Project Delivery and Contract Administration

Who designs, who builds, who pays, and who's protected if it goes wrong.

Before this Lesson

A city is about to sign a $4.2 million contract for a new fire station. Before the first truck arrives, that contract has to answer questions nobody enjoys asking. Does one firm design the station and another build it? If the drawings and the specifications disagree, which wins? If the contractor goes broke halfway through, who finishes, and who pays the electrician? And if the station opens more than five weeks late, what does the city get?

Nearly every provision in a construction contract does one of two jobs. It puts a risk on a particular party, or it gives the owner a lever to get the work finished. Ask whose risk it is and who holds the lever, and most of these questions answer themselves. The Handbook prints none of this, so it's all yours to carry in, and the problem will give you any rate, date, or clause it needs.

Who signs with whom

The project delivery method decides how many contracts the owner signs, with whom, and when the builder comes aboard.

In design-bid-build (DBB), the owner hires a designer to finish the drawings and specifications, puts the complete design out for bids, and awards the construction contract, usually to the low bidder. The owner holds two separate contracts, and the phases run one after another. The designer and the contractor have no contract with each other, so the owner stands in the middle: if the drawings are wrong, the contractor's claim is against the owner.

Design-build (DB) closes that gap. The owner signs one contract with a single firm or team that designs and builds, so one party answers for everything, design errors included. And because the designer and the builder are on the same side, construction can start before the design is finished. The price is control: the designer now works for the builder, not the owner.

Design-bid-build Design-build Design Bid Construction Design Construction Time saved Time
Overlapping design and construction finishes sooner

A construction manager (CM) can hold either of two very different jobs, and the difference is the words "at risk."

A construction manager at risk (CMAR) joins during design, advising the owner and its separately hired designer on cost, schedule, and buildability. When the design is far enough along, it commits to a guaranteed maximum price and builds the job, holding the trade contracts itself. If the work costs more than the GMP, the CM pays. That's the risk.

An agency construction manager is the owner's adviser, paid a fee the way the designer is. It estimates, schedules, and coordinates, but the owner signs the trade contracts, so an overrun is the owner's, and the agency CM carries no cost risk at all.

Design-bid-build Owner Designer Contractor Trade contractors Design-build Owner Design-builder Designer Trade contractors CM at risk GMP Owner Designer CM at risk Trade contractors Agency CM fee coordinates Owner Designer Agency CM Trade contractors Contract Coordination, no contract Holds the trade contracts
Who holds a contract with whom under each delivery method
Checkpoint

A city builds a transit center with five prime contractors, each hired by the city directly. It also retains a construction manager, at a fixed monthly rate, to keep the master schedule, review pay requests, and run the weekly meetings among the five. The work comes in $700,000 over the estimate. What kind of CM is this, and who pays?

A.
A CM at risk, so the construction manager pays
B.
An agency CM, so the construction manager pays out of its monthly rate
C.
An agency CM, so the city pays
D.
A CM at risk, so the five prime contractors pay

Each method trades something for something else, so the right one depends on what the owner wants most.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

Which of these are defining features of design-bid-build?

A.
The owner holds separate contracts with the designer and the contractor
B.
One firm is responsible for both design and construction
C.
The design is complete before the job is bid
D.
The builder joins during design to advise on cost
E.
The construction contract usually goes to the low bidder
F.
Construction can start before the design is finished

The documents that make up the contract

Some of the paper the designer assembles only runs the competition. The invitation to bid announces the job and when bids are due, and the instructions and bid form say how to bid. Once the contract is signed, what binds the parties are the contract documents.

The contract documents and what each holds
DocumentWhat it holds
AgreementThe parties, the price, and the contract time
General conditionsRights, duties, and procedures
Supplementary conditionsChanges to the general conditions
SpecificationsMaterials, workmanship, and quality, in words
DrawingsLocations, dimensions, and arrangement, in pictures

The general conditions are usually a standard form covering how payments, changes, and claims work, and the supplementary conditions edit it for this job. A drawing can show a 6 in. slab in the right place, but it takes the specifications to say what concrete goes in it, how it's cured, and what tests it must pass.

After signing, before the contractor orders anything, it sends the engineer submittals: shop drawings, samples, cut sheets (a manufacturer's catalog pages), and material certifications (a supplier's statement that its material meets a standard). A submittal shows how the contractor plans to meet the requirements. It doesn't set them.

Checkpoint
1 of 3

A contractor laying a water main needs to know what material must go under the pipe as bedding, how it must be placed, and the compaction test it must pass. Which document says?

