Cut, Fill, Shrinkage, and Mass Haul
Dirt changes size when you dig it up, and again when you pack it down.
Before this Lesson
A grading plan for a new lot says to push a knoll at the back into a hollow at the front. The contours say the knoll holds 3,000 cubic yards and so does the hollow, so on paper the job balances. Then the dozers go to work, and the hollow comes up about 300 yd³ short. Nobody mismeasured. The knoll was measured as it sat in the ground, the hollow as the packed fill it will hold, and a yard of one isn't a yard of the other. Keeping those yards straight is the whole game, from one hollow to a mile of road.
One dirt, three volumes
Dig a hole and try to put all the dirt back. You can't: there's a mound left over, because the dirt came out with air worked in between the grains. Now run a roller over that mound long enough, and it can sink below the rim of the hole. Nothing was added and nothing was lost. The same grains sat in three different volumes, and earthwork gives each one a name:
- Bank volume is the dirt in place, undisturbed, as the ground holds it. Cut is measured this way.
- Loose volume is the dirt once it's dug, sitting in a bucket, a truck, or a pile, fluffed up with air.
- Compacted volume is the dirt placed and rolled into a fill. Compaction usually packs it tighter than the ground ever did, so it takes less room than it did in the bank.
Going from bank to loose is swell, and going from bank to compacted is shrinkage. Both are measured against the bank volume:
The dirt in the figure swells 25% and shrinks 10%. The shrinkage factor is the fraction of the bank volume that's left once it's compacted, here 0.90:
Not every problem measures from the bank, though. Some quote shrinkage against the compacted volume, where 10% shrinkage makes the bank 1.10 times the compacted volume, so read which basis a question uses. Loose volume is what a truck carries, and it comes back with load factors in Earthwork Volume States and Hauling. Here, the action is between bank and compacted.
Where does a factor like 0.90 come from? Weigh the grains. The Handbook's Phase Relationships define dry unit weight as the weight of solids over the total volume they occupy, air and water included:
Digging and rolling move air and water around, but the grains stay put, so never changes. That makes , and the same dirt's volumes in any two states are in the inverse ratio of their dry unit weights:
In the figure, that's 108/120 = 0.90. The denser state always gets the smaller volume, which is the quickest check on a ratio: if a fill that's denser than its bank comes out with more volume, the ratio is upside down. Unit Weights of Soil treats dry unit weight fully, but this one definition is all you need here.
Slicing a pond or a knoll by its contours
Average end area, from End Areas and Volumes, doesn't care which way you slice. Along a road, the slices stand up across the centerline. A pond or a knoll comes already sliced, lying down: each contour on the map encloses an area at one elevation, and neighboring contours sit one contour interval apart. Take two neighboring contour areas as the ends and the interval as the length, and each slab is a reach on its side:
Every slab is one interval thick. Using the knoll's whole height as the length treats a stack of slabs as one fat slab with only the top and bottom areas, and that misses the shape in between.
Which state you've measured depends on what you sliced. A knoll's contours outline dirt sitting in the ground, so a knoll cut down to a pad gives bank volume. A pond's contours outline a hole, and the fill packed into it takes exactly that space, so a pond to be filled gives compacted volume. The Handbook has no contour method of its own. It's the Earthwork formulas' average end area, with the interval as . If a knoll's top rises to a point above its last contour, that cap is the Handbook's Pyramid or Cone: one third of the top contour's area times the cap's height.
Slice it the way it was measured
Every volume in this topic is the same move: cut the dirt into slices you can measure, then add them up. How the ground was measured decides the slicing:
- Along a route, such as a road, a ditch, or a levee, the crew takes cross sections at stations, so use average end areas, with the length from the stations.
- A pond, depression, or knoll mapped by contours takes contour areas, with the contour interval as the length.
- A borrow pit is staked as a grid of squares, with the ground shot at every corner before and after digging. Each square is a short column of dirt: its area times the average of its corner cuts.
- Wherever a section pinches down to nothing, as at a cut-fill transition, the solid is a pyramid, .
The Handbook's Earthwork formulas print average end area and the pyramid; the grid method is the same slice-and-add idea.
Cut and fill in the same yards
Back on a road, the mismatch between the knoll and the hollow hides in every table. Cut end areas are drawn on the ground before it's dug, so cut volumes are bank yards. Fill end areas are drawn on the finished embankment, so fill volumes are compacted yards. Subtracting one from the other mixes two currencies.
So convert first. Each compacted yard of fill takes bank yards to build, so the bank volume a fill needs is
and the net is the cut minus that. A plus result is an excess, dirt to haul off and waste. A minus result is a shortage, to be made up from borrow.
The Handbook's Earthwork formulas cover this in one line: shrinkage is handled "by increasing fill at each station by the shrinkage factor." They don't say how. With SF defined as compacted over bank, below 1, increasing means dividing. If a question hands you a factor above 1 for the fill, such as 1.10, it's quoting bank over compacted, so multiply. Either way, the adjusted fill comes out bigger than the fill.
A running balance
A net total says whether a job balances. It doesn't say where the dirt goes. For that, keep the balance as you walk the road, the way a bank statement keeps a running total. Each reach's cut is a deposit, each reach's adjusted fill is a withdrawal, and the balance at a station is its mass ordinate. The Handbook's Earthwork formulas define it as "the cumulative total of excavation and embankment at a given station." With excavation counted plus and adjusted embankment minus,
with both sums running from the start of the job, where . Here's a short road worked that way, with a shrinkage factor of 0.90. Each ordinate is the one above it, plus the reach's cut, minus its adjusted fill.
| Station | Cut (yd³) | Fill (yd³) | Fill ÷ 0.90 | Ordinate (yd³) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0+00 | 0 | |||
| 1+00 | 0 | 270 | 300 | −300 |
| 2+00 | 0 | 450 | 500 | −800 |
| 3+00 | 0 | 180 | 200 | −1,000 |
| 4+00 | 400 | 0 | 0 | −600 |
| 5+00 | 700 | 0 | 0 | +100 |
| 6+00 | 500 | 0 | 0 | +600 |
| 7+00 | 0 | 360 | 400 | +200 |
| 8+00 | 0 | 90 | 100 | +100 |
Reading a mass diagram
Plot the ordinates against station, and the shape tells the story of the job. The Handbook's Earthwork formulas draw a mass haul diagram under the road's profile, and the figure below follows that layout with the numbers from the table.
Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Earthwork formulas
Read the slope first. Where the curve climbs, cut outweighs fill, so the balance grows. Where it falls, fill outweighs cut. So a peak is where cut gives way to fill, here at 6+00, and a valley is where fill gives way to cut, at 3+00. Those are the stations where the ground crosses grade in the profile.
Now lay any horizontal line across the curve. Between two places it meets the curve, the ordinate ends where it started, so the cut in between exactly feeds the fill in between. That's a balance line, and the places it meets the curve are balance points. The zero line meets this curve at 0+00 and 4+86, so the cut from 3+00 to 4+86 fills the stretch from 0+00 to 3+00.
Which way does that dirt travel? Below the balance line, the curve falls before it rises, so the fill comes first in stationing and the cut comes after it. The dirt has to be hauled back, toward lower stations. Above a balance line, as in the hump the line at +100 cuts off between 5+00 and 8+00, the cut comes first and the dirt is hauled ahead on station. That's the whole rule: above the line, haul ahead; below it, haul back.
Last, look at where the curve ends. The final ordinate is what's left over from the whole job: plus is an excess to waste, minus is a shortage to make up from borrow. This road ends at +100 yd³. That's the cut between 4+86 and 5+00, which neither balance line claims.