Mixing and Mass Loading

Mass adds at a confluence; concentrations don't.

A treatment plant discharges effluent carrying 200 mg/L of chloride into a river carrying 20 mg/L. What's the chloride just downstream? Halfway, 110 mg/L, is the number most people's gut offers. Now make the outfall a garden hose and the river the Mississippi, and nobody believes 110. Flow has to count somehow, and how it counts is this whole Lesson.

Count the mass, not the concentration

Try it with buckets. Pour 1 liter of water at 200 mg/L into 9 liters at 20 mg/L. A concentration only says how much stuff is in each liter, so count what you actually have. The small pour holds 200 mg. The big one holds 9×20=1809 \times 20 = 180 mg. That's 380 mg spread through 10 liters, or 38 mg/L, nowhere near 110. The bigger bucket pulled the answer toward its own value because it brought more liters.

A river is those buckets running continuously. A flow QQ delivers volume every second, and each unit of volume carries CC of mass, so the product QCQC is a mass flow: mass passing per unit of time. Where two streams meet, nothing is created or lost, so mass flows add. Call the river stream 1 and the effluent stream 2, and write the balance first:

Q1C1+Q2C2=(Q1+Q2) CQ_1 C_1 + Q_2 C_2 = (Q_1 + Q_2)\,C
River Q1, C1 Effluent Q2, C2 Fully mixed Q1 + Q2, C Mass in = mass out
A balance around the point where an outfall meets a river
The dots stand for dissolved mass, and how crowded they are is the concentration. Mass flow is how many dots cross the dashed line each second.

Solve it for the mixed concentration:

C=Q1C1+Q2C2Q1+Q2C = \frac{Q_1 C_1 + Q_2 C_2}{Q_1 + Q_2}

If the opening river carries nine times the outfall's flow, this is the bucket calculation again, and the chloride below the outfall is 38 mg/L.

You won't find this formula written out in the Handbook. Its Mass Calculations section prints the general balance instead, with MM for mass and rr for a reaction rate:

dMdt=dMindt−dMoutdt±rV\frac{dM}{dt} = \frac{dM_{\text{in}}}{dt} - \frac{dM_{\text{out}}}{dt} \pm rV

Each mass flow there is CQCQ. In steady flow nothing accumulates, so dM/dt=0dM/dt = 0, and in the short stretch where the streams mix nothing has time to react, so rV=0rV = 0. Mass in equals mass out, and with two streams coming in, that's the balance we started with.

A few things make this easy to use:

  • Match the flow units. The flows appear on the top and the bottom, so any unit works as long as both streams use it. A river in cfs and an outfall in MGD need one conversion first.
  • It works for anything that just mixes. Chloride is a conservative substance: nothing in a river consumes it. Dissolved oxygen (DO) and biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), a measure of organic waste that Oxygen Demand covers, do change, but over days. So the balance still holds at the outfall, and BOD Kinetics picks up from there.
  • Temperature mixes the same way. Heat takes the place of mass, and because both streams are water, density and specific heat cancel on the top and the bottom. Put degrees where the concentrations go.
  • "Fully mixed" is a convenience. Real effluent hugs the bank for a while before it spreads across the channel. The phrase means you skip that stretch and take the river after it's over.
Worked Example BOD just below an outfall
1 of 3

A river carries 50 cfs with a BOD of 2 mg/L. A treatment plant discharges 10 MGD of effluent with a BOD of 25 mg/L. Find the fully mixed BOD just below the outfall.

Run the balance backward

A permit writer asks the reverse question: how strong, or how large, can this discharge be and still keep the river within a limit? It's the same balance, with the limit in the place of CC and the unknown moved.

Think of the limit as a budget. At the limit, the combined flow carries a mass flow of (Q1+Q2)Climit(Q_1 + Q_2)C_{\text{limit}} and no more. The river spends its share, Q1C1Q_1 C_1, before the plant adds anything. Whatever's left is the effluent's allowance:

Q2C2=(Q1+Q2) Climit−Q1C1Q_2 C_2 = (Q_1 + Q_2)\,C_{\text{limit}} - Q_1 C_1
Mass flow the limit allows: (Q1 + Q2) Climit River's share: Q1 C1 Left for the effluent: Q2 C2
The limit sets the budget, and the river spends first

To find the largest effluent concentration, divide by Q2Q_2. The largest effluent flow takes one more step, because Q2Q_2 shows up on both sides. Gather its terms and you get:

Q1 (Climit−C1)=Q2 (C2−Climit)Q_1\,(C_{\text{limit}} - C_1) = Q_2\,(C_2 - C_{\text{limit}})

This form reads nicely. The left side is the river's spare room: how far below the limit it runs, times its flow. The right side is the effluent's excess: how far above the limit it runs, times its flow. The room has to cover the excess.

