Manning's Equation

Gravity pulls water down the channel, and friction from the wetted boundary holds it back.

Before this Lesson

Two concrete ditches run down the same hillside at the same slope, each with 12 ft² of water flowing through its section. One is 12 ft wide and runs 1 ft deep. The other is 4 ft wide and runs 3 ft deep. Same area, same slope, same concrete. Do they carry the same flow?

12 ft 1 ft A = 12 ft² 4 ft 3 ft A = 12 ft²
Two ditches, each flowing with 12 ft² of water

They don't. To see which one carries more, and by how much, ask what holds the water back.

Pull and drag in balance

Let water into the top of a long, straight channel on a steady slope. At first it speeds up, as anything does going downhill. But the faster it moves, the harder the bed and banks drag on it, and before long the drag matches the pull. From then on the water stops speeding up, and nothing changes from one reach to the next. The Handbook's Specific Energy Diagram section calls this uniform flow: a flow condition where depth and velocity do not change along a channel. Manning's equation describes that state. With the depth fixed, the water surface runs parallel to the bed, so one slope, SS, describes both.

Now weigh a reach of the flow, LL long. The water in it weighs γAL\gamma A L, where AA is the flow area. Channels slope gently, so the part of that weight pulling along the slope is γALS\gamma A L S. The water pressing on the two ends cancels, since both ends have the same depth. Holding the water back is the shear stress τ\tau from the boundary, acting on every square foot the water touches: the wetted perimeter PP times the length LL.

flow y F F γALS τPL L 1 S Profile A P free surface (not wetted) Section
Gravity and boundary drag on a reach of uniform flow

Nothing accelerates, so the pull and the drag balance:

τPL=γALS⇒τ=γ AP S\tau P L = \gamma A L S \quad\Rightarrow\quad \tau = \gamma\,\frac{A}{P}\,S

The ratio A/PA/P is the hydraulic radius, which the Handbook writes RH=A/PR_H = A/P. Despite the name, it isn't the radius of anything. It's the water each foot of wetted boundary has to hold back. The free surface touches only air, which drags on nothing, so PP runs along the bed and up the sides to the water's edge, and stops there.

That explains the Hook's ditches. The wide one holds its 12 ft² against 12+1+1=1412 + 1 + 1 = 14 ft of concrete, so RH=0.86R_H = 0.86 ft. The deep one needs only 4+3+3=104 + 3 + 3 = 10 ft, so RH=1.20R_H = 1.20 ft. Less boundary drags on the same water, so it can run faster.

How much faster? In a real channel's turbulent flow, the drag grows roughly with the square of the velocity, so setting τ∝v2\tau \propto v^2 equal to γRHS\gamma R_H S gives v∝RHSv \propto \sqrt{R_H S}. The square root on the slope survives into Manning's equation. Fitting measurements of real channels put the power on RHR_H nearer 2/3 than 1/2, and that fit is Manning's equation.

Manning's equation

The Handbook prints Manning's Equation in its fluid mechanics section and again under Hydrology/Water Resources, discharge first:

Q=Kn ARH2/3S1/2v=Kn RH2/3S1/2Q = \frac{K}{n}\,A R_H^{2/3} S^{1/2} \qquad v = \frac{K}{n}\,R_H^{2/3} S^{1/2}

Divide the first by AA and you get the second, because continuity, from Continuity and Bernoulli's Equation, says Q=AvQ = Av. So vv is the average velocity across the section. The other symbols:

  • KK is 1.486 in USCS units, with lengths in feet, vv in ft/sec, and QQ in ft³/sec. It's 1.0 in SI, with meters, m/s, and m³/s.
  • nn is the roughness coefficient, the same number in either system.
  • SS is the slope as a ratio, ft/ft or m/m. A slope of 0.2 percent is S=0.002S = 0.002, not 0.2.

The two values of KK are bookkeeping. Since a lining's nn doesn't change with the units, the conversion hides in KK: (3.281 ft/m)1/3=1.486(3.281\ \text{ft/m})^{1/3} = 1.486. Use the wrong one and the answer is off by that factor.

nn stands in for everything about the boundary that makes the water work harder: the texture of the lining, its grass, stones, or weeds. A rougher boundary drags harder, so nn sits in the denominator, and doubling it halves the flow at the same depth. A lower nn means a smoother lining and more capacity. The Handbook prints no values of nn, so an exam problem gives it, but a few typical values show the scale:

Typical values of Manning's n for channel linings
LiningTypical nn
Finished concrete0.013
Clean, straight earth0.022
Short grass0.030
Natural stream with stones and weeds0.045

Now the Hook's ditches can be finished. They share nn, SS, and AA, so their flows compare as RH2/3R_H^{2/3}, and with equal areas, their hydraulic radii compare inversely as their perimeters:

QdeepQwide=(RH,deepRH,wide)2/3=(1410)2/3=1.25\frac{Q_\text{deep}}{Q_\text{wide}} = \left(\frac{R_{H,\text{deep}}}{R_{H,\text{wide}}}\right)^{2/3} = \left(\frac{14}{10}\right)^{2/3} = 1.25

The narrow, deep ditch carries 25 percent more water through the same area, because it has 4 ft less concrete to drag on.