A.
The pipe manufacturer's cut sheet
B.
The quarry's material certification for its stone
C.
The specifications
D.
The invitation to bid

Sooner or later, two documents disagree: the drawings call for 3,000 psi concrete, and the specifications for 4,000 psi. Most contracts settle this in advance with an order-of-precedence clause, a ranked list in which the higher document governs. One common list runs agreement, supplementary conditions, general conditions, specifications, drawings, so the 4,000 psi would govern. But some contracts rank the drawings higher. On the exam, use the clause the problem gives you, not one from memory.

Checkpoint

A state highway contract's order-of-precedence clause ranks, from highest: special provisions, project plans, standard plans, standard specifications. The standard specifications call for 8 in. of aggregate base, and the project plans show 6 in. Which governs?

A.
8 in., because specifications govern over drawings
B.
6 in., from the project plans
C.
8 in., because the stricter requirement governs

Bids and bonds

If the bidding documents need fixing while the job is out to bid, the owner issues an addendum to every bidder before bids are opened, so they all price the same job. Addenda become part of the contract.

On a lump-sum job, the lowest bid wins. On a unit-price job, the owner builds a bid tabulation: each unit price times the engineer's estimated quantity is an extension, and each bidder's extensions add up to its total.

A bid tabulation for a sewer job
ItemQuantityA, unit priceA, extendedB, unit priceB, extended
Excavation (yd³)18,000$7.50$135,000$9.00$162,000
Pipe (ft)3,200$62$198,400$58$185,600
Manholes (each)12$4,200$50,400$3,600$43,200
Total$383,800$390,800

Bidder B is cheaper on two of the three items, and its unit prices add up to less. Neither matters. A sum of unit prices adds dollars per cubic yard to dollars per manhole, which means nothing, and B's $600 edge per manhole buys only 12 of them, while A's $1.50 edge applies to 18,000 yd³. Bidder A is low, at $383,800.

Checkpoint

A county opens three unit-price bids for a road job.

Unit-price bids for a road job
ItemQuantityBidder XBidder YBidder Z
Clearing (acre)6$2,800$4,500$1,900
Excavation (yd³)24,000$6.20$5.40$7.10
Aggregate base (ton)9,500$24.00$26.00$22.00
Asphalt (ton)3,800$92.00$88.00$95.00

Which bidder is low?

A.
Bidder X
B.
Bidder Y
C.
Bidder Z

Now the owner has a low bidder, and some worries. What if it backs out before signing, or starts the job and goes broke? The answer is a surety bond, which is less like insurance than like a co-signer on a loan. The contractor, the principal, makes a promise to the owner, the obligee. The surety, a bonding company, guarantees it: if the contractor fails, the surety makes the promise good, and then it's entitled to every dollar back from the contractor. The bond protects the owner, not the contractor.

Surety bonding company Principal contractor Obligee owner promises to perform repays the surety if it pays guarantees the promise
The three parties to a surety bond

A construction job uses three bonds, one for each way to fail:

  • A bid bond guarantees that if this bidder wins, it will sign the contract and furnish the other two bonds. If it walks away, the surety pays the owner its loss, usually the gap to the next bid, up to the bond's amount.
  • A performance bond guarantees the owner that the work will be completed as the contract requires.
  • A payment bond guarantees that the contractor will pay its subcontractors, laborers, and suppliers.
Checkpoint
1 of 3

Halfway through building a pump station for a water district, the general contractor stops paying its pipe supplier, who is owed $85,000. Which bond protects the supplier?

A.
The bid bond
B.
The performance bond
C.
The payment bond

Changes after signing

No set of drawings is perfect. When the contractor finds a duct drawn straight through a beam, it sends a request for information (RFI), a written question, and the engineer's answer clarifies what the contract already requires.

A change order is a written amendment, signed by the owner and the contractor after award, that changes the scope, the price, or the time, and it's the only way any of them moves. Asking isn't changing: an RFI clarifies, and a change order changes. The award is also the line between a change order and an addendum, which changes the bidding documents before bids are opened.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Three months after the fire station contract is signed, the city decides to move the emergency generator to the other side of the building. The engineer revises the drawings and labels the revision "Addendum 4." What does this change actually need?

