Loads and Load Combinations

Design for the worst plausible mix of loads, each scaled by how uncertain it is.

A column holds up one floor and a roof. The building's own weight puts 100 kips on it, a packed floor could add 60, and the deepest snow the roof is likely to see could add another 80. What load do you design the column for?

Adding gives 240 kips, and that number has two problems. It treats a weight you can work out from the drawings as if it were as uncertain as a crowd. And it assumes the crowd and the blizzard show up on the same day. Fix both and you get a different number, which you'll have before this Lesson ends.

The loads and their names

Everything that pushes on a structure goes by a short symbol. The Handbook's section "Nominal Loads used in LRFD and ASD Load Combinations" lists seven.

L Lr S R D D W W E
Where each load acts on a building
The seven loads
SymbolLoadWhat it represents
DDDeadThe structure and anything fixed to it
LLLive (floor)People, furniture, movable contents
LrL_rLive (roof)Workers and equipment during maintenance
SSSnowSnow on the roof
RRRainRainwater collected on the roof
WWWindWind pressure, pushing in or lifting off
EEEarthquakeForces from the ground shaking

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Nominal Loads used in LRFD and ASD Load Combinations

The value a symbol stands for is a nominal load, also called a service load: the load before any factor touches it. Problems hand you these values, and Tributary Areas and Load Paths shows how they reach a particular beam or column. Multiply one by a factor and it's a factored load, which doesn't get a second factor.

These numbers don't all deserve the same trust. Dead load you can nearly calculate, because concrete weighs what it weighs. Live load is a bet on how people will use a building for fifty years.

Two ways to keep a margin

Every check in structural design has the same shape: demand versus capacity. Demand is what the loads ask of a member, and capacity is what the member can deliver. Both are estimates, and both can miss. Two methods build in a margin for that, and they differ in where they put it.

LRFD, Load and Resistance Factor Design, hedges on both sides. It marks each load up by its own load factor and marks the strength down with a resistance factor ϕ\phi below 1:

ϕRn≥Ru\phi R_n \ge R_u

RnR_n is the nominal strength, ϕRn\phi R_n the design strength, and RuR_u the factored demand, or required strength.

ASD, Allowable Stress Design, leaves the loads at service level and puts the whole margin on the strength, dividing by a safety factor Ω\Omega above 1:

RnΩ≥Ra\frac{R_n}{\Omega} \ge R_a

Rn/ΩR_n/\Omega is the allowable strength, and RaR_a is the demand from service loads.

LRFD 1.2D = 72 1.6L = 64 Ru = 136 φRn = 153 Rn = 170 ASD D = 60 L = 40 Ra = 100 Rn/Ω = 102 Rn = 170 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Moment (ft-kip)
One member, checked both ways
Service moments of 60 and 40 ft-kip against a nominal strength of 170 ft-kip, with ϕ=0.90\phi = 0.90 and Ω=1.67\Omega = 1.67, the Handbook's values for a steel beam in bending.

The practical difference is that LRFD can charge each load for its own uncertainty. ASD has one Ω\Omega, so a ton of concrete and a ton of crowd get the same margin.

Load factors cover loads that come in higher than assumed and simplifications in the analysis, which is why DD gets 1.2 and LL gets 1.6. Resistance factors cover the capacity side: material weaker than specified, dimensions a little undersized, strength formulas that are only so exact. A failure that comes suddenly gets a smaller ϕ\phi than one that gives warning.

Through the rest of the topic, uu marks factored demand (MuM_u, VuV_u, PuP_u) and nn marks nominal strength (MnM_n, VnV_n, PnP_n), and each design Lesson brings the ϕ\phi and Ω\Omega for its own ways of failing. The Handbook prints those values and the combinations below, and it spells out the check for concrete members. It never prints these two general forms or the reasoning behind them, so that part is yours to carry.

Strength and serviceability

A limit state is a condition in which a member stops doing its job. A strength limit state is about safety: the member can no longer carry the load, and something could come down. A serviceability limit state is about usefulness: everything stays up, but the building doesn't work as intended, like a door that jams because the beam above it sagged. Serviceability is checked under service loads with no factors, often the live load alone, because the question is how the building behaves on an ordinary day. Selecting Steel Beams runs that check.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

Which statement describes how LRFD differs from ASD?