The geometry of a section

Manning's equation needs AA and PP, so most of the work in a channel problem is the section's geometry, and the Handbook gives none of it. Most channels are trapezoids, described by a bottom width bb, a flow depth yy, and a side slope written zz:1, horizontal to vertical. A 2:1 side slope runs out 2 ft for every foot it rises.

b T zy y y√(1 + z²) z 1
A trapezoidal section flowing at depth y

At depth yy, each sloped side reaches out zyzy horizontally while it rises yy. Its wetted length is the hypotenuse of that right triangle, (zy)2+y2=y1+z2\sqrt{(zy)^2 + y^2} = y\sqrt{1 + z^2}, and that length goes into PP. The reach zyzy is only how far the side extends sideways, and it belongs in the area and the top width.

So the area is a rectangle byby plus two triangles of 12(zy)(y)\tfrac12(zy)(y), the wetted perimeter is the bottom plus two sloped sides, and the top width TT, the Handbook's width of the water surface, is the bottom plus two reaches:

Flow-section geometry at flow depth y
SectionArea, AAWetted perimeter, PPTop width, TT
Rectanglebybyb+2yb + 2ybb
Trapezoid(b+zy) y(b + zy)\,yb+2y1+z2b + 2y\sqrt{1 + z^2}b+2zyb + 2zy
Trianglezy2zy^22y1+z22y\sqrt{1 + z^2}2zy2zy

You only need the trapezoid's row. Set z=0z = 0 and its sides stand vertical, giving the rectangle. Set b=0b = 0 and its bottom vanishes, giving the triangle, a V-shaped ditch with the same slope on both sides. In every case, RH=A/PR_H = A/P.

One more ratio comes from this geometry. The hydraulic depth, which the Handbook writes yh=A/Ty_h = A/T beside its Froude number, is the depth of a rectangle with the same area and top width. Specific Energy and Critical Flow puts it to work. Keep it apart from RHR_H: A/TA/T divides by the free surface, the one line the hydraulic radius leaves out.

Checkpoint
1 of 2
2.0 m 1.5 m 0.8 m
A rectangular concrete channel, partly full

A rectangular concrete channel is 2.0 m wide, with walls 1.5 m high, and the water in it is 0.8 m deep. What is its hydraulic radius?

A.
0.29 m
B.
0.32 m
C.
0.44 m
D.
0.60 m
E.
0.80 m

From a section to a discharge

A forward problem takes four steps. Find AA and PP from the geometry, and divide for RHR_H. Put RHR_H, SS, and nn into the velocity form with the KK for your units. Then multiply by AA for QQ. Raise RHR_H to the 2/3 power and take the square root of SS as separate steps on the calculator, since a slipped exponent is easy to make and hard to spot.

Worked Example Discharge of an earth channel
1 of 3

A trapezoidal earth channel has a 10 ft bottom width and 2:1 side slopes. It flows 3 ft deep on a slope of 0.0016, with n=0.022n = 0.022. Find the mean velocity and the discharge.

Reading the exponents

Manning's equation also answers questions with no arithmetic. Hold everything fixed but one thing, and read how the flow responds:

Q=Kn ARH2/3S1/2Q = \frac{K}{n}\,A R_H^{2/3} S^{1/2}
  • Roughness. QQ goes as 1/n1/n.
  • Slope. QQ goes as S1/2S^{1/2}. Drag grows as the square of the speed, so a steeper pull buys only the square root in speed. Doubling the slope raises the flow by a factor of 2\sqrt2, just 41 percent.
  • Size. A bigger section gains twice: more area for gravity to pull on, and a larger RHR_H, because area grows faster than perimeter. So the flow grows faster than the area.
  • Velocity versus discharge. The velocity depends on nn, SS, and RHR_H, and not on AA by itself. Two sections with the same RHR_H on the same slope and lining run at the same speed, however much water each carries.
Checkpoint
1 of 3

A storm channel runs on a slope of 0.1 percent. A new alignment steepens it to 0.4 percent, with the same section and lining. How does its capacity at the same depth change?

A.
It quadruples.
B.
It rises to about 2.5 times.
C.
It rises to 16 times.
D.
It doubles.

Recap

  • In uniform flow, gravity's pull down the slope balances the drag of the wetted boundary. RH=A/PR_H = A/P, and the free surface isn't part of PP.
  • Q=(K/n) ARH2/3S1/2Q = (K/n)\,A R_H^{2/3} S^{1/2} and v=Q/Av = Q/A, with K=1.486K = 1.486 for feet, 1.0 for meters, and SS as a decimal.
  • A trapezoid has A=(b+zy)yA = (b + zy)y, P=b+2y1+z2P = b + 2y\sqrt{1 + z^2}, and T=b+2zyT = b + 2zy, with side slopes zz:1. A rectangle has z=0z = 0, and a triangle b=0b = 0. The hydraulic depth yh=A/Ty_h = A/T divides by the top width, not PP.
  • Flow goes as 1/n1/n and S1/2S^{1/2}, and a bigger section gains both area and hydraulic radius.