Torsion of Circular Shafts

A twisted shaft works hardest at its surface and barely at all at its center.

Draw a grid on a thick rubber rod: lines running along it, and rings around it. Hold one end and twist the other. The lines wind into gentle spirals, and every little square on the surface leans over into a diamond. The rings stay rings, the same size and the same distance apart. That's all you can see from outside, and it's enough to tell you where a shaft works hardest, how far it twists, and why a truck's drive shaft is a hollow tube.

Every slice turns a little more than the last

The rings carry the key fact. Each cross-section of a round shaft stays flat and round and turns as a rigid disk, like a coin on a skewer. With one end fixed, each slice turns a little more than the one before, and the free end turns through the whole angle of twist, ϕ\phi.

γ φ r rφ T L
A shaft fixed at one end and twisted at the other

Follow a line along the surface. Its far end, on the rim at radius rr, swings along an arc rϕr\phi. Spread over the length LL, that tilts the line, and every little square on it, by a small angle γ\gamma: the shear strain of Strain, Hooke's Law, and Poisson's Ratio. For a small angle, γL=rϕ\gamma L = r\phi, so:

γ=rϕL\gamma = \frac{r\phi}{L}

A line deeper inside, at a smaller rr, swings a shorter arc and tilts less, and at the center it doesn't tilt at all. So the strain grows in proportion to the distance from the center. The Handbook's Torsional Strain entry says so, writing γ=r(dϕ/dz)\gamma = r(d\phi/dz), with the twist per unit length in place of ϕ/L\phi/L.

Hooke's law in shear, τ=Gγ\tau = G\gamma, ties the stress at each point to the strain there, and GG is the same everywhere in the shaft. The stress acts along the circle through each point, the way the slices slide.

This needs a round shaft. A twisted square bar's cross-sections warp out of their plane, and none of it holds.

Checkpoint

A solid circular shaft carries a torque and nothing else. Which statements about the shear stress on a cross-section are true?

A.
It is greatest at the center, where the material is most confined.
B.
Halfway from the center to the surface, it is half its value at the surface.
C.
It is the same at every point of the cross-section.
D.
It is greatest at the outer surface.
E.
The material near the center carries most of the torque.

Adding up the torque

Stress follows strain, so it's zero at the center and grows in a straight line to its peak at the surface. Those stresses on a cut have to add up to the torque the shaft carries. Take a small patch of area dAdA at a distance rr from the center. The patch carries a force τ dA\tau\,dA on an arm rr, a torque of τr dA\tau r\,dA.

τmax τ dA dA r O T
Shear stress on the cross-section of a twisted solid shaft

With τ=Gγ=Grϕ/L\tau = G\gamma = Gr\phi/L:

T=∫τr dA=GϕL∫r2 dA=GϕL JT = \int \tau r\,dA = \frac{G\phi}{L}\int r^2\,dA = \frac{G\phi}{L}\,J

There's rr, showing up twice. Material farther out is strained more, so it pushes harder, and it pushes on a longer arm. That makes the sum ∫r2 dA\int r^2\,dA, the polar moment of inertia JJ. A wider shaft also has more area out at those large radii, which is why JJ grows with the fourth power of the radius.

Solve that line for ϕ/L=T/GJ\phi/L = T/GJ and put it back into τ=Grϕ/L\tau = Gr\phi/L. The GG cancels, leaving the formula in the Handbook's Torsion entry:

τ=TrJ\tau = \frac{Tr}{J}

It gives the stress at any distance rr from the center, and the largest at the surface, where r=D/2r = D/2, not DD. The Handbook states it for solid shafts and thick-walled tubes, which covers every shaft here.

TT is the internal torque at the section. Finding it is the statics half, and in a shaft driven at one end and loaded at the other, it's the same all along. Keep one unit family: kip-in., in., and in⁴ give ksi, and N·mm, mm, and mm⁴ give MPa.

Worked Example A solid steel shaft
1 of 3

A solid steel shaft 2 in. in diameter carries a torque of 1,250 ft-lb. Find the maximum shear stress, and the stress halfway from the center to the surface.

