Frames and Machines

Take the frame apart, and each piece is a rigid body you already know how to solve.

Open a stepladder and climb a few steps. It looks like a truss: two legs, a hinge at the top, a spreader bar between them, all triangles. So ask how hard the hinge is working, the way you'd ask about any truss joint, and you're stuck right away. Your weight lands partway up a leg, so that leg bends instead of only pushing along its length, and the force at the hinge points in a direction nobody has told you. Treating the whole ladder as one body won't help, because the hinge is inside it. To see the hinge force, you have to open the hinge.

W hinge ? spreader
A stepladder, with your weight partway up one leg

Count forces, not pins

A truss stays simple because of one promise: loads go only on the joints. That's what makes every member a two-force member. Break the promise, with a load between a member's pins or a third pin along it, and that member has three or more forces on it. It's a multiforce member. It bends as well as stretches, the forces at its pins no longer lie along it, and you can't tell which way they point by looking. So each of its pins brings two unknowns.

A structure with at least one multiforce member is a frame if it's built to stand and hold a load, and a machine if it's built to turn an input force into an output force. The method of joints fails on both, because a joint has only two equations, and each multiforce member brings two unknowns to it. The Handbook prints no procedure for them. It gives you Equilibrium Requirements and, under Concurrent Forces, the two-force rule, and those turn out to be enough.

Some members of a frame are still two-force members, and they're the way in. A two-force member's force lies on the line joining its pins, so it brings one unknown instead of two. Find those first, and count forces, not pins.

Two pins, nothing between F F two-force Two pins, a load between R1 R2 W multiforce Bent bar, two pins F F two-force
Three bars with two pins each, and the forces that act on them

The middle bar is the trap: it has two pins and looks like a truss member, but it isn't one. A hydraulic cylinder is a rod sliding in a barrel, but with a pin at each end and nothing between, it's two-force too. A member's own weight would count as a load, which is why links and cylinders are usually taken as weightless.

Three forces have to meet

Bodies with exactly three forces come up constantly, and they have a rule of their own. You've met one already, in Reactions of Bent Bars, Brackets, and Booms: a weightless 12 ft boom pinned to a wall, with a cable from its tip to an anchor 9 ft above the pin. With 900 lb at the tip, the pin pushed straight along the boom. Hang the load partway along, and the pin's force swung off the boom's line. Swung to where?

Extend the cable's line and the load's line until they cross, and take moments about the crossing point. Neither of those two forces has an arm there. The moments still have to add to zero, so the pin's force can't have an arm there either. Its line has to run through that same point.

That's the three-force rule: three nonparallel forces holding a body in equilibrium must meet at one point. The Handbook's Concurrent Forces entry prints the two-force rule and stops there, so this one is yours to carry.

Load at the tip 9 ft 12 ft 900 lb pin force A B Load at midspan 9 ft 12 ft 6 ft 4.5 ft 900 lb pin force A B
One boom with its load in two places, and where the pin's force has to aim

With the load at the tip, the cable and the load cross at the tip, so the pin's line runs along the boom. With the load at midspan, they cross 4.5 ft above the boom, 6 ft out, so the pin's line rises 4.5 over 6. That's a direction from geometry alone, before any force is known. Solve it the long way and you get Ax=600 lbA_x = 600\ \text{lb} and Ay=450 lbA_y = 450\ \text{lb}, the same 3/43/4.

Keep two limits in mind. Parallel forces never cross, so a beam with only vertical loads gets nothing from this rule. And the rule gives the line only: the sizes, and which way along the line, still come from the equations. A fourth force, such as the boom's own weight, turns the rule off.

Checkpoint
1 of 3
A C D B F G E W boom stick lift cylinder crowd cylinder
A backhoe arm holding a load W

Treat each hydraulic cylinder as one straight member, and ignore the weight of every part. Which are two-force members?

