Triaxial Tests and Failure Planes

At failure, Mohr's circle just touches the strength envelope, and that one point fixes everything else.

Before this Lesson

A vacuum-packed brick of ground coffee is hard. You can stand it on end and lean on it. Snip a corner, and with a hiss it goes soft and the grounds pour like sand. The coffee didn't change. The squeeze did: while the bag was sealed, the air outside pressed on it at 14.7 psi with almost nothing pushing back, and that held the grains together hard enough for their friction to make a solid.

A triaxial test turns that brick into a measurement. Squeeze a cylinder of soil all around, then push on its ends until it gives way. This Lesson works out how hard you have to push.

Squeezing a cylinder

The specimen is a soil cylinder about twice as tall as it is wide, sealed in a rubber membrane inside a chamber of water. Pressurize the water, and it presses on every face with the cell pressure σ3\sigma_3. A piston then pushes on the ends only. That extra is the deviator stress, σ1−σ3\sigma_1 - \sigma_3, and the total vertical stress is σ1\sigma_1. A valve on the drainage line decides whether water can leave the soil.

The cell Stresses on the specimen Drainage valve Axial load Piston Cell fluid at pressure σ3 Rubber membrane Specimen σ1 σ1 σ3 σ3 σ1 − σ3 = deviator stress
A triaxial cell, and the stresses on the specimen
The cell fluid presses σ3\sigma_3 on every face. The piston adds the deviator stress on the ends only.

Water and rubber can't grip, and the end caps are treated as smooth, so no shear acts on the specimen's faces, which makes them principal planes: σ1\sigma_1 acts on horizontal planes and σ3\sigma_3 on vertical ones. Soil almost never carries tension, so soil mechanics takes compression as positive, the reverse of the convention in Principal Stresses and Mohr's Circle. Compressive stresses plot to the right.

On the circle, σ3\sigma_3 and σ1\sigma_1 are the ends, so the center and radius are:

s=σ1+σ32t=σ1−σ32s = \frac{\sigma_1 + \sigma_3}{2} \qquad t = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{2}

These are the CC and RR of Principal Stresses and Mohr's Circle. The Handbook's Mohr-Coulomb diagram, in its Geotechnical section, labels them ss, the mean normal stress, and tt, the maximum shear stress. The radius is half the deviator stress.

Failure is the circle touching the line

Now hold σ3\sigma_3 and push the piston harder. The left end of the circle stays put while the right end slides out, so the circle swells. Every plane in the specimen is a point on it, and the envelope from Shear Strength marks the most shear each plane can carry. While the circle sits below the line, every plane holds. When it touches the line, one plane has reached its strength, and the specimen slips along it.

Shear stress, τ Normal stress, σN φ τF = σN tan φ T σ3 σ1 at failure
Raising σ₁ at a fixed σ₃ swells the circle until it touches the envelope

For a clean sand, c=0c = 0, and the envelope runs through the origin OO at the angle ϕ\phi. The radius to the tangent point TT meets the envelope at a right angle, so OO, the center, and TT make a right triangle, with hypotenuse ss and the side tt opposite ϕ\phi:

sin⁡ϕ=ts=σ1−σ3σ1+σ3\sin\phi = \frac{t}{s} = \frac{\sigma_1 - \sigma_3}{\sigma_1 + \sigma_3}
Shear stress, τ Normal stress, σN φ Mohr-Coulomb failure: τF = σN tan φ T (σN, τF) t = (σ1 − σ3)/2 σ3 σ1 O s = (σ1 + σ3)/2
The circle at failure for a sand, and the right triangle it makes
The Handbook's diagram draws the whole circle and an envelope with an intercept cc. Here c=0c = 0, and the lower half is left off.

