Principal Stresses and Mohr's Circle
Rotate the element and the same stress looks different; Mohr's circle shows every view at once.
Before this Lesson
Twist a stick of chalk until it snaps. It won't break straight across, the way it does when you bend it. It breaks along a spiral that winds around the stick at about 45° to its length. That should bother you. Twisting puts only shear on a shaft's cross-sections, and chalk doesn't fail in shear. It fails in tension. So somewhere in that twisted chalk there's a tension big enough to break it, on a plane you weren't looking at.
Every plane through a point sees a different stress
You've met this once already. In Combined Stresses, a bar you only pulled had shear on its slanted cuts, with the angle from the bar's axis to the cut's normal:
Swap in the double-angle identities, and :
Plot each cut as a point, normal stress across and shear up. The point always sits from , at an angle , so every cut through the bar lands on one circle.
Read it around. The square cut, at 0°, is the right end: all of and no shear. The 45° cut is the top: the largest shear, , with of normal stress still on it. The cut along the bar, at 90°, is the left end, where nothing acts.
That is the one strange thing about the picture: the circle turns twice as fast as the plane. Turn the plane 90°, and you go halfway around, so two faces at right angles always sit at opposite ends of a diameter.
Nothing here is special to a bar. The transformation equations for any element have the same form, a constant plus and terms, so every state of plane stress traces a circle: Mohr's circle, named for Otto Mohr, who put it to work in the 1880s. Only the center and radius change.
Pure shear, and the chalk
In Torsion of Circular Shafts, a little square on a twisted shaft's surface carried shear and nothing else: and . Its face has no normal stress, so it plots on the axis, a distance from the origin. Its face is 90° away on the element, so it's the other end of the diameter, the same distance on the other side. (Which one goes on top is a convention, coming up shortly.) The circle is centered on the origin, with radius .
Go 90° around from either face, and you hit the axis at and : two planes with no shear at all, one in pure tension and one in pure compression. Ninety degrees on the circle is 45° on the element. Turn the square 45°, and its faces meet those stresses head-on: tension on one pair, compression on the other. They run along the original square's diagonals, which is why the squares on the rubber rod in Torsion leaned into diamonds, longer along one diagonal and shorter along the other.
Chalk is weak in tension, so it cracks square to that pull, and a crack square to a pull at 45° to the axis winds around the stick as a spiral. A ductile steel shaft is weaker in shear, so when it fails, it shears off flat across the cross-section, where the shear is largest.
Plotting any element
From Combined Stresses: a normal stress is positive in tension, with its arrows pulling out of the faces. A positive points up on the right face and right on the top face, and the opposite way on the left and bottom faces.
A general element gives you two faces to plot. The face goes at and the face at , with tension positive. Call those points X and Y. Whether each goes up or down comes from the Handbook's rule in Mohr's Circle—Stress, 2D: a shear plots above the axis when the pair on opposite faces "forms a clockwise couple," and below when it forms a counterclockwise one.
Take the Handbook's element, with positive. The shears on its faces, up on the right and down on the left, would spin the square counterclockwise, so X plots below the axis. The shears on its faces would spin it clockwise, so Y plots above. Reverse the arrows, and both points swap sides. To plot a point, you never need a sign for the shear, just a look at which way each pair turns.
Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Principal Stresses and Mohr's Circle—Stress, 2D
X and Y are faces at right angles, so they're the two ends of a diameter, and the center sits halfway between them, on the axis:
That's the average normal stress, and since every plane lands on the same circle, every pair of perpendicular faces has the same average. The radius is the distance from out to X. Before reading on, build it from the figure.
The Handbook prints both under Mohr's Circle—Stress, 2D:
The shear is squared, so its direction can't change the circle's size. It only decides which side of the axis X and Y sit on.
Principal stresses and the largest shear
The circle's two ends on the axis are planes with no shear. They carry the largest and smallest normal stresses of any plane on the circle, and they're the principal stresses. The Handbook writes them:
is the major principal stress and the minor. Minor means algebraically smallest, farthest left on the axis: 50 MPa of compression is smaller than 10 MPa of tension.
The principal planes are always there, and always at right angles. The shears on the faces turn one way and those on the faces turn the other, so as the plane turns from one to the other, its shear has to pass through zero. On the circle, that's the two places it crosses the axis, 180° apart, or 90° on the element.
The top and bottom of the circle carry the most shear, the radius: the Handbook's maximum in-plane shear is . Those points are 90° around from the ends, so the planes of largest shear sit at 45° to the principal planes. And they aren't free of normal stress: both carry . (The Handbook's next line, a three-dimensional , equals whenever and have opposite signs.)
Which way the principal plane faces
The circle also says how far to turn. In the Handbook's circle above, the angle at from X to the end is , where is the angle on the element from the -axis to the major principal plane, measured to the plane's normal as in Combined Stresses. The triangle from to X gives its tangent, the leg over the leg :
The Handbook doesn't print this, so a question that needs it usually gives it. Either way, halve the angle, because the circle turns twice as fast as the element: a circle drawn with 70° from X to means a 35° turn.
With the Handbook's plotting rule, the element turns the same way as the circle. Put in as positive when it points the Handbook's way, up on the right face, and negative when it's reversed. Then a positive is counterclockwise from , and a negative one is clockwise.
One catch: a tangent repeats every 180°, so has two roots on the element, 90° apart, the major and minor principal planes. Your calculator returns the one within 45° of . That's the major plane when is greater than , since X is then nearer the end. When is greater, it's the minor plane, and the major is 90° away. The physical check: the major principal plane always lies within 45° of the face with the larger normal stress.
The stresses on any plane
The circle holds every plane, not just the principal ones. For the plane whose normal is counterclockwise from , start at X and go counterclockwise around the circle. The point you land on is that plane. Its horizontal position is the normal stress on it, its height is the shear, and whether it's above or below the axis tells you which way that shear pair turns.
The arithmetic is one right triangle at the center. If the landing point sits at an angle from the end, its normal stress is and its shear is .
Reading a circle backward
Some questions hand you the circle and ask about the element. Everything runs in reverse. The circle's ends are the principal stresses. The center is halfway between them, and it's also , so knowing gives you . And the radius ties the rest together through its triangle, so a missing shear comes from the other two sides:
For the face itself, use the same triangle at the center as for any plane: X sits at some angle from the end, and that angle's cosine and sine give and .