Professional Competence

A license in civil engineering doesn't make you an electrical engineer.

Before this Lesson

You've spent twenty years designing steel buildings. A client you like calls about a new warehouse. The steel is yours, of course, but could you also write the geotechnical report and lay out the electrical service? "You're a PE," she says. "It'll save me hiring anyone else."

Your license is current, your record is clean, and nobody checks their work more carefully than you do. Does any of that let you say yes?

What a license doesn't tell you

Picture two doctors holding the same state medical license. One treats skin, and the other does heart surgery. If you needed a bypass, you wouldn't want the dermatologist, however brilliant and careful, and the license on her wall wouldn't change your mind. Engineering works the same way.

A license says the state trusts you to practice engineering. Competence decides which engineering you may practice. The license can't draw that line for you. The NCEES Model Law, which the Handbook excerpts, lets a state board name a discipline on a license, but even "civil" spans structures, soils, water, and traffic.

Your license: engineering Structural Geotechnical Transportation Water resources Electrical Mechanical Your competence: education or experience in this field
The license spans the map, and competence is one patch of it

The line is drawn by rule B.1 of the Handbook's Rules of Professional Conduct:

Licensees shall undertake assignments only when qualified by education or experience in the specific technical fields of engineering or surveying involved.

Two words carry the weight. "Or" means either route works, so years of real work in a field can qualify you without a degree in it. "Specific" means the test looks at this assignment's field, and not at you in general. That knocks out what people usually reach for:

  • The license. It's why you may practice at all. It says nothing about this field.
  • Years since licensure. Thirty years of steel design is thirty years of steel design.
  • Society membership. Going to meetings about a field isn't working in it.
  • One course or seminar. It's a start. The Handbook prints no minimum, but a fair test is whether you could catch your own mistakes in that field.

Why be so strict with someone honest and careful? Say you write that geotechnical report anyway. You pull a bearing pressure from a table, check the footing, and your arithmetic is flawless. But twenty years of steel framing never taught you to ask about the soft clay fifteen feet down, which will keep squeezing slowly for a decade. Every number on your sheet is right, and the floor cracks anyway. You can't be careful about a question you don't know to ask.

So this rule isn't aimed at careless engineers. It sits on the ladder's second rung, but its reason is on the top one: work outside your field endangers the public even when it's done honestly and carefully. Competence is the first duty turned on yourself. It's also enforceable, since the Handbook's Model Law lists practicing outside your areas of competence among its grounds for disciplinary action.

Competence has a clock on it, too. Codes and methods change, so a field you knew well in 1995 isn't necessarily a field you know now. The Handbook's Code of Ethics section says engineers "must maintain a high level of technical competence," and rule A.2 ties what you seal to "accepted engineering and surveying standards."

Checkpoint
1 of 2

Which of these is an obligation of licensees under the Model Rules?

A.
Have a panel of peer engineers review each design before sealing it
B.
Make public statements on technical matters whenever an employer directs it
C.
Limit any commission offered when soliciting work to a modest amount
D.
Perform services only in areas of competence and in accordance with current standards

The three proper responses

So your client wants the geotechnical report, and B.1 says you aren't qualified to write it. Now what? The Handbook states the limit and stops there, with no list of what to do next. But there are only three ways to stay inside the limit, and this topic calls them the three proper responses:

  • Decline that part. You don't have to walk away from the whole job. Keep the steel, and say the geotechnical report needs someone else.
  • Gain the competence first. Real education or experience in that field, before you take the work on rather than during it. That rarely fits one project's schedule, but it's how anyone ever adds a field.
  • Bring in a qualified licensee. A colleague or subconsultant who works in that field does that part and seals it. Your client still gets the report.
You're asked to take on an assignment Qualified by education or experience in this specific field? Yes Accept it No The three proper responses Decline that part Gain the competence first Bring in a qualified licensee Dead ends "My license covers it" "I've been licensed 30 years" "I took a seminar" "I'll be extra careful"
The test for any assignment, and what follows from it
The habit gets a new step

Eliminate any answer that puts profit, convenience, or loyalty ahead of public safety. Eliminate any answer that has the engineer practicing or sealing outside their competence. Among what remains, pick the most transparent option that uses proper channels.

Checkpoint
1 of 2

You design water mains for a living. A longtime client wants you to also design the electrical controls for a new pump station. "You're a PE, and I trust you," the client says. What is the proper response?

