Combined Stresses

Stresses from different loads simply add, if they act at the same point in the same direction.

Before this Lesson

Set a 20 kip load dead center on a short concrete post 10 in. square, and every square inch of it carries the same 200 psi. Now slide the load 2.5 in. toward one face. The load hasn't changed, but the face nearest it now carries 500 psi, and the far face isn't just carrying less. It's being pulled apart, at 100 psi of tension, in a material that's weak in tension. You already know both formulas that explain this. The whole trick is adding them.

An off-center load is a centered load plus a couple

A move from statics: at the post's centroid, add two forces PP, one up and one down. They cancel, so nothing changes. Now regroup. The original load and the new upward force form a couple PePe, where ee is the load's distance from the centroid, its eccentricity. What's left is the downward force, dead center.

Off-center load Centered load Couple P e P/A − Mc/I P/A + Mc/I compression P P/A P/A compression M = Pe Mc/I Mc/I tension compression
An off-center load splits into a centered load and a couple, and their stresses add

You've met both pieces. The centered load squeezes the post evenly, with σ=P/A\sigma = P/A from the Handbook's Uniaxial Loading and Deformation. The couple bends it like a beam stood on end, with Mc/IMc/I at the faces from Stresses in Beams, squeezing the side the load is on and stretching the other.

The Handbook's Principle of Superposition, under Beams, says separate effects add, as long as each is linear in its load and the deformations are too small to change how the other loads act. That second condition is why these posts are short. A slender one bows, carrying the load farther off center, and it can buckle, which waits for Euler Buckling.

Stresses add only when they act at the same point, in the same direction, on the same plane, and these do: both are vertical normal stresses on one horizontal cut. At the two faces:

σ=PA±McI=PA±PecI\sigma = \frac{P}{A} \pm \frac{Mc}{I} = \frac{P}{A} \pm \frac{Pec}{I}

For a compressive load, read both parts as compression. The plus sign goes with the face nearer the load, which both parts squeeze. The far face gets the even squeeze minus the bending stretch, and when the bending part is bigger, that face is in tension, as in the opening.

As in every problem in this topic, there's a statics half and a materials half. The statics half is one cut: below the load, the post carries PP and PePe. In the materials half, II is about the centroidal axis at right angles to the offset, so the side along the offset plays the depth hh of Bending Stress. For a solid circle, the Handbook's area table uses the radius aa: A=πa2A = \pi a^2 and I=πa4/4I = \pi a^4/4, with c=ac = a.

Worked Example The largest and smallest stress in a post
1 of 3

A short post carries a compressive load of 600 kN, 50 mm off center along its 400 mm side. Find the largest and smallest normal stresses.

centroid P = 600 kN 50 mm 400 mm 300 mm
The post's cross-section, seen from above

The middle third

So when does the far face go into tension? For a rectangle, call bb the side along the offset. It plays the depth, so c=b/2c = b/2 and I/cI/c works out to Ab/6Ab/6. The bending part becomes a fixed multiple of the even part:

PecI=PeAb/6=PA⋅6eb⇒σ=PA(1±6eb)\frac{Pec}{I} = \frac{Pe}{Ab/6} = \frac{P}{A}\cdot\frac{6e}{b} \qquad\Rightarrow\qquad \sigma = \frac{P}{A}\left(1 \pm \frac{6e}{b}\right)

Mind the letter: this bb isn't the beam width from Bending Stress. It's the side along the offset, doing the job hh did there. The far face, at (P/A)(1−6e/b)(P/A)(1 - 6e/b), stays in compression as long as:

e≤b6e \le \frac{b}{6}

The load can sit up to b/6b/6 either side of center, in a band b/3b/3 wide: the middle third. Inside it, the whole section is in compression. On its edge, the far face is at zero and the near face at 2P/A2P/A. Outside it, the far face is in tension. Wherever the load sits, the face nearest it carries the most compression.

b P b/3 middle third 0.5P/A 1.5P/A compression e = b/12 b P 0 2P/A compression e = b/6 b P 0.5P/A 2.5P/A compression tension e = b/4
The same post with the load inside, on the edge of, and outside the middle third

That matters for whatever can push but can't pull, like plain masonry, or the soil under a footing. The Handbook prints no middle-third rule. Its nearest match is the toe pressure in Retaining Walls, (ΣV/B)(1+6e/B)(\Sigma V/B)(1 + 6e/B), the same expression for a wall's base, and Footing Size and the Water Table uses it under footings.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A short post's section is 15 in. east to west and 9 in. north to south. A compressive load sits 2 in. east of the centroid. Which is true?

A.
The west face carries the largest compression, and the whole section stays in compression.
B.
The east face carries the largest compression, and the west face is in tension.
C.
The east face carries the largest compression, and the whole section stays in compression.
D.
The west face carries the largest compression, and the east face is in tension.

The largest load

A design question turns this around: how big can PP be for an allowable compressive stress? Set the near face equal to the allowable, and factor out PP:

PA+PecI=σallow⇒P=σallow1/A+ec/I\frac{P}{A} + \frac{Pec}{I} = \sigma_{\text{allow}} \qquad\Rightarrow\qquad P = \frac{\sigma_{\text{allow}}}{1/A + ec/I}

For a rectangle, that's P=σallowA/(1+6e/b)P = \sigma_{\text{allow}}A/(1 + 6e/b). With the load on the edge of the middle third, the post carries half what it could dead center.

