Sizing Treatment Units

Treatment units are sized by how fast water passes through them, not by how big they look.

Before this Lesson

Picture a clarifier: a round concrete tank about a hundred feet across, its surface as still as glass. Water wells up at the center, drifts outward, and slips over a weir around the rim, while whatever it carried sinks to the floor. It never stops, because a city sends its water day and night.

Now send twice the flow through the same tank. Not a yard of concrete changes, but the water stays half as long, rises twice as fast, and pours over each foot of weir twice as hard. Those three numbers are how a treatment unit is judged.

One flow, three dimensions

Here's that clarifier cut in half. Water enters at the center, inside a short ring called the feed well, spreads outward and upward, and leaves over the weir into a trough around the rim, the launder.

Feed well Weir Launder Inlet Sludge D h Surface area A = πD2/4 Weir length = πD
A circular clarifier in section and in plan
The water rises through the whole surface to reach the weir, which runs the full circumference.

Three dimensions decide how well the tank treats the water passing through it: its volume, its surface area, and its weir length. Each one, compared with the flow QQ, gives one rate.

Volume sets how long the water stays. A 60-gallon bathtub with its tap and drain both running at 3 gpm turns over every 20 minutes, so a drop spends 20 minutes in it on average. That's the detention time, which the Handbook's Clarifier section calls the hydraulic residence time:

θ=VQ\theta = \frac{V}{Q}

Gallons over gallons per day gives days, so multiply by 24 for hours.

Surface area sets how fast the water rises. The water enters low and leaves at the top, so every gallon has to climb up through the tank's plan area to get out. Spread the flow over that area, and you get the speed of the climb, the Handbook's overflow rate, or hydraulic loading rate:

vo=QAv_o = \frac{Q}{A}

AA is the plan area, LWLW or πD2/4\pi D^2/4. It isn't the volume, and it isn't the cross-section, width times depth, which gives the Handbook's horizontal velocity instead. The units, gpd/ft² or m³/m²·d, are really a speed: the SI unit cancels to m/d, and 800 gpd/ft² is 800/7.481=107800/7.481 = 107 ft/day. Settling and Particle Removal shows why that speed decides which particles a basin catches, even in a rectangular basin where the water travels mostly sideways.

Weir length sets how fast the water leaves. Crowd too much flow over each foot of weir, and the water speeds up near the rim and drags light solids out with it. The Handbook's weir loading, or weir overflow rate, is:

WOR=Qweir length\text{WOR} = \frac{Q}{\text{weir length}}

A weir around a circular rim is πD\pi D long. The Handbook's criteria cap the WOR at 20,000 gpd/ft in water treatment. In wastewater, the cap is 10,000 gpd/ft for a plant of 1 MGD or less, and 15,000 gpd/ft above that.

A filter's rate works the same way: the flow over the bed's plan area, which the Handbook's Filtration Equations call the filtration rate. It's usually given per minute rather than per day, so 1,400 gpm through a 20 ft by 25 ft filter is 1,400/500=2.81{,}400/500 = 2.8 gpm/ft².

Worked Example Rating a circular clarifier
1 of 4

A circular primary clarifier at a wastewater plant is 60 ft in diameter, holds water 11 ft deep, and treats 2.5 MGD over a weir around its rim. Find its overflow rate, detention time, and weir loading.

Running the divisions backward

Design runs the divisions backward. The flow is known, and criteria say what rates to aim for. The Handbook's Design Criteria for Sedimentation Basins lists them by type of basin. Here are four of its rows.

Design criteria for four kinds of sedimentation basin
Type of basinAverage overflow, gpd/ft² (m³/m²·d)Peak overflow, gpd/ft² (m³/m²·d)Residence time (hr)Depth (ft)
Water: after alum coagulation350–550 (14–22)—4–812–16
Water: after ferric coagulation550–700 (22–28)—4–812–16
Wastewater: primary800–1,200 (32–49)1,200–2,000 (50–80)210–12
Wastewater: after activated sludge400–700 (16–28)1,000–1,200 (40–64)212–15

Source: FE Reference Handbook, Design Criteria for Sedimentation Basins, selected rows and columns

