Hydrographs and Detention

Detention can't make runoff disappear; it can only make it wait.

Pave a meadow, and the storm that used to reach the creek at 20 cfs now arrives at 60 cfs. The town wants the peak held to what it was, so you'll build a pond. How big? Neither number can say, because a peak is a rate and a pond holds a volume. The answer is in the whole storm, start to finish, drawn as a graph. By the end of this Lesson, you'll size that pond in three lines.

Flow against time

Stand at a watershed's outlet through a storm and write down the flow every few minutes. Plot it against time, and you have a hydrograph. The flow climbs, tops out, and then sinks back more slowly than it rose.

Everything in this Lesson rests on one fact about that graph: the area under it is a volume of water. Flow is volume per time, so flow times time is volume. One cfs running for one hour delivers 3,600 ft³, an amount you'll see written as 1 cfs-hr. So write the balance first, and read it off the graph: water in, water out, and the difference is whatever got stored.

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 Time (hr) Q (cfs) Baseflow Peak Excess rainfall Lag time Time to peak Rising limb Recession limb Direct runoff
The parts of a storm hydrograph
The excess rainfall lasts 1 hr, and the flow peaks 3.5 hr after it begins. Measured from the center of the burst, the lag is 3 hr.

The Handbook prints no hydrograph diagram and defines none of these terms, so they're yours to carry:

  • Baseflow is what the stream carries anyway, mostly groundwater seeping in.
  • Direct runoff is what the storm adds on top of the baseflow. Spread its volume evenly over the watershed and you get the depth of excess rainfall, the rain left after the ground has taken its share. That's the runoff depth from Curve Number Runoff, under a new name.
  • The rising limb is the climb, as water from farther and farther away starts reaching the outlet.
  • The time to peak runs from the start of the excess rainfall to the highest flow.
  • The lag time runs from the center of the excess rainfall to the peak, so the time to peak is half the burst's duration plus the lag.
  • The recession limb is the long fall after the peak, as water held up in soil, channels, and puddles drains out.

One inch, one shape

Now for a bold claim. Drop exactly 1 in. of excess rainfall evenly across a watershed over some stated duration, say 1 hr, and measure the direct runoff. That hydrograph is the watershed's 1-hour unit hydrograph, with ordinates in cfs per inch of excess rainfall. The claim is that this one curve predicts the watershed's response to any storm.

The Handbook's Hydrology/Water Resources section gives it one sentence, as the direct runoff from "one unit of rainfall occurring uniformly in space and time over a specified period of time." Read that unit as 1 in. of excess rainfall. Since it's direct runoff, there's no baseflow in it.

The area under it is that 1 in., spread over the whole watershed. The claim rests on three assumptions:

  • Linear. Twice the excess rainfall gives twice the flow at every moment, on the same time base.
  • Time-invariant. The same burst an hour later gives the same hydrograph an hour later. The watershed responds the same way every time.
  • Uniform, for a stated duration. The excess rainfall falls evenly over the watershed and steadily through the duration. A 1-hour unit hydrograph is built for 1-hour bursts.

None of this is strictly true, since wet ground answers faster than dry. It's a model, simple enough to use by hand and close enough to earn its keep.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

Which of these are part of the unit hydrograph's definition or assumptions?

A.
It is the direct runoff from 1 in. of total rainfall, including what soaks in
B.
A burst next week would give the same hydrograph as the same burst today
C.
Its ordinates include the stream's baseflow
D.
The excess rainfall falls uniformly over the watershed for a stated duration
E.
A 1.5 in. burst gives ordinates 1.5 times the unit hydrograph's, at the same times
F.
Twice the excess rainfall makes the peak arrive twice as fast

Scale, lag, sum

The first two assumptions are all the machinery you need. A storm with several bursts of excess rainfall is just several unit hydrographs: scale each one by its burst's depth, start each one when its burst starts, and add them at every moment. Take a 1-hour unit hydrograph, UU, with 1.0 in. of excess in the first hour and 2.0 in. in the second.