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Geotechnical section, Mohr-Coulomb failure diagram

Only the triangle's angle matters, not its size. Double σ3\sigma_3, and the triangle scales up, so σ1\sigma_1 doubles too: for a sand, ϕ\phi fixes the ratio σ1/σ3\sigma_1/\sigma_3. Solve for it:

σ1σ3=1+sin⁡ϕ1−sin⁡ϕ=tan⁡2 ⁣(45∘+ϕ2)\frac{\sigma_1}{\sigma_3} = \frac{1 + \sin\phi}{1 - \sin\phi} = \tan^2\!\left(45^\circ + \frac{\phi}{2}\right)

The last step is a trig identity. Check it at ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ: (1+0.5)/(1−0.5)=3(1 + 0.5)/(1 - 0.5) = 3, and tan⁡260∘=3\tan^2 60^\circ = 3. That sand fails when σ1\sigma_1 reaches three times the cell pressure, whatever the pressure. That's the coffee brick's secret: squeeze it harder, and it holds proportionally more.

The Handbook's name for this ratio

The Handbook prints neither form above, but under Horizontal Stress Profiles and Forces, its Rankine passive coefficient KP=tan⁡2(45∘+ϕ/2)K_P = \tan^2(45^\circ + \phi/2) is exactly σ1/σ3\sigma_1/\sigma_3 at failure, and the active coefficient KA=tan⁡2(45∘−ϕ/2)K_A = \tan^2(45^\circ - \phi/2) is its inverse. Lateral Earth Pressure shows why.

Worked Example A sand at 100 kPa of cell pressure
1 of 3

A drained triaxial test is run on a dry sand with ϕ=36∘\phi = 36^\circ at a cell pressure of 100 kPa. Find σ1\sigma_1 and the deviator stress at failure.

The plane that fails

The tangent point TT is the plane that failed, and its coordinates are that plane's stresses, which the Handbook's diagram marks (σN,τF)(\sigma_N, \tau_F). To find which way the plane faces, start at the σ1\sigma_1 end of the circle. It stands for the plane σ1\sigma_1 acts on, the major principal plane, which is horizontal in a triaxial test. The angle at the center from there around to TT is 2θ2\theta. Inside the triangle, the angle at the center is 90∘−ϕ90^\circ - \phi, so:

2θ=180∘−(90∘−ϕ)=90∘+ϕθ=45∘+ϕ22\theta = 180^\circ - (90^\circ - \phi) = 90^\circ + \phi \qquad \theta = 45^\circ + \frac{\phi}{2}
On the circle Shear stress, τ Normal stress, σN φ T: failure plane 2θ = 90° + φ 90° − φ σ3 σ1: horizontal plane In the specimen σ1 σ1 σ3 σ3 θ = 45° + φ/2 Failure plane Major principal plane (horizontal)
From the circle at failure to the plane in the specimen
Going 2θ2\theta around the circle from the σ1\sigma_1 end reaches the tangent point. In the specimen, the failure plane is tilted θ\theta from the horizontal major principal plane. Drawn for ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ.

The failure plane is tilted 45∘+ϕ/245^\circ + \phi/2 from the major principal plane. The Handbook's diagram marks 2θ2\theta but doesn't print this result. For ϕ=30∘\phi = 30^\circ, that's 60° from the horizontal. Measured from the vertical, the same plane is at 45∘−ϕ/245^\circ - \phi/2: the right plane from the wrong reference. Its stresses come off the triangle: σN=s−tsin⁡ϕ\sigma_N = s - t\sin\phi and τF=tcos⁡ϕ\tau_F = t\cos\phi.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A sand with ϕ=34∘\phi = 34^\circ fails in a drained triaxial test. At what angle from the horizontal does the failure plane lie?

°

Clay with the drains shut

Now shear a saturated clay with the valve shut the whole time. Raising the cell pressure then raises the pore pressure by the same amount, just as the water took a quick fill's weight in Shear Strength, so the effective stress and the strength don't change. Every circle has the same diameter and touches the same horizontal envelope, the ϕ=0\phi = 0 line at sus_u. A test with the drains shut throughout is unconsolidated-undrained, or UU.

