Conflicts of Interest

The appearance of a conflict counts, so disclose it before anyone else finds it.

Before this Lesson

You're scoring three bids for a county pump station. Bidder B is the firm where you worked for nine years. You left on good terms two years ago, you own no part of it, and it owes you nothing. You're sure you'd score all three bids the same way, and you're probably right.

Nobody has asked about your history with Bidder B. Do you have to bring it up? The answer has nothing to do with how honest you are, and that's the idea this whole Lesson runs on.

The part nobody can check

Think about what the county is buying from you. It isn't a filled-in score sheet. It's your judgment, your undivided opinion on which bid serves the county best, and judgment happens inside your head, where nobody can inspect it.

Inside your head What the county sees No tie to Bidder B Bid B looks best Recommend Bid B A tie to Bidder B Bid B looks best Bidder B is my old firm Recommend Bid B
Two evaluations, one identical piece of paper

From the county's side, those two rows can't be told apart. They may feel much the same from your side too, because a tilt rarely feels like a tilt. It feels like Bid B just looks a little better.

You can't prove your judgment stayed straight, and the client can't check it, so the rules don't ask anyone to try. They treat the appearance of influence like the real thing, and they ask for the one thing that does work: put the facts on the table, and let the client, whose project it is, decide how much they matter.

That doesn't mean you've done anything wrong. Having a sister in the paving business isn't a sin, and neither is having worked somewhere. A conflict of interest is a fact about your circumstances. Hiding it is the wrongdoing.

Most of this Lesson sits on the ladder's second rung, your duties to employer and clients. The Handbook's rule on conflicts is B.6:

Licensees shall disclose to their employers or clients all known or potential conflicts of interest or other circumstances that could influence or appear to influence their judgment or the quality of their professional service or engagement.

Three phrases in there are wider than they first look. "Known or potential" means it needn't have caused trouble yet. "Other circumstances" means it needn't be money. And "could influence or appear to influence" means it needn't have influenced anything at all.

Start with the money

The plain case is a financial stake. You or a close relative hold an interest in a contractor, a supplier, or a piece of land the project touches, so your judgment could move money toward your own family. The Handbook never mentions relatives. They come in through those broad words, and the exam counts them.

The move is the same first step you know from the escalation sequence: tell your employer or client. B.6 doesn't print the word "promptly," but expect it in the right answer, because a disclosure that shows up after the decision tells the client about a choice it can no longer make.

Worked Example The sister's aggregate yard
1 of 2

You're a consulting engineer writing a road rehabilitation specification for a county. It will list the approved aggregate suppliers. You own no part of any supplier, but your sister owns a large share of one, and it happens to be among the best in the region. What do the Model Rules require?

Being sure doesn't count

Now take the money away and go back to the pump station. You own nothing, nobody in your family owns anything, and you're confident. Does that let you off?

Try a thought experiment. Bid B wins. A week later, the losing bidders find out that you spent nine years at Bidder B and never said so. Would they feel cheated? Would the county enjoy explaining it at a public meeting? If so, you're looking at a circumstance that could appear to influence your judgment. The Handbook doesn't mention former employers, so the words "other circumstances" do the work here.

Your confidence doesn't help, because the engineer with the tilt feels just as sure. So you tell the county before you score anything. It may well shrug and ask you to carry on, and that's fine: now the decision is the county's, made with the facts.

Checkpoint

You're one of three engineers scoring proposals for a transit agency's new station. One proposer is a firm where your close friend is a principal. You have no financial stake in it, and you're confident you can score it fairly. Must you disclose the friendship?

A.
No, because only a financial interest counts as a conflict
B.
No, as long as you score your friend's firm a little lower, to be safe
C.
Yes, but only after the scores are in, and only if your friend's firm ranks first
D.
Yes, promptly, because the friendship could appear to influence your judgment

What about a free lunch?