A.
Decline the electrical part, gain the competence first, or bring in a qualified licensee for it
B.
Accept the whole job, since your license authorizes you to practice engineering
C.
Accept the whole job, and have the pump supplier look over the controls when you're done
D.
Turn down the entire project, since you can't accept a job that includes a field outside your own

When the owner requires a licensed engineer

Sometimes an owner writes a requirement into the job. Say a client wants a specialized system evaluated and insists on a currently licensed engineer. Now two things have to be true of whoever does the evaluation: a current license, because the owner asked for one, and competence in that system's field, because B.1 does. A long career doesn't supply either.

Checkpoint

A civil engineer first licensed 35 years ago is asked to evaluate a hospital's backup power system. The owner requires a currently licensed engineer. Under which of these conditions may the engineer accept?

A.
The engineer holds a current license and is personally competent in backup power systems
B.
The engineer took one college course on power systems, decades ago
C.
The engineer has deep experience in backup power, but let the license lapse three years ago
D.
Another licensed engineer on staff, competent in these systems, does the evaluation and seals it
E.
The engineer regularly attends meetings of an electrical engineering society

A seal doesn't stretch

The same limit follows you to the seal, where a new temptation shows up: supervision. Rule B.2 reads:

Licensees shall not affix their signatures or seals to any plans or documents dealing with subject matter in which they lack competence, nor to any such plan or document not prepared under their responsible charge.

The sentence has two halves, joined by "nor." The second half, responsible charge, belongs to Licensure, Seals, and Responsible Charge. The first half is the one that matters here, and it has no exception for work you oversaw.

Say you're the only licensed engineer in a small office, and a designer you supervise draws up a building's HVAC system. You assigned the work, you watched every sheet come together, and your boss wants your seal by Friday. But could you tell a good duct layout from a bad one? Supervising speaks to B.2's second half at most. The first half asks whether you can judge the work, and the boss's deadline doesn't supply that.

Checkpoint

You're a civil engineer at a small firm. A technician you supervise has prepared the electrical power plans for a parking structure, and the firm's electrical engineer left last month. A principal of the firm asks you to seal the plans, since they were prepared under your supervision. You have no training or experience in electrical design. What is the correct response?

A.
Seal them, since you supervised the technician from start to finish
B.
Review them closely, then seal them with a note limiting your seal to that review
C.
Decline to seal them, and recommend a qualified licensee for that work
D.
Seal them, once the principal agrees in writing to take responsibility for them

Leading more than you can design

None of this confines you to projects that fit inside your own field. A water treatment plant needs civil, structural, mechanical, and electrical engineering, and almost nobody is competent in all four. Someone still has to lead it, and rule B.3 says you may:

Licensees may accept assignments and assume responsibility for coordination of an entire project if each technical segment is signed and sealed by the licensee responsible for preparation of that technical segment.

Everything hangs on that "if." Coordinating is real work: schedules, interfaces, making sure the pipes miss the beams. You can do it without being able to design the pipes or the beams.

Checkpoint

You're a civil engineer asked to lead the design of a new transit station. You'll prepare the site and drainage design yourself. A licensed structural subconsultant and a licensed electrical engineer will each prepare their own segments. Which arrangement do the Model Rules permit?

A.
You coordinate and seal all three segments, since you're responsible for the station as a whole
B.
You coordinate and seal the site and drainage design, and the structural and electrical engineers each sign and seal their own segment
C.
You coordinate and seal the site and drainage design, and also seal the structural segment after reviewing it line by line
D.
You coordinate and seal a cover sheet for the whole set, so the subconsultant's segment can go out unsealed

Here's the treatment plant with every seal in place. Your coordination reaches all four segments, and your seal appears once, on the sheet you prepared.

Water treatment plant You: coordinate the entire project Civil Prepared and sealed by you Structural Prepared and sealed by the structural engineer Mechanical Prepared and sealed by the mechanical engineer Electrical Prepared and sealed by the electrical engineer
One coordinator, four segments, four seals

Recap

  • A license says the state trusts you to practice engineering, and competence decides which engineering. What qualifies you is education or experience in the specific technical field, not the license, years since licensure, one course, or society membership.
  • Licensees perform services only in areas of competence and in accordance with current standards, because work outside your field endangers the public even when it's honest and careful.
  • The three proper responses to work outside your field: decline that part, gain the competence first, or bring in a qualified licensee, who may already be on your staff.
  • Supervision doesn't stand in for competence. Asked to seal documents in a discipline outside your competence, decline and recommend a qualified licensee.
  • You may coordinate a multidisciplinary project if each technical segment is signed and sealed by the licensee who prepared it.