A.
Nothing more, since an addendum changes the drawings
B.
A change order, since the contract has been awarded
C.
An RFI response, since the engineer is answering the city
D.
A submittal, since the generator location has changed

Over a job, change orders pile up. The revised contract sum is the original plus the approved additions, minus the approved deductions, and the revised completion date is the original plus the days the approved change orders add. A proposed change order counts for nothing until it's approved. To price one, find the direct cost of the changed work, quantities times unit costs, and add the markup the contract allows. A bid stacks several markups, which is the business of Crew Costs, Task Duration, and Markups.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A county library renovation has an original contract sum of $2,960,000 and a completion date of March 15. Here is its change-order log.

Change orders on the library renovation
Change orderStatusAmountTime
CO 1Approved+$41,250+10 days
CO 2Approved−$18,6000 days
CO 3Approved+$73,900+14 days
CO 4Proposed+$25,000+7 days

What are the revised contract sum and completion date?

A.
$3,081,550 and April 15
B.
$3,056,550 and March 15
C.
$3,056,550 and April 8
D.
$3,093,750 and April 8

Getting paid as the work goes in

A contractor is paid monthly, in progress payments, for the work in place to date. On a unit-price job, that's each item's measured quantity to date times its unit price. On a lump-sum job, it's each line of the schedule of values, the contract price split by part of the work, times its percent complete.

The owner holds back retainage, a stated percentage of the work in place to date, until the job is done. That's its lever over the finish: a contractor with a tenth of the job's value in the owner's drawer has every reason to come back for the last repairs. The earlier payments already had their retainage taken out, so everything works in totals to date, with rr the retainage rate:

Payment=(work in place to date)(1−r)−(previous payments)\text{Payment} = (\text{work in place to date})(1 - r) - (\text{previous payments})
Work in place to date Earlier payments This payment (1 − r) × (work in place to date) Retainage r × (work in place to date)
Where the value of the work in place goes

So take retainage on the whole amount to date, not just this month's work, and subtract what was actually paid.

Worked Example Month 3 on the sewer job
1 of 2

Bidder A won the sewer job at its bid prices: $7.50/yd³ for excavation, $62/ft for pipe, and $4,200 per manhole. By the end of month 3, the measured quantities to date are 11,400 yd³ of excavation, 2,150 ft of pipe, and 7 manholes. The contract holds 10% retainage, and previous payments total $151,200. What is the payment for month 3?

Finishing late

When the fire station opens late, the city pays for it: rented space for the trucks, an inspector's extra weeks, an old station kept running. Those costs are real but hard to prove, so the contract settles them up front. Liquidated damages (LDs), the owner's other lever over the finish, are a daily amount, agreed at signing, that the contractor owes for each day it finishes past the contract completion date. They must be a reasonable estimate of the owner's cost, not a penalty set to punish, which courts won't enforce, and they aren't a charge for damaged work.

They count only the days that are the contractor's own. An approved time extension moves the completion date, and LDs count from the new date until, usually, substantial completion. The fire station's contract set a completion date of September 30 and LDs of $1,800 per day. The city approved 14 days of extensions, moving the date to October 14, and the station reached substantial completion on November 5.

Oct 14 Completion date with extensions Sept 30 Contract completion date Nov 5 Actual completion 14 days of approved extensions no LDs 22 days of LDs at $1,800/day
Liquidated damages count from the extended completion date
(22 days)($1,800/day)=$39,600(22\ \text{days})(\$1{,}800/\text{day}) = \$39{,}600

Charging all 36 days from September 30 would bill the contractor for 14 days the city had already excused.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A contract's completion date is May 20, with liquidated damages of $2,500 per calendar day. The owner approved two time extensions, of 6 days and 10 days. The contractor reaches substantial completion on July 2. What are the liquidated damages?

dollars

Recap

  • Design-bid-build: two owner contracts, a complete design, the low bid. Design-build: one contract, one responsible party, overlapping design and construction. A CM at risk holds the trade contracts under a GMP; an agency CM advises and carries no cost risk.
  • Agreement: parties, price, time. Conditions: rights and procedures. Specifications: materials and quality. Drawings: locations and dimensions. In a conflict, follow the stated order of precedence.
  • Extend unit prices by the engineer's quantities; the lowest total wins. Bid, performance, and payment bonds guarantee signing, finishing, and paying the subs, and the surety recovers from the contractor.
  • An addendum changes the bidding documents before bids open, a change order changes scope, price, or time after award, and an RFI answer changes nothing.
  • Retainage and liquidated damages are the owner's levers over the finish. Payment = work to date × (1 − r) − previous payments. Liquidated damages = days past the extended completion date × the daily rate.