A.
The boom
B.
The lift cylinder
C.
The stick
D.
The crowd cylinder

One link, one unknown

Now put the two-force member to work on the simplest frame there is: a loaded arm on a pin, held by a link, a strut, or a hydraulic cylinder. The arm is multiforce. The link isn't, so all it brings is one size. With the pin's two components, that's three unknowns on one rigid body, and you've solved this before: the strut propping a shelf back among the booms was a two-force member all along. Moments about the arm's pin skip the pin's two unknowns and give the link's force in one line.

The link's own slope gives the split, and its arm is the perpendicular distance to its line, not the distance to where it ties on. If that arm is hard to read, slide the force along its line first.

Checkpoint
1 of 3
3 ft 1,200 lb 4 ft 6 ft A B C D
A horizontal arm held by a hydraulic cylinder

What force must the cylinder exert to hold the load? Ignore the weight of the arm and the cylinder.

lb

Open the pins

Often no single member gets you there, and then you take the frame apart. At each pin, two members push on each other, and those pushes are equal and opposite, because they're one push seen from each side. So a pin brings two unknowns, not four: CxC_x and CyC_y, drawn one way on one member and the opposite way on the other. Same letters, opposite arrows. Draw them the same way on both, and the two members' equations won't agree.

Whole frame 800 lb Ax Ay By A B C D E Taken apart Ax Ay 800 lb T Cx Cy A D C T T By T Cx Cy B E C
An A-frame as one body, and taken apart

Look at what's missing on the left. The tie's pull and the pin force at C are inside that body, so they stay off its diagram. They appear only once the frame is open, and then each piece is an ordinary rigid body with three equations, like the brackets and booms. Here's the order:

  1. Spot the two-force members. The tie here brings one unknown.
  2. Find the whole-frame reactions, if you can. A pin and a roller make three unknowns, so the whole frame settles them. Two pins on a wall make four, so skip this step.
  3. Take the frame apart, and go to the piece with the fewest forces, usually one with no load.
  4. Take moments about the pin where two unknowns meet, then sum forces.
Worked Example The hinge force in an A-frame
1 of 3

Here's your stepladder, with a tie for a spreader, a pin at one foot, and a roller at the other. Find the force in the tie and the pin force at C. Ignore the frame's weight.

800 lb 4.5 ft 1.5 ft 6 ft 4 ft 8 ft A B C D E
An A-frame with a tie, on a pin and a roller

Force in, force out

A machine is a frame with a job: turn the force you supply into a different one somewhere else, usually a bigger one. At any moment it's holding still against whatever it grips, so the method doesn't change. Take it apart, and write moments about each lever's own pivot. That hides the pivot's unknown force and leaves force in against force out, so a machine becomes a chain of lever equations, with each one's output feeding the next one's input.

Pliers are the shortest chain. Take one bar: your hand's force times its arm from the pivot equals the jaw's force times its arm from the pivot. The other bar does the same with your other hand, so your hands don't add. Each one drives its own jaw.

A toggle clamp works differently. Two two-force links meet at a knee, nearly in a straight line, and you push the knee. The knee is a particle, and because the links are so nearly flat, each needs a huge force for its small vertical part to hold your push. The horizontal part of that force does the clamping, so the flatter the links, the harder it clamps.

Worked Example A two-lever linkage
1 of 3

Find the force the lower lever puts on the workpiece. Ignore all weights.

workpiece 40 lb 12 in 3 in 2 in 8 in A B C F E D
A hand lever linked to a clamping lever

Recap

  • A multiforce member has three or more forces, so its pin forces don't lie along it. Find the two-force members first, counting forces, not pins: each brings one unknown, on the line joining its pins.
  • Three nonparallel forces holding a body in equilibrium must meet at one point, which fixes the line of an unknown pin force.
  • For a link, strut, or cylinder holding a loaded member, take moments about that member's pin, with the arm measured to the link's line.
  • Open a frame at its pins, with equal and opposite forces on the two members each pin joins. Those forces stay off the whole-frame diagram.
  • In a machine, write moments about each lever's own pivot, and let each output feed the next input.