BOD Kinetics

BOD is exerted fast at first and then ever more slowly, like a cooling cup of coffee.

Before this Lesson

A lab hands you a wastewater's BOD5\mathrm{BOD}_5: 200 mg/L. That's the oxygen the bacteria used by day five, which is when the test stopped. Nobody told the bacteria. They keep eating for weeks, in the bottle or in a river.

So how much oxygen will this waste take in the end, and how quickly? One more number answers both: how fast the bacteria eat.

The same fraction every day

Bacteria eat what they can find. Plenty of food means plenty of eating, and as the food runs short, the eating slows. The simplest version of that idea says the rate of eating is proportional to the food still left. Call that LL, the BOD remaining: the oxygen the bacteria have yet to use.

dLdt=−kL\frac{dL}{dt} = -kL

That's first-order kinetics, and it means the same fraction disappears every day. Take k=0.23k = 0.23 per day, a common value for sewage at 20°C. Each day multiplies LL by e−0.23=0.79e^{-0.23} = 0.79, so about a fifth of whatever's left goes. Starting from 300 mg/L, that's 62 mg/L on the first day, then 49, then 39. Same fraction, smaller bites. Coffee cools the same way, losing heat in proportion to how far it still sits above room temperature. Starting from the ultimate BOD, L0L_0, the BOD remaining decays exponentially:

Lt=L0e−ktL_t = L_0 e^{-kt}

Every bit of food eaten is oxygen used, so the BOD exerted is whatever no longer remains, L0−LtL_0 - L_t. That gives the equation in the Handbook's BOD Exertion section:

BODt=L0(1−e−kt)\mathrm{BOD}_t = L_0 \left(1 - e^{-kt}\right)

The Handbook calls kk the BOD decay rate constant, in base ee per day, and writes the ultimate BOD with a small letter o, LoL_o. It prints no typical kk, so a problem has to give you one.

0 5 10 15 20 0 100 200 300 Time (days) BOD (mg/L) L0 = 300 mg/L Half exerted, day 3 205 95 Day 5 BOD exerted, BODt BOD remaining, Lt
BOD remaining and BOD exerted for L₀ = 300 mg/L and k = 0.23 per day
The two curves add up to L0L_0 at every moment. On day 5, that's 205 + 95 = 300 mg/L.

Look at the rising curve. It climbs quickly, then ever more slowly toward L0L_0. At this kk, day 5 is only about 68% of the way up. So the lab's 200 mg/L from the opening isn't the whole bill.

Worked Example The rest of the bill
1 of 3

A wastewater has a BOD5\mathrm{BOD}_5 of 200 mg/L and k=0.23k = 0.23 per day. Find its ultimate BOD.

What's left, and constants in base 10

Problems also ask for the falling curve: how much BOD remains after tt days. The Handbook prints only the exerted form, so either use Lt=L0e−ktL_t = L_0 e^{-kt} or subtract the exerted BOD from L0L_0. Read the question's word carefully.

Watch the base, too. Some references state a base-10 constant, written with a capital KK:

Lt=L0⋅10−KtL_t = L_0 \cdot 10^{-Kt}

It's the same curve in a different base. Since 10=e2.30310 = e^{2.303}, the exponent just picks up that factor:

k=2.303 Kk = 2.303\,K

So the common k=0.23k = 0.23 per day is K=0.10K = 0.10 per day. The Handbook has only the base-ee form, so a constant labeled base 10 is your cue to convert before it goes anywhere near an ee. Skip that, and the bacteria look 2.3 times slower than they are.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A wastewater has an ultimate BOD of 220 mg/L and k=0.30k = 0.30 per day, base ee. How much BOD remains after 4 days?

mg/L

Warm bacteria, same food

Warm a bottle and the bacteria eat faster. They don't get any more to eat. So temperature changes kk and never L0L_0. The Handbook's Kinetic Temperature Corrections section adjusts kk from the standard test's 20°C to temperature TT:

kT=k20 θ T−20k_T = k_{20}\,\theta^{\,T - 20}

Each degree multiplies kk by θ\theta, so the correction compounds. At 20°C the exponent is zero and nothing changes. Below 20°C the exponent is negative and kk shrinks.

