Reactions of Bent Bars, Brackets, and Booms
Odd shapes, same three equations.
Before this Lesson
Lay a 10 ft bar on a pin and a roller, and hang 600 lb from it, 4 ft from the pin. You know this one: the roller carries 240 lb. Now take the bar to a forge and bend it into something ridiculous, keeping the pin, the roller, and the line the load hangs on exactly where they were. What does the roller carry now?
The equations never see the bar
- From Beam Reactions: take moments where the unknowns meet, then sum forces for the rest.
- From Moments and Couples: a vertical force's arm is a horizontal distance and a horizontal force's arm is a vertical one, and a force can slide along its line without changing its moment.
- From Free-Body Diagrams and Supports: a pin gives and , a fixed support adds , a roller or smooth surface pushes normal to the surface, and a cable pulls along its length.
It still carries 240 lb. A moment equation about the pin has three ingredients: each force, its line of action, and the perpendicular distance from the pin to that line. The bar isn't one of them. Its job is to hold the forces where they are, and whatever the metal does in between is internal and stays off the free-body diagram. So every body in this Lesson, from a bent bar or a bracket to a boom or a ladder, gets the routine you already have.
Two details do change in problems like these. First, forces stop lining up. On a straight beam, a load's horizontal part ran along the centerline, through both supports, with no arm. On a bent bar, it usually misses the moment point, so it has an arm, and it may turn the bar the opposite way from the vertical part of the same force.
Second, a roller can sit on a slope. It still brings one unknown, , normal to the surface it rolls on. But a tilted has a horizontal part, so the roller now shares sideways loads with the pin. And a surface tilted some angle from horizontal tilts its normal by that same angle from vertical, which is where people slip: the slope's rise pairs with 's horizontal part.
So a slope of 3 in 4 gives across and up, and a 30° incline gives across and up. The leg-over-hypotenuse form is in the Handbook's Resolution of a Force. The Handbook prints nothing about supports or rollers, so the normal rule is yours to carry.
When a question wants the pin reaction as one force, apply the Handbook's Resultant (Two Dimensions) to the pin's components:
A cable's arm isn't where it ties on
Now a boom: a bar pinned to a wall, held up by a slanted cable, with a weight hanging from it. Say a weightless 12 ft boom has 900 lb hanging at its tip, and the cable runs from the tip to an anchor 9 ft above the pin. The unknowns are , , and . Two of them meet at the pin, so moments about the pin leave only .
What's 's arm? It's tempting to say 12 ft, since that's how far out the cable ties on. But the arm is the perpendicular distance from the pin to the cable's line, which here is 7.2 ft, and using 12 ft would make a too-small 900 lb. You rarely need that perpendicular, though. can slide along its line, so resolve it wherever the arms are easy to read. At the tip, its horizontal part aims straight at the pin and has no arm. At the anchor, its vertical part runs straight down through the pin and has no arm.
Each way gives the same moment, so:
Summing forces gives and . So the pin pushes straight along the boom, and it's easy to conclude that pins on booms always do. They don't. That happened only because this boom is weightless and loaded at its two ends. Give it weight at its middle, or hang the load partway along, and the pin's force swings off the boom's line. Keep and as two unknowns, and let the equations say where it points.
A strut does the same job from below. It pushes along its line instead of pulling, and the moment equation doesn't care.
A post gives horizontal forces an arm
A sign post cast into a footing, or a bent bar built into a wall, is a cantilever with a bend in it. All three unknowns sit at the base, and each equation catches exactly one. As on a bent bar, the difference is the horizontal forces. On a straight cantilever, a load's horizontal part ran along the beam, through the wall. On a post, a horizontal force acts up high, so it has an arm, and it often supplies most of .
You've met the result already. Moments and Couples moved a load from the tip of a sign post's arm to its base, as a force and a couple. The base's reactions are that same force and couple turned around.
When the load is the unknown
Sometimes the reactions aren't what you're after. An L-shaped bar sits on one pin, with loads on both legs, and the question is where another load has to go, or how big it has to be, to hold the bar still. The pin stops both slides on its own, by adjusting and . All that's left to go wrong is turning, so the bar is in equilibrium when the moments about the pin add to zero.
Write and put a letter in for whatever you don't know. If the other loads add up to 300 lb·ft counterclockwise, and you're adding 75 lb on the side that turns the bar clockwise, then and from the pin. Get each load's sense first, because a sideways load on one leg usually fights the downward loads on the other, and that balance is what the problem is built on.
Hold it or lift it
Levers, hinged doors, and leaning ladders all turn about one point. Take moments there, and the force at the pivot disappears, leaving the force you need against the loads you've got. Lifting is just holding at the last instant, when the ground's push has dropped to zero, as at lift-off on a beam. The Handbook prints nothing on any of these, so they're yours to carry.
A lever is the plainest case: force times arm on one side, load times arm on the other. Push at a slant, and only the part of your push perpendicular to the bar counts.
A trapdoor or hinged gate carries its own weight , at its middle, straight down. So the weight's arm is the horizontal distance from the hinge to the middle, which shrinks as the door tilts up. Lift the far edge with a force straight up, and that arm shrinks by the same factor, so at any angle. A force in any other direction has its own arm to work out. Gates and Buoyancy takes moments about a hinge the same way, with water as the load.
A ladder is the same idea with one more contact. A smooth wall pushes normal to itself, which means horizontally, with no vertical grip at all. So all the weight comes down through the foot, and the foot acts like a pin: and . Moments about the foot leave only the wall's force, whose arm is the height of the contact, not the ladder's length. The ladder's own weight acts at its middle. What supplies ? Here, a stop at the foot. On a rough floor, it's friction, and Static Friction picks up from there.
Frames and Machines takes whole structures apart, and every piece it leaves on the table is a body like these.