So the cheapest version skips the cell. In the unconfined compression test, a clay cylinder stands in the open, σ3=0\sigma_3 = 0, and the axial load at failure PP over the area AA is the unconfined compressive strength:

qu=PAq_u = \frac{P}{A}

The circle runs from the origin to quq_u, and a horizontal envelope touches it at the top, where the shear is the radius:

su=t=qu2s_u = t = \frac{q_u}{2}

quq_u is the diameter, and sus_u the radius. The Handbook prints neither, so carry this one in. The top is 90° around from the σ1\sigma_1 end, so the failure plane is at 45°, which is 45∘+ϕ/245^\circ + \phi/2 with ϕ=0\phi = 0. And unlike sand, which would slump like the opened coffee, a saturated clay stands with no cell, because its pore water went into suction when the sample was unloaded.

Shear stress, τ Total normal stress, σN τF = su (φ = 0) su = qu/2 Unconfined: σ3 = 0 UU tests at higher cell pressures qu qu qu
Undrained tests on one saturated clay: every circle is the same size
The unconfined test is the circle that starts at the origin. More cell pressure only slides the circle to the right.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

An unconfined compression test on a saturated clay specimen 38 mm in diameter fails under an axial load of 120 N. What is the clay's undrained shear strength?

kPa

Matching the test to the field

A triaxial test's name records two stages. The first word covers the cell pressure going on: consolidated means the valve is open and the clay settles under that pressure, as clay in the ground has under the soil above it, and unconsolidated means it stays shut. The second covers shearing: drained, with the valve open and the loading slow enough that no excess pore pressure builds up, or undrained, with it shut. Match the test's drainage to the field's.

The three triaxial tests
TestUnder cell pressureWhile shearingUse for
UUDrains shutDrains shutEnd of construction on clay
CUDrains openDrains shut, u measuredLong term, from σ′ = σ − u
CDDrains openDrains open, slowlyLong term, directly

An embankment built in a few months loads a soft clay faster than it can drain, so at the end of construction the field clay hasn't drained either. A UU or unconfined test gives its sus_u, with ϕ=0\phi = 0. That's often the critical moment, since the clay gains strength as it drains.

The long term runs on c′c' and ϕ′\phi'. A consolidated-drained (CD) test measures them directly, but shearing a clay slowly enough can take days. A consolidated-undrained (CU) test shears quickly with the valve shut and measures the pore pressure uu. Subtracting uu from both principal stresses slides the circle left without changing its size, onto the same envelope a CD test finds. Without uu, a CU test gives only total stresses. And a soil with cohesion needs at least two tests, with the envelope drawn tangent to both circles.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A grain silo will be built and filled within a month on a thick deposit of soft, saturated clay. Which test models the clay for the bearing check right after the silo is first filled?

A.
Consolidated-drained (CD)
B.
Consolidated-undrained (CU), with pore pressures measured
C.
Unconsolidated-undrained (UU)
D.
A drained direct shear test

Recap

  • Compression is positive. The cell pressure is σ3\sigma_3, the deviator stress σ1−σ3\sigma_1 - \sigma_3, and the circle's radius tt half of it.
  • Failure is the circle touching the envelope. For a sand, sin⁡ϕ=(σ1−σ3)/(σ1+σ3)\sin\phi = (\sigma_1 - \sigma_3)/(\sigma_1 + \sigma_3) and σ1=σ3tan⁡2(45∘+ϕ/2)\sigma_1 = \sigma_3\tan^2(45^\circ + \phi/2), the Handbook's KPK_P.
  • The tangent point is the failure plane, at 45∘+ϕ/245^\circ + \phi/2 from the major principal plane, the horizontal in a triaxial test.
  • Unconfined compression: σ3=0\sigma_3 = 0, qu=P/Aq_u = P/A, and su=qu/2s_u = q_u/2.
  • UU for the end of construction on clay. CD, or CU with pore pressures measured, for the long term.