Scale 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 100 200 300 400 Time (hr) Q (cfs) 2.0 in. × U 1.0 in. × U Lag 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 100 200 300 400 Time (hr) Q (cfs) 2.0 in., second hour 1.0 in., first hour Sum 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 100 200 300 400 Time (hr) Q (cfs) Direct runoff 400 cfs at hour 3
Two bursts of excess rainfall: scale, lag, sum
All three panels share one scale. The sum peaks at 400 cfs at hour 3.
The same storm as a table, with flows in cfs
HourU (cfs/in.)1.0 in.2.0 in., 1 hr laterDirect runoff
0000
15050050
2150150100250
3100100300400
46060200260
53030120150
610106070
7002020
800

In symbols, with excess depths E1E_1, E2E_2, and E3E_3 in consecutive periods of the unit duration DD, the flow at any time is:

Q(t)=E1U(t)+E2U(t−D)+E3U(t−2D)Q(t) = E_1 U(t) + E_2 U(t - D) + E_3 U(t - 2D)

Look where the peak landed: hour 3, though the unit hydrograph itself peaks at hour 2, because the bigger burst came second. So sum the rows around the peak instead of assuming it. If a problem asks about one time, you need just that row: at hour 4, (1.0)(60)+(2.0)(100)=260(1.0)(60) + (2.0)(100) = 260 cfs.

The sum is direct runoff only, so add the baseflow to the final sum, once. And the scale factor is always excess rainfall. When a problem gives a storm depth and a curve number, find the runoff depth first.

Worked Example A two-burst storm with baseflow
1 of 4

A watershed has the 1-hour unit hydrograph below. Two consecutive 1-hour periods produce 1.5 in. and then 0.5 in. of excess rainfall, and the baseflow is a steady 25 cfs. Find the peak flow in the stream.

1-hour unit hydrograph
Hour0123456
U (cfs/in.)0401209050200

What paving does to the hydrograph

Now build a subdivision on the watershed and think about the graph. Two physical things change. Less rain soaks in, because roofs and streets have replaced soil: that's the higher curve number from Curve Number Runoff. And the water that runs off travels faster, through gutters and pipes instead of across grass: that's the shorter time of concentration from Time of Concentration and Design Storms. The first changes how much water there is, which is the area under the curve. The second changes how soon it gets there. Run those two forward and see what they do to the peak.

Checkpoint

The dashed curve is a watershed's hydrograph for a design storm before development. Which solid curve is the same storm after a subdivision covers most of the watershed?

A.
Q t Before After
B.
Q t Before After
C.
Q t Before After
D.
Q t Before After

Making the water wait

A detention pond takes that flood and passes it through a small outlet. To see what it does, picture a bathtub with its drain open, and turn the tap up and then back down. The deeper the water, the harder the drain runs. While the tap beats the drain, the tub fills and the drain speeds up, even after you start closing the tap. The level stops rising at the moment the two are equal. That's the deepest the water gets, so it's also the hardest the drain ever runs.

So a routed outflow peaks where it crosses the falling limb of the inflow hydrograph, the same instant the pond is fullest. It can't peak with the inflow, because at that moment the pond is still filling fast.

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Time (hr) Q (cfs) 60 cfs Inflow Going into the pond Outflow peak, 20 cfs: pond fullest Outflow Coming back out
A flood routed through a pond
The outlet here runs in proportion to the water stored. Inflow beats outflow until hour 1.5, and the two shaded areas are equal.

Before the crossing, the water between the curves is going into the pond. After it, that same water comes back out, and the two areas match because the pond has no other exit. So detention lowers the peak and delays it, and it doesn't remove a single cubic foot. The release depends on the outlet, usually an orifice or a weir, whose equations are in Tanks, Siphons, and Weirs. The Handbook has nothing on detention itself.

Retention and infiltration are a different deal. A retention basin holds water with no routine surface release, until it evaporates or soaks in, and an infiltration trench sends it straight into the ground. That water never reaches the creek as runoff, so the runoff volume really does drop. Detention works on the peak. Retention and infiltration work on the volume too.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Development raises a site's runoff in a design storm from 5 acre-ft to 8 acre-ft and its peak from 20 cfs to 60 cfs. A detention pond holds the peak to 20 cfs. Which of these are true?

A.
The volume reaching the creek returns to 5 acre-ft
B.
All 8 acre-ft still reaches the creek
C.
The peak at the creek comes later than it would with no pond
D.
The pond's outflow peaks at the same moment the inflow peaks
E.
Soaking the extra 3 acre-ft into the ground in an infiltration basin would cut the volume reaching the creek

Sizing the pond from two triangles

Now you can size the pond. Draw the post-development inflow as a triangle with peak QpostQ_{\text{post}} and time base TbT_b, its full length from start to finish. The outflow is capped at the pre-development peak, QpreQ_{\text{pre}}, so draw it as a triangle too: it rises in a straight line from the start, reaches QpreQ_{\text{pre}} on the falling limb, just as the bathtub says, and then follows that limb down. Both peaks are the kind you found with Q=CIAQ = CIA in Time of Concentration and Design Storms.