Hollow shafts put the steel where the stress is

Look at the stress picture again. The steel near the center is barely stressed, and its force has almost no arm, so it adds weight and little strength. Spend that steel on a wider ring instead, and the shaft gets much stronger. That's the drive shaft's secret.

A tube's JJ is the outer circle's minus the hole's, π(Do4−Di4)/32\pi(D_o^4 - D_i^4)/32: fourth powers first, then subtract. A wall thickness tt comes off both sides, so Di=Do−2tD_i = D_o - 2t.

The stress still grows with rr, but the line starts at the inner wall instead of at zero. Tr/JTr/J gives both surfaces, with ro=Do/2r_o = D_o/2 outside and ri=Di/2r_i = D_i/2 inside, so τi=τo(ri/ro)\tau_i = \tau_o(r_i/r_o).

6.37 ksi T 2.73 ksi 2.03 ksi T solid tube D = 2 in. A = 3.14 in2 J = 1.57 in4 Do= 3 in. Di= 2.24 in. A = 3.14 in2 J = 5.50 in4
A solid shaft and a tube with the same area, under the same 10 kip-in. torque

Those two sections hold the same steel. The tube's JJ is 3.5 times the solid's, so its peak stress is 2.73 ksi against 6.37 ksi, and at the same stress it could carry 2.33 times the torque.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A hollow shaft has a 4 in. outside diameter and a 0.5 in. wall. It carries a torque of 60 kip-in. What is the shear stress at its outer surface?

ksi

Torque from power

A turning shaft carries power P=TωP = T\omega, as in Power and Efficiency. The Handbook prints it under Rotating Machines. A motor's nameplate gives power and speed, so turn it around, T=P/ωT = P/\omega, and take care with the units, from the Handbook's Units and Conversion Factors table:

  • Horsepower times 550 gives ft-lb/s. Kilowatts times 1,000 give watts, or N·m/s.
  • Rpm times 2π/602\pi/60 gives rad/s.
  • The torque comes out in ft-lb or N·m. Times 12 gives in.-lb, and times 1,000 gives N·mm, ready for Tr/JTr/J.
Worked Example From horsepower to stress
1 of 2

A motor delivers 40 hp at 600 rpm through a solid shaft 1.5 in. in diameter. Find the maximum shear stress.

The thinnest shaft that's strong enough

For a solid shaft, put J=πD4/32J = \pi D^4/32 and r=D/2r = D/2 into Tr/JTr/J, and the stress collapses into one handy form. The Handbook doesn't print it, but it's one substitution away:

τmax⁡=T(D/2)πD4/32=16TπD3⇒Dmin⁡=16Tπ τallow3\tau_{\max} = \frac{T(D/2)}{\pi D^4/32} = \frac{16T}{\pi D^3} \quad\Rightarrow\quad D_{\min} = \sqrt[3]{\frac{16T}{\pi\,\tau_{\text{allow}}}}

A thinner shaft is more stressed, so this diameter is a floor: if a question offers sizes, take the first one above it. If it gives power instead of torque, find the torque first.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A solid shaft carries a torque of 2,500 ft-lb, and its shear stress may not exceed 8 ksi. What is its minimum diameter?

in.

How far it twists

The torque sum already handed over the twist. Solve T=(Gϕ/L)JT = (G\phi/L)J for ϕ\phi, and you have the Handbook's angle of twist, under Torsional Strain:

ϕ=TLGJ\phi = \frac{TL}{GJ}

It holds where the torque, the material, and the section stay the same along the length LL. Set it beside axial loading, and the two match term for term:

Torsion mirrors axial loading
AxialTorsion
Internal loadPPTT
Stressσ=P/A\sigma = P/Aτ=Tr/J\tau = Tr/J
ModulusEEGG
Deformationδ=PL/AE\delta = PL/AEϕ=TL/GJ\phi = TL/GJ
StiffnessAE/LAE/LGJ/LGJ/L

Two things to watch. Twisting is sliding, so the modulus is GG, the modulus of rigidity in Table 1 - Typical Material Properties: 11,500 ksi or 80,000 MPa for steel, and 3,800 ksi or 26,000 MPa for aluminum. And ϕ\phi comes out in radians, as the Handbook says, so multiply by 180/π180/\pi for degrees.

