Earthwork Volume States and Hauling

Dig up a cubic yard, and you'll haul more than a cubic yard.

Before this Lesson

A basement excavation measures 1,200 cubic yards on the plans, and the haul trucks carry 15 cubic yards each, so the dispatcher books 80 loads. Load 80 pulls away, and a fifth of the hole is still in the ground. The plans were right, and so were the trucks. The 1,200 yards were measured in the ground and the 15 in a truck bed, and dirt that has been dug takes more room than dirt that hasn't. This job needed 100 loads.

One weight, three volumes

Digging doesn't make dirt, and rolling doesn't destroy it. Both only change how much air sits between the grains. So a batch of soil weighs the same in the ground, in the truck, and in the fill, and since weight is volume times unit weight,

Vbank γbank=Vloose γloose=Vcompacted γcompactedV_{\text{bank}}\,\gamma_{\text{bank}} = V_{\text{loose}}\,\gamma_{\text{loose}} = V_{\text{compacted}}\,\gamma_{\text{compacted}}

Nearly everything in this Lesson comes out of that one line. Every conversion factor is a ratio of two unit weights, and the state with the lighter unit weight always takes the bigger volume.

A number like 1,200 yd³ means little until you know which state it's in, so construction writes the state into the unit: BCY for bank cubic yards, LCY for loose, and CCY for compacted. Label every volume with its state, and most of the mistakes in this Lesson can't happen. Each state has its place on a job:

  • Excavation is in BCY. A hole computed from the plans, or ground surveyed before it's dug, measures soil that sat in the bank.
  • Hauling is in LCY. A truck bed, a loader bucket, and a stockpile all hold soil that has been dug.
  • Fill is in CCY. The plans give the finished embankment or pad, rolled to its final density.
loose truck, bucket, pile 1.25 LCY 3,000 lb γ = 2,400 lb/LCY bank in the ground 1.00 BCY 3,000 lb γ = 3,000 lb/BCY compacted in the fill 0.80 CCY 3,000 lb γ = 3,750 lb/CCY × 1.25 ÷ 1.25 × 0.80 ÷ 0.80
One bank yard of a soil that swells 25% and shrinks 20%
Each container holds the same 3,000 lb. Arrows leaving bank multiply, and arrows returning to it divide.

Bank sits in the middle for a reason: swell and shrinkage are both percentages of the bank volume, so every conversion goes into or out of bank. The next sections walk each arrow. None of these conversions is in the Handbook, which prints no swell, load factor, or loose volume, so they're worth knowing cold.

From the ground to the truck

A 25% swell means each bank yard comes out of the ground as 1.25 loose yards. With the swell written as a decimal,

Vloose=Vbank (1+swell)V_{\text{loose}} = V_{\text{bank}}\,(1 + \text{swell})

That's the Hook's arithmetic: 1,200 BCY × 1.25 = 1,500 LCY, and at 15 LCY a load, 100 loads.

To go back from the truck to the ground, you divide by the same 1.25. Its reciprocal has a name, the load factor:

LF=VbankVloose=11+swell\text{LF} = \frac{V_{\text{bank}}}{V_{\text{loose}}} = \frac{1}{1 + \text{swell}}

At 25% swell, LF = 0.80: each loose yard in the truck came from 0.80 of a yard in the ground. The tempting shortcut is to multiply by 1−swell1 - \text{swell}, 0.75 here, and a round trip shows what it costs. 100 BCY swells to 125 LCY, and 125 × 0.75 = 93.75 BCY, so more than six yards vanished on the way back. The 25% was a percentage of the bank, not of the loose, and only dividing by 1.25 undoes it.

Counting truckloads is a division with one rule: round up. If the loose volume over the truck's capacity comes out to 64.1, the last tenth of a load still needs a truck, so it's 65 loads.

Checkpoint

A utility trench yields 845 BCY of clay that swells 30%. How many loads will it take to haul it in trucks that carry 14 LCY each?

loads

Unit weights, and a truck's two limits

Questions often skip the percentage and give unit weights instead, such as 3,000 lb/BCY in the bank and 2,400 lb/LCY loose. The weight line turns them straight into the factors:

swell=γbankγloose−1LF=γlooseγbank\text{swell} = \frac{\gamma_{\text{bank}}}{\gamma_{\text{loose}}} - 1 \qquad \text{LF} = \frac{\gamma_{\text{loose}}}{\gamma_{\text{bank}}}

Here, swell = 3,000/2,400 − 1 = 0.25, and LF = 2,400/3,000 = 0.80. The load factor is less than 1, so the lighter loose weight goes on top.

For the factors, either kind of unit weight works. The Handbook's Phase Relationships define the total unit weight γ=W/V\gamma = W/V, water included, and the dry unit weight γD=WS/V\gamma_D = W_S/V, solids only. Digging and hauling don't add or remove water, so both give the same ratio between bank and loose. For a fill that's watered before it's rolled, use dry unit weights.

Unit weights matter for a second reason. A haul truck has two limits. Its heaped capacity is the loose volume its bed holds, heaped in a mound above the sides. Its rated payload is the weight its frame, axles, and tires are built to carry. A light soil fills the bed before it gets near the payload. A heavy soil reaches the payload with room still left in the bed.

allowed loads 0 4 8 12 16 20 0 5 10 15 20 25 loose soil in the bed (LCY) load weight (tons) heaped capacity,16 LCY rated payload, 20 tons topsoil, 2,000 lb/LCY wet clay, 2,800 lb/LCY bed full:16 tons 20 tons at 14.3 LCY
Load weight as a 16 LCY, 20-ton truck fills
Each load stops at whichever limit it reaches first: the bed for the topsoil, the weight rating for the wet clay.