Temperature coefficients for the BOD rate constant
Temperatureθ
4–20°C1.135
21–30°C1.056

Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Kinetic Temperature Corrections

BOD gets two values, so check which side of 20°C you're on before you pick one. When a problem states its own θ\theta, such as 1.047, use that.

Worked Example The same waste on a warmer day
1 of 3

A wastewater has L0=300L_0 = 300 mg/L and k20=0.23k_{20} = 0.23 per day. Using the Handbook's θ\theta, find the BOD it exerts in 5 days at 25°C.

Running the clock backward

Sometimes the unknown is kk or tt, stuck up in the exponent. Divide the exertion equation by L0L_0. The ratio BODt/L0\mathrm{BOD}_t / L_0 is the fraction exerted; call it ff. Then get the exponential alone and take the natural log:

f=1−e−kt⇒kt=−ln⁡(1−f)f = 1 - e^{-kt} \quad \Rightarrow \quad kt = -\ln(1 - f)

Notice that L0L_0 is gone. How long it takes to exert a given fraction depends only on kk. For half, kt=ln⁡2kt = \ln 2 and t=0.693/kt = 0.693/k, the half-life the Handbook prints in its Radiation section for a biologically degraded contaminant. At k=0.23k = 0.23 per day, that's 3 days, where the two curves crossed in the earlier figure.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A wastewater has a BOD5\mathrm{BOD}_5 of 160 mg/L and an ultimate BOD of 240 mg/L. What is its base-ee rate constant?

per day

Speed versus food

Two numbers set the whole curve, and they do different jobs. kk is how fast the bacteria eat, which sets how quickly the curve closes in on its ceiling. L0L_0 is how much food there is, which sets how high that ceiling is. A BOD5\mathrm{BOD}_5 reading depends on both, because it's a snapshot taken partway up.

A long test shows one more feature. Everything so far is carbonaceous demand. As Oxygen Demand noted, nitrifying bacteria also breathe oxygen as they turn ammonia into nitrate, and they grow slowly. In raw sewage they often get going only after a week or so, so a curve that looks ready to level off picks up a second rise. The L0L_0 and kk in this Lesson describe the first stage alone. The Handbook prints nothing on the second stage, and doesn't draw this curve.

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Time (days) BOD exerted BOD5 Carbonaceous stage Nitrogenous stage L0
BOD exerted over a 30-day test on raw sewage
The nitrogenous rise starts after day 5, so BOD5\mathrm{BOD}_5 misses it. The start day varies from one sewage to another.
Checkpoint
1 of 2

Two bottles of the same wastewater incubate side by side, one at 20°C and one at 30°C. Which plot shows their carbonaceous BOD curves?

A.
0 5 10 15 20 Days BOD exerted 20°C 30°C
B.
0 5 10 15 20 Days BOD exerted 20°C 30°C
C.
0 5 10 15 20 Days BOD exerted 20°C 30°C
D.
0 5 10 15 20 Days BOD exerted 20°C 30°C

Mix first, then decay

So far the bacteria have sat in a bottle. Now let the bottle float down a river. Follow one parcel of water from the outfall. The bacteria in it don't know they're moving, so the same decay runs, and the clock reads the parcel's travel time: distance xx over velocity vv.

t=xvt = \frac{x}{v}

That time has to be in days to match kk, which in U.S. units takes 5,280 ft per mile and 86,400 sec per day.

Write the balance first. The parcel's starting BOD is the fully mixed value just below the outfall, the same balance as in Mixing and Mass Loading:

L0=Q1L1+Q2L2Q1+Q2L_0 = \frac{Q_1 L_1 + Q_2 L_2}{Q_1 + Q_2}

So the order is: mix, turn distance into days, decay. The effluent's clock starts at the outfall, and from there the river's BOD and the effluent's decay together, as one mixed value.

River: Q1, L1 Effluent: Q2, L2 Downstream point x Outfall Distance downstream BOD L1 Fully mixed, L0 Lt at t = x/v Lt = L0 e−kt
BOD along a river, above and below an outfall
BOD jumps where the streams mix, then decays with travel time.
Worked Example Fifteen miles below the outfall
1 of 3

A river carries 40 cfs with an ultimate BOD of 3 mg/L. A plant adds 10 cfs of effluent with an ultimate BOD of 33 mg/L. The river flows at 0.8 ft/sec, and k=0.25k = 0.25 per day. Find the BOD remaining 15 miles below the outfall.