Checkpoint

A short post's section is 250 mm by 400 mm. A compressive load sits 50 mm off center along the 400 mm side. The allowable compressive stress is 10 MPa. What is the largest load?

kN

Brackets, clamps, and beams with an end load

The post is one case of a section carrying an axial force and a moment at once. A bracket on a column, a crane hook, a C-clamp's frame, and a beam squeezed end to end all work the same way. For the statics half, cut through the section and find PP and the moment MM about its centroid. For the materials half, add P/AP/A and Mc/IMc/I face by face, keeping track of tension and compression.

For an offset load, the moment arm runs from the load's line of action to the section's centroid, not to its near face. A load 3 in. outside a 10 in. column has an arm of 3+5=83 + 5 = 8 in. The face nearer the load gets both parts in the same direction: extra compression for a push, extra tension for a pull. When the moment comes from something else, like a beam's own load, read it off the bend: a positive moment compresses the top.

Worked Example The frame of a C-clamp
1 of 3

A C-clamp squeezes a block with 400 lb, so the block pushes the jaws apart with 400 lb. Section a–a cuts the frame's back. Find the largest tensile and compressive stresses there.

400 lb 400 lb a a 3 in. Section a–a 1.0 in. 0.5 in. inner
A C-clamp and the cross-section of its back

The same force on a slanted cut

Every stress so far sat on a cross-section, the cut square to the member. But a stress belongs to a point and a plane together. Pull a bar with a force PP and cut it at a slant, with the cut's normal, the line square to it, at an angle θ\theta to the bar's axis. That's also the angle between the slanted cut and a square one.

P A A/cos θ θ P P cos θ P sin θ
A bar cut at a slant, with the force on the cut face split in two

Two things change. The slanted face is bigger, A/cos⁡θA/\cos\theta. And the force no longer points straight out of the face, so it splits into Pcos⁡θP\cos\theta along the normal and Psin⁡θP\sin\theta along the face. Divide each by the face's area:

σθ=Pcos⁡θA/cos⁡θ=σcos⁡2θτθ=Psin⁡θA/cos⁡θ=σsin⁡θcos⁡θ\sigma_\theta = \frac{P\cos\theta}{A/\cos\theta} = \sigma\cos^2\theta \qquad \tau_\theta = \frac{P\sin\theta}{A/\cos\theta} = \sigma\sin\theta\cos\theta

Here σ=P/A\sigma = P/A. So a bar you only pulled has shear inside it. At 0°, the square cut carries all of σ\sigma and no shear. At 90°, a cut along the bar carries nothing, since fibers side by side don't pull on each other. In between, the shear, (σ/2)sin⁡2θ(\sigma/2)\sin 2\theta, peaks at 45°, where τ=σ/2\tau = \sigma/2. That's why a ductile steel bar in a tension test yields by slipping along planes near 45°: yielding is a shearing.

The Handbook prints neither formula, so bring this with you. And watch the angle. These formulas want the angle between the plane's normal and the axis. Given the angle between the plane itself and the axis, use 90° minus it.

The stress element

To describe the stress at a point completely, shrink a square around it, with its faces square to an xx-axis and a yy-axis: the stress element. Its xx faces carry a normal stress σx\sigma_x, its yy faces carry σy\sigma_y, and the shear on them is τxy\tau_{xy}. The Handbook draws it under Principal Stresses, with every component in its positive sense:

σx σx σy σy τxy τxy x y
A plane stress element with every component positive

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Principal Stresses

  • A normal stress is positive in tension, with its arrows pulling out of the faces. An arrow pushing in is compression, a negative stress.
  • A positive τxy\tau_{xy} points up on the right face and right on the top face, and the opposite way on the left and bottom faces.

All four shears have the same size, because the pair on the right and left faces would spin the square unless the top and bottom pair balanced it. On a drawn element, the arrows carry the signs, so read them before you substitute.

The Handbook doesn't print the transformation equations for a slanted plane through an element, so a question that needs them gives them. A common form, with θ\theta counterclockwise from the xx-axis to the plane's normal, is:

σθ=σx+σy2+σx−σy2cos⁡2θ+τxysin⁡2θ\sigma_\theta = \frac{\sigma_x + \sigma_y}{2} + \frac{\sigma_x - \sigma_y}{2}\cos 2\theta + \tau_{xy}\sin 2\theta

Your job is the bookkeeping: each sign from its arrow, and the angle doubled where the equation says 2θ2\theta. With σx=σ\sigma_x = \sigma and nothing else, it gives σcos⁡2θ\sigma\cos^2\theta, the same as the slanted cut. Mohr's circle, and the Handbook's shear rule for plotting it, wait for Principal Stresses and Mohr's Circle.

Worked Example Stresses on a slanted plane in a bar
1 of 3

A steel bar 50 mm by 20 mm carries an axial tension of 80 kN. Find the normal and shear stress on a plane whose normal makes 30° with the bar's axis, and the largest shear stress anywhere in the bar.

Recap

  • Stresses add when they act at the same point, in the same direction, on the same plane. An off-center load is a centered load plus a couple, so σ=P/A±Pec/I\sigma = P/A \pm Pec/I, plus at the face nearer the load.
  • For a rectangle, σ=(P/A)(1±6e/b)\sigma = (P/A)(1 \pm 6e/b), with bb the side along the offset. The whole section stays in compression while e≤b/6e \le b/6, the middle third.
  • For a bracket or clamp, measure the moment arm from the load's line of action to the section's centroid, not to its near face.
  • On a plane whose normal makes θ\theta with a bar's axis, σθ=σcos⁡2θ\sigma_\theta = \sigma\cos^2\theta and τθ=σsin⁡θcos⁡θ\tau_\theta = \sigma\sin\theta\cos\theta, with the largest shear, σ/2\sigma/2, at 45°.
  • On the stress element, tension is positive, and a positive τxy\tau_{xy} points up on the right face and right on the top face.