A.
ASD has no margin of safety, because it uses unfactored loads and the full nominal strength.
B.
LRFD factors the loads and reduces the strength, and ASD keeps service loads and divides the strength by Ω.
C.
LRFD checks strength limit states, and ASD checks serviceability limit states under service loads.
D.
LRFD pairs service loads with a strength reduced by φ, and ASD pairs factored loads with a strength divided by Ω.

Loads don't peak together

Now the Hook's second problem. Designing for every load at its lifetime maximum, all at once, means designing for a day that never comes.

L at its peak S at its peak W at its peak D L S W 1.2D + 1.6L + 0.5S 1.2D + 1.6S + L 1.2D + 1.0W + L + 0.5S Time over the building's life
Loads over a building's life
A sketch, not data. At each load's peak, the others sit at ordinary values.

That picture is what a load combination describes: one load at its lifetime peak, with the others at the values likely to be present at that moment. Which moment is worst depends on the member, so you check them all, and the largest governs. The Handbook's LRFD section prints seven, and nominal loads go into all of them:

LRFD load combinations
CombinationAt its peak
1.4D1.4DDead load alone
1.2D+1.6L+0.5(Lr or S or R)1.2D + 1.6L + 0.5(L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R)Floor live load
1.2D+1.6(Lr or S or R)+(L or 0.5W)1.2D + 1.6(L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R) + (L \text{ or } 0.5W)Roof load
1.2D+1.0W+L+0.5(Lr or S or R)1.2D + 1.0W + L + 0.5(L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R)Wind
1.2D+1.0E+L+0.2S1.2D + 1.0E + L + 0.2SEarthquake
0.9D+1.0W0.9D + 1.0WWind, dead load resisting
0.9D+1.0E0.9D + 1.0EEarthquake, dead load resisting

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Load Combinations using Strength Design (LRFD)

Read the second line as a sentence. The floor is having its worst day, so LL gets 1.6. The roof is having an ordinary day, so it gets 0.5. Dead load is always there, at 1.2. The 1.4D1.4D line covers a member with almost nothing but dead load, and the 0.9D0.9D lines get their own section below.

The Handbook defines two pieces of shorthand: (Lr or S or R)(L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R) means the largest of the three, and (L or 0.5W)(L \text{ or } 0.5W) means the larger of the two. They're choices, not sums. To find the governing load, treat any load the problem doesn't mention as zero, run every line that could win, and take the largest.

Worked Example The governing LRFD load
1 of 3

A member carries nominal loads D=50D = 50 kips, L=30L = 30 kips, Lr=10L_r = 10 kips, and S=15S = 15 kips, with no wind or earthquake. Find the governing LRFD factored load.

The same factors work on moments and shears

Double the load on a linear structure and the moment doubles, along with the shear and the axial force. So it makes no difference whether you scale a load or the effect it produces, and the combinations work on either. Swap DD for the moment the dead load causes and LL for the moment the live load causes. With only those two loads, just two lines can govern, and the larger is the required strength:

Mu=larger of {1.4MD1.2MD+1.6MLM_u = \text{larger of } \begin{cases} 1.4M_D \\ 1.2M_D + 1.6M_L \end{cases}

Shears and axial forces work the same way, giving VuV_u and PuP_u.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A floor beam has service moments MD=120M_D = 120 ft-kip and ML=150M_L = 150 ft-kip. What is the required strength MuM_u?

ft-kip

When the snow takes over

Back to the Hook's column, which sees both a floor and a roof. Two lines take turns here: 1.2D+1.6L+0.5S1.2D + 1.6L + 0.5S has the floor at its peak, and 1.2D+1.6S+L1.2D + 1.6S + L has the snow at its peak. They share 1.2D1.2D, so dead load has no say in which one wins. The snow line wins when

1.6S+L>1.6L+0.5S⇒1.1S>0.6L⇒S>0.545L1.6S + L > 1.6L + 0.5S \quad\Rightarrow\quad 1.1S > 0.6L \quad\Rightarrow\quad S > 0.545L

So the snow doesn't have to outweigh the floor. It takes over at about 0.55L0.55L, little more than half the floor live load.

0 20 40 60 80 100 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 Pu (kips) S (kips) S ≈ 33 kips 1.2D + 1.6S + L 1.2D + 1.6L + 0.5S 1.4D
Which combination governs as the snow load grows
A column with D=100D = 100 kips and L=60L = 60 kips. Past S≈33S \approx 33 kips, which is about 0.55L0.55L, the snow line governs. 1.4D1.4D sits well below both.
Worked Example The column from the Hook
1 of 3

A column supports a floor and the roof, with nominal axial loads D=100D = 100 kips, L=60L = 60 kips, and S=80S = 80 kips. Find the governing LRFD axial load PuP_u.