The oxygen sag

BOD is the threat, but dissolved oxygen is what the fish feel. Follow the same parcel and watch its DO. Two things change it at once:

  • Bacteria pull oxygen out, at a rate proportional to the BOD left, kdLk_d L. The Handbook writes kdk_d for this deoxygenation rate constant, the river's version of kk.
  • Air puts oxygen back, at a rate proportional to the deficit DD, how far the water sits below saturation, krDk_r D. The emptier the water, the faster it takes oxygen in.

Just below the outfall, BOD is at its highest and the deficit is still small. The bacteria win, and DO falls. But that changes both rates. BOD is being eaten, so the bacteria's pull weakens. The deficit is growing, so the air's pull strengthens. Eventually they match, and at that moment DO stops falling. That's the low point, called the critical point. Beyond it the air pulls ahead and the river slowly recovers.

0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10 Travel time below the outfall (days) DO (mg/L) Saturation, DOsat Deficit, D Critical point: minimum DO DO falls outpace air: Bacteria DO recovers Air outpaces bacteria:
The oxygen sag below an outfall
DO falls until the two rates match, and that happens well below the outfall, not at it.

The Handbook's Stream Modeling section prints the Streeter Phelps equations behind this curve, including DO=DOsat−D\mathrm{DO} = \mathrm{DO}_{\text{sat}} - D, though it doesn't draw the curve. This Lesson doesn't compute with them. To read the curve, you only need the two rates.

So to predict how the sag moves, ask what a change does to each rate. For temperature, two more facts help. In the Handbook's Kinetic Temperature Corrections, the θ\theta for BOD above 20°C, 1.056, beats the 1.024 for reaeration. And warm water holds less oxygen: about 9.1 mg/L at 20°C against 7.6 mg/L at 30°C. The Handbook prints no saturation table, so a problem would supply those values.

Checkpoint
1 of 4

Four days of travel below an outfall, bacteria are using 1.8 mg/L of oxygen per day and the air is returning 2.6 mg/L per day. Where is this point on the sag, and what is its DO doing?

A.
Upstream of the critical point, with DO falling
B.
At the critical point, with DO at its minimum
C.
Downstream of the critical point, with DO rising
D.
Downstream of the critical point, with DO falling
Heavier BOD load 0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10 Travel time (days) DO (mg/L) Deeper, slightly later Warmer water, 30°C 0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10 Travel time (days) DOsat, 20°C DOsat, 30°C Deeper, sooner Faster reaeration 0 2 4 6 8 10 0 2 4 6 8 10 Travel time (days) Shallower, sooner Dashed: base case Solid: changed case
How each change moves the sag
In each panel, the dashed curve is the same base case. A heavier load deepens the sag and shifts it slightly downstream. Warmer water deepens it and pulls it closer to the outfall. Faster reaeration makes it shallower and closer.

Recap

  • First-order means the same fraction goes every day. BOD remaining is Lt=L0e−ktL_t = L_0 e^{-kt}, BOD exerted is BODt=L0(1−e−kt)\mathrm{BOD}_t = L_0(1 - e^{-kt}), and they always add up to L0L_0.
  • Convert a base-10 constant with k=2.303 Kk = 2.303\,K. To find kk or tt, use kt=−ln⁡(1−f)kt = -\ln(1 - f), where ff is the fraction exerted.
  • kk sets how quickly the curve closes in on its ceiling, and L0L_0 sets how high that ceiling is. Temperature changes only kk: kT=k20 θ T−20k_T = k_{20}\,\theta^{\,T - 20}, with the Handbook's θ\theta of 1.135 for 4–20°C and 1.056 for 21–30°C. Nitrogenous demand adds a later second rise.
  • Down a river: mix at the outfall, turn distance into days with t=x/vt = x/v, then decay the mixed BOD.
  • DO is lowest at the critical point, where the bacteria's take equals the air's return. A heavier load deepens the sag and shifts it slightly downstream, warmer water deepens it and pulls it closer, and faster reaeration makes it shallower and closer.