Everything so far has been something you already had when the job came along: a sister, a history, a friend. You can't un-have those, so the rules have you disclose them. A gift is different. Somebody whose work you judge decides to hand you something, and you decide whether to take it. Here's B.5:

Licensees shall not solicit or accept gratuities, directly or indirectly, from contractors, their agents, or other parties in connection with work for employers or clients.

Suppliers aren't named, but "other parties" takes them in, and "directly or indirectly" takes in the gift that goes to your spouse or arrives through a sales agent. Read the rule again and look for fine print: a dollar limit, an exception for small things, a clause about telling someone. Then try these.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

A steel fabricator's rep drops off shop drawings for you to review, then offers to buy you a $15 sandwich across the street. May you accept?

A.
Yes, because $15 is too small to influence anyone's judgment
B.
No, because the rule bars gratuities from this party at any amount
C.
Yes, as long as you buy the next lunch, so that it evens out
D.
No, because a $15 meal is over the rule's dollar limit

So there's no fine print. That may seem harsh for a sandwich, until you ask what a threshold would do: it would tell every supplier exactly how much to spend. Nobody thinks a sandwich gets a bad submittal approved. It buys a little goodwill, and goodwill is the tilt you can't see from inside.

It's also why no disclosure cures it. A tie you can't get rid of, but a gift you can simply refuse. The Handbook doesn't define "gratuity," so you're free to wonder about the coffee at a job-site meeting, but the exam's versions are a gift, a meal, a trip, or tickets.

Two paychecks

Not all outside money is a gift. You're the owner's engineer on a bridge rehabilitation, and the contractor offers you a fair fee to design its temporary shoring. That's real work for real pay, so what's the problem? Picture the day the shoring moves and the two of them start arguing over whose fault it is. Whose engineer are you? B.7 makes sure everyone knows the answer before they have to ask:

Licensees shall not accept compensation, financial or otherwise, from more than one party for services pertaining to the same project, unless the circumstances are fully disclosed and agreed to in writing by all interested parties.

Unlike a gift, this can be cured, because the pay buys honest work and the harm lies in someone not knowing. Read the end of that rule word by word, then try this.

Checkpoint

A city hires you to inspect a sewer project. The contractor offers to pay you separately to troubleshoot its dewatering on the same job. The city's project manager says over the phone that it's fine with her. When may you accept the contractor's pay?

A.
Right away, because the city is your client and its project manager agreed
B.
Never, because pay from two parties on one project is banned outright
C.
Once you've told the city the amount and kept the two invoices separate
D.
Once the circumstances are fully disclosed and all interested parties agree in writing

The cure has three parts, and the exam likes to drop one:

  • Fully disclosed: the whole arrangement, not a hint of it.
  • In writing: a nod over the phone doesn't count.
  • All interested parties: the owner, the contractor, and anyone else with a stake, not just whoever you told first.

Paying to win work

B.5 is about gifts coming to you from people whose work you judge. C.2 is the mirror image: gifts going from you to people who hand out work. Either way, the gift flows toward whoever holds the decision.

Licensees shall not offer, give, solicit, or receive, either directly or indirectly, any commission, or gift, or other valuable consideration in order to secure work, and shall not make any political contribution with the intent to influence the award of a contract by public authority.

The Handbook files this one on the third rung, under other licensees, which tells you who else it protects: the competitor who lost the job for refusing to pay. All four verbs count, so an offer that gets turned down still violates it, and so does asking for one. In the political half, look at the word "intent."

Paying for work can go a long way up. In 1973, Spiro Agnew resigned as Vice President of the United States while under investigation for taking kickbacks from Maryland engineers and contractors who wanted public work, and he pleaded no contest to a single tax charge.

Checkpoint

Which of these violate the Model Rules?