So check both, and weigh the load with the total unit weight, because the truck carries the water too. A heaped load weighs its heaped capacity times γloose\gamma_{\text{loose}}. If that's under the payload, the bed limits each load. If it's over, the payload limits it, and each load holds the payload divided by γloose\gamma_{\text{loose}}. Payloads usually come in tons, and the Handbook's Units and Conversion Factors give the short ton as 2,000 lb.

Worked Example A truck hauling heavy clay
1 of 3

A clay weighs 3,200 lb/BCY in the bank and 2,500 lb/LCY loose. The haul trucks are rated for 18 tons and hold 16 LCY heaped. Find the load factor, decide what limits each load, and find how many bank yards each load removes.

Working back from the fill

A fill question runs the other way. The plans give compacted yards, and you need the bank yards to dig and the loose yards to haul. Shrinkage is a percentage of the bank volume too, so

Vcompacted=Vbank (1−shrinkage)⇒Vbank=Vcompacted1−shrinkageV_{\text{compacted}} = V_{\text{bank}}\,(1 - \text{shrinkage}) \quad\Rightarrow\quad V_{\text{bank}} = \frac{V_{\text{compacted}}}{1 - \text{shrinkage}}

where 1−shrinkage1 - \text{shrinkage} is the shrinkage factor. A soil fill always needs more yards dug than it holds. Multiplying by 1+shrinkage1 + \text{shrinkage} instead is the trap here, and it fails the same round trip: at 20% shrinkage, 100 BCY packs down to 80 CCY, and 80 × 1.20 = 96, four yards short of the bank you started with.

From bank, swell the volume to get the loose yards the trucks will carry. With percentages, there's no shortcut that skips bank. Adding the swell and shrinkage percentages, or swelling the compacted yards, applies a percentage to a volume it was never measured against.

Worked Example Borrow for a highway embankment
1 of 2

A highway embankment needs 10,200 CCY of fill from a borrow pit whose soil shrinks 15% and swells 25%. Find the bank volume to excavate and the loose volume to haul.

Which way is bigger?

With three states and four arrows, it helps to have a check that needs no formula. For ordinary soil, the states line up by how much air they hold: loose has the most, then bank, then compacted, and the same weight takes the most room where there's the most air. So a factor that carries a volume toward a looser state is greater than 1, and one that carries it toward a denser state is less than 1. If a converted volume moves the wrong way, a factor is upside down.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Which of these pair a quantity with the state it's in?

A.
Soil counted by the truckload as it leaves the site: bank
B.
A borrow pit cross-sectioned before digging: bank
C.
The trench backfill quantity on the plans: compacted
D.
A spoil pile beside a trench: compacted

Stockpiles stand at the angle of repose

Dump dirt in one spot and it builds itself a cone. Grains roll down the sides until the slope is just gentle enough for them to stay put, and that steepest stable slope is the soil's angle of repose, φ\varphi. Seen from the side, the pile is a triangle, with the height rising over the base radius at that angle:

h=rtan⁡φh = r \tan\varphi
h φ angle of repose r D
A conical stockpile in elevation

The Handbook's Mensuration of Areas and Volumes gives a right circular cone's volume as V=πr2h/3V = \pi r^2 h/3, the same one third its Earthwork formulas print for a pyramid or cone. Substitute h=rtan⁡φh = r\tan\varphi, and the volume depends on the radius alone, so you can solve for it:

V=π3 r3tan⁡φ⇒r=3Vπtan⁡φ3V = \frac{\pi}{3}\,r^3 \tan\varphi \quad\Rightarrow\quad r = \sqrt[3]{\frac{3V}{\pi \tan\varphi}}

With rr in hand, the base diameter is 2r2r and the height is rtan⁡φr\tan\varphi. The Handbook prints no stockpile formula, so these come from the geometry. Two things decide the inputs. A stockpile holds dug soil, so VV is a loose volume, and bank yards get swelled first. And the dimensions come out in feet only if VV goes in as cubic feet, at 27 ft³ per yd³.

Worked Example A stockpile beside a footing excavation
1 of 2

A footing excavation removes 400 BCY of soil that swells 25%, and the soil is piled in a cone beside the hole. Its angle of repose is 35°. Find the pile's base diameter and height.

Recap

  • Digging and rolling change the air in soil, not the soil, so VγV\gamma is the same in every state and every factor is a ratio of unit weights. Label every volume with its state: BCY in the ground, LCY in a truck, bucket, or pile, and CCY in the fill.
  • Bank to loose multiplies by 1+swell1 + \text{swell}, and the load factor, 1/(1+swell)1/(1 + \text{swell}), takes loose yards back to bank. Round truckloads up.
  • A truck is limited by its heaped capacity or its rated payload, whichever it reaches first, so compare the weight of a heaped load with the payload.
  • Bank is the hub, because both percentages are measured against it. Leaving bank, multiply; coming back, divide, so a fill needs Vcompacted/(1−shrinkage)V_{\text{compacted}}/(1 - \text{shrinkage}) bank yards. A factor toward a looser state is greater than 1.
  • A stockpile is a cone of loose soil at its angle of repose: h=rtan⁡φh = r\tan\varphi and V=πr2h/3V = \pi r^2 h/3, with VV in cubic feet.