Crew Costs, Task Duration, and Markups
Divide the quantity by the production rate, and time and cost both follow.
The takeoff for a retaining wall says it needs 2,700 ft² of formwork. Your five-person carpentry crew (a foreman, three carpenters, and a laborer) sets forms at about 60 ft² an hour. That line has a long way to go before it's a number on a bid. It has to become hours, then payroll, then dollars, and finally a price that also covers the company and leaves a profit. Each step is one multiplication or division, and each has a classic way to go wrong. The crew will work 45 hours, for instance, and you'll pay for 225.
Quantity over rate is time
In Fleet Balancing and Equipment Cost, two divisions price a machine: time = quantity / production, and unit cost = hourly cost / hourly production. A loader that moves 150 yd³ an hour needs 8 hours for 1,200 yd³, and if it costs $240 an hour to run, each cubic yard costs . This Lesson runs the same divisions with a crew in place of the machine.
Every estimate asks the same first question: how long? A crew's production rate says how much work it finishes in a unit of time, and dividing the quantity by that rate gives the time:
For the wall, that's hours. These are crew-hours: hours with the whole crew on the job, working as a unit. They're the clock the schedule runs on. The Handbook prints nothing on crews, wages, or markups, so the question supplies every rate and you bring the method.
A schedule counts days, so divide the crew-hours by the hours the crew works each day. At 8 hours a day, the wall takes days. When a question asks how many working days the crew needs, round up to 6: the forms aren't finished until partway through the sixth day, and 5 days would leave five hours of forms unset. Use the hours per day the question states.
A crew-hour pays everyone
Here's the step that trips people up. During each hour of the wall job, five people are on the clock, so one crew-hour is five hours of somebody's wages. Picture the crew's time sheet for one day as a grid, with a row for each person and a column for each hour.
Each cell is a labor-hour: one person working one hour. A column is a crew-hour. The day is 8 crew-hours, but 40 labor-hours, so:
The wall's 45 crew-hours are labor-hours. The schedule runs on crew-hours, because the crew moves as a unit. Payroll runs on labor-hours, because everyone gets paid. If a question gives productivity in labor-hours per unit instead, the conversion runs backward: labor-hours divided by crew size gives crew-hours.
What a crew-hour costs
Since a crew-hour pays every member, its cost is one column of that grid: each member's wage, added up. Wages aren't the whole cost of a worker, though. On every wage dollar, the contractor also pays payroll taxes, workers' compensation and unemployment insurance, and often benefits. Estimators lump these into payroll burden, a percentage of wages, and multiply the bare wages by one plus it.
| Crew member | Count | Wage ($/hr) | Per crew-hour ($) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foreman | 1 | 44.00 | 44.00 |
| Carpenter | 3 | 38.00 | 114.00 |
| Laborer | 1 | 30.00 | 30.00 |
| Bare wages | 5 | 188.00 | |
| Payroll burden, 35% | 65.80 | ||
| Crew hourly cost | 253.80 |
The labor cost of an activity is its crew-hours times the crew hourly cost:
You'd get the same total from 225 labor-hours at the crew's average burdened wage, . What you can't do is multiply labor-hours by the crew hourly cost. That counts the crew size twice and comes out five times too high, at $57,105.
Adding equipment, and the cost of one unit
Most crews work with machines: a backhoe, a concrete pump, a forklift to lift form panels. When a machine is charged for each hour it works alongside the crew, its hourly cost simply adds to the crew's. It adds after the burden, though. Burden is a cost of employing people, and a forklift draws no wages, so burden never touches equipment.
Say the wall crew uses the company's forklift, charged to the job at $65 an hour. Crew and forklift together cost an hour, and the forms cost in labor and equipment.
Estimators also want that cost per unit of work, to compare crews or price a quantity that might change. Divide the total by the quantity, or go straight there:
That route never touches the quantity. An hour of crew and forklift costs $318.80 and sets 60 ft², so each square foot carries a sixtieth of that hour. A wall ten times bigger takes ten times as long and costs exactly the same per square foot.
Rentals bill by the whole period
Not every machine is charged by the hour. A rental yard rents by the day or by the week, and it bills whole periods: once the machine leaves the lot, it's yours until the period ends, whether it works or sits. So count the working days, then round up to whole rental periods.
Suppose the wall's forklift comes from a rental yard that rents it only by the week, at $1,150 for a week of 5 working days. The forms take 5.625 working days, which runs 0.625 days into a second week.
The yard bills 2 weeks, or $2,300. Charging 1.125 weeks, $1,293.75, is the classic wrong answer, because there's no such thing as an eighth of a rental week. The crew is different. When the forms are done, the carpenters move on to the next activity, so labor is paid for the 45 hours actually worked, unless the question says otherwise.
Estimating references organize all this in crew tables. Each entry lists a crew's members and equipment, their cost, and the crew's daily output: how much it produces in a working day. With output per day, the division gives days directly:
Three kinds of cost in a bid
Everything so far is direct cost: the labor, equipment, materials, and subcontracts that go into a specific item of work. A bid has to cover more than that, and two kinds of overhead sit on top of it.
- Job overhead, also called general conditions or field overhead, is the cost of running this job that belongs to no single item of work: the project superintendent, the field-office trailer, temporary power, water, and toilets.
- Home-office overhead, or general overhead, is the cost of running the company: headquarters rent, accounting, estimators, executives. Every job the company holds pays a share of it.
Two questions sort any cost. Is it spent on this project? If not, it's home-office overhead. If it is, does it go into one item of work, like the concrete in the footings? Then it's direct cost. If it serves the whole job, it's job overhead. The superintendent is the classic case: on this job full time, so not home-office overhead, but running all of it rather than building any one item, so job overhead.
Markups stack
The bid is built from direct cost by markups, each a stated rate on a stated base. Besides the two overheads, there's usually a contingency, a cushion for what the estimate can't foresee, and the profit. A single markup, like the one allowed on a change order in Project Delivery and Contract Administration, is the one-step version. A bid usually takes several in a row, and the base is where the trap is. A markup on the running subtotal is charged on everything beneath it, including the markups before it.
Say the whole wall, from excavation to backfill, comes to $100,000 in direct cost. The contractor adds job overhead at 12%, then home-office overhead at 6%, contingency at 5%, and profit at 10%, each on the running subtotal.
Each step multiplies the subtotal by one plus its rate, so the bid is a product:
Adding the rates to 33% and applying that once gives $133,000, which is $4,121.60 short, because it leaves out the markups on the markups. Read each rate's base, though. Two markups that are both on direct cost are percentages of the same number, so they simply add. Only markups on a running subtotal multiply.
Going backward, undo each factor by dividing. The order doesn't matter, so divide the bid by the whole product: . The profit needs only the last factor. Profit was 10% of the subtotal under it, so the bid is 1.10 times that subtotal, and the profit is 0.10/1.10 of the bid: . Taking 10% of the bid, $13,712.16, overstates it, because the bid is bigger than the base the 10% was charged on.
Markup on cost, margin on price
Contractors talk about profit two ways, and they aren't the same number. Markup is profit as a fraction of cost. Margin is profit as a fraction of price. A job that costs $100 and sells for $125 makes $25 either way.
The $25 is 25% of the cost but 20% of the price, because the price is the bigger base. On any job, the margin is smaller than the markup. To convert:
Check them on the example: , and . When a question asks for the bid that makes profit a stated percent of the price, the cost is the rest of the price, so price = cost / (1 − margin). For a $400,000 cost and a 10% margin, the bid is . Marking the cost up by 10% instead gives $440,000, and its $40,000 of profit is only 9.1% of that price.