A.
Agreeing to pay a local consultant 5% of the fee if they land your firm a county contract
B.
Donating to a council candidate whose platform you support, with no contract in view
C.
Sending a case of wine to the county engineer while your firm competes for county work
D.
Explaining to a client, at a scheduled interview, why your approach would cost less
E.
Contributing to a mayor's campaign so that your firm gets a better shot at a city contract

Both sides of the table

Here's a case where nobody has offered anyone anything. One of your firm's principals serves on the county's port commission, and the commission is choosing a consultant for its new terminal. Your firm is well qualified. The trouble is where she's sitting: the commission would be judging a proposal from a colleague's firm, and the public has no way of checking how that went. B.8 handles it twice over. Its first sentence stops the firm:

Licensees shall not solicit or accept a professional contract from a governmental body on which a principal or officer of their organization serves as a member.

Its second sentence stops the member. A licensee who serves a government body as a member, advisor, or employee, and who works for a private firm as a principal or employee, "shall not participate in decisions" on services that firm offers or provides to that body.

Checkpoint

The president of your firm serves on the city council, which is selecting a consultant for a water plant upgrade. She offers to leave the room for the discussion and abstain from the vote, and the firm would note her seat in its proposal. What do the Model Rules say?

A.
The firm may pursue the contract, because she'll abstain and the tie will be disclosed
B.
The firm may not pursue the contract, and she may not take part in decisions on its services
C.
The firm may pursue the contract, as long as the selection is open and competitive
D.
The firm may not pursue the contract, but she may still take part in decisions on its services
Your firm Public board Same person Principal Member Vote 2 Proposal 1 1 The firm may not solicit or accept the contract. 2 The member may not take part in the decision.
One person, two seats, two separate bans

Source: Adapted from the FE Reference Handbook, Rules of Professional Conduct

What you learn on the job isn't yours

Clients tell you things so you can do the work: their process data, their expansion plans, the site they're about to buy. All of that comes to you on loan, for one purpose. You've met B.4, which says you don't reveal it without prior consent, except as authorized or required by law or rules. B.9 closes off the other way to cash in:

Licensees shall not use confidential information received in the course of their assignments as a means of making personal profit without the consent of the party from whom the information was obtained.

Between them, those rules leave two exits: consent from whoever gave you the information, obtained beforehand, or a law or rule that authorizes or requires the disclosure. Hold those up against two tempting cases.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

While working on a traffic study for a retailer, you learn it's about to buy a site for a regional distribution center. The farmland next door is cheap, and it won't stay that way once the news is out. Buying it would cost the retailer nothing. May you buy it?

A.
Yes, because the purchase does the retailer no harm at all
B.
No, never, because land near a client's project is always off limits
C.
Only with the retailer's prior consent, since your assignment is how you know
D.
Yes, once your traffic study is finished and the assignment has closed

What openness can and can't fix

One question sorts everything in this Lesson: can openness fix this?

What fixes each situation
SituationWhat fixes itRule
A stake or tie that could sway youPrompt disclosureB.6
Two payers, one projectDisclosure, all agree in writingB.7
Using what a client told youPrior consentB.4, B.9
A gift from someone you reviewNothing: declineB.5
Paying or giving to win workNothing: don'tC.2
A contract from your principal's boardNothing: don't pursueB.8

The elimination habit from Obligations to the Public still works: discard anything that puts profit, convenience, or loyalty first, then pick the most transparent option that uses proper channels. The one refinement is the bottom three rows, where the most transparent option is still a refusal, because a gift you've disclosed is still a gift.

Recap

  • A conflict of interest isn't wrongdoing, but hiding one is. Nobody can check your judgment from outside, so even the appearance of influence gets disclosed, and the client decides.
  • Promptly disclose to your employer or client a financial interest held by you or a close relative, or a tie with no money in it, however sure you are of your objectivity.
  • Decline gifts, meals, trips, and tickets from anyone whose work you review, specify, or approve, at any dollar amount. A commission, gift, or political contribution to help win work is a violation.
  • A firm may not pursue a contract from a public board on which its principal serves, even if that member abstains, and the member may not take part in decisions on its services.
  • Pay from two parties on one project takes full disclosure and the written agreement of all interested parties. Using confidential information for another client or yourself takes prior consent, unless law or rules authorize or require it.