70G_s = 2.70, it reads 168.5 lb. Lower it into a tank until it's under water, and the water pushes up with the weight of the water it shoves aside, 62.4 lb. The scale drops to 106.1 lb. That's Archimedes' principle, from Gates and Buoyancy, and every grain below the water table is in that tank.

In air 168.5 lb 1 ft3 solid grain Weight 168.5 lb Under water 106.1 lb Weight 168.5 lb Water pushes up 62.4 lb
One cubic foot of solid grain, weighed in air and under water

Now put that cube back in the box. One unit of solids under water bears down with (Gs−1)γW(G_s - 1)\gamma_W. What about the water in the voids? It's water sitting in water, and its weight is canceled by its own buoyancy, so it adds nothing. Spread what's left over the box's volume:

γ′=(Gs−1)γW1+e\gamma' = \frac{(G_s - 1)\gamma_W}{1 + e}

You don't need a new formula to get there. Subtract γW\gamma_W from the saturated form, and the ee's cancel on top:

γsat−γW=(Gs+e)−(1+e)1+e γW=(Gs−1)γW1+e\gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W = \frac{(G_s + e) - (1 + e)}{1 + e}\,\gamma_W = \frac{(G_s - 1)\gamma_W}{1 + e}

So γ′=γsat−γW\gamma' = \gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W, which is the line the Handbook prints, naming it the effective (submerged) unit weight. Most exam questions and textbooks say buoyant. For our sand it comes to 62.4 lb/ft³, or 9.81 kN/m³. That's exactly half of γsat\gamma_{sat} only because these numbers are friendly, but ordinary soils land close to it. Below the water table, about half of a soil's weight disappears as far as its grains can tell.

Worked Example Saturated and buoyant from the same two numbers
1 of 3

A soil has Gs=2.68G_s = 2.68 and e=0.75e = 0.75. Find its saturated and buoyant unit weights.

Working backward from a dry unit weight

Compaction tests report dry unit weights, so a question may hand you γD\gamma_D and GsG_s and ask about the soil once it's soaked. When GsG_s is known, γD\gamma_D and ee are one fact written two ways, so solve the dry form for ee:

e=GsγWγD−1e = \frac{G_s\gamma_W}{\gamma_D} - 1

Now you know the voids, and the voids are all you need. Filling them means S=1S = 1, so the saturated form gives γsat\gamma_{sat}. And with S=1S = 1, Se=ωGsSe = \omega G_s becomes e=ωGse = \omega G_s, so the water content at saturation is e/Gse / G_s.

Worked Example Soaking a soil on paper
1 of 3

A soil has a dry unit weight of 105 lb/ft³ and Gs=2.70G_s = 2.70. Find its saturated unit weight and its water content at saturation.

Squeezing out the last of the air

Fix the water content and pack the soil tighter. For our sand at ω=15%\omega = 15\%, the box with Vs=1V_s = 1 holds ωGs=0.405\omega G_s = 0.405 units of water, and packing can't change that. Only the air can leave. So the box shrinks from the top, the same grains sit in less volume, and the dry unit weight climbs. When the last of the air is gone, the box has nowhere left to go. That's the zero-air-voids condition, and it's a ceiling on the dry unit weight at that water content.

Air Water Solids Some air Va = 0.295 ft3 Vw = ωGs = 0.405 ft3 Vs = 1 ft3 V = 1.70 ft3 γD = 168.5 / 1.70 = 99.1 lb/ft3 Squeeze out the air Water Solids Zero air voids Vw = ωGs = 0.405 ft3 Vs = 1 ft3 V = 1 + ωGs = 1.405 ft3 γD = 168.5 / 1.405 = 119.9 lb/ft3
One sand at 15% water content, with air and with the air squeezed out

Zero air means S=1S = 1, and the form takes two moves. Putting S=1S = 1 in Se=ωGsSe = \omega G_s gives e=ωGse = \omega G_s. Putting that ee in the dry form gives

γD=GsγW1+ωGs\gamma_D = \frac{G_s\gamma_W}{1 + \omega G_s}

For our sand that's (2.70)(62.4)/1.405=119.9(2.70)(62.4) / 1.405 = 119.9 lb/ft³, up from 99.1 with the air in. It sounds odd to give a saturated soil a dry unit weight, but "dry" still means only that you're counting the grains alone. The Handbook neither prints this form nor mentions zero air voids. Some questions give you the form and others expect you to derive it, and those two moves are all it takes. The Proctor Test puts it to work.

Worked Example The ceiling at 20% water content
1 of 3

Find the zero-air-voids dry unit weight of a soil with Gs=2.70G_s = 2.70 at a water content of 20%.

Which one does the question want?

Questions rarely say "use the buoyant unit weight." They describe a situation and leave the choice to you. Two things settle it: where the soil sits relative to the water table, and what you're counting.

Choosing a unit weight
SituationCountingUse
Above the water tableGrains and their waterγ\gamma
Below the water tableGrains and waterγsat\gamma_{sat}
Below the water tableGrain-on-grain pushγ′\gamma'
How tightly it's packedGrains aloneγD\gamma_D

The Handbook's Vertical Stress Profiles follow the same rule, labeling the layer below the water level with its saturated unit weight. Turning these into stresses is the job of Effective Stress.

To rank the four for one soil, follow the water. Filling voids adds weight without adding volume. Going under water does more than take that added weight back, because it also lifts the grains themselves.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A soil is partly saturated. Which ranks its unit weights from largest to smallest?

A.
γsat>γ>γ′>γD\gamma_{sat} > \gamma > \gamma' > \gamma_D
B.
γD>γ>γsat>γ′\gamma_D > \gamma > \gamma_{sat} > \gamma'
C.
γsat>γ>γD>γ′\gamma_{sat} > \gamma > \gamma_D > \gamma'
D.
γ>γsat>γD>γ′\gamma > \gamma_{sat} > \gamma_D > \gamma'

Recap

  • One expression covers every amount of water: γ=(Gs+Se)γW/(1+e)\gamma = (G_s + Se)\gamma_W / (1 + e), grains plus water over total volume, from the box with Vs=1V_s = 1. Dry is S=0S = 0 and saturated is S=1S = 1. The Handbook prints only the saturated case.
  • "Dry" means counting the grains alone, not a soil that has been dried: γD=γ/(1+ω)\gamma_D = \gamma / (1 + \omega), with ω\omega as a decimal.
  • Below the water table, Archimedes lifts every grain: γ′=γsat−γW=(Gs−1)γW/(1+e)\gamma' = \gamma_{sat} - \gamma_W = (G_s - 1)\gamma_W / (1 + e), roughly half of γsat\gamma_{sat}.
  • Full voids tie ee to ω\omega through e=ωGse = \omega G_s. From a dry unit weight, back out e=GsγW/γD−1e = G_s\gamma_W / \gamma_D - 1 to find γsat\gamma_{sat} or the water content at saturation. From a water content, e=ωGse = \omega G_s gives the zero-air-voids ceiling, γD=GsγW/(1+ωGs)\gamma_D = G_s\gamma_W / (1 + \omega G_s).
  • For one soil, γsat>γ>γD>γ′\gamma_{sat} > \gamma > \gamma_D > \gamma'. Below the water table, use γsat\gamma_{sat} to count everything and γ′\gamma' for what the grains press on each other with.