Primary clarifiers settle raw sewage, and those after activated sludge settle the bacteria it grows. The last row leaves out the Handbook's lower rates for extended aeration. Sizing takes three moves:

  1. Area: A=Q/voA = Q/v_o. When several basins share the flow, each gets Q/nQ/n. When the table gives a peak rate too, find the area for each flow and keep the larger.
  2. Diameter or count: D=4A/πD = \sqrt{4A/\pi}. The Handbook allows circular tanks up to 200 ft across, and a problem may set a smaller limit. If one tank can't supply the area, divide by one tank's area and round up.
  3. Depth: with V=AhV = Ah, θ=Ah/Q=h/vo\theta = Ah/Q = h/v_o, so:
h=vo θh = v_o\,\theta

Water rising at vov_o for a time θ\theta climbs the whole depth. Put vov_o in ft/day first, by dividing gpd/ft² by 7.481, and θ\theta in days. A higher overflow rate means a smaller tank, so the smallest area that meets the criteria comes from the top of the range.

Worked Example Sizing primary clarifiers
1 of 4

A wastewater plant needs primary clarifiers for 12 MGD, at an overflow rate of 1,000 gpd/ft² and a detention time of 2 hr. The circular tanks can be at most 100 ft in diameter. How many tanks does it need, and what diameter and depth?

Making small particles settle

Some particles are too small for any clarifier. Clay and many bacteria come in particles a micron across or smaller, and a 1-micron clay particle would take over a month to sink the depth of a tank. Worse, most carry a negative surface charge, so they repel each other and never clump. The fix takes two steps.

Coagulation destabilizes the particles. A coagulant, usually alum (aluminum sulfate) or ferric chloride, is churned through the water in a rapid mix, within seconds. It works in two main ways:

  • Charge neutralization: positively charged aluminum or iron species stick to the particles and cancel their negative charge, so nothing keeps them apart.
  • Sweep floc: at higher doses, the coagulant precipitates as a solid hydroxide, Al(OH)3\mathrm{Al(OH)_3} or Fe(OH)3\mathrm{Fe(OH)_3} in the Handbook's Coagulation Equations, which traps particles as it forms, like a net dragged through the water.

Flocculation grows the floc. Destabilized particles stick when they touch, but first they have to touch, so a flocculation basin stirs gently for 20 to 40 minutes. Stir too hard and the floc tears apart. Stir too gently and the particles rarely meet.

Stable Like charges repel Coagulation coagulant, rapid mix seconds Destabilized Charges neutralized Flocculation slow mix 20–40 min Floc Large enough to settle
Stable particles, destabilized particles, and floc
Coagulation changes the particles' charge in seconds. Flocculation changes their size over many minutes.

The right dose depends on the water, and above all on its pH. The Handbook's chart, Typical Operating Ranges for Coagulation with Alum and Ferric Chloride, maps which mechanism works at which dose and pH. It even marks a restabilization zone, where so much coagulant sticks to the particles that their charge flips and they repel again. No formula gives the dose for one river on one day.

So operators ask the water. A jar test doses a row of jars of raw water differently and runs them all through a rapid mix, a slow mix, and a settle, a plant in miniature on a lab bench. Then it compares how cloudy each jar ends up. Its job is chiefly to find the best coagulant dose and pH.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A jar test doses six jars of river water with alum at 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, and 30 mg/L. After settling, their turbidities are 8.1, 3.2, 0.9, 1.0, 1.6, and 3.4 NTU. What dose should the plant use?

A.
30 mg/L, the largest dose tested
B.
Any dose of 15 mg/L or more, since extra coagulant can only help
C.
15 mg/L
D.
5 mg/L, the least chemical

How hard to stir

What makes particles collide isn't the water's speed. Water sliding along as one block would carry its particles side by side forever. Collisions come from a faster layer carrying its particles into a slower neighbor's, which is a velocity gradient, the same dv/dydv/dy that sets viscous stress.