Q Time Qpost Qpre Tb Vs Post-development inflow Outflow
Detention storage as the area between two triangles
Both triangles share the base TbT_b. The shaded area is the water stored by the moment of the crossing.

The storage is the area between them. The two triangles share a base, so subtract their areas:

Vs=12TbQpost−12TbQpre=12Tb(Qpost−Qpre)V_s = \tfrac{1}{2} T_b Q_{\text{post}} - \tfrac{1}{2} T_b Q_{\text{pre}} = \tfrac{1}{2} T_b \left( Q_{\text{post}} - Q_{\text{pre}} \right)

The time to peak never appears: slide the inflow's peak left or right, and the area doesn't change. The time base does appear, because the difference in the peaks is only a rate, and it takes a time to make it a volume. A real outflow curves, so this is an estimate, and a fair one: the routed pond above has the same peaks and base, and it stores about 38 cfs-hr where the triangles give 40.

Development often shortens the hydrograph too, so a problem may give each triangle its own base. Then find each area with its own base:

Vs=12TpostQpost−12TpreQpreV_s = \tfrac{1}{2} T_{\text{post}} Q_{\text{post}} - \tfrac{1}{2} T_{\text{pre}} Q_{\text{pre}}

That one is a rougher estimate. It counts pre-development volume that would leave after the pond's fullest moment, so a real pond can need more. Real designs route the storm step by step, which is beyond this Lesson.

Worked Example The pond from the start of this Lesson
1 of 3

A site's pre-development peak is 20 cfs, and its post-development peak is 60 cfs. Both hydrographs are triangles with a 2 hr time base. Find the detention storage that holds the peak to 20 cfs, in ft³ and in acre-ft.

Sizing the pond from a table

Sometimes the inflow comes as a table of readings, and the outlet as a constant allowable release rate, QrQ_r. The balance is the same: whenever the inflow is above the release, the pond stores the difference. When the inflow is below it, the pond is either still empty, with the water just passing through, or already past its fullest and draining. Neither adds to the size you need.

0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 0 30 60 90 120 Time (min) Q (cfs) 50 80 40 Release, 30 cfs Inflow
Inflow above a constant 30 cfs release, with readings every 30 minutes
The shaded area is the storage. The dashed lines mark the excess.

So for each reading above the release, find the excess, add those up, and multiply by the time step:

Vs=∑(Qin−Qr)ΔtV_s = \sum \left( Q_{\text{in}} - Q_r \right) \Delta t

In the figure, the excesses are 50, 80, and 40 cfs, which add to 170 cfs. Each one lasts a 30-minute step, or 1,800 sec, so Vs=(170)(1,800)=306,000V_s = (170)(1{,}800) = 306{,}000 ft³, about 7.0 acre-ft. This is the Trapezoidal Rule from the Handbook's Numerical Integration section, with the excess at zero at both ends. If a crossing falls between two readings, the sum is an estimate, but the method is the same.

Worked Example Storage from an hourly table
1 of 2

The table gives the inflow to a pond whose outlet can release 40 cfs. Find the storage needed, in ft³ and in acre-ft.

Inflow to the pond
Hour01234567
Inflow (cfs)1040120906040150

Recap

  • The area under a hydrograph is a volume, so every question here is a flow balance read off a graph. 1 cfs-hr is 3,600 ft³.
  • Time to peak runs from the start of the excess rainfall, and lag time from its center. Urbanization means a higher peak, an earlier peak, and more volume.
  • A unit hydrograph is the direct runoff from 1 in. of excess rainfall, spread uniformly over a stated duration. Assuming a linear, time-invariant watershed, scale by excess rainfall, lag by the unit duration, sum, and add baseflow once.
  • Detention lowers and delays the peak without reducing the volume, unlike retention and infiltration. The outflow peaks where it crosses the inflow's falling limb.
  • Storage is the area between hydrographs, not the difference in peaks: Vs=12Tb(Qpost−Qpre)V_s = \tfrac{1}{2} T_b (Q_{\text{post}} - Q_{\text{pre}}) for triangles, or the inflow above the release times the time step for a table.