When dead load helps

So far every load has pushed the same way, and more load has meant more trouble. Wind breaks that. Air moving over a roof can suck upward on it, the way a wing gets lift. Now dead load is what holds the roof down, and the danger is that there's less of it than you thought.

So the cautious estimate flips. Where dead load adds to the demand, it gets 1.2. Where it resists, it gets 0.9, because you can only count on what's surely there. The line 0.9D+1.0E0.9D + 1.0E uses the same reasoning.

Wind pushing down D W 1.2D + 1.0W largest compression Wind lifting D W 0.9D + 1.0W largest net uplift
The same roof member under wind in each direction

Wind can push either way, so problems often write it as ±W\pm W, and two checks follow. For the largest compression, wind pushes down alongside the dead load. For the net uplift, wind lifts against it, so you subtract. Wind keeps a factor of 1.0 in both because WW is already written at the level of a rare storm, so its peak is built in.

Worked Example Compression and uplift on a light roof column
1 of 3

A light roof column has a nominal dead load of D=20D = 20 kips in compression and a wind effect of W=±35W = \pm 35 kips, with no other loads. Find the maximum factored compression and the net uplift.

The ASD side

ASD runs the same idea with service loads, so a load at its peak simply carries no factor. The Handbook's ASD section prints nine lines, with (Lr or S or R)(L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R) again meaning the largest:

ASD load combinations
CombinationAt its peak
DDDead load alone
D+LD + LFloor live load
D+(Lr or S or R)D + (L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R)Roof load
D+0.75L+0.75(Lr or S or R)D + 0.75L + 0.75(L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R)Floor and roof together
D+(0.6W or 0.7E)D + (0.6W \text{ or } 0.7E)Wind or earthquake
D+0.75L+0.75(0.6W)+0.75(Lr or S or R)D + 0.75L + 0.75(0.6W) + 0.75(L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R)Floor, wind, and roof
D+0.75L+0.75(0.7E)+0.75SD + 0.75L + 0.75(0.7E) + 0.75SFloor, earthquake, and snow
0.6D+0.6W0.6D + 0.6WWind, dead load resisting
0.6D+0.7E0.6D + 0.7EEarthquake, dead load resisting

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Load Combinations using Allowable Stress Design (ASD)

When two variable loads share a line, each gets 0.75: the same "they won't both peak" logic in a different form. That line beats either load at full value whenever the smaller load is more than a third of the larger. WW and EE are the exception to nominal meaning service: they're written at a strength level, which LRFD takes at 1.0 and ASD scales back to service level with 0.6 and 0.7.

Worked Example The governing ASD load
1 of 3

A member supports nominal loads D=30D = 30 kips, L=40L = 40 kips, and S=25S = 25 kips. Find the governing ASD load.

Reading the combinations at a glance

Some questions ask which combination governs without asking you to run them. You already have two of the tests: the snow line takes over when S>0.55LS > 0.55L, and uplift is about how little dead load you can count on. Here's a third. With only DD and LL, 1.4D1.4D beats 1.2D+1.6L1.2D + 1.6L when 0.2D>1.6L0.2D > 1.6L, which is when D>8LD > 8L.

To tell the methods apart, look at the dead load. A factor of 1.4, 1.2, or 0.9 on DD means LRFD. A plain DD or 0.6D0.6D means ASD.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

A problem describes the load from a reroofing crew and their equipment. Which symbol does it use?

A.
LL
B.
DD
C.
RR
D.
LrL_r

Recap

  • LRFD checks ϕRn≥Ru\phi R_n \ge R_u: factored loads against reduced strength. ASD checks Rn/Ω≥RaR_n/\Omega \ge R_a: service loads against strength divided by one safety factor.
  • Load factors scale each load by its uncertainty, and resistance factors cover shortfalls in capacity. Both guard strength limit states. Serviceability limit states are checked under service loads with no factors.
  • Each combination puts one load at its peak with the others at ordinary values, so check them all, and the largest governs. (Lr or S or R)(L_r \text{ or } S \text{ or } R) means the largest of the three, never their sum.
  • Watch for 1.4D1.4D when dead load dominates (D>8LD > 8L, with only DD and LL), the snow line when S>0.55LS > 0.55L, and 0.9D+1.0W0.9D + 1.0W for uplift.
  • The same factors apply to moments, shears, and axial forces, and a factored number never gets factored again.