Mixers are rated by power, so connect the two. Call the film's gradient G=v/δG = v/\delta. Dragging the plate takes power P=Fv=τAvP = Fv = \tau A v, and the film's volume is AδA\delta, so:

PV=τAvAδ=τG=μG2\frac{P}{V} = \frac{\tau A v}{A \delta} = \tau G = \mu G^2

Every watt a mixer puts in ends up as internal friction, μG2\mu G^2 per unit volume. Turn that around, and the power gives the gradient. A real tank's gradient varies from place to place, so the Handbook's Rapid Mix and Flocculator Design calls this the root mean square velocity gradient:

G=PμVG = \sqrt{\frac{P}{\mu V}}

PP is the power delivered to the water. Use watts, Pa·s, and m³, or ft-lbf/sec (1 hp = 550 ft-lbf/sec), lbf-sec/ft² from the water table, and ft³. Either way, GG comes out in s⁻¹, but only with the dynamic viscosity μ\mu, not ν\nu.

GG sets how often particles collide, and the time in the basin sets for how long, so the Handbook's target is a product, Gt=104Gt = 10^4 to 10510^5, with tt the detention time V/QV/Q in seconds. Typical practice, which the Handbook doesn't print, runs a rapid mix at several hundred to about 1,000 s⁻¹ for under a minute, and a flocculator at a few tens of s⁻¹ for 20 to 40 minutes.

Worked Example The velocity gradient in a flocculator
1 of 3

A flocculation basin holds 1,200 m³ of water at 20°C and treats 0.60 m³/s. Its paddles deliver 2.0 kW to the water. Find GG and GtGt.

The treatment train

Now put the units in order. Every plant follows the same logic: take out the big, easy things first, with screens and gravity, then use chemistry or bacteria on what's left, and disinfect last, on the cleanest water, since particles shield microbes and organic matter uses up chlorine. The Handbook draws neither train, so these come from standard practice.

Watertreatment Rawwater Rapid mix destabilizes particles Flocculation grows floc Sedimentation settles floc Filtration fine floc and particles Disinfection pathogens To mains Wastewatertreatment Rawsewage Bar screen rags and debris Gritchamber sand and gravel Primaryclarifier settleable solids Aerationbasin dissolved BOD Secondaryclarifier settles the bacteria Disinfection pathogens To river
Conventional water and wastewater treatment trains
Each unit, in order of flow, with the main thing it's there to do. The highlighted units are the ones this Lesson sizes.

A water plant coagulates, flocculates, and settles. Its filters then catch the fine floc that didn't settle, along with many pathogens, and disinfection takes the rest.

In a wastewater plant, the bar screen catches rags that would jam pumps, and the grit chamber settles sand that would wear out everything downstream. The primary clarifier settles organic solids: by the Handbook's Typical Primary Clarifier Efficiency table, 54 to 68% of the suspended solids but only 30 to 36% of the BOD5\mathrm{BOD}_5, since much of the BOD is dissolved. Bacteria in the aeration basin eat the rest, as in Activated Sludge, and the secondary clarifier settles those bacteria out.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Which pairings of something in the water with the unit chiefly there to remove it are correct?

A.
Eggshells and coffee grounds in raw sewage: grit chamber
B.
Dissolved sugar from a soft-drink bottler: primary clarifier
C.
Clay turbidity in river water: a sedimentation basin, with no coagulant
D.
Giardia cysts that escape the sedimentation basin: filtration
E.
The biological solids leaving an aeration basin: secondary clarifier

Recap

  • θ=V/Q\theta = V/Q is how long water stays, vo=Q/Av_o = Q/A over the plan area is how fast it rises, and the WOR, over a weir length of πD\pi D for a circular rim, is how fast it leaves.
  • To size a clarifier, take A=Q/voA = Q/v_o for each basin's share and for the peak, round the count up, and set h=voθh = v_o\theta.
  • Coagulation destabilizes particles in a rapid mix, by charge neutralization or sweep floc. Flocculation grows floc with slow mixing. A jar test sets the coagulant dose and pH.
  • G=P/(μV)G = \sqrt{P/(\mu V)} with the dynamic viscosity, and GtGt is about 10410^4 to 10510^5.
  • Water: rapid mix, flocculation, sedimentation, filtration, disinfection. Wastewater: screen, grit chamber, primary clarifier, aeration basin, secondary clarifier, disinfection.