Worked Example The twist in the first shaft
1 of 2

The solid steel shaft from the first example, 2 in. in diameter and carrying 15 kip-in., is 6 ft long. Using Table 1, find its angle of twist in degrees.

A shaft is a torsional spring

Rearrange ϕ=TL/GJ\phi = TL/GJ the way Axial Deformation rearranged PL/AEPL/AE:

T=GJL ϕT = \frac{GJ}{L}\,\phi

GJ/LGJ/L is the torque per radian of twist. The Handbook calls T/ϕT/\phi the torsional stiffness, and its Torsional Vibration entry prints kt=GJ/Lk_t = GJ/L. Given a twist, the stiffness gives the torque. Given a twist limit, it gives the least JJ the shaft can have, and so its diameter:

Jmin⁡=TLG ϕallowDmin⁡=32Jmin⁡π4J_{\min} = \frac{TL}{G\,\phi_{\text{allow}}} \qquad D_{\min} = \sqrt[4]{\frac{32J_{\min}}{\pi}}

Put the limit in radians before it goes in. A shaft with both a stress limit and a twist limit needs the larger of the two diameters.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A solid steel shaft 4 ft long carries 10 kip-in., and its twist may not exceed 1°. Using Table 1, what is its minimum diameter?

in.

Segments in a row

A stepped shaft is torsional springs in a row, like a stepped bar. Each segment twists by its own share, and the shares add:

ϕ=∑iTiLiGiJi\phi = \sum_i \frac{T_i L_i}{G_i J_i}

Each TiT_i is that segment's internal torque, found by cutting, as in Axial Stress: keep the piece away from the wall, and the torque at the cut balances the torques on that piece, each with its sign.

The case to know cold is a shaft fixed at one end, with the torque part way along. Cut beyond the torque, and the piece you keep has no torque on it, so that segment carries nothing and doesn't twist. It still turns, riding along with the point where the torque acts, so the free end turns exactly as far as that point.

T twists no torque, no twist φB φC= φB A B C
A shaft fixed at A with a torque at B: only AB twists
Worked Example A stepped shaft loaded part way
1 of 2
D = 2 in. D = 1.25 in. 12 kip-in. 3 ft 2 ft A B C
A stepped steel shaft fixed at A, with a torque at B

Using Table 1, find the angle of twist at the free end C.

Changing one thing at a time

For a solid shaft, put J=πD4/32J = \pi D^4/32 into both formulas, and the powers of the diameter show:

τmax⁡=16TπD3ϕ=32TLπGD4\tau_{\max} = \frac{16T}{\pi D^3} \qquad \phi = \frac{32TL}{\pi G D^4}

The stress goes with 1/D31/D^3, because JJ brings four powers of the diameter and rr gives one back. The twist goes with 1/D41/D^4, from JJ alone. Length is in the twist but not the stress: a longer shaft twists more, but no slice of it works any harder. To compare two shafts, write new over old and cancel whatever didn't change.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A solid shaft is replaced by one of the same material with twice the diameter, carrying the same torque. What happens to the maximum shear stress?

A.
It falls to half.
B.
It falls to a quarter.
C.
It falls to an eighth.
D.
It falls to a sixteenth.

Recap

  • Cross-sections stay flat and turn as rigid disks, so shear stress grows in proportion to rr, from zero at the center to its peak at the surface.
  • τ=Tr/J\tau = Tr/J, with r=D/2r = D/2 at the surface, or rir_i at a tube's inner wall. The core does little, so a tube uses its steel far better.
  • T=P/ωT = P/\omega, with rpm times 2π/602\pi/60. For a solid shaft, τmax⁡=16T/(πD3)\tau_{\max} = 16T/(\pi D^3) sets the least diameter.
  • ϕ=TL/GJ\phi = TL/GJ in radians, with GG, not EE, and the stiffness GJ/LGJ/L runs it backward. A segment beyond the last torque carries none and turns without twisting.
  • Double the diameter, and the stress falls to an eighth and the twist to a sixteenth.