Worked Example The strongest effluent a river can take
1 of 3

A river carries 40 cfs with a BOD of 2 mg/L. A plant discharges 10 cfs, and the mixed BOD must stay at or below 8 mg/L. Find the largest effluent BOD.

See the answer without arithmetic

That spare-room equation holds for any mix, not just one at a limit: Q1(C−C1)=Q2(C2−C)Q_1(C - C_1) = Q_2(C_2 - C). It's also the condition for a seesaw to balance. Lay concentration out along a beam, set each stream on it at its own concentration, and give each a weight equal to its flow. The mixed concentration is the pivot point where the beam balances.

0 4 8 12 16 20 24 Concentration (mg/L) C = 4 mg/L River 90 cfs at 2 mg/L Effluent 10 cfs at 22 mg/L
A 90 cfs river and a 10 cfs outfall balance at 4 mg/L
Each side of the balance is the same: (90)(4−2)=(10)(22−4)=180(90)(4 - 2) = (10)(22 - 4) = 180.

You can read two facts off this with no numbers at all. The mix always lands between the two concentrations, never outside them. And it lands closer to the stream with more flow. Only equal flows put it halfway, which is the one case where the gut answer is right.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

In a drought, the river in that figure falls from 90 cfs to 30 cfs. The plant keeps discharging 10 cfs at 22 mg/L, and the river stays at 2 mg/L. What happens to the mixed concentration?

A.
It stays at 4 mg/L, because the plant still adds the same mass flow.
B.
It rises, because the plant's mass flow goes into less water.
C.
It falls, because the river now brings less mass.
D.
It triples to 12 mg/L, because the river's flow fell to a third.

Where 8.34 comes from

So far the product QCQC has come out in an awkward unit, cfs·mg/L, and that hasn't mattered because a division got rid of it. Often, though, the mass flow itself is the answer: how many pounds of BOD reach a plant each day, or how much chlorine to feed. Then you want real units, which in American practice means lb/day.

Water hands you the factor. The Handbook's Commonly Used Equivalents say a gallon of water weighs 8.34 lb, so a million gallons weighs 8.34 million lb. A liter of water has a mass of a million milligrams, so 1 mg/L is one part per million by weight. One part per million of 8.34 million lb is 8.34 lb. So 1 MGD at 1 mg/L moves 8.34 lb/day, and everything else is proportion. The Handbook's Mass Calculations section prints it this way:

M (lb/day)=C (mg/L)×Q (MGD)×8.34M\ (\text{lb/day}) = C\ (\text{mg/L}) \times Q\ (\text{MGD}) \times 8.34

That's QCQC with the units sorted out. The factor only works for mg/L and MGD, so a flow in gpm or cfs gets converted to MGD first.

SI is simpler, because 1 mg/L is exactly 1 g/m³. So mg/L times m³/day is g/day, and dividing by 1,000 gives kg/day. The Handbook prints only the lb/day form, so this one is yours to carry:

M (kg/day)=C (mg/L)×Q (m3/day)1,000M\ (\text{kg/day}) = \frac{C\ (\text{mg/L}) \times Q\ (\text{m}^3\text{/day})}{1{,}000}

As with MGD, get the flow into the right unit first: a flow in m³/s gets multiplied by 86,400 s/day.

A chemical feed rate is the same multiplication, with the dose playing the part of CC. One catch: read what the dose refers to. A dose stated for the pure chemical gives pounds of pure chemical, but what's in the drum may be only partly active. If half of the product is active, you need twice the pounds, so divide by the active fraction. A dose already stated for the product as delivered needs no division. The Handbook doesn't cover this, so the problem has to give you the strength.

Worked Example A plant's influent BOD load
1 of 4

A plant receives 5,000 gpm of raw wastewater with a BOD of 220 mg/L. Find the BOD load in lb/day.

Recap

  • Concentrations don't add, but masses do. Flow times concentration is a mass flow, and mass flows add at a confluence.
  • The fully mixed concentration is C=(Q1C1+Q2C2)/(Q1+Q2)C = (Q_1 C_1 + Q_2 C_2)/(Q_1 + Q_2), with both flows in the same unit. BOD, DO, chloride, and temperature all mix this way.
  • A limit sets a mass budget. The river spends its share first, and the effluent gets what's left.
  • The mix lands between the two concentrations, closer to the larger flow, so a drought slides it toward the effluent.
  • A mass load is C×Q×8.34C \times Q \times 8.34 in lb/day with mg/L and MGD, or C×Q/1,000C \times Q / 1{,}000 in kg/day with mg/L and m³/day. For a dose stated as pure chemical, divide by the strength to get the product as delivered.